Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Let The Big Three Go Bankrupt


Recommended Posts

Posted

My income was $11,000 below the poverty line in the SF Bay Area last year, and yet I paid $1,900 in federal income taxes (and that does not include FICA or State income taxes). The federal government has no business transferring 11% of my income to GM, Ford, and Chrysler.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1708303' date='Nov 23 2008, 12:32 AM']But it's the bizarre "enthusiasm" which is making me sick.[/quote]

The enthusiasm isn't just for seeing a large American company finally go down the tubes. It's also a sense of looking forward to the creativity and ingenuity that would follow. After all, if Ford and GM are too large to just disappear overnight. Most likely, Toyota, Honda, or even an entrepreneur with a big wallet would buy up the assets, hire most of the former employees, and start something from scratch. [i]Then[/i] we would see Japan get a run for their money.

Just think... without the Great Depression, we would never have played Monopoly or Scrabble. :)

Those are two small examples, but it's true that capitalism works a lot like the natural world: death brings about new life in another form or species. And there's no such thing as an economy where it's always summer. The fall and winter months are needed to bring spring and summer.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

The airlines got bailed out and most of them still ended up declaring bankruptcy within a few years. But what is bankruptcy? It's not the death of a company--all it is is another form of a bailout. It allows them to start over, and the creditors, investors, business partners and employees all end up getting the short end of the stick.

So, in reality, it's bailout #1 vs bailout #2.

Here's an idea... How about the big three do what the airlines did and actually start running more efficiently by eliminating wastes and cutting costs. Okay, so the consumer will see an inferior product, employees will lose benefits.... but at least my Ford stock will still have value!!!

Posted

If the big 3 go down, it hurts everyone. No, it should have never been allowed to get to this point - which is why the government tries to make sure companies never grow so large and powerful in the first place, so their failure doesn't screw everybody over - but it is at this point, so we have to bite the bullet.

I'm not saying we keep pumping money into failure...just that [i]something [/i]has to be done to prevent further collapse of the economy. Perhaps the government could bail them out, then split them up into smaller companies with new leadership with the intentions of paying the government back with interest.

But if the big 3 go under, it destroys the income and benefits of between 1 and 2 million people more or less directly - and ultimately could destroy up to four million more because of the ripple effect through the various ties to the auto-industry (we're speaking of both employees and retirees). Furthermore, it would destroy confidence in the market and send us crashing even farther and faster than we've seen in the past couple of months.

Posted

The problem with the big 3 is not the product. Their quality has increased and they made very good cars. I drive one. The problem is that their costs are out of line with the competition. Let's face it, it is the huge union contracts that are a big part of the problem.

dUSt is right. they need to file charter 7 bankruptcy and restructure. But the big 3 would not consider it. They testified before Congress said that it they filed it would be Charter 11 liquidation. That is stupid but a good indicator of their thinking.

The problem facing all of us is that you have poorly managed auto companies saddled with massive labor contracts threatening to go out of business in front of a democrat controlled congress that is in bed with the labor unions.

Everybody grab you wallet! It is about to be picked again.

LouisvilleFan
Posted (edited)

[quote name='dUSt' post='1709468' date='Nov 24 2008, 11:28 AM']The airlines got bailed out and most of them still ended up declaring bankruptcy within a few years. But what is bankruptcy? It's not the death of a company--all it is is another form of a bailout. It allows them to start over, and the creditors, investors, business partners and employees all end up getting the short end of the stick.

So, in reality, it's bailout #1 vs bailout #2.[/quote]

No, it isn't another form of a bailout. For one, the stakeholders realize the downside risk of their investments. It's not "getting the short end of the stick." Every investment involves risking the loss of capital in exchange for the prospect of capital gains. There is no guarantee of either outcome, hence the risk and reward.

[quote name='dUSt' post='1709468' date='Nov 24 2008, 11:28 AM']Here's an idea... How about the big three do what the airlines did and actually start running more efficiently by eliminating wastes and cutting costs. Okay, so the consumer will see an inferior product, employees will lose benefits.... but at least my Ford stock will still have value!!![/quote]

Several people in this thread have explained why it's basically impossible for the American automakers to eliminate costs. The UAW has them tied down with fixed labor costs. What can you do when you have to pay money to people who no longer work for you? The automakes are socialist institutions (effectively speaking, if not technically), which is why they are dying a slow and painful death.

Plus, I don't think the airlines aren't doing any better. Except for the low-cost leader (Southwest), they've always been a poor investment and always will be. The business model simply doesn't work in a competitive environment with such great price elasticity, unless you can afford to consistently undercut the competion, as Southwest does.

[quote name='Ziggamafu' post='1709510' date='Nov 24 2008, 12:16 PM']If the big 3 go down, it hurts everyone. No, it should have never been allowed to get to this point - which is why the government tries to make sure companies never grow so large and powerful in the first place, so their failure doesn't screw everybody over - but it is at this point, so we have to bite the bullet.

I'm not saying we keep pumping money into failure...just that [i]something [/i]has to be done to prevent further collapse of the economy. Perhaps the government could bail them out, then split them up into smaller companies with new leadership with the intentions of paying the government back with interest.

But if the big 3 go under, it destroys the income and benefits of between 1 and 2 million people more or less directly - and ultimately could destroy up to four million more because of the ripple effect through the various ties to the auto-industry (we're speaking of both employees and retirees). Furthermore, it would destroy confidence in the market and send us crashing even farther and faster than we've seen in the past couple of months.[/quote]

Not allowing companies to grow too big? Splitting up large companies? You're just talking about more government intervention, which is exactly the problem. Let companies grow big... and when they grow too big, let them fail. Then let investors pick up the pieces and grow new companies, most of which will also fail, leading the way for still more new companies to grow from that aftermath. [b]The success of capitalism is found in the failure of corporations.[/b] The government's role being purely to write and enforce legislation that sets as fair a playing field as possible and keeps greed in check.

The Big Three going under would not cause all those millions of jobs to disappear. Do you think Americans would suddenly cut our vehicle purchases to only the numbers that overseas companies can produce? Of course not! All the Fords, GMs, and Chryslers we currently buy would have to be purchased from somebody, and it would have to happen very quickly. The failure of even one of the Big Three would be the best thing for the American auto industry and our economy. We would probably take a year or so of pain, but out of the destruction of just one former company could be formed several smaller manufacturers, each appealing to new and creative niches, growing and hiring employees. In fact, as a group, the new companies formed out of the Big Three's downfall could easily employ several times as many people as the Big Three does now.

Of course, it won't happen until it's forced to happen... when the U.S. Government defaults.

Edited by LouisvilleFan
Posted

+J.M.J.+
[url="http://www.spiegel.de/international/business/0,1518,592658,00.html"]German Auto Industry Facing the Abyss[/url]

fides quarens intellectum
Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1708303' date='Nov 22 2008, 10:32 PM']I know.

But it's the bizarre "enthusiasm" which is making me sick.[/quote]


[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1708304' date='Nov 22 2008, 10:34 PM']I do not see it as enthusiasm; instead, I think that many of the posts in this thread reflect the anger and frustration of many people in seeing our government do things that it is never meant to do.[/quote]


Thanks, Apo :)

Posted

My Uncle was President of the local UAW Chapter for years and like half of my family were empoloyed by UAW. However, I don't think the bailout is really a solution. Unfortunately, the auto industry has been dwindling for years and I don't think band aid solutions work. Job outsourcing is a huge part of the problem and I think the government needs to make lessening that a priority if they want to help. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1705969' date='Nov 20 2008, 04:35 PM']Public opinion also seems to be against bailouts for the Big Three. If the public maintains this kind of economic common-sense, hopefully the Federal Reserve will also go the way of General Motors. Good riddance with all that socialist hooey.

Not that out next president will help... except possibly by being so extremely socialist that people will rebel against him and his policies.[/quote]

I think that some conservatives have a tendency to brand anything that is slightly statist (such as the Federal Reserve) as outright socialism. No; that's hyperbole.

I remember hearing something on Relevant Radio today (or yesterday?) that was a quote of JP II ... capitalism ... but moderated capitalism.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1711070' date='Nov 25 2008, 09:46 PM']My Uncle was President of the local UAW Chapter for years and like half of my family were empoloyed by UAW. However, I don't think the bailout is really a solution. Unfortunately, the auto industry has been dwindling for years and I don't think band aid solutions work. Job outsourcing is a huge part of the problem and I think the government needs to make lessening that a priority if they want to help. -Katie[/quote]

Here again, if we pass legislation to restrict job outsourcing, we only stack the deck in favor of foreign competition. Of course, outsourcing doesn't always mean losing American jobs. The American auto industry has been outsourcing non-union labor through employers like Toyota and BMW who aren't tied down with these UAW agreements. Too often, we try to treat the symptom like it's the problem: taking a cough drop to alleviate a sore throat doesn't cure the common cold. In other words, we could pass laws the restrict outsourcing, but we can't change the laws of economics that cause companies to outsource in the first place, and eventually those laws will catch up with us.

[quote name='mommas_boy' post='1711132' date='Nov 25 2008, 11:11 PM']I think that some conservatives have a tendency to brand anything that is slightly statist (such as the Federal Reserve) as outright socialism. No; that's hyperbole.

I remember hearing something on Relevant Radio today (or yesterday?) that was a quote of JP II ... capitalism ... but moderated capitalism.[/quote]

John Smith also wrote about the need for charitable organizations and government regulation in "The Wealth of Nations." However, there is a strong case to be made for the creation of the Federal Reserve marking the beginning of the problems we are now experiencing, along with New Deal institutions like Fannie and Freddie. In fact, an economist interviewed by Raymond Arroyo on EWTN's "The World Over" even stated this. Part of the problem is that the Fed Chairman simply has too much power, not to mention the arbitrary nature of who the Chairman happens to be and how interest rates are set. The Fed's power and decisions go unchecked, except for how they affect economic growth, and we must admit there is more incentive to make the popular decisions more than the right one. It simply isn't a good system.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...