Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Question For The Theologians Out There


Recommended Posts

Madame Vengier
Posted

Those of you who study or have studied theology and are familiar with a wide variety of theologians both liberal and orthodox: Would you consider Karl Rahner "orthodox"? I am about 99.9% sure I know the answer but I'm not a theologian and haven't read Rahner. I need to know this becuase I was in a conversation with a liberal Religious sister who kept talking about "challenging" the Church with "dialolgue" mainly on the issues of male priesthood. She stated that her primary argument against male priesthood was based on Catholic teaching about Baptism. She maintains that by Baptism all Catholics are equal in Christ and have been afforded the same rights through Baptism to receive all the sacraments and to participate equally on the mission of the Church. I was so exasperated at her total lack of knowledge of the subject--I stated to her that the teaching on male priesthood is not just about "because the Apostles were male" but it is a very deep theology and has to be studied. She claimed she has done that and it still makes no sense why some baptized Catholics would be denied rights to sacraments that others have (meaning women can't be priests but men can). I asked her if she had actually read solid Church teaching from a theological perspective and she said "Of course I have! I've read lots of Karl Rahner!" to which I responded that Rahner certainly does NOT fall into the category of "solid and orthodox Catholic theologians" to which she expressed total and complete shock and insisted that he most certainly IS solid and orthodox. Really, I'm not even for certain that she knows what this means. In any case, she's a really nice person but the fact that Karl Rahner is the only answer she gave for what "orthodox theologians" she's read is really kind of sad.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1667992' date='Oct 1 2008, 09:08 PM']Those of you who study or have studied theology and are familiar with a wide variety of theologians both liberal and orthodox: Would you consider Karl Rahner "orthodox"? I am about 99.9% sure I know the answer but I'm not a theologian and haven't read Rahner. I need to know this becuase I was in a conversation with a liberal Religious sister who kept talking about "challenging" the Church with "dialolgue" mainly on the issues of male priesthood. She stated that her primary argument against male priesthood was based on Catholic teaching about Baptism. She maintains that by Baptism all Catholics are equal in Christ and have been afforded the same rights through Baptism to receive all the sacraments and to participate equally on the mission of the Church. I was so exasperated at her total lack of knowledge of the subject--I stated to her that the teaching on male priesthood is not just about "because the Apostles were male" but it is a very deep theology and has to be studied. She claimed she has done that and it still makes no sense why some baptized Catholics would be denied rights to sacraments that others have (meaning women can't be priests but men can). I asked her if she had actually read solid Church teaching from a theological perspective and she said "Of course I have! I've read lots of Karl Rahner!" to which I responded that Rahner certainly does NOT fall into the category of "solid and orthodox Catholic theologians" to which she expressed total and complete shock and insisted that he most certainly IS solid and orthodox. Really, I'm not even for certain that she knows what this means. In any case, she's a really nice person but the fact that Karl Rahner is the only answer she gave for what "orthodox theologians" she's read is really kind of sad.[/quote]

He's good friends with Ratzinger and Ratzinger dedicated a book to him and wrote a book in his honor. Rahner is, so far as I have ever heard, solid orthodox. I read some of his, "Theological Investigations" back in 11th grade, so I can't say I remember anything, but I never remember reading anything that would constitute "unorthodox".

He has fascinating ideas on "the fall" and Origional Sin.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1667996' date='Oct 1 2008, 10:13 PM']He's good friends with Ratzinger and Ratzinger dedicated a book to him and wrote a book in his honor. Rahner is, so far as I have ever heard, solid orthodox. I read some of his, "Theological Investigations" back in 11th grade, so I can't say I remember anything, but I never remember reading anything that would constitute "unorthodox".

He has fascinating ideas on "the fall" and Origional Sin.[/quote]


The only "nonorthodox" idea of his I have ever heard of is his notion of "anonymous Christians". I have heard Ratzinger reference this isea, and ot the idea from the tone of his language that he rejects the notion, but he never attacked it as wrong.

Posted

I believe Ratzinger himself said that Rahner was orthodox, and that was the exact word he used. However he is associated with a more liberal approach to theology than is popular nowadays. He was very "in" back in the 60s and 70s and you will find clergy and religious from that era are quite fond of him.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Maggie' post='1668019' date='Oct 1 2008, 10:27 PM']I believe Ratzinger himself said that Rahner was orthodox, and that was the exact word he used. However he is associated with a more liberal approach to theology than is popular nowadays. He was very "in" back in the 60s and 70s and you will find clergy and religious from that era are quite fond of him.[/quote]


The tricky part is that Ratzinger also was considered "liberal" back in that same era. It is a fact that he himself stated (in his memoirs I do believe) that he had a distinct turn-around at some juncture and moved away from that to a more completely orthodox adherence.

I'm still waiting for the Phatmass theologians to answer, though. I really just don't know myself so I want to be sure.

Posted

My Ecclesiology professor last semester had done her doctoral dissertation on Rahner, and she was on the liberal side, so that makes me think he can be questioning of things that maybe makes the rest of us uncomfortable. I actually like his "anonymous Christians" theory. I have a lot of family members that I'd like to think could fall under that category.

I think one of the problems that we deal with when dealing with these freakishly smart theologians, is that sometimes they are so smart, such an expert in a particular area, that they simply ask questions about things that are settled, and don't need study or discussion. My mom would say that they have gotten too big for their britches.

Posted

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1668028' date='Oct 1 2008, 10:35 PM']The tricky part is that Ratzinger also was considered "liberal" back in that same era. It is a fact that he himself stated (in his memoirs I do believe) that he had a distinct turn-around at some juncture and moved away from that to a more completely orthodox adherence.

I'm still waiting for the Phatmass theologians to answer, though. I really just don't know myself so I want to be sure.[/quote]
I have read Ratzinger's autobiography. I do not remember any big swing from the left. I beleive he once supported more lay involvement in the Church. I think his liberalism was more related to Liturgical issues than anything that would have to do with women being ordained.

His praise of Rahner that I read was recent.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1668038' date='Oct 1 2008, 09:37 PM'][b][size=4]My Ecclesiology professor last semester had done her doctoral dissertation on Rahner, and she was on the liberal side, so that makes me think he can be questioning of things that maybe makes the rest of us uncomfortable[/size].[/b] I actually like his "anonymous Christians" theory. I have a lot of family members that I'd like to think could fall under that category.

I think one of the problems that we deal with when dealing with these freakishly smart theologians, is that sometimes they are so smart, such an expert in a particular area, that they simply ask questions about things that are settled, and don't need study or discussion. My mom would say that they have gotten too big for their britches.[/quote]

I don't think that's fair.

I'm not a conservative Catholic, nor a practicing Catholic, nor do I consider myself a Catholic anymore. My point is that I am quite sure that I am much more unorthodox than your professor and I draw a great deal of inspiration from Ratzinger(not pre Vatican II more liberal Ratzinger, but today's Ratzinger).

Intelectually I'd probably be more inclined towards Hans Kung, yet I have always considered Ratzinger a deeper thinker, drawn on Ratzinger a lot, and believe him to be one of the most profound thinkers of the 20th century.

So simply because your professor does draw on Rahner does not mean Rahner is liberal as well.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1668038' date='Oct 1 2008, 09:37 PM'][b][size=4]My Ecclesiology professor last semester had done her doctoral dissertation on Rahner, and she was on the liberal side, so that makes me think he can be questioning of things that maybe makes the rest of us uncomfortable[/size].[/b] I actually like his "anonymous Christians" theory. I have a lot of family members that I'd like to think could fall under that category.

I think one of the problems that we deal with when dealing with these freakishly smart theologians, is that sometimes they are so smart, such an expert in a particular area, that they simply ask questions about things that are settled, and don't need study or discussion. My mom would say that they have gotten too big for their britches.[/quote]

I don't think that's fair.

I'm not a conservative Catholic, nor a practicing Catholic, nor do I consider myself a Catholic anymore. My point is that I am quite sure that I am much more unorthodox than your professor and I draw a great deal of inspiration from Ratzinger(not pre Vatican II more liberal Ratzinger, but today's Ratzinger).

Intelectually I'd probably be more inclined towards Hans Kung, yet I have always considered Ratzinger a deeper thinker, drawn on Ratzinger a lot, and believe him to be one of the most profound thinkers of the 20th century.

So simply because your professor does draw on Rahner does not mean Rahner is liberal as well.

Brother Adam
Posted

I'm not a PM theologian and my research experience with Rahner is his revelation theology which I find extremely difficult to call orthodox, though it is certainly influential in Catholic theology. I've never heard of Ratzinger calling him a solid orthodox thinker so I'd be interested in a quote. I most often hear Rahner quoted by religious sisters and very liberal educators who do so to support theological dissent. I know he has influenced the experiential view of worship at our current parish.

Posted

Karl Rahner advocated a change in Church teaching against contraception.

goldenchild17
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1667992' date='Oct 1 2008, 09:08 PM']Those of you who study or have studied theology and are familiar with a wide variety of theologians both liberal and orthodox: Would you consider Karl Rahner "orthodox"? I am about 99.9% sure I know the answer but I'm not a theologian and haven't read Rahner. I need to know this becuase I was in a conversation with a liberal Religious sister who kept talking about "challenging" the Church with "dialolgue" mainly on the issues of male priesthood. She stated that her primary argument against male priesthood was based on Catholic teaching about Baptism. She maintains that by Baptism all Catholics are equal in Christ and have been afforded the same rights through Baptism to receive all the sacraments and to participate equally on the mission of the Church. I was so exasperated at her total lack of knowledge of the subject--I stated to her that the teaching on male priesthood is not just about "because the Apostles were male" but it is a very deep theology and has to be studied. She claimed she has done that and it still makes no sense why some baptized Catholics would be denied rights to sacraments that others have (meaning women can't be priests but men can). I asked her if she had actually read solid Church teaching from a theological perspective and she said "Of course I have! I've read lots of Karl Rahner!" to which I responded that Rahner certainly does NOT fall into the category of "solid and orthodox Catholic theologians" to which she expressed total and complete shock and insisted that he most certainly IS solid and orthodox. Really, I'm not even for certain that she knows what this means. In any case, she's a really nice person but the fact that Karl Rahner is the only answer she gave for what "orthodox theologians" she's read is really kind of sad.[/quote]

Considering my non-Catholic tag, take this for what its worth (not much) but I consider Rahner to be in the top 10 most influential yet heretical men in the church of the 20th century. If you want I can send you some articles about him and his positions, just email me.

Edited by goldenchild17
LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1668192' date='Oct 2 2008, 01:03 AM']I'm not a PM theologian...[/quote]

You are part of the exclusive "Church Militant" group ;)

Brother Adam
Posted

You need to be elevated to "Church Scholar" by dUSt though to be part of that "PM theologian" group. Maybe I will get it when I get my MA, but hopefully by the time my PhD is done.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Brother Adam' post='1668192' date='Oct 1 2008, 11:03 PM']I most often hear Rahner quoted by religious sisters and very liberal educators who do so to support theological dissent. I know he has influenced the experiential view of worship at our current parish.[/quote]


Exactly. That's why I'm wondering about this.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Dave' post='1668205' date='Oct 1 2008, 11:32 PM']Karl Rahner advocated a change in Church teaching against contraception.[/quote]

Definitely doesn't sound orthodox!

I think one of the problems here is something that this Sister I mentioned says a lot which is that she considers herself "a traditional Catholic" and that she doesn't see herself in dissent but rather as exercising her right as a Baptized Christian to challenge the Church to "an open dialogue". She claims she is not so much angry at the teachings as she is at the Magisterium for refusing to even engage in dialogue on these "issues" (hers mainly being male priesthood--I don't know her feelings on contraception and other things, though she is against abortion, and she also has deep-seated issues with "exclusive language"--that is referring to God by a male pronoun--she believes this is "oppressive".) Naturally, I do not agree with her on any of this but it certainly gives me another perspective on the liberal, dissenting mentality. If many liberal Catholics have this same perspective on "dissenting" (i.e. that they are not dissenting at all but only exercising their right to challenge the Church) then it would certainly explain why they consider Rahner a bastion of right theology.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='goldenchild17' post='1668452' date='Oct 2 2008, 11:51 AM']Considering my non-Catholic tag, take this for what its worth (not much) but I consider Rahner to be in the top 10 most influential yet heretical men in the church of the 20th century. If you want I can send you some articles about him and his positions, just email me.[/quote]


Thanks for the offer of the articles but to be honest I don't have any personal interest in reading Rahner. I have loads of stuff to read--it is in a pile almost as high as I am tall. I really just wanted someone to confirm (or correct, if I was mistaken) what I already thought on Rahner's orthodoxy...or lack thereof.

Noel's angel
Posted (edited)

Some people 'made up' and interview with Rahner, using excerpts from his writings and from interviews he gave in the last years of his life. Here's one interesting part:

Toe: Taking for granted the Church’s teaching of the hierarchy of truth, are there some areas in which your own theology exercises its freedom to disagree with the opinions of Church authority?

Rahner: This is a difficult question. I can point to two areas. One has to do with the question of birth control. "On the one hand,… I am obliged to attach great importance to the position of the highest authority in the Catholic Church presented" in the birth control encyclical. "On the other hand, I also have the right and the duty not to consider such a position simply and absolutely the last word, but to give it more thought and eventually to reach my own personal position, assumed on my own responsibility." Without saying "that this is my solid, my clear, my unequivocal conviction," "I would rather think that the approval of certain forms of contraceptives "would not conflict with the essential Catholic conception of sexuality."20

Toe: What do you think about the question of the ordination of women?

Rahner: "When the Vatican declaration against the ordination of women (even in the future) came out a few years back, I published an article saying that it failed to convince me. (Of course, it was not an infallible definition). Rome is digging in its heels, it seems to me, against the development that one ought to admit calmly might not be a bad thing."21

Edited by Noel's angel
Posted

Rahner is an interesting theologian. He did come up with some good insights, yet ultimately he was/is a mere theologian. He had no authority of himself. And so, as is often the case with theologians (even Aquinas himself) they come up with some good insights in which the faithful can build on and some incorrect insights which the faithful will reject in time.

There are three levels of teaching in the Church

Infallible teachings/dogma

Non-infallible teachings/doctrine

Theological speculation/pious opinion

The three levels are an important part of the Church and her mission to save and proclaim truth to the world. Some of Rahners' (even Ratzingers) writings fall into theological speculation, thus the Faithful must meditate and consider and weigh their teachings against Sacred Tradition and Sacred Scripture and Sacred Magisterium.

It is quite possible that Rahner did indeed come up with some good insights, yet he may have been wrong about other things.

Time will tell.

Posted

[quote name='Dave' post='1668205' date='Oct 2 2008, 12:32 AM']Karl Rahner advocated a change in Church teaching against contraception.[/quote]
More than that, he advocated for a position of "loyal dissent" or "freedom of conscience" with regard to contraception which grew into an ugly, ugly thing in the hands of many priests around the world. Rahner himself did not take it to the point of heresy (unlike, say, Charles Curran), but he provided the theological groundwork for millions of people to dissent from longstanding church teaching on contraception. This was in the wake of [i]Humanae Vitae[/i]

Like many theologians, Rahner has had good and bad points. I think he meant well with his positions on dissent and conscience. He may have changed his tune in the 40 years since he wrote on the topic; I am not as familiar with his more recent work as I am with his response to [i]Humanae Vitae[/i]. I think some of the reason for his concern was dealing with the pastoral problems (and there were many) that bishops and parish priests faced when [i]Humanae Vitae[/i] was issued. Rahner was not alone in his feelings on this subject. Many, many church leaders, including bishop councils in countries like Canada and Germany (and several others) strongly questioned Pope John VI's encyclical.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...