Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Relationship Advice Needed...


Recommended Posts

Posted

Hi, so its been a while since I've posted on here, but much has changed and I'm looking for some feedback from people who have probably had more life experience than I.

I've been dating this girl for about a year now (at varying degrees of "officialness") and recently we decided that it was time to begin the process of seriously discerning whether or not we ought to be married together.

She is very much in love with me and attracted to me. I'm attracted to her and I'm still sorting through my feelings in terms of what "in love" actually means. I have decided that love is a choice and each day I choose to make a choice to love her despite her flaws, her quirks, etc. etc.

Everything says yes about this relationship. We are open and authentic with each other. We know each other truly, we've seen the best and the worst, we haven't argued instead we talk disagreements out, we agree on essentially all moral matters, we have talked about the purpose of marriage, we've prayed (if not together, apart), and everything that one could see in this relationship says that this is a healthy relationship. We feel that we can be open and honest to each other without condemning one another. We respect each other's purity and desire to bring out the best in one another.

But there is still this nagging feelling in me...a sense of doubt...but I can never pin point why it exists or what it is. I'm a very analytical person and I've gone through a crisis of faith which has left me with no other choice than to question everything and also doubt everything. I've slowly been coming out of a depression that I've had for several years and she has truly lifted my spirits. At times I am so confident that God has placed one another in each other's live for a reason. If you had seen me a year ago, and me today, there is a 180 degree turn. Its not just me saying that, other people have recognized the change. As our relationship has progressed, so has my relationship with God. It is still weak at times, but I've learned more about relationship with God in the past year than I have in several years of trying to figure it out on my own.

I know she loves me, I know that she wants to be married to me, I know that she is attracted to me, I know that she desires the best for me.

And I desire all the same things for her. I want to love her, I do my best to love her, I want to be married to her, I can see us together, we enjoy each other's company, I am attracted to her, and I desire the best for her.

But there is still this nagging doubt!

And it is driving me nuts!

Anyone having any advice?

Posted

Those little nagging doubts will always creep in because we're human. If you could actually read her mind, then maybe they would go away, or maybe not. This is the best advice I can give about marriage: #1 Don't marry someone you can live with, marry someone you can't live without. #2 Be absolutely clear going in that divorce is NEVER an option. #3 Spend more time preparing for the marriage than you do preparing and planning for the wedding.

If you both agree that divorce is not an option, then you are forced to communicate and work out things that might fester otherwise. If you know there is an easy out, you might be more willing to just divorce than deal with the icky stuff of working to stay together.

Marriage is never between two perfect people. What it takes for the long term is two people who are willing to work through anything that happens. I can even say that I would forgive and work through even if my husband had an affair, that is if I didn't actually kill him. I take that "till death do us part" stuff pretty serious.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1700186' date='Nov 12 2008, 11:26 AM']#3 Spend more time preparing for the marriage than you do preparing and planning for the wedding.[/quote]

Good advice! Thanks for that one Catherine!

Dust's Sister
Posted

Go before the Most Blessed Sacrament and pray about it. Pray for God's Will To be Done, and He will give you all the answers. :) Maybe go together as a couple and also maybe do a novena to St Joseph for your relationship. :)

Posted

You said you "want to love her." But, do you love her? I think your definition of love as a choice is excellent. It is also self-sacrifice.

I recommend the book called Blessed Gianna Beretta Molla: "Love Letters to My Husband" (she's a Saint now). It really is a compilation of their "mundane" letters to each other (mostly Gianna's to her husband). I know it's written from the woman's side of things, but it represents the day to day decisions of love a committed Catholic constantly seeks. You could both read it...

It seems that you are on the right path. Why not meet with a wise priest to discuss your thoughts?

Posted

I'd say to wait another year or so before even getting engaged. Time will tell if you're right for each other.

Posted

[quote name='tinytherese' post='1700426' date='Nov 12 2008, 09:32 PM']I'd say to wait another year or so before even getting engaged. Time will tell if you're right for each other.[/quote]

Long dating relationships are not recommended. I've actually heard that it is advised to date less then a year before getting engaged, and that engagements are best if they are between 6 months and one year. Waiting "another year or so" is a LONG time.

I've been dating for a little over two months, and marriage is already something we've talked about. I've also been up front saying I could easily see her and I engaged within a year. In all honesty, 8-9 months of serious dating is plenty of time to really discern marriage.

God bless,
Marcus

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1700186' date='Nov 12 2008, 01:26 PM']Those little nagging doubts will always creep in because we're human.[/quote]

Phew! I'm glad I'm not the only one!

[quote]#2 Be absolutely clear going in that divorce is NEVER an option.[/quote]

We've both agreed to this that we would exhaust EVERYTHING to heal a marriage.

Posted

[quote name='-I---Love' post='1700275' date='Nov 12 2008, 04:13 PM']You said you "want to love her." But, do you love her? I think your definition of love as a choice is excellent. It is also self-sacrifice.

I recommend the book called Blessed Gianna Beretta Molla: "Love Letters to My Husband" (she's a Saint now). It really is a compilation of their "mundane" letters to each other (mostly Gianna's to her husband). I know it's written from the woman's side of things, but it represents the day to day decisions of love a committed Catholic constantly seeks. You could both read it...

It seems that you are on the right path. Why not meet with a wise priest to discuss your thoughts?[/quote]

We're planning to talk to the parish priest soon to begin seriously discerning marriage.

I say that I want to love her because I think that I do love her, I just want to love her more and more.

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1700509' date='Nov 13 2008, 03:15 AM']Long dating relationships are not recommended. I've actually heard that it is advised to date less then a year before getting engaged, and that engagements are best if they are between 6 months and one year. Waiting "another year or so" is a LONG time.

I've been dating for a little over two months, and marriage is already something we've talked about. I've also been up front saying I could easily see her and I engaged within a year. In all honesty, 8-9 months of serious dating is plenty of time to really discern marriage.

God bless,
Marcus[/quote]

Well I agree with you about long dating relatoinships. I don't want to date more than 2 years.

At this point, we'll probably have to wait until next fall to get engaged as both of us are still in university. I can't see us getting married before then unless I went part-time and worked. She said she didn't want me to do that.

Archaeology cat
Posted

My husband and I made a point of doing a Bible study together and praying together. Of course, we also had a long-distance relationship. But it definitely helped, I think. I'll say a prayer for the two of you. :)

Posted

I also agree about long dating. We married within a year. I don't think that you should date until your are ready to marry. I actually like the idea of courting better. Dating is for fun, courting is for the serious business of discerning the future vocation.

Posted

[quote name='sdenko' post='1700148' date='Nov 12 2008, 11:30 AM']And I desire all the same things for her. I want to love her, I do my best to love her, I want to be married to her, I can see us together, we enjoy each other's company, I am attracted to her, and I desire the best for her.[/quote]

Those are good indications that you are heading in the "marriage" direction.

[quote name='Dust's Sister' post='1700230' date='Nov 12 2008, 01:18 PM']Go before the Most Blessed Sacrament and pray about it. Pray for God's Will To be Done, and He will give you all the answers. :) Maybe go together as a couple and also maybe do a novena to St Joseph for your relationship. :)[/quote]
My husband and I did this as we were discerning marriage. It not only made us stronger, it made our relationship continue to be Christ-centered.

[quote name='sdenko' post='1700513' date='Nov 13 2008, 02:31 AM']I say that I want to love her because I think that I do love her, I just want to love her more and more.[/quote]
Well, again, that is a pretty good indication that you are going in the right direction.

As for the dating for a long time thing... Studies show (I wrote a paper about this in sociology) that shorter dating relationships before marriage is an indicator of longer, stronger marriages. Now, that being said, there are other factors also. How old are you? Do you live close or far? etc. etc.

I would say that doubts are there for everyone. They even have a term for it : cold feet. I would say that if you were entering in this lightly, and with no inkling of the enormity of what you would be doing, then it would be normal to have no doubts. Doubts are probably more of a sign of maturity and realization of the seriousness of marriage.

Good luck. Pray together. And remember to post pictures if and when you get engaged ;)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='prose' post='1700593' date='Nov 13 2008, 11:47 AM']Those are good indications that you are heading in the "marriage" direction.

As for the dating for a long time thing... Studies show (I wrote a paper about this in sociology) that shorter dating relationships before marriage is an indicator of longer, stronger marriages.[/quote]

Interesting findings. Perhaps its just the way that a couple approaches a relationship and the temperment of both people.

My mom engrained it into my head that I should know someone for years until I marry them. If I were called to the married life I'd personally go onto that route most likely but that's just because of my own temperment. I'm a take it slow kind of person (and not just in regards to relationships.) My work/school schedule would probably play a factor in it too.

Well it must vary for different people.

Edited by tinytherese
Posted

No idea... I think I remember though that age also was an indicator. I believe (and I would have to go back and look it up for sure) that couples who were engaged in under a year and married in under an year after that were the highest success rates. Totally interesting course. It was Sociology of the Family. I loved it.

Posted

Welp, you asked for it. ;)

I met my husband through PhatMass in Summer '05. We talked online and on the phone then decided we wanted to meet. On October 1st 2005, we met face to face in Portland Maine. He had driven from Steubenville Ohio to meet me. We obviously had a long distance thing goin' on for a long while, which made it easier for me to doubt. I broke it off in November, asked him back in December, and decided after not seeing him from Nov.05-March 06, that he was the man I wanted to marry more than anyone in the world (Absence really DOES make the heart grow fonder :lol: )

Well long story short, we got married in April '07 and havent looked back. I have never felt such immense peace in my entire life. The day I DECIDED that he was the man I wanted to marry, that was it, history man.

I think prayer is a good thing. Also, to seriously examine why you feel these feelings of doubt? I had doubt because I was 19 when I met him so I wondered if I was rushing into something that was over my head. Turns out I was more ready than I realized when I figured out that was a lame reason considering the man I was marrying. (Not saying everyone should rush into something like marriage, just sayin' when you know you know...)

Anyway, thats my story. Take what you want from it, leave what you dont want. :topsy:

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1700509' date='Nov 13 2008, 10:15 AM']Long dating relationships are not recommended. I've actually heard that it is advised to date less then a year before getting engaged, and that engagements are best if they are between 6 months and one year. Waiting "another year or so" is a LONG time.

I've been dating for a little over two months, and marriage is already something we've talked about. I've also been up front saying I could easily see her and I engaged within a year. In all honesty, 8-9 months of serious dating is plenty of time to really discern marriage.

God bless,
Marcus[/quote]

I would be careful not to make a rule of that kind of advice ; after all, we're all different...
My parents waited 5 or 6 years, and they've been married for 50 years now...
Which doesn't mean that I would recommend that to anyone.
One thing often recommended is : spend a long time (several hours) before the Blessed Sacrament, and desire nothing more than being with the Lord... it's a way to get free of many other desires, and to discern more clearly what He has for us.
God bless !

Posted

90% of the people I know who married after short dating are divorced now, or are in physically abusive marriages.

Posted

I feel kinda like you, Sdenko, I've been with my guy about 6 months now, and I'll go through phases of feeling very insecure and phases where I could certainly see us marrying.
I like him a lot, but if he asked me to right now, I couldn't say yes to marriage. I'm so lucky though, because every time I'm feeling unsure, I talk to him about it, and we talk through what my fears are and get things straightened out. I think I have commitment issues, but besides that, I don't know if I love him in the way that means I can't live without him. But I want to, and I plan on dating him until I do, however long that takes, or until we discern that we aren't meant to be together. We do a lot of praying, together and apart too (we're long distance right now, which also makes things hard) but that has been a very important part of our relationship.

Anyways, I'm very interested too in what other people say about this stuff. My question especially is: How do you know when you're in love with someone and can't live without them? Or do you simply choose to and go from there?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='MStar' post='1700817' date='Nov 13 2008, 06:55 PM']I feel kinda like you, Sdenko, I've been with my guy about 6 months now, and I'll go through phases of feeling very insecure and phases where I could certainly see us marrying.
I like him a lot, but if he asked me to right now, I couldn't say yes to marriage. I'm so lucky though, because every time I'm feeling unsure, I talk to him about it, and we talk through what my fears are and get things straightened out. I think I have commitment issues, but besides that, I don't know if I love him in the way that means I can't live without him. But I want to, and I plan on dating him until I do, however long that takes, or until we discern that we aren't meant to be together. We do a lot of praying, together and apart too (we're long distance right now, which also makes things hard) but that has been a very important part of our relationship.

Anyways, I'm very interested too in what other people say about this stuff. My question especially is: How do you know when you're in love with someone and can't live without them? Or do you simply choose to and go from there?[/quote]

Wow...you have essentially the same exact experience as I do. I think I have committment issues. She's my first girlfriend...ever. And even before we met, I'd have a hard time committing to even doing things with friends on the weekend. I'd always say maybe. But when I met her, it seemed like all those fears of committment disapated to some degree. They're still there at times.

When I get insecure I talk to her too and we normally are able to work through it even though for her it is confusing at times as to why I have these doubts.

Your question is the same as mine by the way.

How do I know?

And thank you for the other suggestions folks. I really do appreciate them. I'm not Catholic, but I guess you could kind of call me one. I talk like one, I look like one (in mass that is) and there's a feeling inside of me that I know that I'm going to be Catholic at some point in my life.

Along with the other toughies that us Protestants have to work through as we're learning about Catholicism (e.g. Mary, papal infalibility) the Eucharist is still the hardest. I mean, I believe that the arguments for the Real Presence are far greater than any "its just a memorial" arguments that I've grown up with. I do believe, intellectually, that is, after reading St Thomas Aquinas and other saints and Church Fathers on the Eucharist, I accept that the Jesus is in the Eucharist.

But when it comes to putting that into practise and believing it with all my heart, mind and soul, I just have a hard time doing that.

So yes, I want to go a pray in front of Jesus...at some point...but right now I'm having a hard time with that.

But we have talked about doing a novena. We may choose one that is preahps a little more "protestant"-friendly as I'm also figuring the saint stuff out too. You see, I do ask St Frances de Sales to pray for me, but I'm still unsure about a whole long prayer just to a saint.

Edited by sdenko

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...