she_who_is_not Posted October 2, 2008 Author Posted October 2, 2008 My issue at the moment is not neccesarily with the quality of instruction, in fact, participating in RCIA has been a great opportunity for me to engage and interact with scripture in some new ways. I grew up in an extremely intellectual spiritual community and enjoy the emphasis on lectio divina, rather than the more scholastic approach I am used to. Though I could tell you some real horror stories. My problem is in the difficulty of attending the two hour classes which fall on an inconvenient day at an inconvenient time. Also, the parish does not comport with my liturgical taste, but I can deal with that. I honestly just can't sacrifice the time. I've prayed about it. The classes certainly provide some spiritual benefit, but at this time, they are not essential to my catechesis. The only impediment to my full profession until this time, has been my belief that my confirmation may possibly be valid. I wished to receive the sacrament conditionally. No DRE has ever felt qualified to discuss this issue, and I have always gotten major avoidance when trying to discuss it with a priest. I come from a tradition where challenge and discussion are used to enhance faith, and where one is encouraged to use your reason in addition to scripture and tradition to answer questions. I always get the impression, that those I question feel I am questioning the authority of the Church or being nitpicky about things. I don't mind being wrong I just want a logical and well reasoned answer as to why I am wrong. Related to my question about confirmation, I want to know how I should feel about the years I recieved the Eucharist and participated in Eucharistic Adoration outside the Church. Was I adoring bread or did my belief that it was indeed the body of Christ change it. I guess the best way to explain this to cradle Catholics is to imagine waking up one day and discovering that your parish priest did not have holy orders. How would feel? It's very troubling to think you had spent your entire life recieving the increase of grace conferred by the sacraments of the living and then finding out that you are somehow not what you thought. Also, I just don't get extraordinary ministers of communion. It justs seems wrong. The only answer I ever get is it is a Vatican II thing. So? Still seems wrong. Maybe I need to read the Vatican II documents. But in the end, this again is a minor issue, and one I probably should not be vexed about. I have never felt as distant from God as I have while I have been seeking full communion. I don't know why. I trust that I have made the right decision and I have prayed for the grace of dying in the Church. I trust that it will happen. Will it happen this year? I don't know. I want to be in an environment where I can ask my questions. Where I don't feel like I am confusing the catechumens, or at least am not told that I am. RCIA is supposed to be for converts from other faith traditions as well as the un-baptized. However, in my experience, the capacity of leaders and team members to effectively work with candidates well-catechized in other traditions is somewhat lacking. I don't see the point in attending. I also wonder if i will always feel lonesome for the Anglican liturgy. It hurts so badly sometimes. I miss the incense, and the altar rail, the chanting of the Gospel, and the altar decked with candles and flowers. I remind myself these things are mere "puff" and pray that I would never make a false deity of the liturgy but, it doesn't cure my lonesomeness. Thanks for your prayers! I really appreciate it. Had a lovely day celebrating St. Therese, yesterday. Sorry, again, for the super long post. Honestly, I am so unbelievably lonely here. I don't have very many opportunities to have real conversations and I think it is addling my head. Peace, Amanda
MStar Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 [quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1668461' date='Oct 2 2008, 11:16 AM']My issue at the moment is not neccesarily with the quality of instruction, in fact, participating in RCIA has been a great opportunity for me to engage and interact with scripture in some new ways. I grew up in an extremely intellectual spiritual community and enjoy the emphasis on lectio divina, rather than the more scholastic approach I am used to. Though I could tell you some real horror stories. My problem is in the difficulty of attending the two hour classes which fall on an inconvenient day at an inconvenient time. Also, the parish does not comport with my liturgical taste, but I can deal with that. I honestly just can't sacrifice the time. I've prayed about it. The classes certainly provide some spiritual benefit, but at this time, they are not essential to my catechesis.[/quote] Then maybe in this case the priest will let you have private instruction. I don't know much about how that works. [quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1668461' date='Oct 2 2008, 11:16 AM']The only impediment to my full profession until this time, has been my belief that my confirmation may possibly be valid. I wished to receive the sacrament conditionally. No DRE has ever felt qualified to discuss this issue, and I have always gotten major avoidance when trying to discuss it with a priest. I come from a tradition where challenge and discussion are used to enhance faith, and where one is encouraged to use your reason in addition to scripture and tradition to answer questions. I always get the impression, that those I question feel I am questioning the authority of the Church or being nitpicky about things. I don't mind being wrong I just want a logical and well reasoned answer as to why I am wrong. Related to my question about confirmation, I want to know how I should feel about the years I recieved the Eucharist and participated in Eucharistic Adoration outside the Church. Was I adoring bread or did my belief that it was indeed the body of Christ change it. I guess the best way to explain this to cradle Catholics is to imagine waking up one day and discovering that your parish priest did not have holy orders. How would feel? It's very troubling to think you had spent your entire life recieving the increase of grace conferred by the sacraments of the living and then finding out that you are somehow not what you thought. Also, I just don't get extraordinary ministers of communion. It justs seems wrong. The only answer I ever get is it is a Vatican II thing. So? Still seems wrong. Maybe I need to read the Vatican II documents. But in the end, this again is a minor issue, and one I probably should not be vexed about.[/quote] Do you mean the sacraments you recieved at the Anglican church? I'm think it would have to be the fact that you did not recieve them in actuality, because Anglicans, as far as I know, don't have the ability to confer them. Like if someone mailed a bunch of letters without stamps or a return address; they think that the letters are getting mailed because they keep putting them in the box, but without the stamps the letters won't arrive properly. Maybe they're even putting 32 cent stamps on and so they think everything's fine, but that doesn't change the fact that the letters won't get delievered because you need the correct 42 cent stamps. Sorry if that's a bad analogy, it's the best I could think of on the spot . As for recieving Communion and Adoration, I guess it must not have really been Christ physically, but I don't think that means you were not recieving some sort of graces from those things. Certainly you meant to be worshipping and recieving God, and I'm sure He would honor that, even though I don't think your belief would change what it actually was. Maybe it would be like if you ate Tofu all your life thinking it was meat; you never meant to be a vegitarian and you didn't think you were, but that doesn't change the fact that you didn't eat meat (I hope it's not disrespectful to draw that kind of analogy! I don't mean to be ) [quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1668461' date='Oct 2 2008, 11:16 AM']I have never felt as distant from God as I have while I have been seeking full communion. I don't know why. I trust that I have made the right decision and I have prayed for the grace of dying in the Church. I trust that it will happen. Will it happen this year? I don't know. I want to be in an environment where I can ask my questions. Where I don't feel like I am confusing the catechumens, or at least am not told that I am. RCIA is supposed to be for converts from other faith traditions as well as the un-baptized. However, in my experience, the capacity of leaders and team members to effectively work with candidates well-catechized in other traditions is somewhat lacking. I don't see the point in attending.[/quote] Yeah, this is where my frustrations with RCIA comes up. My lad is going through the same sort of stuff, and he could probably teach the class better than the team members, but of course that can't be done until he is recieved into the Church. I have a few other convert friends who want to lead the groups themselves (and are) now that they are Catholic, because they know how much good programs are needed. I've been thinking about helping out, but since I'm a cradle Catholic I feel that I don't have enough experience with other traditions, as you said, to effectivly understand where the candidates are coming from. Still, I think that the team members should be open to tough questions, and find answers if they don't know them right off the top of their heads. There's always answers so questions shouldn't be feared but welcomed! Sorry about the super long answer
she_who_is_not Posted October 2, 2008 Author Posted October 2, 2008 (edited) Thanks MStar, I understand that the sacraments aren't valid but I went through my entire life believing that they were. It is troubling. Should I believe the Church just because they say they are correct? Because I have heard some pretty convincing arguments that contend a) apostolic succession was never broken or b) it has been restored through con-celebration of ordinations by Old Catholics. I have read Leo XIII's Apostolicae Curae and am willing to accept it even if I do not neccesarily agree. However, I would like to agree with it. I would like to discuss it with someone. When I asked if I could talk about it, I was laughed at and told "not to be obsessive" I really don't think I am being obsessive. I think I am examining the issues relevant to my own conversion. This is far more relevant to me than elementary discussions on the nature of the trinity or explanations that Catholics don't worship Mary. Now, I'm ranting again. This is why I shouldn't go. RCIA just makes me angry. I'm not the kind of girl who gets angry at things. It isn't spiritually healthy. Really, my feelings are hurt. At the root of this is that whenever I have been involved in RCIA my feelings are hurt. Once before, I was told not to refer to Mary as the Theotokos because it was "politically incorrect." That hurt my feelings. Perhaps, I'm too sensitive. Perhaps, I don't have the inner strength to be a Catholic. I like my old church where we had lovely music and kind people and revered the virgin with her ancient titles. There is a part of me that would rather live a beautiful lie than an ugly truth. I think the devil is certainly mixed up in that. And I have far too much work to do to be worrying about this. Or at least moaning about it. Edited October 2, 2008 by she_who_is_not
Thomist-in-Training Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 [quote name='she_who_is_not' post='1668500' date='Oct 2 2008, 02:57 PM']Thanks MStar, I understand that the sacraments aren't valid but I went through my entire life believing that they were. It is troubling. Should I believe the Church just because they say they are correct? Because I have heard some pretty convincing arguments that contend a) apostolic succession was never broken or b) it has been restored through con-celebration of ordinations by Old Catholics. I have read Leo XIII's Apostolicae Curae and am willing to accept it even if I do not neccesarily agree.[/quote] I read that too, about the issue of possible validity of some Anglican orders. The thing to do would be some detective work on: the Anglican priest or bishop who possibly confirmed you, and his reported line of apostolic succession, and the formula for Orders used by the Anglicans at whatever time. You'd also have to make sure that the Anglican method of confirmation is the same (anointing with oil--possibly has to be blessed by a valid bishop? I'm not sure myself; laying on of hands; are there words?). That's interesting. [quote]Really, my feelings are hurt. At the root of this is that whenever I have been involved in RCIA my feelings are hurt. Once before, I was told not to refer to Mary as the Theotokos because it was "politically incorrect." That hurt my feelings. Perhaps, I'm too sensitive. Perhaps, I don't have the inner strength to be a Catholic. I like my old church where we had lovely music and kind people and revered the virgin with her ancient titles. There is a part of me that would rather live a beautiful lie than an ugly truth. I think the devil is certainly mixed up in that.[/quote] You're not too sensitive at all; the example you give of being told not to call our Lady "Theotokos" is absurd! Any right-thinking person would be angry! I understand perfectly what you mean about a thirst for good liturgy with a pretty church and where people love Our Lady. If I were you I would definitely go to the Latin Mass if you said there is one around--I am quite sure it will be much more what you are used to. About EMHCs, I think they are awful and I wish they would go away. You don't have to feel any need to approve of them. One of many reasons I am glad I am lucky enough to be able to go to the Latin Mass. A "third way" option is, if there are any Byzantine Catholic or other Eastern [i]Catholic [/i]churches in Tennessee. Myself I tried that but found it is quite alien to me, but perhaps you would like that also. And, I'm sure they will have another outlook on how you may be received into the Church... probably wouldn't touch RCIA with a ten-foot pole. Looks like there's one in Seymour, TN... also a group in Nashville that wants to set up a church, but right now just has Divine Liturgies from time to time.
-I---Love Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 I can certainly sympathize with such difficulties. However, wanting to give up is a sign of despair. We are called to hope, not despair. Despair against the Church is from the devil. Not believing that the Sacraments are necessary for Salvation is a heresy. We NEED the Sacraments. One may receive actual grace through ordinary prayer, but there is no sanctifying grace (share in the divine life of God) w/out the Sacraments. I've read through your posts, and what you have described is still not all together clear to me, but if you desire the fullness of Truth, then perserving (the virtue of fortitude) through these RCIA classes, no matter how hard, can serve as a purifying penance. If we only knew the value of suffering, we would desire crosses, said Sts. Padre Pio and Therese to that effect.
somethingfishy Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 As a convert raised in a traditional Anglican church, I feel like I know where you're coming from. It IS hard for those of us raised in a scholastic tradition to understand something with the heart. And Catholicism must be understood both with the mind and with the heart. It took me a long time to come to that kind of understanding. All I can suggest is to open your heart to whatever God wants to teach you. Though you cannot receive him bodily yet, let your heart be a tabernacle of love for him. Build a relationship with him, and be honest about how you are feeling. God will always lead you to himself. Your job is to stay close to him wherever he leads you. I like this prayer, by Thomas Merton. My Lord God, I have no idea where I am going. I do not see the road ahead of me Nor do I really know myself, And the fact that I think I am following Your will Does not mean that I am actually doing so. But I believe that the desire to please You Does in fact please You. And I hope that I will never do anything apart from that desire. And I know that if I do this, You will lead me by the right road Though I may know nothing about it. Therefore will I trust You always though, I may seem to be lost and in the shadow of death. I will not fear, for You are ever with me, And You will never leave me to face my struggles alone. Amen. God be with you in your journey.
Guest jenneffere Posted October 6, 2008 Posted October 6, 2008 I went through RCIA at my church and I can say that during the class I was definitely being tested at some points. At a point I too almost quit, but I prayed hard and realized that it wasn't God that wanted me to quit, it was the devil tempting me. Don't let him win! As far as questions being shot down or not being answered, I hate to say it, I understand that not everything has an answer, but maybe the person teaching your class is not as knowledgable or isn't putting the time or effort into finding answers for you. You might have to find them yourself. I know that our class asked some pretty intense and very hard theological questions. We might not have gotten an answer that week, but the next week we were, because our priest and stand in (our priest was deployed) given an answer and even references we could look at.
she_who_is_not Posted October 18, 2008 Author Posted October 18, 2008 I found a document in the defense directory that seemed to speak directly to me! It helped clear up so many of my questions. I am going to do this. With Jesus and Mary, and all the Saints in heaven to help me and pray for me, I will do it. Phatmass is such a blessing. I would still be living in ignorance and comfort, without the Truth. I appreciate all of y'all so much. God Bless, Amanda
Selah Posted October 19, 2008 Posted October 19, 2008 I know. Phatmass we the best thing to happen to me as well. They've taught me so much
MissyP89 Posted October 19, 2008 Posted October 19, 2008 Hang in there!!! Once it's over and done, you'll be Catholic and never have to go to RCIA ever again! Just trying to be a little light-hearted. Think of it this way, Amanda--nothing worth having in life is ever easy. Stick it out; it'll all be worth it. Prayers for you! Missy
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now