Didacus Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1712732' date='Nov 28 2008, 11:53 AM']I would stack the Swiss Guard up against anything Obama could throw at them.[/quote] How about Saint Micheal?
Justin86 Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1712744' date='Nov 29 2008, 01:12 AM']How about Saint Micheal?[/quote] Him I would coincide. The Swiss Guard? Um, no.
rkwright Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 ok nevermind what I said earlier... I found the opinion... this is the first paragraph of it so far [quote]On June 4, 2004, plaintiffs, who claim to have been victims of sexual abuse by Roman Catholic clergy, filed a class action suit against the Holy See. The Holy See is both a foreign state and an unincorporated association and the central government of an international religious organization, the Roman Catholic Church. The United States has recognized the Holy See as a foreign sovereign since 1984.[/quote] I'll post anymore interesting bits when I read them. The opinion is unpublished so far. The case is O'Bryan v. Holy See.
CatherineM Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1712736' date='Nov 28 2008, 10:04 AM']Seriously?[/quote] Okay, lets assume that you get a big promotion, and they put you in charge of the invasion of the Vatican. First off, you know you can't actually destroy anything, or the world would freak out, so no smart bombs. I've seen documentaries on the training the Swiss Guard receives in close in, street to street tactics. I'll bet they also know where all the old secret passages are. You also probably wouldn't get any Catholic soldiers to obey you invasion plans. Besides, you'd have to go through lines of elderly nuns to even get to the Swiss Guard.
rkwright Posted November 28, 2008 Posted November 28, 2008 (edited) Well I think the Court applied the law correctly. Here is the law... 28 USC 1605 (a) A foreign state [b]shall not be immune [/b]from the jurisdiction of courts of the United States or of the States in any case- ... (5) not otherwise encompassed in paragraph (2) above, [b]in which money damages are sought against a foreign state[/b] for personal injury or death, or damage to or loss of property, [b]occurring in the United States and caused by the tortious act [/b]or omission of that foreign state or [b]of any official or employee of that foreign state while acting within the scope of his office or employment[/b]; except this paragraph shall not apply to - The Holy See won on a few of the claims... [quote]Looking first to the fourth requirement for the application of the tortious act exception, the Kentucky Supreme Court's holding in Osborne, 31 S.W.3d at 915, leads to the inescapable conclusion that the alleged acts of sexual abuse were not done while the alleged tortfeasors were acting within the scope of their employment. Thus, the tortious act exception to the FSIA's grant of immunity cannot apply to permit suit against the Holy See for sexual abuse by its clergy, even if the other requirements for its application are met. Furthermore, as per the FSIA's explicit terms, in order for the tortious act exception to apply, the tortious acts in question must have occurred in the United States. Therefore, any portion of plaintiffs' claims that relies upon acts committed by the Holy See abroad cannot survive. For example, the tortious act exception to the FSIA's grant of immunity would not include any theory of liability premised on the Holy See's own negligent supervision because such acts presumably occurred abroad; moreover, a direct claim leveled against the Holy See for promulgating the 1962 Policy would not fall within the tortious act exception because it too presumably occurred abroad. In turn, plaintiffs cannot pursue claims based upon the alleged sexual abuse of priests or based upon the acts of the Holy See that occurred abroad.FN11[/quote] But lost on a few others... [quote]First and contrary to the Holy See's protestations, plaintiffs have pled both that the relevant archbishops, bishops and other Holy See personnel had knowledge of the alleged sexual abuse of priests and that they failed to act on that knowledge. In doing so, it would seem that the complaint also pleads that conduct of the archbishops, bishops and other Holy See personnel were a substantial factor in causing plaintiffs' damages, satisfying Kentucky's causation requirements. In addition, and as already noted, tortious acts committed by bishops, archbishops and other Holy See personnel while engaged in the supervision of allegedly abusive priests satisfy the requirements of the FSIA's tortious act exception that the tortious act occur in the United States and within the scope of employment. Also, for the conduct of bishops and archbishops and other Holy See personnel to serve as a basis for jurisdiction under the tortious act exception, these bishops, archbishops and Holy See personnel must have been employees of the Holy See. As noted above, under Kentucky law, this inquiry focuses on the degree of control exercised by the employer over the individual or individuals in question. In their complaint, plaintiffs allege facts that demonstrate that the Holy See exercised a significant degree of control over the bishops and archbishops accused of having committed the tortious acts in question. Taking these allegations as true, plaintiffs have sufficiently pled the employee element of the tortious activity exception.[/quote] Either way this only proves jurisdiction, no damages yet. As a side note, O'Bryan the listed plaintiff, was allegedly molested in 1920. Almost 100 years ago.... Edited November 28, 2008 by rkwright
Mr_Private_Person Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [img]http://www.lifeemerging.com/files/images/captain-kirk.jpg[/img] Captain Kirk, while on trial in a Klingon Court, for what his two crewmen had done to the Klingon ambassador, said that he was responsible for what his crewmen did, and was sentenced to a prison world very few people live through. Why is your leaders not held up to the same accountability?
Era Might Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1712759' date='Nov 28 2008, 11:35 AM']Okay, lets assume that you get a big promotion, and they put you in charge of the invasion of the Vatican. First off, you know you can't actually destroy anything, or the world would freak out, so no smart bombs. I've seen documentaries on the training the Swiss Guard receives in close in, street to street tactics. I'll bet they also know where all the old secret passages are. You also probably wouldn't get any Catholic soldiers to obey you invasion plans. Besides, you'd have to go through lines of elderly nuns to even get to the Swiss Guard.[/quote] Isn't the Vatican in the middle of Rome, which is technically in the separate nation of Italy? So theoretically, wouldn't an invasion of the Vatican require permission from the Italian state to wage war from their land/air?
Justin86 Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1712759' date='Nov 29 2008, 01:35 AM']Okay, lets assume that you get a big promotion, and they put you in charge of the invasion of the Vatican. First off, you know you can't actually destroy anything, or the world would freak out, so no smart bombs. I've seen documentaries on the training the Swiss Guard receives in close in, street to street tactics. I'll bet they also know where all the old secret passages are. You also probably wouldn't get any Catholic soldiers to obey you invasion plans. Besides, you'd have to go through lines of elderly nuns to even get to the Swiss Guard.[/quote] Why would Obama have any inhibitions against bombing the Vatican? He's the Messiah, after all.
Mr_Private_Person Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 LOL! I don't understand why you don't want your leaders accountable? I guess the holy see is above the law. What do you call any large group of people who have leaders who are not accountable, a dictatorship. Good luck living in it.
CatherineM Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [quote name='Mr_Private_Person' post='1713323' date='Nov 28 2008, 10:22 PM']LOL! I don't understand why you don't want your leaders accountable? I guess the holy see is above the law. What do you call any large group of people who have leaders who are not accountable, a dictatorship. Good luck living in it.[/quote] I don't mind holding a leader responsible for something within his area of responsibility or control. Suing the Vatican for what a priest did decades ago is equivalent to suing the US government for a rape committed by a mailman during the depression.
Justin86 Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1713327' date='Nov 29 2008, 01:31 PM']I don't mind holding a leader responsible for something within his area of responsibility or control. Suing the Vatican for what a priest did decades ago is equivalent to suing the US government for a rape committed by a mailman during the depression.[/quote] Good analogy.
Justin86 Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 Oh, and I would really have to get a big promotion to be put in charge of something that big. The Navy doesn't even seem to have it in their hearts to promote me to E-4.
Maximilianus Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1713367' date='Nov 29 2008, 12:13 AM']Oh, and I would really have to get a big promotion to be put in charge of something that big. The Navy doesn't even seem to have it in their hearts to promote me to E-4.[/quote] If you get promoted you'd have to change your title thingy to "Resident Petty Officer of Phatmass", Anchor Clanker would be unfitting for an NCO.
CatherineM Posted November 29, 2008 Posted November 29, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1713367' date='Nov 28 2008, 11:13 PM']Oh, and I would really have to get a big promotion to be put in charge of something that big. The Navy doesn't even seem to have it in their hearts to promote me to E-4.[/quote] I think my son passed the test 6 times before he got promoted. He was ready to give up. When he signed up for his rating during delayed entry, there were a lot of openings because they had decided to pull all civilian cooks out of shore/base installations because of security concerns. There had been a threat to poison the entire base by food. By the time he got to boot camp, they had changed their minds. Mostly because civilian cooks are cheaper. Once he finally got his crow, he said that his job didn't change any, he got a few more dollars in his pay, which were promptly spent for him by the little woman, so I don't think he really cared. He was also short by then, and wasn't going to make the Navy a career.
Justin86 Posted November 30, 2008 Posted November 30, 2008 (edited) double post... Edited November 30, 2008 by Justin86
Justin86 Posted November 30, 2008 Posted November 30, 2008 [quote name='Maximilianus' post='1713383' date='Nov 29 2008, 02:50 PM']If you get promoted you'd have to change your title thingy to "Resident Petty Officer of Phatmass", Anchor Clanker would be unfitting for an NCO.[/quote] Well, if I ever did get Petty Officer I would have to change my member title to fit in with my tradtion of ridiclousness. I was thinking "Resident Hospital Corpsman Third Class Petty Officer of the Navy of Phatmass", should do the trick. [quote name='CatherineM' post='1713562' date='Nov 30 2008, 12:51 AM']I think my son passed the test 6 times before he got promoted. He was ready to give up. When he signed up for his rating during delayed entry, there were a lot of openings because they had decided to pull all civilian cooks out of shore/base installations because of security concerns. There had been a threat to poison the entire base by food. By the time he got to boot camp, they had changed their minds. Mostly because civilian cooks are cheaper. Once he finally got his crow, he said that his job didn't change any, he got a few more dollars in his pay, which were promptly spent for him by the little woman, so I don't think he really cared. He was also short by then, and wasn't going to make the Navy a career.[/quote] In these down-sizing days I'm not even sure if it's possible to take the E-4 exam six times before high year tenor kicks in and they give you the boot. I think it's something like you have five years to make it.
Vincent Vega Posted December 1, 2008 Posted December 1, 2008 [quote name='Justin86' post='1713364' date='Nov 29 2008, 01:07 AM']Good analogy.[/quote] [i]Awesome[/i] Analogy.
Tinkerlina Posted December 1, 2008 Posted December 1, 2008 [quote name='cappie' post='1712471' date='Nov 27 2008, 03:34 PM']Central to the case is a 1962 Vatican mandate, which outlined a policy of "strictest" secrecy regarding allegations of sexual abuse by clergy and threatened those who spoke out with excommunication.[/quote] Does anyone know more about this document? It worries me BUT I realize that it could've been reported inaccurately or at least, misunderstood. -Katie
Didacus Posted December 3, 2008 Posted December 3, 2008 [quote name='Didacus' post='1712744' date='Nov 28 2008, 12:12 PM']How about Saint Micheal?[/quote] [quote name='Justin86' post='1712748' date='Nov 28 2008, 12:15 PM']Him I would coincide. The Swiss Guard? Um, no. [/quote] Not sure waht you mean here.
IrishSalesian Posted December 3, 2008 Posted December 3, 2008 Id like to see someone try to sue the Vatican. And an invasion on a defenseless nation, one that is protected by nearly every super power in the world, is not going to happen, especially when we are one of the nations sworn to protect the Vatican.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now