mortify Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 Karl Rahner apparently rejected the literal physical resurrection of Christ.
kafka Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1668608' date='Oct 2 2008, 06:51 PM']Karl Rahner apparently rejected the literal physical resurrection of Christ.[/quote] that seems highly unlikely. Any quotes?
goldenchild17 Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1668563' date='Oct 2 2008, 04:59 PM']Thanks for the offer of the articles but to be honest I don't have any personal interest in reading Rahner. I have loads of stuff to read--it is in a pile almost as high as I am tall. I really just wanted someone to confirm (or correct, if I was mistaken) what I already thought on Rahner's orthodoxy...or lack thereof.[/quote] not a problem. but just to clarify, they are articles about Rahner and the Catholicity of his theology, not articles of his articles themselves. But yeah I know what you mean about having too much to read.
mortify Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 [quote name='kafka' post='1668645' date='Oct 2 2008, 07:07 PM']that seems highly unlikely. Any quotes?[/quote] Unfortunately its very real, just google it.
Noel's angel Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 (edited) The Jesuit Karl Rahner once wrote, "it is obvious that the resurrection of Jesus neither can be nor intends to be a `historical' event" (p. 277). Hans Küng makes essentially the same point, but in greater detail. He believes in a no-material resurrection. Is that right? Eh? Edited October 2, 2008 by Noel's angel
mortify Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 When atheists use our prominent theologians to *discredit* the resurrection, you know we're living in a "Dark Age" of the Church.
kafka Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 [quote name='Noel's angel' post='1668675' date='Oct 2 2008, 07:33 PM']The Jesuit Karl Rahner once wrote, "it is obvious that the resurrection of Jesus neither can be nor intends to be a `historical' event" (p. 277). Hans Küng makes essentially the same point, but in greater detail. Eh?[/quote] weird. I wonder if he meant it in some other context. The Resurrection of course is infallible and it seems that a theologian of his stature wouldnt deny that. It doesnt make sense. What book are you quoting?
Noel's angel Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 I'm reading it from a site. It doesn't give the name of the book. Maybe the guy just made it up.
mortify Posted October 2, 2008 Posted October 2, 2008 I personally came accross it several months ago when I picked up a book in Barnes and Noble, unfortunately I can't recall the name.
Madame Vengier Posted October 3, 2008 Author Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='Barbarus' post='1668603' date='Oct 2 2008, 05:46 PM']More than that, he advocated for a position of "loyal dissent" or "freedom of conscience" with regard to contraception which grew into an ugly, ugly thing in the hands of many priests around the world. Rahner himself did not take it to the point of heresy (unlike, say, Charles Curran), but he provided the theological groundwork for millions of people to dissent from longstanding church teaching on contraception. This was in the wake of [i]Humanae Vitae[/i] Like many theologians, Rahner has had good and bad points. I think he meant well with his positions on dissent and conscience. He may have changed his tune in the 40 years since he wrote on the topic; I am not as familiar with his more recent work as I am with his response to [i]Humanae Vitae[/i]. I think some of the reason for his concern was dealing with the pastoral problems (and there were many) that bishops and parish priests faced when [i]Humanae Vitae[/i] was issued. Rahner was not alone in his feelings on this subject. Many, many church leaders, including bishop councils in countries like Canada and Germany (and several others) strongly questioned Pope John VI's encyclical.[/quote] Thanks. I think that gives me the answer I was looking for. Clearly the Sister I was speaking to doesn't have the first clue as to what an "orthodox theologian" is since when I asked her if she had ever read one she replied Karl Rahner and then was incredulous when I stated that he wasn't orthodox. She was so incredulous that I had to double check. This is the same sister who also told me that Jesus never revealed God as our Father becuase the Hebrew word "Abba" didn't mean father 2,000 years ago, but rather it was a word that "indicated a paternal relationship for either gender". Just such utter nonsense. It's really sad, actually.
CatherineM Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 We discussed Rahner today in Pastoral Theology. The issue of female ordination has been deemed by the Holy See as closed for discussion. Therefore those who wish to debate about it and push for it, can not call themselves orthodox.
Madame Vengier Posted October 3, 2008 Author Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1668715' date='Oct 2 2008, 08:24 PM']We discussed Rahner today in Pastoral Theology. The issue of female ordination has been deemed by the Holy See as closed for discussion. Therefore those who wish to debate about it and push for it, can not call themselves orthodox.[/quote] That's exactly what I said to this Sister. Almost word for word. She insists the Magisterium doesn't have a right to tell Catholics what they can and cannot discuss. In any case, this is all very, very old and played out. Liberal theology is tired, played out and has nothing to offer. All it does is make these liberals miserable and unhappy all the time.
CatherineM Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='Madame Vengier' post='1668732' date='Oct 2 2008, 07:44 PM']That's exactly what I said to this Sister. Almost word for word. She insists the Magisterium doesn't have a right to tell Catholics what they can and cannot discuss. In any case, this is all very, very old and played out. Liberal theology is tired, played out and has nothing to offer. All it does is make these liberals miserable and unhappy all the time.[/quote] The church can certainly tell us what is closed for discussion. I mean we don't discuss whether Jesus was divine anymore. That was settled, and we've moved on. There are so many things in theology to discuss, why bother with settled things? You're right, they do seem really miserable. They remind me of old cranky guys who put signs up on their lawns complaining about something weird, or the ones that disrupt city council meetings all the time.
mortify Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 I don't understand the sister's argument about baptism effacing our gender and that suddenly the sacerdotal priesthood becomes available to all.
CatherineM Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1668765' date='Oct 2 2008, 08:18 PM']I don't understand the sister's argument about baptism effacing our gender and that suddenly the sacerdotal priesthood becomes available to all.[/quote] You don't understand it, because it's gobbledygook. It's good that you don't understand it. That is your little voice telling you that something is against the rules.
eagle_eye222001 Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 This "baptism" argument sounds like a typical argument a non-Catholic would use. An argument where your evidence does not really support what you want it to support but you pretend it supports it. In the case of a bible verse, you make the verse say something it is not really saying.
Madame Vengier Posted October 3, 2008 Author Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='mortify' post='1668765' date='Oct 2 2008, 08:18 PM']I don't understand the sister's argument about baptism effacing our gender and that suddenly the sacerdotal priesthood becomes available to all.[/quote] She didn't say (and I didn't say she said) that she believes Baptism "effaces" our gender. You said that. She believes that through Baptism we have complete gender equality and that as such there is no right in denying women certain ministries in the Church. The great problem here is that "equality" never means "we all can do the same thing". I called her attention to the Scripture which talks about how many members have different gifts. She still doesn't see that as evidence of why only men can be priests. It really doesn't matter--she's in rebellion, period. And the Bible has something to say about people in rebellion, too.
Madame Vengier Posted October 3, 2008 Author Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1669097' date='Oct 3 2008, 12:59 AM']This "baptism" argument sounds like a typical argument a non-Catholic would use.[/quote] How could you know, since when you posted this I had not yet even gone into detail or clarified the sister's Baptism argument?
Madame Vengier Posted October 3, 2008 Author Posted October 3, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1668873' date='Oct 2 2008, 10:15 PM']You don't understand it, because it's gobbledygook.[/quote] It is, it really, really is. When you listen to them talk and try to make sense of what they are saying it's just arguments built on sand. The thoughts just float in and out of their mouths with no foundation or substance. And they are so angry. And miserable in their dissent. It's sad--I said that before and I really mean it--it makes me sad.
Pio Nono Posted October 3, 2008 Posted October 3, 2008 JMJ 10/3 - Twenty-sixth Friday I don't know if this will help, but this is the first draft of a VERY short assignment on Karl Rahner's method. I hope it gives some of the background to his thought, especially his concern to be "supratemporal" or "transhistorical". I'm no Rahnerian, by the way. I think he's faulty in many, many ways. And neither am I a good writer, so read at your own risk. [quote]Rahner’s “Transcendental” Apologetics Karl Rahner sets forth his method of apologetics in his work Hearer of the Word. This method, which can be called “transcendental,” is one which seeks to discover the necessary preconditions if man is to receive a revelation from God, assuming that man is capable of receiving such a revelation and God is capable of giving it. Rahner uses this method in the context of a general transcendental movement in the philosophy of religion. The secular form of this movement, which was key to the Modernist controversy, held that no historical event had metaphysical value. Thus, no individual could say that he had received a definitive revelation from God. Dogmatic definitions, therefore, which were necessarily historical declarations, had no real binding force and could change over time. This idea itself came out of the thought of men like David Hume and the continental rationalists of the eighteenth and nineteenth centuries. Hume held that causality did not exist in itself, but was simply our conclusion derived from the constant juxtaposition of two events. For instance, hemlock does not cause the death of Socrates. I merely observe the juxtaposition of the events “Socrates drinks hemlock” and “Socrates dies” enough times to conclude, “Hemlock caused the death of Socrates.” In Hume’s mind, there is no causal connection between consuming poison and dying. The continental rationalists held a priori that man had no free will. The deterministic universe of Newton made it clear to these men that free will was an illusion. This presented philosophers with a twofold problem. On the one hand, causality was no longer regarded as true, making everything “without cause,” so to speak. On the other, the Newtonian, deterministic universe required causality if it were to function at all. Philosophy was nearing a dead-end, so to speak. Immanuel Kant sought to reconcile these two views by providing a philosophy of free will that agreed with a Humian philosophy of acausality. Thus, he posited a bifurcated world of phenomena – the things we sense – and the noumenon – reality in itself. He and his disciples used this distinction to argue that God, who dwells in the noumenon, cannot reveal Himself to mankind, who dwells exclusively in the phenomenal world. Since man has no direct access to the noumenon, he cannot know God. Karl Rahner seeks to maintain Kant’s distinction while holding that, indeed, God is capable of revealing and man is capable of receiving such a revelation. He seeks to set up a philosophy of religion, therefore, that is capable of validating epistemically the belief that, a priori, man has the capacity to listen to a revelation from God (cf. 5).[/quote]
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now