Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

When Did Your Church Begin


Recommended Posts

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1741844' date='Jan 3 2009, 03:15 AM']lol, yes we can mock debate =P

I think that the reason that many evangelicals will cling to sola scriptura even after hearing a compelling account of history is that, well, frankly once someone fully realizes a truth they are compelled to act upon it. Whatever that truth happens to be, in this case the realization of the undeniable nature of church history, that person is immediately put at a fork-in-the-road. They must decide to accept or deny the facts they have been shown.

The bugger about truth is that it then requires action. Many protestants are unwilling to face the social rejection from their fellow protestants that will happen if they embrace the Catholic Church.[/quote]

Yes, culture and social pressure have a lot to do with it. For example, during this Reformed Theological Seminary podcast I started on Church history, the professor expresses some level of disappointment about both the maturity of doctrine in the first centuries and, specifically, the teaching of meritorious good works. Of course, he's searching for confirmation of Reformed theology and that sure ain't it! But, he proceeds to quote one Church Father who he believed got it right: Clement of Rome, a successor of Peter!

When a Reformed professors quotes one of the popes to affirm his own doctrine, one has to question just how far apart we are. Granted, there are real differences, and one reason I'm listening to this podcast is to engage my Baptist friend (who recommended it to me) in conversation about it. He's asked me to recommend some good Catholic podcasts. Only grace can bring conversion. In the meantime, Reformed theologians will continue to accept from the Fathers what they find acceptable and reject the rest, accounting the difference to the failings that are expected of imperfect people discerning truth.

Although, I have to think that another reason Reformed Christians are able to "get away" with their interpretation of the Fathers is that none of their peers is in a position to challenge them to seriously consider the implications of what they observe from Christianity's infancy. While they may dialogue with Catholics once in a while, their inner circles are fellow Reformed thinkers.

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1741844' date='Jan 3 2009, 03:15 AM']As protestants we are trained from an early age that anything Catholic is automatically wrong and should be dismissed. Fellow converts, is this not true?[/quote]

That's actually not my experience. For one, the [url="http://www.thearda.com/mapsReports/reports/state/21_2000_Adherents.asp"]two largest denominations in Kentucky[/url] are the Southern Baptist Convention and Roman Catholic Church :) Baptists here, if they live in any urban area, are going to run into Catholics either at work or in class or wherever. For that matter, I know quite a few Baptists who teach at Catholic schools, and some of the city and state's biggest events are Catholic picnics attended by all kinds of people. The result (besides a lot of Baptist-Catholic marriages) is believers on each side have a more realistic view of the other.

In addition, my own family is all over the place. My dad was raised Baptist, my mom was Church of Christ, and they eventually joined a Lutheran church after getting married following their neighbor's invitation (you cannot underestimate the value of [i]personally inviting[/i] your friends and neighbors to church or Mass). Now, my dad's sister converted to Catholicism and all her kids and grandkids are Catholic. The extended family is everywhere from Nazarene, Unitarian, Jewish, theistic, and agnostic. Suffice to say, my parents were pretty laid back about my beliefs, long as I'm Christian.

And when it comes to my Baptist friends that I went to church with here in Louisville for three years before swimming the Tiber, some expressed disagreement and others curiosity. One couple actually became Orthodox. None have condemned my decision or been ugly in any way. I know things wouldn't go so smoothly in most of the South where Catholicism is a tiny minority, but I also wonder if most of those who consider Catholicism aren't intimidated both by the "royalty," hierarchy, and immensity of the Catholic Church and an overblown expectation that their family and friends might reject them.

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1742083' date='Jan 3 2009, 03:17 PM']But, he proceeds to quote one Church Father who he believed got it right: Clement of Rome, a successor of Peter![/quote]
What is the quote, and what did Clement supposedly get right?

Posted

[quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1742083' date='Jan 3 2009, 06:17 PM']That's actually not my experience. For one, the [url="http://www.thearda.com/mapsReports/reports/state/21_2000_Adherents.asp"]two largest denominations in Kentucky[/url] are the Southern Baptist Convention and Roman Catholic Church :) Baptists here, if they live in any urban area, are going to run into Catholics either at work or in class or wherever. For that matter, I know quite a few Baptists who teach at Catholic schools, and some of the city and state's biggest events are Catholic picnics attended by all kinds of people. The result (besides a lot of Baptist-Catholic marriages) is believers on each side have a more realistic view of the other.[/quote]


You are fortunate then sir. If my Texan Southern Baptist Grandmother on my mom's side (who now has alzeimers and doesn't know who I am) had found out I'd pope'd while she still had her faculties she would have driven me out of her home with a bullwhip.

My brother, who attends Moody Bible Institute in Chicago and is studying to be a minister, accuses me of making a rash decision (took 1.5 years) and a horrible mistake by joining the Catholic Church.

Maybe it was because I went to a protestant highschool?

Posted

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1742283' date='Jan 3 2009, 06:34 PM']My brother, who attends Moody Bible Institute in Chicago and is studying to be a minister, accuses me of making a rash decision (took 1.5 years) and a horrible mistake by joining the Catholic Church.[/quote]
Such a quick decision. It took me eight years to convert to Catholicism.

:biglol:

cmotherofpirl
Posted

If you are a member of the Jewish faith, your religion was founded by Abraham about 4,000 years ago.
If you are a Hindu, your religion was developed in India around 1,500 B.C.

If you are a Buddhist, your religion split from Hinduism, and was founded by Buddha, Prince Siddhartha Gautama of India, about 500 B.C.

If you are Catholic, Jesus Christ began your religion in the year 33.

If you are Islamic, Mohammed started your religion in what is now Saudi Arabia around 600 A.D.

If you are Eastern Orthodox, your sect separated from Catholicism around the year 1000.

If you are a Lutheran, your religion was founded my Martin Luther, an ex-Monk of the Catholic Church, in 1517.

If you belong to the Church of England (Anglican), your religion was founded by King Henry VIII in the year 1534 because the pope would not grant him a divorce with the right to remarry.

If you are a Presbyterian, your religion was founded when John Knox brought the teachings of John Calvin to Scotland in the year 1560.

If you are a Unitarian, your religious group developed in Europe in the 1500's

If you are a Congregationalist, your religion branched off from Puritanism in the early 1600's in England.

If you are a Baptist, you owe the tenets of your religion to John Smyth, who launched it in Amsterdam in 1607.

If you are a Methodist, your religion was founded by John and Charles Wesley in England in 1744.

If you are an Episcopalian, your religion was brought over from England, to the American colonies and formed a separate religion founded by Samuel Seabury in 1789.

If you are a Mormon (Latter-Day Saints), Joseph Smith started your church in Palmyra, N.Y., NOT Salt Lake City, which would have been my guess. The year was 1830.

If you worship with the Salvation Army (yes, it's a religious group, not just an organization that collects money in kettles on Christmas and serves dinners to the homeless), your sect began with William Booth in London in 1865.

If you are a Christian Scientist, you look to 1879 as the year your religion was founded by Mary Baker Eddy.

If you are a Jehovah's Witness, your religion was founded by Charles Taze Russell in Pennsylvania in the 1870's.

If you are a Pentecostal, your religion was started in the United States in 1901.

If you are an agnostic, you profess an uncertainty or a skepticism about the existence of God or a Higher Being.

If you are an atheist, you do not believe in the existence of God or any other higher power.

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1742289' date='Jan 3 2009, 06:40 PM']If you are Eastern Orthodox, your sect separated from Catholicism around the year 1000.[/quote]
I doubt the Eastern Orthodox would agree with that statement.

:bigshock:

Posted

[quote name='sweens8403' post='1742283' date='Jan 3 2009, 07:34 PM']You are fortunate then sir. If my Texan Southern Baptist Grandmother on my mom's side (who now has alzeimers and doesn't know who I am) had found out I'd pope'd while she still had her faculties she would have driven me out of her home with a bullwhip.

My brother, who attends Moody Bible Institute in Chicago and is studying to be a minister, accuses me of making a rash decision (took 1.5 years) and a horrible mistake by joining the Catholic Church.

Maybe it was because I went to a protestant highschool?[/quote]

My Okie Southern Baptist Grandmother pretty much disowned my mom for marrying a Catholic. When I was in high school, she begrudging told me that I'd sure gotten a good education from those nuns.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

My grandfather who was scots presbyterian couldn't get work after marrying my irish catholic grandmother. My baptist aunt reassured me everytime I saw her I was going to hell for being catholic.

Posted (edited)

My family thought a Catholic had to give a quarter to the priest every time he received communion and that was why hosts were about the size of a quarter.

Edited by Apotheoun
cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1742386' date='Jan 3 2009, 10:56 PM']My family thought a Catholic had to give a quarter to the priest every time he received communion and that was why hosts were about the size of a quarter.[/quote]
:lol_pound: now that is a new one.

Posted

[quote name='Apotheoun' post='1742311' date='Jan 3 2009, 09:56 PM']I doubt the Eastern Orthodox would agree with that statement.

:bigshock:[/quote]


Agreed. The video linked at the beginning is even worse regarding the seperation of the churches in the east. The schisms in the Church were hardly one-sided, and I see no purpose in assigning blame at this late juncture. Suffice it to say there was a separation and, God willing, we will be able to heal those divisions and once more share in full communion, East and West. But saying, "You left the true church!" doesn't really lend itself to that, does it?

I understand that the proliferation of Protestant churches, some with quite bizarre, wacky and even harmful theology, is a cause for concern, but I don't really think that this is the best way to engage people in a discussion over it. Sure, real knowledge of Church history can sometimes lead to conversions. But a list of names and dates? Chances are that most members of those denominations are quite aware of the relevant ones! Seriously, have you ever met a Lutheran who didn't know who Luther was and what his beef with the Catholic church was? They drill that at Confirmation class. Likewise on a Methodist being ignorant of the Wesley brothers; have you seen a Methodist hymnal? Who wrote about half of those songs? (Okay, I'm exagerating, but you get the point.) The author of the list may have been surprised to find out that Joseph Smith started in New York state, but Mormons sure wouldn't be; they know all about the persecution early Mormons faced that led to them fleeing West to Utah.

I guess my point is that I don't really like in-your-face tactics and don't find that they encourage dialogue.

Of course, I do believe that the Catholic Church was founded by Jesus Christ, and began on Pentacost, when the Holy Spirit descended upon the Apostles gathered in the upper room.

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1742470' date='Jan 4 2009, 12:19 AM']I understand that the proliferation of Protestant churches, some with quite bizarre, wacky and even harmful theology, is a cause for concern, but I don't really think that this is the best way to engage people in a discussion over it. Sure, real knowledge of Church history can sometimes lead to conversions. But a list of names and dates? Chances are that most members of those denominations are quite aware of the relevant ones! Seriously, have you ever met a Lutheran who didn't know who Luther was and what his beef with the Catholic church was? They drill that at Confirmation class. Likewise on a Methodist being ignorant of the Wesley brothers; have you seen a Methodist hymnal? Who wrote about half of those songs? (Okay, I'm exagerating, but you get the point.) The author of the list may have been surprised to find out that Joseph Smith started in New York state, but Mormons sure wouldn't be; they know all about the persecution early Mormons faced that led to them fleeing West to Utah.

I guess my point is that I don't really like in-your-face tactics and don't find that they encourage dialogue.

Of course, I do believe that the Catholic Church was founded by Jesus Christ, and began on Pentacost, when the Holy Spirit descended upon the Apostles gathered in the upper room.[/quote]
While one might know the origin of one's own denomination, many people are surprised to find the source of others. Simple historical facts are not in-your-face tactics, but simple honesty.
Dialogue must proceed in truth.

Vincent Vega
Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1742470' date='Jan 4 2009, 12:19 AM']...Likewise on a Methodist being ignorant of the Wesley brothers; have you seen a Methodist hymnal? Who wrote about half of those songs? ...[/quote]
Agreed on the bit about the Orthodox, however, I don't think the majority of protestants don't spend nearly the amount of time on church history that you seem to think they do. I spent the first 10 years of my life a Presbyterian, and the next 5 a Methodist, attending sunday school, youth group, vacation bible school, so forth. Never once in those fifteen years did I learn a thing about church history. I'd bet a hefty sum that if you asked my mother, grandmother, or great-grandmother who founded the Presbyterian church, they wouldn't know. Heck, I know more about the Presbyterian synods in this country than they do! (PCA vs. PCUSA and so on).
Sure, the Wesleys are all over the Methodist hymnal (and even all over our "Catholic Community Hymnal" published by OCP...that's another story), but how many really know what's behind those names?
Mind you, I'm certain that there are groups that spend a great deal of time on church history, - I'd be willing to bet that fundies are amongst those, probably some Lutherans too - however, I don't think your run of the mill protestant would know Calvin from Wesley.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...