Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Just A General Question...


Recommended Posts

Rebirth flame
Posted

ok, i'm taking justice & peace in high school this year, and our teacher says that having an abortion warrants excommunication. I disagreed with her, however.
i do not stand for abortion in the least bit, but i feel that God is forgiving enough to excuse us from any mistake we will make.

that being said,
1. does abortion warrant excommunication?

2. what kind of actions do?

thanks!!!

Posted

In the current canon law, the following mortal sins result in automatic excommunication:

By anyone:[list]
[*]Procuring a successful abortion
[*]Heresy, schism, and/or apostasy
[*]Sacrilegious abuse of the consecrated bread or wine
[*]Physical violence against the Pope
[*]Being absolved (outside the danger of death) by a priest with whom one has had a sinful sexual relationship
[/list]
By a priest:[list]
[*]Absolving someone (outside the danger of death) with whom the priest has had a sinful sexual relationship
[*]Direct violation of the confessional seal
[/list]
By a bishop:[list]
[*]Ordaining someone as a bishop without a pontifical mandate
[/list]
The excommunication extends to accomplices in these acts, and does not apply under certain mitigating factors (e.g., age, compulation, ignorance).

Rebirth flame
Posted

thanks a bunch PhatPhred!!!
i appreciate it!!!

God Bless

Posted

You're welcome.

P.S. "compulation" should be "compulsion". Don't know how I did that one.

EcceNovaFacioOmni
Posted

If you search Excommunication at NewAdvent.org, there is a large list of offenses that can warrant excommunication.

Mateo el Feo
Posted

Here are some good links:

[url="http://www.ewtn.com/expert/answers/abortio2.htm"]Abortion/Excommunication topic at EWTN[/url]

[url="http://www.catholicherald.com/saunders/98ws/ws981001.htm"]Abortion/Excommunication topic at Arlington Catholic Herald (Fr. William P. Saunders)[/url]

[url="http://www.cin.org/mateo/m920918c.html"]Abortion/Excommunication topic at the Catholic Infomation Network (Fr. Mateo)[/url]

[url="http://www.google.com/search?hl=en&ie=UTF-8&oe=UTF-8&q=abortion+excommunication+priest"]My Google Search (~3000 sites!)[/url]

God bless!

Rebirth flame
Posted

thanks guys!!!
i appreciate it!!!

Jake Huether
Posted

On the abortion issue. Indeed it does merit excommunication.

I believe that even those who are a dirrect influence / support for the one getting the abortion will be excommunicated.

Abortion is murder in the highest degree. It is killing an innocent child.


Anyway. Hopefully those links cover it.

Posted

[quote name='thedude' date='Mar 6 2004, 11:26 PM']If you search Excommunication at NewAdvent.org, there is a large list of offenses that can warrant excommunication.[/quote]
There were many more offenses that resulted in excommunication in the prior incarnations of canon law. The old Catholic Encyclopedia was written before the 1917 Code of Canon Law, which in turn was replaced by the 1983 Code of Canon Law now in force.

Posted

i could very well be wrong, but i think PhatPhred listed the things that under current cannon law automatically excommunicate you.

the larger list would consist of things that if you did you COULD be excommunicated if the Church took actions to do so.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Jake Huether' date='Mar 7 2004, 12:40 AM']I believe that even those who are a dirrect influence / support for the one getting the abortion will be excommunicated.[/quote]
The canonical criterion for being an accomplice (and thus sharing in the excommunication) is "without their assistance, the crime would not have been committed".

Of course, this assumes that the accomplice or accomplices are also Catholics, since non-Catholics can't be excommunicated.

Edited by PhatPhred
Posted

thats cuz non Catholics themselves choose not to be in communion with the CHurch ;) there's no point in excommunicating them.

anyway, excommunication does not equal damning someone to hell, you seemed at least implying that when you said, but i think God would have mercy...

excommunication means they cannot receive the sacraments, they are essentially no longer Catholic, unless they publicly renounce their previous sins and repent and seek to come back in communion with the Church. so, of course God's mercy is not cut off from them, but they are cut off from the normative means of salvation, the Church.

Posted

The automatic (latae sententiae) excommunication can't apply to you if you are ignorant about it. For example, if you don't know abortion incurs an automatic excommunication, you aren't automatically excommunicated.

If you're reading this right now, then your excuse about ignorance has just vanished..... :abduction:

Rebirth flame
Posted

thank you all very much!!! i appreciate all the help
God Bless!!! :D

Jake Huether
Posted

[quote name='Adeodatus' date='Mar 7 2004, 07:37 AM'] The automatic (latae sententiae) excommunication can't apply to you if you are ignorant about it. For example, if you don't know abortion incurs an automatic excommunication, you aren't automatically excommunicated.

If you're reading this right now, then your excuse about ignorance has just vanished..... :abduction: [/quote]
Hahahah!

That cracks me up. Like I was talking to some nominal Catholics about things of this nature (like the mortality of grave sins resting on your knowledge of them being grave, etc.). And they were like, "stop telling me these things, your going to send me to hell!"

LOL! Because, presumably, if they wallow in their ignorance they will get a free trip to heaven.



Better to know, and to please God. Then to not know, and please yourself.

Posted

yeah, and we can never assume INVINCIBLE ignorance. only God knows how culpable we are for our own ignorance, we could never judge someone invincibly ignorant, we must teach them cuz ignorance is just an extraordinary way God shows mercy and should never be presumed :cool:

  • 4 weeks later...
ilovechrist
Posted

well rebirth, its obvious you have a lot of help in here.. a LOT!
my advice isn't needed too much... but check out Rock For Life's website on anything abortion, cuz they sure have that subject covered! :cool:

CatholicCrusader
Posted (edited)

[quote]anyway, excommunication does not equal damning someone to hell, you seemed at least implying that when you said, but i think God would have mercy...

excommunication means they cannot receive the sacraments, they are essentially no longer Catholic, [/quote]

That right there is a huge contradiction. If excommunication makes you no longer a Catholic, then you pretty much ARE damned to Hell (Outside the Church no salvation). That is why if one is excommunicated, he cannot receive a Catholic burial (neither can one who is in a state of public mortal sin nor one who kills himself nor one who is not Catholic). God bless.

Edited by CatholicCrusader
cmotherofpirl
Posted

Excommunication does not kick you out of the Churrch. It is a wake-up call to repent of your sin. As soon as you repent you can come back. You are still a Catholic.

If you read Scripture Paul says to have nothing to do with such people.

CatholicCrusader
Posted

Actually...excommunication is separation from the Church completely (St. Thomas Aquinas in Second Part of the Second Part, Question 11, Article 3, in Suma states that a heretic should be separated from the Church by excommunication then separated from the world by death, likening to two to one another). Therefore, just as death completely severs one from the world, so also does excommunication sever one from the Church (like I said, those who are excommunicated are not permitted Catholic burial). God bless.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...