tinytherese Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 [quote name='dominicansoul' post='1700661' date='Nov 13 2008, 02:32 PM']i have to say something, with all due respect...and you know i love you missy... i think that in the past few months, there has been a widespread effort to be overly critical of people's post on this phorum. I can honestly say, I do not believe posters here want to be rude, or insensitive... People are just posting ideas and thoughts and observations. We need to chill and take them for what they are, with a grain of salt. I can't help but feel that the majority of those who have been calling people out for rudeness and "uncharitableness" have themselves been rude and uncharitable in the manner in which they criticize others. It is like you all have been riding a high horse, whether it be in this section or the election section or wherever...you guys are not right all the time, in fact, you can be downright judgmental! "Where is Christ in you all?" That's a bit harsh, don't you think? CHRIST is in all of us, and He loves the most wretched of us all..(that's me!) And how do you know God likes the dancing? Why didn't God approve of Cain's offering? Why did He only approve of Abel's? Think about it. Why did God give the Jews such detailed rubrics on how to worship Him? Why has He continued to give us rubrics to follow in the Mass? There is a certain manner God wants us to approach Him at His Altar. It isn't fair for groups and people with agendas to push their own ideas into the worship at Mass. Mass is too too Sacred for other's inspirations. We must use the norms God has given us through His Church. Lest "Mass" becomes a do-whatever-appeals-to-us-free-for-all...which sadly, it has become in certain places...and yes, it definitely does affect the Faith in those areas! God isn't the one turning His nose up at dancers...it's the other way around...we turn our noses up at God when we decide what is the better way to worship Him....[/quote]
MissyP89 Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 (edited) Okay, DS, let me try again. I was having a rough moment when I posted that--so I apologise for blowing up. (And on an irrelevant note, I posted I think twice in the election section...I did my best effort to avoid being there, because I knew it was a situation that would bring out my rough side.) I think liturgical dance is ... odd. I don't think it belongs in America, or anywhere else, really. I do respect that in some cultures, honor and praise can be shown in different ways. Look at the charismatic movement within the Church, for example. Anyhow, what I was trying to say is that I thought it was rather silly that we were criticizing this woman. Someone brought up the question of Samoan culture, and I think it deserves some looking into. Remember WYD? Raymond Arroyo said during the commentary that it was a traditional dance of the indigenous people there. There were tons of cultures represented there, and for that reason, I thought it was okay. (What was not okay was the crazy music. There still needs to be an element of the sacred in the music we use for worship.) Regarding my other comments: I'll be honest, I was just frustrated. I feel like we as a phamily can be overly nitpicky and critical...at the end of the day, Jesus is still really present in a valid Mass. Maybe it's because my church is one of those hippy NO parishes (I am there for the wonderful priests), but I'm not terribly sensitive to odd things going on at Mass, because I go for Jesus, and He still comes even if there is craziness involved. Edit: About standards of worship and knowing what God desires, I can't speak for Him. I just have my doubts that God would be less appreciative of our worship if it isn't what he would ideally desires from us. The only analogy I can think of here is that if my OH were to get me roses instead of carnations (my favorites), I would still be touched by the gesture, even if I don't particular care for roses. A honest question: David danced before the Lord in the Ark. Was that wrong of him? Not trying to make an argument here, trying to get your perspective. I hope that what I'm trying to convey makes more sense now; I meant no animosity in saying what I did earlier and above. Pax Christi, Missy Edited November 13, 2008 by MissyP89
dominicansoul Posted November 13, 2008 Posted November 13, 2008 I hear ya, Missy! And I knew you would understand where I was coming from, because I would never want to offend you by any of my posts... Your points are very well taken. You are right, in order for our points to be taken more seriously, we do need to give them more lovingly. Criticizing this dancer was a big no-no, and we need to be more aware of seeing people where they are at in their faith formation. How do we know where this woman's heart was while she danced? She may as very well have been lifting it up to God. In that case, we cannot judge her heart and know what God thought of it all... I belong to a parish that has a school. During the week, the students go to Adoration with the faculty and staff. I always cringe when I see these teachers reprimanding students because they are not "paying attention" by talking to each other, or playing with their hand-held nintendo's (or whatever they are called these days...) and text messaging...I cringe because getting angry at them doesn't TEACH those children anything about JESUS in the BLESSED SACRAMENT. The reason they are behaving in such a manner, is because they have no real relationship with Christ, and they are oblivious to what their Faith is all about. IN that, these TEACHERS have failed as instructors of the Faith. We all know Catechesis has suffered greatly these 40 years... My first thought would be to let these kids be kids before the Blessed Sacrament. Their hearts are not purposely offending Jesus...they seem clueless on how to behave in Church, but so do so many of these adults and teachers, too! I always have to think that Jesus loves them "where they are at" and HE's working on them...and what can I do to spread the Fullness of our Faith, so that one day, they will be able to come to Adoration without all the distractions? As for David, I know he danced before the Ark of the Covenant NAKED...not sure if I would want to see that start happening at the Mass!
CatherineM Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 We actually discussed liturgical dance in pastoral theology. The consensus was not positive.
cmotherofpirl Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 [quote name='alicemary' post='1699041' date='Nov 10 2008, 05:40 PM']This is in Australia, among Samoans. I doubt reporting this to your bishop is going to help much. A little open mindness might be nice on this phorum. Attitudes here scare me more then someone dancing in their culture at their Mass in their country.,[/quote] DANCING, LITURGICAL Moving rhythmically to music as part of a religious ceremony. Certain forms of dancing have at various times been introduced into Catholic worship, but the Church has set down two conditions. First, to the extent to which the body is a reflection of the soul, dancing has to express sentiments of faith and adoration in order to become a prayer. And second, dancing must be under the discipline of competent Church authority. "Concretely, there are cultures in which this is possible in so far as dancing is still reflective of religious values and becomes a clear manifestation of them. Such is the case among the Ethiopians. In their cultures, even today, there is the religious ritualized dance, clearly distinct from the martial dance and from the amorous dance." The same is found among Christians in the Syriac and Byzantine traditions. "However, the same criterion and judgment cannot be applied in the Western culture. Here dancing is tied in with love, with diversion, with profaneness, with unbridling of the senses; such dancing, in general, is not pure. For that reason it cannot be introduced into liturgical celebrations of any kind whatever." What about dancing outside the liturgy? This is permissible, but only under certain conditions. Thus "if the proposal for a religious dance in the West is to be acceptable, care must be taken that this occurs outside of the liturgy, in assembly areas that are not strictly liturgical. Moreover, priests must always be excluded from the dance" (Sacred Congregation for the Sacraments and Divine Worship, Notitiae, 1975, 11, pp. 202-5). When a group of Samoans came to Rome for a missionary festival in 1971, [color="#FF0000"]they assisted at Mass in St. Peter's and then carried out their dance in St. Peter's Square, outside the church. [/color] All items in this dictionary are from Fr. John Hardon's Modern Catholic Dictionary, © Eternal Life. Used with permission.
littlesister Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 Pham, please, after lurking for quite a while...could we cool this discussion down? If dance is a legitimate expression of the culture and is permitted in some areas, why all these objections from the other side of the world? Our continent is a small part of this planet. There's a fine Irish expression about trying to be "more Catholic than the Pope." Let's be a tad open-minded here. Where dance is a legitimate and permitted expression...dance! Where it is neither legitimate nor permitted...sit still! If someone somewhere finds it justified to stretch a point and dance anyway...quietly and respectfully question the proper people without broadcasting your criticism! Actually, a neat hornpipe step for the Offertory Procession might not be a bad idea...
cappie Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 Liturgical Dance and Inculturation Written by Most Rev. Peter John Elliott DD Auxiliary Bishop of Melbourne The following is an article on a series "Liturgical Question Box" featured in the international missionary review "Christ to the World." The Most Rev. Elliott deals with an accurate treatment of liturgical dance and inculturation which is a phenomena experienced by missionaries whether in the West or in the indigenous mission lands. Liturgical dance during Mass Question One: Is liturgical dancing permitted during Mass? Answer: This short question opens the whole problem of appropriate inculturation and there can be no brief answer to it. The best approach would be to make a clear distinction between liturgical dancing In the West and religious dancing in other cultures in the wider world. a) Let us begin in the West. In 1975 there was a negative reply to your question from the then Sacred Congregation for the Sacraments and Divine Worship, Dance in the Liturgy. The profane and erotic elements in dancing in the West were cited and the distracting nature of this dancing and Its worldly associations were adduced as a strong reason against it. In Western society we should ask an initial question: What is liturgical dancing meant to convey? Our habit of watching someone dance, our ballet tradition, seems to cause problems once dancing enters worship. The liturgical dance becomes a spectacle. Is this meant to teach us, to inspire us or to entertain us? When it ends with applause it has obviously entertained us. It may have been done well, or, as I also recall, it may have involved the children of admiring mothers! But that applause shows that it is not liturgical. This presentation has become a form of religious ballet, a show, an item on the program. This dancing may find a legitimate place in religious theater, such as a medieval mystery play, but not within the action of holy Mass. [url="http://www.missiomariae.net/magazine/index.php?option=com_content&task=view&id=58&Itemid=81"]http://www.missiomariae.net/magazine/index...8&Itemid=81[/url] We may therefore ask a more basic question: What is liturgical dancing meant to do? Here we need to take account of the modern crisis of Christian worship, which largely revolves around a disastrous overstatement of the instructional dimension of worship. This problem still plagues us—words and more words, the altar (1) turned into a pulpit, the personality cult of the "presider," trite songs and rationed silence. Therefore it is interesting, and not surprising, that liturgical dancing spread in the West at the very time when ceremonial and ritual actions were being rejected and when language came to dominate Catholic worship. Here I would honor the intentions of some who promoted liturgical dancing in the unfortunate years of “experimentation” and desacralization. They at least were trying to resacralize the liturgy by giving it back some sense of movement and ceremony. They knew that ceremonial is a specific religious spectacle where watching can be active participation. I believe they were trying to fill the vacuum left by stripped sanctuaries and Masses reduced to a talk show. One only had to listen to the rationale they presented to justify their dancing. Some described the movements of the old High Mass as a “solemn holy dance,” and there is some wisdom in that unusual per¬ception. But when the argument shifted to the “dancing altar boys of Seville” or the swaying Shakers, this seemed to be appealing to obscure exceptions to set up a general rule. Putting it simply, religious dance is not a normal part of Western culture and thus "liturgical dancing" can find no place in the celebration of holy Mass and the sacraments. This is not to exclude it absolutely from religious experience. In a reverent and skilled form, it may be appropriate in a paraliturgy, in religious theater and at grand outdoor events, such as a secondary event (2) in Eucharistic congresses. But within the Eucharistic celebration, the ceremonial Itself, the gestures, reverences and processions already there, are enough to make up our sacred “dance before the Lord." b) When we turn to the wider Church, beyond the West, we find cultures where traditions of religious dance pre-date evangelization. This is where dancing In worship seems "natural"; hence we should cease calling It “liturgical dancing.” It is religious dancing. In these countries In re¬cent decades Christian religious dancing or movement such as swaying, rhythmic clapping, etc., has become well established and it is regulated by the competent authorities, the local Ordinary and the Episcopal conference. But I would underline a major difference between this appropriate inculturation and what happened in the West. This is really religious dance and the people often spontaneously take part in it. I was particularly impressed by participatory religious dancing at the procession of gifts during some liturgies celebrated in Kenya and by the rhythmic movements of the people during the procession of the gifts in Ghana—a pro¬cession involving the whole congregation. This was a participatory activity, not an entertaining spectacle or performance, with self-conscious overtone. This activity does not come under most of the strictures of the 1975 ruling from the Sacred Congregation for Divine Worship and the Sacraments. Therefore, in 1994 in the Instruction on Inculturation and the Roman Liturgy, from the same Congregation, we find that dancing may be incorporated into the liturgy where dance is an inherent part of the culture of the people and is “not simply a performance. This activity may even be promoted in places where dancing has a religious meaning compatible with Christianity. This cultural context accounts for the positive approach various Episcopal conferences have taken to the question. But the same conferences and other authorities have pointed out that even in traditional cultures a blanket approval for all forms of dance during worship must be avoided. Some dances and gestures from pre-Christian traditions relate to cults or worship of false gods, even demons, not to mention the erotic overtones of some dances, that would also exclude them from Catholic worship. Borrowing from another religious culture, for example Hinduism, may also raise problems of catechetical confusion or even syncretism. But when actions and gestures have wider cultural meanings, the Church can sometimes appropriate them, just as she has done over the two Millennia of her glorious history. Therefore, in answer to this simple question, liturgical dancing should not take place during Mass in Western societies, where dancing in this context is not part of the culture. However Christian religious dance may be appropriate, even praiseworthy, in those cultures where It is part of the cultural patrimony and where it is regulated by the Ordinary and the Episcopal conference.
Justin86 Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 Hmmmm, is she going to scalp me with that machete?
dominicansoul Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 is that a machete? I thought it was a huge ice-pick....
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now