Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

When Did Your Church Begin


Recommended Posts

Posted

When did you church begin

[url="http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erqi86NCvWA"]http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Erqi86NCvWA[/url]

I've seen this in a tract before but it is powerful in video form on youtube.

Posted

When I worked at an ecumenical agency, there was a book on the shelf called, world denominations, I think. Anyway, it listed when and by whom each denomination was started, and under Catholic it said, Jesus Christ, 33AD. I thought that was wicked that a protestant publication (I'm pretty sure it was WCC) would actually admit that in writing.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1731302' date='Dec 18 2008, 01:26 PM'][snip]

I thought that was wicked that a protestant publication (I'm pretty sure it was WCC) would actually admit that in writing.[/quote]

And yet not come home?

that is what I find strange about it. But I agree its cool nonetheless.

Posted

[quote name='Didacus' post='1731305' date='Dec 18 2008, 11:38 AM']And yet not come home?

that is what I find strange about it. But I agree its cool nonetheless.[/quote]

I've known two former Protestant ministers who converted, and both said that when they started to study the early church history, and the writings of the early church fathers, was when they started to look at the Catholic church. I guess they don't teach those topics real hard in Protestant theological colleges.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1731367' date='Dec 18 2008, 03:05 PM']I guess they don't teach those topics real hard in Protestant theological colleges.[/quote]
Well duh! It would be like playing a video of the source of the meat in the tacos, so very tasty and good for you,, so very tasty and good for you, at Taco Bell next to the cash register. It would drive the entire customer base away. :P

Maria_Faustina
Posted

It definitely makes a good point! (Because it's true, of course). People really don't know the history of Christian churches other than their own, and sometimes not even theirs! Would be good to make them think about it...I quite like it.
(Oh how I wish there were no typos in it, however...personally it is hard for me to take people/their point seriously when letters are missing, etc. I'm not saying a misspelled word in casual online conversation is wrong, but when you're trying to prove something, and being serious, and using cool music behind it and all...it helps to appear reliable, even if grammatically!)

Posted

"evil men"? i don't think that was necessary. "misled" or "confused" is better

Maria_Faustina
Posted

[quote name='Seven77' post='1733888' date='Dec 22 2008, 01:48 PM']"evil men"? i don't think that was necessary. "misled" or "confused" is better[/quote]

Yes, that is true... most of the various founders thOUGht they were doing the right thing.

Posted

[quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1733973' date='Dec 22 2008, 03:35 PM']Yes, that is true... most of the various founders thOUGht they were doing the right thing.[/quote]


While I agree that might have been a bit over the top, I would say that this is under the bottom. We don't know their hearts and so they may well have had evil in them. We should simply let God be the judge. The fruits of their works are evil.

Posted

[quote name='Maria_Faustina' post='1733610' date='Dec 21 2008, 09:52 PM'](Oh how I wish there were no typos in it, however...personally it is hard for me to take people/their point seriously when letters are missing, etc. I'm not saying a misspelled word in casual online conversation is wrong, but when you're trying to prove something, and being serious, and using cool music behind it and all...it helps to appear reliable, even if grammatically!)[/quote]+J.M.J.+
off topic, but i totally agree!

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1731367' date='Dec 18 2008, 03:05 PM']I've known two former Protestant ministers who converted, and both said that when they started to study the early church history, and the writings of the early church fathers, was when they started to look at the Catholic church. I guess they don't teach those topics real hard in Protestant theological colleges.[/quote]

Some of them do. I know my friends at Southern Baptist Theological Seminary study plenty of Church history. They read Augustine, study the Didache, etc. They seem to know their Church history better than most priests, even if they do interpret many events their own lens.

dominicansoul
Posted

i think many protestants will admit we were the Church founded by Jesus Christ, but they say somewhere down the road, we went off the deep end, and they are the true Christians, continuing the true church...

LouisvilleFan
Posted

Yeah, the grammatical and spelling errors are a bit annoying.

Right from the start, they assume that most Christians are concerned with who founded their church. I think they first need to give people a reason to be concerned before jumping into the topic of who founded each denomination.

Second, for each denomination, they don't give any convicting reasons to question one's existing belief. Anyone who gets into Church history knows the Great Schism was largely the fruit of cultural division in the Roman Empire between East and West that was exacerbated by pride on both sides.

And with King Henry VIII, some of our own popes put him to shame. At least he wanted to be married. While we know about apostolic succession, most people don't know about that and even fewer care about it. They need to be shown a reason to care that applies to their own lives. The biggest challenge is first convincing someone from our post-modern culture that they should care about truth.

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1736834' date='Dec 28 2008, 02:00 PM']i think many protestants will admit we were the Church founded by Jesus Christ, but they say somewhere down the road, we went off the deep end, and they are the true Christians, continuing the true church...[/quote]


The problem that they seem to miss is that Christ promised that the gates of hell would never overcome his church. So then for them to say it had deteriorated to the point where it needed replacement violates what Christ said about his Church.

Also, how can they be continuing the church if they don't believe many of its teachings that have been passed along from the beginning?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1741015' date='Jan 1 2009, 10:32 PM']The problem that they seem to miss is that Christ promised that the gates of hell would never overcome his church. So then for them to say it had deteriorated to the point where it needed replacement violates what Christ said about his Church.

Also, how can they be continuing the church if they don't believe many of its teachings that have been passed along from the beginning?[/quote]

Perhaps the Reformation was being the very movement through which Christ defended his Church.

The Church Fathers aren't unanimous in their teachings. Obviously, some fell into heresy. Besides, when there appears to be a contradiction between Scripture and a Father of the Church, which do you think wins out?

LouisvilleFan
Posted

If you want to actually learn about a Protestant view of Church history, you have to go to the source. It's rare that a person on one side of a debate can honestly present the other side, so why accept a Catholic's opinion of the Protestant understandin of Church history? Writing them off as uninformed or even dumb is simply being uninformed yourself. If you're interested in engaging the debate, you first have to know who your are debating. There are several podcasts you can get off iTunes about Church history by Protestant professors and preachers. They're free... you can listen to them on the road or at work (if you sit in a cubicle all day like me).

I'm starting a series now that one of my Baptist friends has been recommending to me from the Reformed Theological Seminary called "History of Christianity I." This is a recorded lecture series from RTS... like auditing the class without being there. There's another series by a Baptist minister that I probably won't listen to entirely, but want to at least get the good stuff on stuff like the Reformation :)

Posted

First, I used to be a protestant. While I was still a protestant I looked at the history of my denomination's beliefs and how they arrived at them. Now I'm a convert. So I'm not speaking out of ignorance sir.

As far as the reformation being the means by which Christ defended his church: if the "faithful" departed the mothership to become protestants it cannot be true that this is the mechanism Christ used to protect his church since the form and beliefs of protestantism are radically different and the sacraments are missing (runon sentence?). If you mean that the reformation was the wakeup call for the church then what you say would make sense since the counter-reformation did do some good.

Please clarify what you meant by the reformation being the means by which Christ defended his Church.

Second, one does not debate in the transmundane lane.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1741499' date='Jan 2 2009, 02:42 PM']First, I used to be a protestant. While I was still a protestant I looked at the history of my denomination's beliefs and how they arrived at them. Now I'm a convert. So I'm not speaking out of ignorance sir.[/quote]

The ignorance I'm referring to is those Catholics who think all Protestants must be igorant of Church history because they are not Catholic. I just heard two hour-long podcasts from the Reformed Theological Seminary about the Apostolic Fathers and heard a lot of stuff that rings bells for me (nice pun, eh?). Still, many Evangelicals remain convinced of the singular authority of Scripture even [i]after[/i] learning Church history. It isn't because they never got the Didache memo.

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1741499' date='Jan 2 2009, 02:42 PM']Please clarify what you meant by the reformation being the means by which Christ defended his Church.[/quote]

I meant the Reformation itself was the tool used by Christ to defend his Church. Of course, the Church I'm referring to believes in Scripture Alone and Faith Alone, so naturally this Church has no concept of a "mothership." That idea might as well be from outer space.

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1741499' date='Jan 2 2009, 02:42 PM']Second, one does not debate in the transmundane lane.[/quote]

But we are free to mock-debate, right? ;)

Posted

lol, yes we can mock debate =P

I think that the reason that many evangelicals will cling to sola scriptura even after hearing a compelling account of history is that, well, frankly once someone fully realizes a truth they are compelled to act upon it. Whatever that truth happens to be, in this case the realization of the undeniable nature of church history, that person is immediately put at a fork-in-the-road. They must decide to accept or deny the facts they have been shown.

The bugger about truth is that it then requires action. Many protestants are unwilling to face the social rejection from their fellow protestants that will happen if they embrace the Catholic Church.

As protestants we are trained from an early age that anything Catholic is automatically wrong and should be dismissed. Fellow converts, is this not true?

Lucky for me I had friends who were unwilling to tolerate my evasive maneuvers and irish stubbornness.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...