Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Let The Big Three Go Bankrupt


Recommended Posts

Posted

+J.M.J.+
[url="http://www.baltimoresun.com/topic/orl-will2008nov20,0,5534683.story"]Article here[/url]
[quote]Congress could help the Detroit Three by allowing them, when meeting corporate average fuel economy standards imposed by Congress, to count fuel-efficient cars they import from their overseas factories. Congressional Democrats oppose that because those imports are not made by members of the United Auto Workers members. Those Democrats care most about the union; saving the planet, second; and auto companies' health, last.

Some opponents of bankruptcy say it might terminate health-care coverage enjoyed by UAW retirees who are too young for Medicare. If people want to retire before 65, or 35 for that matter, that is their business. But there is no public interest in protecting the luxury of retirement in the prime of life just because a private contract established it as an entitlement for all seasons.[/quote]

[quote]x decades later, a "rescue" without bankruptcy will make those four entities wards of government. Doing so would make the five entities (including Washington) collaborators in unfair competition with America's thriving automobile industry that employs 113,000 Americans making vehicles containing many American-made components, but with foreign, mostly Japanese, nameplates.

As Detroit continues to shrink, many American jobs "lost" will be regained in this industry, and its American suppliers, as Americans continue to buy cars. (Disclosure: Mrs. Will, who drives a GM product, is a public-relations consultant for the Japan Automobile Manufacturers Association.)

The Economist reports that in the next 40 years, the world's automobile fleet will surge from 700 million to 3 billion. After being restructured through bankruptcy, the Detroit Two, or One, might flourish. Let's find out. The ruinous alternative is to squander, in a doomed attempt to "save jobs," more scores of billions of scarce capital that will then be unavailable for job-creating investments in rising industries.[/quote]

i am against a bailout for the Big Three. What does everyone else think?

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='Lil Red' post='1705699' date='Nov 20 2008, 12:51 PM']i am against a bailout for the Big Three. What does everyone else think?[/quote]

i'm from Detroit and come from auto industry families. That said, i am ABSOLUTELY against YET ANOTHER HUGE GOVERNMENT BAILOUT. Sorry - i agree - let them go bankrupt.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

I agree. let them go. I am against it for a couple reasons.

1. I am against government intervention in general.

2. I honestly don't think the money is going to save them. Let's pretend they get the money. The allowance the government gives them will encourage bad decision making as they will look to the government in times of trouble as they will have little incentive to stand by themselves.

Someone may argue about all the potential jobs lost..........it is going to happen regardless. I think the big three are headed to being bankrupt regardless of what happens. Before the economy really went south, was not the big three struggling?

This down turn of the economy is all about the economy correcting itself. It will be painful but that is what happening and how capitalism works.

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1705865' date='Nov 20 2008, 02:42 PM']I agree. let them go. I am against it for a couple reasons.

1. I am against government intervention in general.

2. I honestly don't think the money is going to save them. Let's pretend they get the money. The allowance the government gives them will encourage bad decision making as they will look to the government in times of trouble as they will have little incentive to stand by themselves.

Someone may argue about all the potential jobs lost..........it is going to happen regardless. I think the big three are headed to being bankrupt regardless of what happens. Before the economy really went south, was not the big three struggling?

This down turn of the economy is all about the economy correcting itself. It will be painful but that is what happening and how capitalism works.[/quote]

Totally agree!!!

Might i submit a reason #3, just to put things in perspective.

Before this year, our last government bailout was in 2001 with the airline industry to the tune of $15 billion - i remember that being a huge issue/debate. Then came money to 9/11 victims' families: $38.1 billion, then $16.7 billion after Hurricane Katrina.

JUST THIS YEAR, in 2008, we've had 5 bailouts that add up to $1.1 TRILLION dollars.

[url="http://www.propublica.org/special/government-bailouts"]Source[/url]

Seriously, people!

Posted

If they give a bailout it should be given equally to all the auto companies not just he big 3. As Toyota and Honda all have major plants here in N. America and employ 1000s of people directly and what 10s of 1000s indirectly.

So what if they did better business planning to stay afloat in these times and surpass the American companies. How is that fair to give only 3 companies that much money just because they cant even make a fair business decision.

I think the root cause of all this is simple GREED. The congressman who ask the CEOs how they all arrived in Washington the other day was spot on. They all flew their private jets. Why not fly commercial or "jet pool". While their companies are going under and people are loosing their livelyhood they are out flying around in ther jets giving there selves huge bonuses. They have so much redundancey in their products its no wonder they are all going to go under.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Public opinion also seems to be against bailouts for the Big Three. If the public maintains this kind of economic common-sense, hopefully the Federal Reserve will also go the way of General Motors. Good riddance with all that socialist hooey.

Not that out next president will help... except possibly by being so extremely socialist that people will rebel against him and his policies.

eagle_eye222001
Posted (edited)

Oh, I bought the wrong item at school the other day, does anyone know where I send in the paperwork to get reimbursed from the government to correct my poor decision making and judgment.

Edited by eagle_eye222001
Posted

yeah, american car manufacturers have been having their butts handed to them by the japanese for like 30 years now. if they havent caught up or figured out how to compete with efficiency and good products by now then let them die. shape up or ship out i say.

Posted

Great article on the advisability of bankruptcy yesterday by Mitt Romney, whose father faced the same situation. Wall Street Journal (I think) yesterday. Sorry not to be more precise - I'd look it up but am due to play Benediction in five minutes.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1706048' date='Nov 20 2008, 06:25 PM']yeah, american car manufacturers have been having their butts handed to them by the japanese for like 30 years now. if they havent caught up or figured out how to compete with efficiency and good products by now then let them die. shape up or ship out i say.[/quote]

They've actually improved greatly since the 80s. I think the problem comes down to a "good ol' boy" mentality that rewards the Detroit establishment along with all the silly legislation that Congress passes so they can claim to promote the environment and keep Detroit in line, as of Detroit is our enemy. When they pass laws forcing fuel efficiency standards by certain deadlines, they aren't giving our manufacturers the flexibility that is sorely needed to develop new technology during those money-losing years.

Toyota started selling hybrid vehicles in Japan way back around '98. When we were first seeing hybrids in the showrooms, it already an established technology over there. But, Toyota lost money on every car they sold during those experimental years. Likewise, GM is coming out with the Chevrolet Volt, and they're going to lose money on every one they sell. Unfortunately, GM loses money on every car they sell, so they probably won't have the cushion they need to experiment with the Volt. Plus, they have to lobby with Congress to make its fuel efficiency numbers count in their favor because it uses a different technology that those efficiency laws were written for (the Volt runs on battery for 40 miles, then switches to fuel combustion while recharging the battery, so it's either zero emission or your typical 22/35 for a small car).

In short, without the silly laws and government intervention, GM would be free to develop the Volt without concerning themselves with the possibility of paying federal fines sometime in the future. That's just one example, but this kind of silliness has been happening for decades. Detroit is failing because our politicians have effectively nationalized the American auto industry.

Posted

Not a big fan of rewarding failure in any market. And I am certainly not a fan of the government repeatedly tying the entire nation to economic failures. (That didn't work out so well for the USSR; why wouldn't we move as far away from anything like that as possible?)

Posted

From one who had family members in the senior leadership at Ford...

There are some other factors to be considered. Part of the problem of the big 3 is bad products, marketing, ect. just bad business. But I think that is only a small part. At this point most of the cars are at least comparable. There are other factors:

Union wages. Our union wages are nearly double that of a Japanese worker. Ie. our cars are twice as high in cost.

Benefits. Japanese companies don't have to provide their Japanese workers with medical benefits; their government does it for them. There is an extra $2,000 in every american car that goes towards health benefits.

Loyalty to the dollar. Face it: Americans are more loyal to the dollar than the flag. If you go to Japan, you will only see Japanese cars. The most popular car in Sweden is Volvo. Germany - Volkswagen or Mercedes. These countries have a bit of pride in supporting their local manufactures. In the 70's and 80's the US actually took Japan to the world court (I think it was the world court?) for not letting American cars into their markets. Japan lost the suit and in agreement, agreed to let more American dealers into Japan and to build factories in America. The dealers in Japan never worked out, demand was never high enough. Japan now has factories in America, which is good for Americans.

I mean face it, would you buy a car that is $3-$6 K more, less fuel efficient, and maybe doesn't look as good just because its American?

Now, on the other hand... I don't think the taxpayers should be punished for this. Bankruptcy will let the companies restructure and re-negotiate those union wages. Its going to hurt the entire nation, but we'll be better after.

PS: To all those who own foreign cars, I don't think you're not patriotic or anything. Not trying to say that. But Americans buy the best value for their money; whether that product comes from the USA, China, or Japan. The big 3 need to figure that out and start offering products people value.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1706982' date='Nov 21 2008, 10:08 AM']They've actually improved greatly since the 80s. I think the problem comes down to a "good ol' boy" mentality that rewards the Detroit establishment along with all the silly legislation that Congress passes so they can claim to promote the environment and keep Detroit in line, as of Detroit is our enemy. When they pass laws forcing fuel efficiency standards by certain deadlines, they aren't giving our manufacturers the flexibility that is sorely needed to develop new technology during those money-losing years.

Toyota started selling hybrid vehicles in Japan way back around '98. When we were first seeing hybrids in the showrooms, it already an established technology over there. But, Toyota lost money on every car they sold during those experimental years. Likewise, GM is coming out with the Chevrolet Volt, and they're going to lose money on every one they sell. Unfortunately, GM loses money on every car they sell, so they probably won't have the cushion they need to experiment with the Volt. Plus, they have to lobby with Congress to make its fuel efficiency numbers count in their favor because it uses a different technology that those efficiency laws were written for (the Volt runs on battery for 40 miles, then switches to fuel combustion while recharging the battery, so it's either zero emission or your typical 22/35 for a small car).

In short, without the silly laws and government intervention, GM would be free to develop the Volt without concerning themselves with the possibility of paying federal fines sometime in the future. That's just one example, but this kind of silliness has been happening for decades. Detroit is failing because our politicians have effectively nationalized the American auto industry.[/quote]

With gas this cheap, hybrids are dead... at least for now...

The Volt looks cool, but I heard there isn't even a working prototype of it? Too good to be true?

Posted

[quote name='rkwright' post='1707622' date='Nov 21 2008, 11:24 PM']Benefits. Japanese companies don't have to provide their Japanese workers with medical benefits; their government does it for them. There is an extra $2,000 in every american car that goes towards health benefits.[/quote]
This is not actually true -- employers must pay for their employees' health insurance. (Today appears to be my day of clearing up misconceptions about Japan.)

I'm sure it's not as costly as what US automakers pay, though.

Good post, BTW, thanks for sharing.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='rkwright' post='1707622' date='Nov 22 2008, 01:24 PM']Union wages. Our union wages are nearly double that of a Japanese worker. Ie. our cars are twice as high in cost.[/quote]
This is the biggest factor in my opinion.

[quote]Benefits. Japanese companies don't have to provide their Japanese workers with medical benefits; their government does it for them. There is an extra $2,000 in every american car that goes towards health benefits.[/quote]
And what does an extra $2,000 come out to on my car payment? An extra $10 a month maybe? I'm not worried about that.

[quote]Loyalty to the dollar. I mean face it, would you buy a car that is $3-$6 K more, less fuel efficient, and maybe doesn't look as good just because its American?[/quote]
No I wouldn't, and our economy wouldn't be better off if we did. Buying a product that you don't really want just because of it's nationality only drives up the prices of the better products.

[quote]Now, on the other hand... I don't think the taxpayers should be punished for this. Bankruptcy will let the companies restructure and re-negotiate those union wages. Its going to hurt the entire nation, but we'll be better after.[/quote]
Agreed.

Edited by Justin86
HisChildForever
Posted

[quote]Someone may argue about all the potential jobs lost..........it is going to happen regardless.[/quote]

This thread is slightly insensitive. My Dad works for General Motors. I don't even want to [i]begin[/i] to think what it would be like if he lost his job.

Posted

Losing a job is never a pleasant thing (I know because I have lost a few jobs in my time), but the federal government has no business bailing out companies.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1708179' date='Nov 22 2008, 11:32 PM']Losing a job is never a pleasant thing (I know because I have lost a few jobs in my time), but the federal government has no business bailing out companies.[/quote]

I know.

But it's the bizarre "enthusiasm" which is making me sick.

[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1705846' date='Nov 20 2008, 04:33 PM']Sorry - i agree - let them go bankrupt.[/quote]


[quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1705865' date='Nov 20 2008, 04:42 PM']I agree. let them go.[/quote]


[quote name='fides quarens intellectum' post='1705903' date='Nov 20 2008, 04:54 PM']Totally agree!!![/quote]


[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1705969' date='Nov 20 2008, 05:35 PM']If the public maintains this kind of economic common-sense, hopefully the Federal Reserve will also go the way of General Motors. Good riddance with all that socialist hooey.[/quote]


[quote name='Jesus_lol' post='1706048' date='Nov 20 2008, 06:25 PM']if they havent caught up or figured out how to compete with efficiency and good products by now [b]then let them die[/b]. shape up or ship out i say.[/quote]

Posted

I do not see it as enthusiasm; instead, I think that many of the posts in this thread reflect the anger and frustration of many people in seeing our government do things that it is never meant to do.

Posted

I agree. When big companies (and everyone in general) make mistakes, they need to learn that they aren't going to be babied. :idontknow:

Job loss is harsh, paying stupid taxes isn't fair for everyone else


IMO

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...