Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Ready To Give Up


Recommended Posts

she_who_is_not
Posted

I'm in round three of RCIA at a new parish in the new city where I live. Once again, I really can't handle it. I'm not going to go into the specifics. People here will just shoot me down.
So, this what I am thinking. I have accepted the truth of the Catholic Church. That means I can't go back. But, do I have to be recieved into the Church? Do I have to make a public profession of faith if I have been making a private one every day for a couple years now?
I've been attending Mass without recieving the Eucharist for 4+ years. Why start now? I could just keep making a spiritual communion.
I was confirmed invalidly, just as I recieved the Eucharist invalidly, but really why bother with validation at this point?
I'll probably never get married. I can recieve reconciliation without being formally recieved. Same with unction.
I'm pretty decently catechised, and when I have a question, I'm told it is too specific, and it goes without an answer.
I've prayed my entire life. I've prayed in manner consistent with the teachings of the Catholic church all my life and continue to do so.
I have renounced my former congregation, I renounce any heresy I may have accepted willingly or by default.
I know that catechised, Baptised Christians are supposed to be allowed to enter at a time other than Easter Vigil. When I sugggest it, I've been told that it isn't fair to the other participants. I've been through RCIA all the way until vigil but made the choice not to be recieved at that time. I honestly don't mind waiting, I just don't want to go to anymore ridiculous pseudo-therapy sessions.
Why should I go through it again, just to recieve the sacraments I've been living my whole life without. Why can't I be carried through life merely on the grace of my Baptism?
I don't have anything against RCIA. but good grief, it's bad enough going through it once! Is it worth it?
I know the answer is yes, but, maybe I'm not good enough to recieve the grace of the other sacraments. Maybe God doesn't want me in the Church. Perhaps, I was born into a family outside the Church for a reason. I trust in Jesus, I know he will never abandon me, but maybe I'm just not called to a great degree of glory.
I'm sorry if this sounds like a rant...It may well indeed be a rant. I'm so lonely right now and I feel so rejected.
ajj

puellapaschalis
Posted

You have my prayers. Whilst I'm "cradle" much of what you've talked about sounds familiar to me.

However, despite all your troubles, you [i]should[/i] be received completely, fully and in the proper way (no matter how much your parish might like to do things in a slightly "odd" way). For the same reason that marriage vows should normally be made in public: your faith and your being part of Christ's holy Church started with Him whispering into the intimate secrecy of your heart, but it draws you into public Communion with Him. Thus, you need to get up there and declare in front of everyone that which you already profess privately (no matter how often you might say you believe on an internet forum or in personal conversations, none of that compares with standing up during the liturgy dedicated to this purpose and declaring to any Tom, Johnsonville brat and Harry who cared to walk in off the street that it is your intention and desire to live entirely for Him and Him alone.

Posted

I understand you are frustrated, but you need to keep going. RCIA won't last forever, but going through it will have great rewards.
The Eucharist is the source and summit of our faith. It is the Body, Blood, Soul and Divinity of Christ, and receiving it is the most wonderful thing we can do on this earth. God wants nothing more than for you to be received into His Church so that He can give you the grace of all the Sacraments. We are all unworthy of God's love, but He gives it to us freely anyway. Remember the words we all say at Mass, 'Lord, I am not worthy to receive you, but only say the word and I shall be healed.'
I know it seems so hard right now, but if you can stick RCIA until the end, it will be worth your while.
As for us shooting you down, this board is pretty safe. People who come to this section of phatmass aren't usually here for a debate, so vent away and maybe we will be able to answer some of the questions that other people won't. Who runs the RCIA in your parish? What's the priest like-is he approachable?
Please, don't give up. Jesus said living out your faith would never be easy. You cannot live a Catholic life privately. Imagine if Jesus hadn't began His public ministry. He encountered so much negativity, so many rejections, so much evil, but He did it anyway because He knew good would come from it.
Keep ranting, too. It's always good to get stuff off your chest.

Posted

Why watch the show in black and white when you can get it in color? :)

Don't give up. My prayers are with you.

Posted

I love Ash's response. Until you are received fully you truly can't appreciate the color. It is much more vivid than you think it is. I know. I will pray for your perseverance.

Posted

My mother isn't Catholic. She went through instruction twice, what we had before RCIA, but because my father refused to go through annulment for his first wedding, she was never able to be baptized. She went to church with us, made clerical vestments, and did the funeral dinners at our parish for 35 years. She calls herself Catholic but has never received communion.

I've been involved with RCIA off and on since 1987, and the reason that it has been off and on, is that I truthfully hate the RCIA model. Some parishes did a better job than others, and I was able to stay much longer. The way the RCIA is done here in the parish I left just this week, was done so horribly, I was glad that only one person signed up. That means that only one improperly catechized neophyte will be produced this year.

If you've been through RCIA twice already, you may be able to find a priest willing to do private initiation with you. It isn't encouraged, but it can be done in certain circumstances. For example, it is sometimes done with people whose work schedule will not allow them to attend RCIA, or someone like a soldier getting ready to deploy. Tell them the problems you have had in RCIA, and see if the Holy Spirit will touch his heart. You might have luck with an older priest since private instruction was the way it was handled before RCIA was developed.

Posted

[quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1665832' date='Sep 28 2008, 04:48 PM']I'm in round three of RCIA at a new parish in the new city where I live. Once again, I really can't handle it. I'm not going to go into the specifics. People here will just shoot me down.
So, this what I am thinking. I have accepted the truth of the Catholic Church. That means I can't go back. But, do I have to be recieved into the Church? Do I have to make a public profession of faith if I have been making a private one every day for a couple years now?
I've been attending Mass without recieving the Eucharist for 4+ years. Why start now? I could just keep making a spiritual communion.
I was confirmed invalidly, just as I recieved the Eucharist invalidly, but really why bother with validation at this point?
I'll probably never get married. I can recieve reconciliation without being formally recieved. Same with unction.
I'm pretty decently catechised, and when I have a question, I'm told it is too specific, and it goes without an answer.
I've prayed my entire life. I've prayed in manner consistent with the teachings of the Catholic church all my life and continue to do so.
I have renounced my former congregation, I renounce any heresy I may have accepted willingly or by default.
I know that catechised, Baptised Christians are supposed to be allowed to enter at a time other than Easter Vigil. When I sugggest it, I've been told that it isn't fair to the other participants. I've been through RCIA all the way until vigil but made the choice not to be recieved at that time. I honestly don't mind waiting, I just don't want to go to anymore ridiculous pseudo-therapy sessions.
Why should I go through it again, just to recieve the sacraments I've been living my whole life without. Why can't I be carried through life merely on the grace of my Baptism?
I don't have anything against RCIA. but good grief, it's bad enough going through it once! Is it worth it?
I know the answer is yes, but, maybe I'm not good enough to recieve the grace of the other sacraments. Maybe God doesn't want me in the Church. Perhaps, I was born into a family outside the Church for a reason. I trust in Jesus, I know he will never abandon me, but maybe I'm just not called to a great degree of glory.
I'm sorry if this sounds like a rant...It may well indeed be a rant. I'm so lonely right now and I feel so rejected.
ajj[/quote]

Without knowing the details, I don't think any of us can give you any good feedback. It could be a case of a wishy-washy RCIA program, or it could be that the questions you are asking are beyond the scope of what most people ask in RCIA (or anywhere).

Posted

You seem like a very sincere person, its unfortunate you are going through such a difficult time, most of which probably isn't your fault. My question to you is, have you ever attended a Latin Mass?

Archaeology cat
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1665879' date='Sep 28 2008, 11:40 PM']If you've been through RCIA twice already, you may be able to find a priest willing to do private initiation with you. It isn't encouraged, but it can be done in certain circumstances. For example, it is sometimes done with people whose work schedule will not allow them to attend RCIA, or someone like a soldier getting ready to deploy. Tell them the problems you have had in RCIA, and see if the Holy Spirit will touch his heart. You might have luck with an older priest since private instruction was the way it was handled before RCIA was developed.[/quote]
I second this. Or if there's a Landings program at the parish, you might be able to do that. It's technically for lapsed Catholics, but they sometimes make exceptions with those who are already knowledgeable of the Faith, as I imagine you are since you've been through RCIA twice. I actually went through Landings and had private instruction with my priest when I entered the Church.

Thomist-in-Training
Posted

I'm guessing that mortify's question is answered by your mentioning that you have attempted but invalidly received some sacraments... but perhaps not. I would say...

1. Yes, get received into the Church properly, by hook or by crook, and receive the Blessed Eucharist.

2. Look everywhere for a way to do it without RCIA, but if you can't find another way:

grit your teeth and do RCIA,

unless the program is so bad that it actually destroys your faith. Then, do as you've mentioned and keep making spiritual communions.

If you're still in Tennessee, there are (at least) 4 places in Tennessee with Latin Mass centers approved by Rome according to this list :

[url="http://web2.airmail.net/~carlsch/MaterDei/churches.htm"]Approved US & Canada Latin Mass Locations[/url]

and I am sure as anything that if there is one of those that you can get to, you can be received into the Church without RCIA. (Even if they're kinda far, I would call or write anyways, people are helpful and maybe a priest can come see you or knows someone else in your area.)

God bless! Don't let go of your Rosary, and ask Our Lady to help you find a way to be formally received into the Church. I will remember you at Holy Mass today.

she_who_is_not
Posted

Hi everyone,
Thanks for all your advice, counsel, and comments. I certainly appreciate. Prayers, too!
I found out today that I have been coming down with an ear infection which may explain yesterdays rotten mood. I am generally have a more positive approach to things.
When I referred to the recieving invalid sacraments, I was referring to sacraments recieved in the Episcopal church. I recieved Eucharist, Confirmation, and Reconciliation from Episcopalian clergy (Baptism, as well) but as they are not authorized by apostolic succession to confer those sacraments they are not valid. Though I did recieve them in good faith and truly believed that grace was granted or increased by the reception.
Anyway, I will update more when I am feeling better. There is a latin mass nearby. I would love to go. I think the latin mass, as absurd as it sounds, would be more like what I am used to.
Again, thanks for all your support. It's been a long hard road since I read Newman and realized that 'branch theory" was wrong and there is only one true Church. I just hope there is room in her for me.

Posted

of course there's room for you!! I know I can speak for all of us when I say we're delighted that you're joining the Church. I'm so excited for you! God bless. :)

Posted

I am a convert to the Catholic Church and was baptised long before RCIA ever existed. I had private instruction with a priest and then after I had moved to another parish, I asked to be baptised and the Monsignor met with me and asked me a few questions about my faith - and then said I could be baptised at that Christmas' Midnight Mass (a few weeks later).

In a case like yours, I would sincerely think that you could find a priest or Bishop who would make an exception for you, after an interview.

Before doing that however, my first advice is always to take it to Jesus and ask Him what He wants. Prayer is the most powerful force on Earth. Carry everything to God in prayer, and let Him handle the details. Let Him guide you and don't hesitate to tell Him everything you have told us. It isn't as if He doesn't know already, but you need to open your heart to Him in trust, like a child and ask Him to lead you now, and always.

Once you have given it to Him, don't take it back - let Him do whatever needs to be done. He might find a solution that none of us have thought of!

Posted

[quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1666587' date='Sep 29 2008, 09:57 PM']There is a latin mass nearby. I would love to go. I think the latin mass, as absurd as it sounds, would be more like what I am used to.[/quote]

Is this at a Roman Catholic parish? If so, why not just go through RCIA there? Are there not any other parishes or priests around that you can talk to?

To follow up all those questions you were asking yourself in the original post, perhaps all this is happening for a reason, and maybe you're supposed to remain commited to the RCIA class you're already in. Even if they are wacky liberals, it doesn't mean you can't learn anything, assuming your idea of learning isn't restricted to book knowledge.

Posted

Best advice I can give you is speak with a priest. If you don't feel that RCIA is giving you significant teaching or it is not suited for you then speak with your priest about private one on one meetings in which you and he can discuss the teachings of the Church, etc.

Posted

[quote name='Brigid' post='1666701' date='Sep 29 2008, 11:39 PM']of course there's room for you!! I know I can speak for all of us when I say we're delighted that you're joining the Church. I'm so excited for you! God bless. :)[/quote]

All of heaven rejoices when one person comes to Him. :)

Posted

Don't give up, lovely. God bless you. Keep on truckin!

Prayers :sign:

Posted

It really bothers me that I've heard so many negative things about RCIA. It seems to me that people who teach them should be some of the best catechized Catholics there are, capable of correctly teaching things and able to answer the challenging questions of some of the honest, hard searchers I've met. What better way to turn people away from the Church or to introduce doubt than to have ignorant teachers initiating people?

Sorry to add to the rant, it's a sore spot of mine. But I hope that you will grit your teeth and pull through if there is absolutly no other way, because I cannot imagine that a few months of unpleasant RCIA would be worse than living your life without the delightful aid of the Sacraments. They were instituted by Christ for a reason, and they're well worth pulling through RCIA for, especially the Eucharist and Confession. Why give up a lifetime of recieving Christ into your body physically? I think it might be worth it, although I guess, as Thomist said, if it is destroying your faith it obviously isn't. I hope you can find a better way of being recieved though. I'm also curious, why were the programs you were in so bad?

God Bless you! Don't give up the fight for the Church, you certainly deserve to be a part of it! I will pray for you too :)

Posted

I have been involved in some great RCIA programs over the last 20 years, and some truly bad ones. It really depends on the parish, and the DRE or Pastoral Associate in charge of the program. The good programs required all catechists to have theology degrees, the worst one, my last one, allowed neophytes to become catechists and spent half the class on new age stuff.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...