tinytherese Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 (edited) This may be something helpful for you to read. [url="http://chastity.com/chastity/index.php?id=7&entryid=43"]http://chastity.com/chastity/index.php?id=7&entryid=43[/url] The website has lots of helpful information in regards to relationships and even talks about courtship. Edited November 14, 2008 by tinytherese
CatherineM Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 I always recommend [url="http://www.6stonejars.com/"]6 Stone Jars[/url]. It has lots of relationship advice, and is run by a very orthodox Catholic. The same man who started Ave Maria Singles.
MStar Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 [quote]Wow...you have essentially the same exact experience as I do. I think I have committment issues. She's my first girlfriend...ever. And even before we met, I'd have a hard time committing to even doing things with friends on the weekend. I'd always say maybe. But when I met her, it seemed like all those fears of committment disapated to some degree. They're still there at times.[/quote] Yeah, I've had a hard time saying yes to even simple things too, it's usually always maybe. And my guy isn't Catholic either, although you sound like you're in a similar spot as him, he expects to be Catholic someday if things keep going as they are Those are interesting links, Tinytherese and Catherine, although I would really like advice that's a little more personal. Even stories can be encouraging
curtins Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1700956' date='Nov 13 2008, 11:50 PM']I always recommend [url="http://www.6stonejars.com/"]6 Stone Jars[/url]. It has lots of relationship advice, and is run by a very orthodox Catholic. The same man who started Ave Maria Singles.[/quote] I would just be skeptical of some of the things on this 6 stone jars website. There is an article that basically says if you are married or dating, you cannot be friends with someone of the opposite sex. This is a frightening and radical view- one that I'm positive most people, myself included, would flat out reject as being unhealthy and just plain weird. I've been dating a girl for over a year now and one of my best friends is a girl. If my girlfriend had a problem with that she wouldn't be my girlfriend. Also, my girlfriend has many good friends that are guys. But we have enough basic trust that its a total non issue. Big red flag-- when you're significant other tries to get you to kill your friendships. This blogger's advice sounds like junior high. "You can only date me and you can't have friends that are girls!" Scary. beware.
Barbarus Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 [quote name='curtins' post='1701417' date='Nov 14 2008, 04:00 PM']I would just be skeptical of some of the things on this 6 stone jars website. There is an article that basically says if you are married or dating, you cannot be friends with someone of the opposite sex. This is a frightening and radical view- one that I'm positive most people, myself included, would flat out reject as being unhealthy and just plain weird. I've been dating a girl for over a year now and one of my best friends is a girl. If my girlfriend had a problem with that she wouldn't be my girlfriend. Also, my girlfriend has many good friends that are guys. But we have enough basic trust that its a total non issue. Big red flag-- when you're significant other tries to get you to kill your friendships. This blogger's advice sounds like junior high. "You can only date me and you can't have friends that are girls!" Scary. beware.[/quote] Yeah ... I read that same article and was particularly struck by this line: "That is why the Sacrament of Matrimony is primarily an exchange of 'rights' to each other's body, and as a result of those 'rights', a deepening of love can happen and children may be conceived as a result." Um, what???? There is definitely a physical component to marriage, and marriage vows do allude to this (we promise to be open to children, etc.) but I would not say that a) the sacrament is "primarily an exchange of rights" to one another's bodies, or even primarily focused on the physical.
CatherineM Posted November 14, 2008 Posted November 14, 2008 [quote name='Barbarus' post='1701423' date='Nov 14 2008, 03:20 PM']Yeah ... I read that same article and was particularly struck by this line: "That is why the Sacrament of Matrimony is primarily an exchange of 'rights' to each other's body, and as a result of those 'rights', a deepening of love can happen and children may be conceived as a result." Um, what???? There is definitely a physical component to marriage, and marriage vows do allude to this (we promise to be open to children, etc.) but I would not say that a) the sacrament is "primarily an exchange of rights" to one another's bodies, or even primarily focused on the physical.[/quote] I guess I didn't have a problem with that because it comes straight from John Paul II's Theology of the Body.
Barbarus Posted November 15, 2008 Posted November 15, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1701442' date='Nov 14 2008, 04:42 PM']I guess I didn't have a problem with that because it comes straight from John Paul II's Theology of the Body.[/quote] Please elaborate. I'd love a cite to this effect, if you wouldn't mind.
CatherineM Posted November 15, 2008 Posted November 15, 2008 [quote name='Barbarus' post='1701578' date='Nov 14 2008, 07:31 PM']Please elaborate. I'd love a cite to this effect, if you wouldn't mind.[/quote] Sure, I love reading from Theology of the Body. There are several dozen sections that talk about the mutual gift. I just pulled a few out to give a taste. I have no trouble with the idea that my body belongs to my husband, just as his body belongs to me. Marriage works best when you completely empty yourself to another person, surrender. It's not something we humans like to do, surrender ourselves, but it is liberating if you are willing to submit totally to the sacrament. I especially love JPII's discussion of the Song of Songs. GENERAL AUDIENCE 6 FEBRUARY, 1980 Giving becomes accepting 4. According to Genesis 2:25, "The man and his wife were not ashamed." We can conclude that the exchange of the gift, in which the whole of their humanity participated, body and soul, femininity and masculinity, was actualized by preserving the interior characteristic (that is, precisely, innocence) of the donation of oneself and of the acceptance of the other as a gift. These two functions of mutual exchange are deeply connected in the whole process of the gift of oneself. The giving and the accepting of the gift interpenetrate, so that the giving itself becomes accepting, and the acceptance is transformed into giving. Real communion of persons 6...Therefore, the man not only accepts the gift. At the same time he is received as a gift by the woman, in the revelation of the interior spiritual essence of his masculinity, together with the whole truth of his body and sex. Accepted in this way, he is enriched through this acceptance and welcoming of the gift of his own masculinity. Subsequently, this acceptance, in which the man finds himself again through the sincere gift of himself, becomes in him the source of a new and deeper enrichment of the woman. The exchange is mutual. In it the reciprocal effects of the sincere gift and of the finding oneself again are revealed and grow. GENERAL AUDIENCE OF 5 JANUARY [1983] 5...The persons—man and woman—become for each other a mutual gift. They become that gift in their masculinity and femininity, discovering the spousal significance of the body and referring it reciprocally to themselves in an irreversible manner—in a life-long dimension. GENERAL AUDIENCE OF 30 MAY [1984] 4..At the same time, this discovery expresses the authentic depth of the mutual belonging of the spouses who are aware of belonging to each other, of being destined for each other: "My lover belongs to me and I to him" (Sg 2:16; cf. 6:3). 5. This awareness of mutual belonging resounds especially on the lips of the bride. In a certain sense, with these words she responds to the groom's words with which he acknowledged her as the master of her own mystery. When the bride says, "My lover belongs to me," she means at the same time, "It is he to whom I entrust myself." Therefore she says, "and I to him" (Sg 2:16). The words "to me" and "to him" affirm here the whole depth of that entrustment, which corresponds to the interior truth of the person. GENERAL AUDIENCE OF 6 JUNE [1984] 3...The truth about love is expressed in the awareness of mutual belonging, the fruit of the aspiration and search for each other, and in the need for the aspiration and the search, the outcome of mutual belonging. In this interior necessity, in this dynamic of love, there is indirectly revealed the near impossibility of one person's being appropriated and mastered by the other. The person is someone who surpasses all measures of appropriation and domination, of possession and gratification, which emerge from the same language of the body. If the groom and the bride reread this language in the full truth about the person and about love, they arrive at the ever deeper conviction that the fullness of their belonging constitutes that mutual gift in which love is revealed as "stern as death," that is, it goes to the furthest limits of the language of the body in order to exceed them. The truth about interior love and the truth about the mutual gift in a certain sense continually call the groom and the bride—through the means of expressing the mutual belonging, and even by breaking away from those means—to arrive at what constitutes the very nucleus of the gift from person to person.
Barbarus Posted November 17, 2008 Posted November 17, 2008 See, I can buy all that, but that's not when I think of when I read that marriage is "primarily an exchange of rights" to one anothers' bodies. To me, that sounds more like a property exchange or a contract, and doesn't begin to encompass the beauty of the sacrament. If he'd said "primarily about an exchange of persons" or something like that, I don't think it would have jumped out at me as it did.
CatherineM Posted November 17, 2008 Posted November 17, 2008 [quote name='Barbarus' post='1703139' date='Nov 17 2008, 12:22 AM']See, I can buy all that, but that's not when I think of when I read that marriage is "primarily an exchange of rights" to one anothers' bodies. To me, that sounds more like a property exchange or a contract, and doesn't begin to encompass the beauty of the sacrament. If he'd said "primarily about an exchange of persons" or something like that, I don't think it would have jumped out at me as it did.[/quote] Yeah, this is certainly an area where slight nuance of word can really change a meaning. 6 Stone Jars has lots of interviews with relationship experts, but I prefer the interviews with the priests, especially Fr. Groeschel.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now