Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

I was searching online for pictures of St. Brigid (so I could make more pretty personal photos :) ) when I ran across a site for a Catholic church in Australia named after her. I wondered if they had any statues or windows of her in their church (I found one in Canada that did, which is now my current personal photo ^_^ ), so I was looking through their photo albums. While looking at the Christmas Eve album, I found this:

[img]http://i195.photobucket.com/albums/z266/Brigid_Ireland/random/2176561771_faa79d9db9.jpg[/img]
[i]Bernadette, one of our Samoan parishioners, dances with a machete during the Offertory Procession [/i]

I mean... seriously? seriously?? I'd heard that it happened, but it didn't really hit home until I saw this. people actually do add random dance moves to the Mass.

*shivers*

it's not a situation where it's acceptable because of the culture, is it? I mean, I guess I don't know much about the Australian or Samoan culture, so I can't say for sure. but if I had to guess, I'd guess that that wasn't the case.

I complain about the little abuses at my parish, but when I see stuff like this, I'm grateful. thank goodness my parish doesn't believe this is acceptable. :(

Edited by Brigid
Posted (edited)

Ahh, you should see the African dusters...they bring up the offertory gifts with feather dusters.

Also, the Paulist women (though they aren't technically Paulists) can be pretty intense when they have incense bowls in their hands.

[url="http://www.paulist.org/150/story_gala.php#"]http://www.paulist.org/150/story_gala.php#[/url]

I won't tell you where I am in those pictures, but I'm not the women.

Edited by qfnol31
Archaeology cat
Posted

I like the look on the face of the woman immediately to the right of the dancer in the picture. I mean, her look is like "this should not be happening!". Happy to say I've never encountered this particular happening.

Posted

Some dance like that happened on tv down under at world youth day. Afterwards, someone emailed Life on the Rock and asked if it was a pagan ritual. Fr. Mark explained that the dance was okay since it was apart of the culture. Then Doug went on this long tirade about how we don't know that much about other people's cultures and that we need to learn more about them and be more considerate. I think that he spent too much time talking about that, besides the real issues were whether or not it pagan and if it was a valid thing to do at mass, and not cultural intolerance.

Posted

We had a woman do a liturgical dance last Easter. I can't remember now if it was to a song, or to one of the readings. I mean, she's got a BFA, so she can certainly dance, but I just found it creepy for some reason. She was wearing this white tissue kind of flowing dress that reminded me of a costume from Midsummer's Night Dream. Maybe it was from some play she did in college. I hope she doesn't do it again. She had just gotten baptized the year before, and our former pastoral assistant who just died, was very liberal about such things. It certainly wasn't cultural in any way, except she's Irish, so I guess maybe Druid.

Posted

Liturgical dance is not approved in the US. Write your bishop please.

Posted

This probably won't happen since our pastoral associate passed away. She was the force behind these kinds of things.

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1698946' date='Nov 10 2008, 12:06 PM']Liturgical dance is not approved in the US. Write your bishop please.[/quote]

Well, we are Canadian, not American... Not sure what the official stance of the CCCB is.

Posted

Ridiculous. Is it the mass or a pow wow?

Ive seen pretty bad before too. A young woman in way too pants and top dancing with a bowl of water and this was the Easter Vigil weird eh?

Posted

[quote name='thessalonian' post='1698946' date='Nov 10 2008, 11:06 AM']Liturgical dance is not approved in the US. Write your bishop please.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
umm, hello? brigid said it was in Australia. they might have different rules there.

Posted

I thought he was responding to Catherine. Either way, none of us are American.

dominicansoul
Posted (edited)

during the offertory at Mass for the feast day of Our Lady of Guadalupe in most of the churches in my area, dancers in traditional Aztec dress dance up the aisle...i think i saw this at St. Juan Diego's canonization Mass, too.

I don't believe it belongs in the Mass, but since higher ups don't stop it...i don't know what else to think about it...

it's disturbing...

Edited by dominicansoul
Posted

This is in Australia, among Samoans. I doubt reporting this to your bishop is going to help much. A little open mindness might be nice on this phorum. Attitudes here scare me more then someone dancing in their culture at their Mass in their country.,

Posted

Only place I know it may be allowed is africa. Ask cappie but I seem to remember him saying it wasn't allowed in australia.

Posted

[quote name='alicemary' post='1699041' date='Nov 10 2008, 02:40 PM']This is in Australia, among Samoans. I doubt reporting this to your bishop is going to help much. A little open mindness might be nice on this phorum. Attitudes here scare me more then someone dancing in their culture at their Mass in their country.,[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
:rolleyes: and sometimes your 'whatever goes' attitude scares me.

Maria_Faustina
Posted

[quote name='qfnol31' post='1698757' date='Nov 10 2008, 01:53 AM']Also, the Paulist women (though they aren't technically Paulists) can be pretty intense when they have incense bowls in their hands.

[url="http://www.paulist.org/150/story_gala.php#"]http://www.paulist.org/150/story_gala.php#[/url][/quote]

Ah yes, my home parish would be one of the ones that thinks a woman dancing with incense at the Epiphany is absolutely necessary and...symbolic, and...um.. well, I was going to say "liturgically allowed," but sadly, I know my parish defies the liturgy with full knowledge (they do the same with the Gloria, for example...because our music director doesn't have a version of it he likes, he just leaves it out sometimes. He and the other people that decide the music have actually told each other "We won't tell if you don't", *wink wink* You think the priest would notice...). And like someone above said, the girl who usually does it is actually a very good dancer.. she's a friend of my family. But you already knew all this, Brigid. :)

Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1699031' date='Nov 10 2008, 05:06 PM']+J.M.J.+
umm, hello? brigid said it was in Australia. they might have different rules there.[/quote]

It doesn't matter what country or "culture" it is. Liturgical dance is NEVER appropriate at Mass under any circumstances. If there is some dispensation existing somewhere that permits it, that dispensation should be revoked immediately. Please indicate the city in Australia that this occured so the appropriate bishop can be made aware.

Posted

I don't so much have a problem if it is cultural, and it is on a specific feast day. I think the First Nation church here does something like that, but what happened at our church, at Easter no less, was not in anyway cultural, it was just "interpretation."

Posted

[quote name='daytondog' post='1699075' date='Nov 10 2008, 03:30 PM']It doesn't matter what country or "culture" it is. Liturgical dance is NEVER appropriate at Mass under any circumstances. If there is some dispensation existing somewhere that permits it, that dispensation should be revoked immediately. Please indicate the city in Australia that this occured so the appropriate bishop can be made aware.[/quote]
+J.M.J.+
you best check yourself. it IS allowed in Africa (not sure if all cultures/countries though).

Posted

Allowances are made for 'mission lands'. Australia, America and Europe are not among those places where such allowances are made for cultural reasons.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...