cappie Posted November 27, 2008 Posted November 27, 2008 A US Court of Appeals judge has ruled that a law suit may proceed against the Vatican alleging that Church officials should have warned of child sexual abuse by priests. The Australian reports the Vatican had tried to block a class action alleging that it orchestrated a cover up of sexual abuse by clergy with the argument that it was protected by laws granting sovereign states immunity from most US civil proceedings. Central to the case is a 1962 Vatican mandate, which outlined a policy of "strictest" secrecy regarding allegations of sexual abuse by clergy and threatened those who spoke out with excommunication. A US federal appeals court ruled the case brought by three Kentucky men can proceed because exceptions in the law allow the Vatican to be held liable for the actions of Church employees acting within the scope of their employment in the United States. "The portions of plaintiffs' claims that are based upon the conduct of bishops, archbishops and Holy See personnel while supervising allegedly abusive clergy satisfy all four requirements of the tortious act exception," Circuit Judge Julia Smith Gibbons wrote in a 20 page ruling. The Vatican cannot, however, be held liable for the actual abuse because these acts "were not done while ... acting within the scope of their employment," Ms Gibbons wrote. Jeffrey Lena, the lawyer for the Holy See, described the ruling as "very incremental" and noted it does not establish whether Vatican policy contributed to the allegations of thousands of incidents of abuse by Catholic clergy. "We're miles away from liability," he said. The ruling was hailed as a potential breakthrough by abuse victims. "This is a very encouraging sign and very long overdue step in the long march toward justice, prevention and healing," said Barbara Dorris, outreach director for the victims group, Survivors Network of those Abused by Priests. [url="http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story/0,25197,24709711-12377,00.html"]http://www.theaustralian.news.com.au/story...1-12377,00.html[/url]
Brother Adam Posted November 27, 2008 Posted November 27, 2008 How do they propose enforcing any ruling against the Holy See? War?
CatherineM Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 Deep pockets. De-frocked priests don't have any money. I wonder if any of these lawyers are catholic?
Brother Adam Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 They are not suing a diocese though, they are suing a sovereign independent nation. It would be like the US suing France. If the US ruled against France the only way to enforce the judgment should France not pay is to go to war with France. That's why we don't sue other nations. I don't see any way to enforce any judgment against the Holy Catholic Church.
CatherineM Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 They'd freeze assets. There is an elderly Canadian woman who has lived in Cuba for over 60 years. Her husband was very wealthy, and they have large accounts in a bank in Boston. She is now living in complete poverty in a mansion that is completely run down from decades of neglect. The US government will not let her have any of her money because she lives in Cuba. The Canadian government has tried intervening on her behalf, but nothing.
Brother Adam Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 The Vatican keeps its assets in the US?
CatherineM Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1712550' date='Nov 27 2008, 07:50 PM']The Vatican keeps its assets in the US?[/quote] I wouldn't be surprised if they didn't have bank accounts, brokerage accounts on Wall Street, and if they are allowing them to be sued, they may consider any Catholic property as fair game. I wonder how much of a lien they could get on the St. Patrick's Cathedral?
Brother Adam Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 If I sue the US government and win, can I take Wal-Mart as monetary compensation for my win? To me that would be the same situation. Each diocese is a sole cooperation onto itself and for business purposes is owned by the bishop, not the Holy See, right? I imagine the law is complex, but I don't see this going anywhere good.
CatherineM Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1712565' date='Nov 27 2008, 08:52 PM']If I sue the US government and win, can I take Wal-Mart as monetary compensation for my win? To me that would be the same situation. Each diocese is a sole cooperation onto itself and for business purposes is owned by the bishop, not the Holy See, right? I imagine the law is complex, but I don't see this going anywhere good.[/quote] The St. Pete diocese got sued for the actions of a priest that was pawned off on us by the Boston diocese. Our bishop at the time had no idea this guy was a pedophile. St. Pete did no cover-up, but still had to pay for the actions of a priest who was not a member of the diocese, and sexual abuse was obviously outside his job description. I have no doubt that they can find a judge willing to pierce that veil. This one will be before the Supreme Court at some point, where there are a couple of Catholics. The problem is that most people think the Vatican has complete control over the actions of every diocese (if only it worked that way). I would not want to be the Vatican lawyer arguing that the Vatican has no control over this stuff, when it is the Pope who has been expected to apologize for it all over the world. Plus, you don't want to seem to set a precedence that the Pope has no authority over the financial dealings of local churches when it is that threat of shackling a church or dismissing a priest that is used when a parish gets out of communion.
rkwright Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 wow this is really interesting. It seems to me that they are looking at the Catholic church, even the local ones, as some sort of business/organization - thus the employer/employee language. But the Church is claiming that the Church itself is a sovereign entity? But its hard to see the actual Catholic Church (not the Vatican city state) as a sovereign entity... would that mean that local parishes are more like embassies? I actually tend (at least right now) to see the Church more as an organization than a sovereign entity... but I'm open to other ideas?
Justin86 Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 (edited) No one said the the Catholic Church was a sovereign state, just the Vatican. These people are trying to sue the Vatican, not the Catholic Church. Edited November 28, 2008 by Justin86
Maximilianus Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 I'm going to sue the Vatican for discriminatory practices. I couldn't join the Swiss Guard because I wasn't tall enough. Sure, I wasn't a Swiss citizen or go to a Swiss military school, but that could have been easily fixed.
Tinkerlina Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='cappie' post='1712471' date='Nov 27 2008, 03:34 PM']Central to the case is a 1962 Vatican mandate, which outlined a policy of "strictest" secrecy regarding allegations of sexual abuse by clergy and threatened those who spoke out with excommunication.[/quote] It is ridiculous to try to sue the Vatican, and I don't see how the US Court of Appeals has any authority to allow or disallow the case as the Vatican is actually another country; however, the document mentioned is pretty disturbing! I don't understand it. -Katie
Didacus Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='Brother Adam' post='1712478' date='Nov 27 2008, 03:58 PM']How do they propose enforcing any ruling against the Holy See? War?[/quote] That's my thought. I wonder is president elect Obama would open a neww front against 'terrorism'?
Justin86 Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 I remember reading about how the US government believed Libya (I think) was responsible for the bombing an airplane in Europe back in the 80s that killed many Americans, and they filed suit to the World Court or something like that. In either case, Libya (or whoever it was) did have to pay up to the victims families.
CatherineM Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 I would stack the Swiss Guard up against anything Obama could throw at them.
Justin86 Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 (edited) I found a few things online that I was talking about: [quote]Bush Thanks Qaddafi for Settlement of Pan Am 103 Lawsuit U.S. and Libya will resume full diplomatic relations after Tripoli pays $1.5 billion into fund for families of American victims of Libyan terror. FOXNews.com Monday, November 17, 2008 WASHINGTON-- President Bush called Libya's Muammar al-Qaddafi to voice his satisfaction with a $1.5 billion payment that Tripoli made to settle a long-standing dispute over terrorist attacks, including the bombing a Pan Am jet over Scotland, the White House said Monday. In their conversation, Bush and Qaddafi "discussed that this agreement should help to bring a painful chapter in the history between our two countries closer to closure," White House spokesman Gordon Johndroe said in a statement. Libya's Oct. 31 payment cleared the last hurdle in restoration of full normalization of diplomatic relations between Washington and Tripoli. The money will go into a $1.8 billion fund that will pay $1.5 billion in claims for the 1988 Pan Am 103 bombing over Lockerbie, Scotland, and the 1986 bombing of a German disco. Another $300 million will go to Libyan victims of U.S. airstrikes ordered in retaliation for the disco bombing. David Welch, a State Department diplomat who negotiated the agreement, said at the time that payments to U.S. victims' families should start within days, and family groups hailed the news. "While we will always mourn the loss of life as a result of past terrorist activities, the settlement agreement is an important step in repairing the relationship between Libya and the United States," said the statement that Johndroe released Monday. "Libya has taken important steps on the road to normalizing its relations with the international community, beginning with its renunciation in 2003 of terrorism and weapons of mass destruction," the statement said. "The United States will continue to work on the bilateral relationship with Libya, with the aim of establishing a dialogue that encompasses all subjects, including human rights reform and the fight against terrorism."[/quote] Apparently, there is also a law on US books that allows Americans to sue foreign nationals if they were involved in a terrorist acts. [quote]AIRLINE INDUSTRY INFORMATION-©1997-2002 M2 COMMUNICATIONS LTD The relatives of seven Americans killed in the 1989 bombing of a UTA aircraft are suing Libya for more than USD3bn. The lawsuit - [b]filed under the Foreign Sovereign Immunities Act, which enables Americans to sue foreign nationals for personal injuries caused by terrorist acts[/b] - has been launched against the Libyan government and its leader, Moammar Gadhafi, for ... [url="http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-92946427.html"]http://www.highbeam.com/doc/1G1-92946427.html[/url][/quote] You have to subscribe to the site to get the rest of the article (sorry about that). Edited November 28, 2008 by Justin86
Justin86 Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1712732' date='Nov 29 2008, 12:53 AM']I would stack the Swiss Guard up against anything Obama could throw at them.[/quote] Seriously?
rkwright Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 I could be wrong, but I think the article could be read with the word 'Vatican' meaning Catholic Church, not the Vatican City State. Often times news articles will call bishops from the Vatican "The Vatican" refering to the Catholic Church and not the City State. Think of headlines like "Vatican calls for peace" "Vatican does X".
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now