cheryl Posted December 22, 2008 Posted December 22, 2008 I know I said that I was going to address another issue (universal salvation) before now, but to tell you the truth, I have been so down lately that I haven't really had it in me to do the research I promised. My gentleman friend, has told me that he could never become catholic and that he needed a 'lutheran girl'. It's obvious that he still loves me immensely, and I can understand him saying as much, but I still feel somewhat broken up with. One of his concerns is that he feels (and rightly so) that if we are a couple, we ought to work together toward a common end (in this case, religion), and not act as if we were two separate individuals with two separate goals, deciding to 'co-habitate'-his words (if in the event we were to get married). The thing is, this, 'working together' has turned into trying to persuade me to his 'side'. And I have contributed to that out of fear. I am afraid that if I don't come to agree with the lutheran confessions et al, I will loose him and my heart is breaking. To top matters off, as I mentioned before, he is a walking encyclopedia and I am no match for him. I can't argue sufficiently, I don't have the bible verses he needs to back up my assertions, and I am just at a lost. For example, we got to discussing (arguing really) over whether or not the saints in heaven are aware of our particulars. Whenever I bring up examples, such as Moses and Elijah, he says that we don't know if that's the rule and not the exception. When I tried to point out that the saints are now with God and that God is with us, ergo, the saints are with us too, he says, (following Chemnitz (a lutheran theologian)) that we all are in Christ, and yet we can't say based on that that the saints are with us as God is with us, because Christians in both Europe and China are in Christ to, and yet a European Christian is not aware of every single thing pertaining to the Chinese Christian, unless he were to write him a letter ect. And then he added, there is nothing to say that the saints can read hearts (and thus know the unspoken prayers therein). In the past, he's also quoted the verse which goes, "But you are our Father, though Abraham does not know us or Israel acknowledge us; you, O LORD, are our Father, our Redeemer from of old is your name. " (Is 63:16). I've found this verse as a proof-text bothersome for awhile now. It doesn't strike me as saying anything about whether or not we can talk to the saints in heaven, but I can't really put my finger on why....something just doesn't seem right. Given all of this, the only other thing I could say to him was, 'It breaks my heart to think that a person--that is Mary, whom I loved and thought I had a relationship with most of my life, doesn't even know me'. Which doesn't really 'prove' anything. Only that to concede to his 'side' makes me very, very sad. Like I said, I've been so down about this, that I haven't really felt like doing much at all, so please forgive me for not fulfilling my obligations. If anyone has any advice or comfort...I could really use a shoulder right now. It's too close to Christmas to talk to my priest. And I've been so down that I haven't been to Mass or Confession. I don't even know if I'll make it to Mass on Christmas. All I want to do is sleep and cry (but most of the time the tears won't come).
CatherineM Posted December 22, 2008 Posted December 22, 2008 I've had enough experience with divorce and annulments unfortunately to know one thing, marriage is hard even when everything lines up. When you have a major philosophical difference whether it is cultural, religious or even an OU grad trying to marry an OSU grad, it can lead to conflict. I know you are going through some serious anguish right now, and I wish I could say something to make you feel better. Your situation is why I was always told to never date someone you couldn't marry. Falling in love with someone only to realize later that the marriage would be full of strife or a compromise to your faith, is so painful. Marriage should be two people trying to help each other to salvation. If marriage to this man would lead you away from the church, I think you know the answer I would give you. Knowing just doesn't make it any easier.
HisChildForever Posted December 22, 2008 Posted December 22, 2008 I agree with Catherine. Understand that this is, unfortunately, very common in our society. I was in a situation where I was asked to compromise my beliefs, which was really a segway into being asked to throw my beliefs into the trash. It really is not worth it. I thank God that I left before I lost everything. I know it is painful but you can not turn from God to turn towards a human being, no matter how much you love the man.
cheryl Posted December 23, 2008 Author Posted December 23, 2008 Catherine and HisChildForever, [quote name='CatherineM' post='1733865' date='Dec 22 2008, 02:06 PM']Your situation is why I was always told to never date someone you couldn't marry. Falling in love with someone only to realize later that the marriage would be full of strife or a compromise to your faith, is so painful.[/quote] I got involved with him years before dad died (almost two yrs ago), and thought I'd remain lutheran (because of dad-he made being lutheran bearable, because I could talk to him about the things which bothered me, and since he was very active in the church, I could be also (it took my mind off certain theological tenets). Dad would have supported me becoming catholic, the thing that mattered to him the most was that I was going to church, but at that time, I couldn't really conceive of doing anything apart from Dad. --------------------- [quote]Marriage should be two people trying to help each other to salvation. If marriage to this man would lead you away from the church, I think you know the answer I would give you. Knowing just doesn't make it any easier.[/quote] [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1733877' date='Dec 22 2008, 02:31 PM']I agree with Catherine. Understand that this is, unfortunately, very common in our society. I was in a situation where I was asked to compromise my beliefs, which was really a segway into being asked to throw my beliefs into the trash. It really is not worth it. I thank God that I left before I lost everything. I know it is painful but you can not turn from God to turn towards a human being, no matter how much you love the man.[/quote] I know. I suppose I keep hoping that somehow things will work out. And because I don't have the answers he needs, I'm starting to doubt things myself and yet it offends me greatly when Scripture is slung back and forth-each 'side' having their own 'proof-texts' as it were. He says it's not, but a part of my arguments with him seem to be reduced to what I have termed, 'biblicalism'. It doesn't matter what's in my heart, what others have told me, ect. -I feel as if I can't 'prove' something from Scripture to another's satisfaction (at the moment, his) then I'm sunk. Maybe it's pride-wanting to come up with an answer to every objection I come across-maybe a feeling of inadequacy (as if I'm always having to 'prove' myself). Maybe both...I don't know. When I told him I was going to convert to Catholicism, he didn't take it well (God bless him). I told him, that I would back up. I would continue to talk to my priest and attend RCIA after the first of the yr. and just see how things go and that I would share with him whatever I thought was pertinent. But as of now, my conscience is starting to become unsettled at the idea. I want to be catholic! I don't want to wait and see! I understand that if we are a couple, we need to work together toward a common end as he and Catherine mentioned, but he's already told me flat-out that he will never be catholic. When I told him that there are certain things I will not compromise on (we were discussing at the time, whether the saints are aware of our particulars ala Chemnitz (again a lutheran theologian, with whom I disagree)), he replied that I was going off on my own again----oh God! If he's not willing to consider catholicism for my sake---then I suppose it's over. I need to do what I need to do--he's partaking of Communion--for the most part I've been deprived of the Eucharist---I can't deal anymore. It isn't fair. And yet in becoming catholic--which I need to do quickly--even if he agrees to consider it--I don't want to sin by abandoning him. How can I go forward without him, and not abandon him?
Archaeology cat Posted December 23, 2008 Posted December 23, 2008 I will pray for you, cheryl. And for him.
princessgianna Posted December 23, 2008 Posted December 23, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1734312' date='Dec 23 2008, 09:27 AM']I need to do what I need to do--he's partaking of Communion--for the most part I've been deprived of the Eucharist---I can't deal anymore. It isn't fair. And yet in becoming catholic--which I need to do quickly--even if he agrees to consider it--I don't want to sin by abandoning him. How can I go forward without him, and not abandon him?[/quote] gee cheryl that really really stinks! My prayers for you. Just always remember "Whatever God calls us to do-He ll provide the gut and grace to do so"!! God will always be with you if you allow Him. Prayers and Pax princessgianna
MithLuin Posted December 23, 2008 Posted December 23, 2008 I know it hurts - a lot - to have a relationship brought to an end like this. But I think that what you need is a break from him right now. You might not be able to see what direction God is calling you in at the moment, but there is a way to move forward. It is not surprising that this young man wants you to come around to his way of thinking - wouldn't it be happier and easier for you if he came around to yours? The reality, though, is that each of you would have to give up a lot to 'come around' so working out a compromise is going to be fraught with a lot of pain and heartache - for you both. Bible verses are the Word of God. Semantics and exegesis are important, but the Word of God is living - Jesus Christ. If reading the Bible becomes about 'proving' things rather than seeking God's will and truth, we are misusing it. We might want to use scripture for apologetics, but that isn't the only (or even the primary) use of it. We should be using it to deepen our relationship with God, and bring our own thinking more in line with His. I am not saying that you and your boyfriend aren't doing this, just that it seems that your arguments might be getting in the way of that. You may want to refer him to a friend to work out some of these arguments rather than continuing to argue about them together. As for the communion of saints - there is a difference between our relationship with God in this life and in the next. Now, we see as in a mirror darkly. Then, we will see face to face. The saints in heaven are already experiencing this communion with God, and so it is not surprising that their relationship with Christians on earth is going to be different from our relationships with each other. I do not know your heart, and can not read it from here. But in heaven? Will my heart be hidden from you? Or will we share in a much greater knowledge and intimacy with one another because we will both be fully known by God...and fully open to Him? Some saints experience this (to a lesser extent) on earth. I realize that interpretting the Bible and learning about Padre Pio are two totally different things, but it is sometimes good to look at what is meant by ideas when they are lived out. To suggest that Mary doesn't know you, when her Son said, from the cross, "Behold, your mother," is to cut off and deny a valid part of many people's spirituality. It is a negation, and for what purpose? To strengthen our relationship with God? No; if we truly have a relationship with Mary, she does nothing but lead us to Jesus. Seeing that fruit, it becomes clear that [i]denying[/i] any posibility of a relationship with the community of saints does not strengthen our faith in God, but rather weakens it by taking away some of our supports. Now, does this mean every good Christian needs to have a special devotion to the saints? Does it mean you can't have a relationship with Jesus without them? No. But to deny them, and to say that being in heaven is no different from being dead would call into question some other important tenets of faith. Don't get me wrong; there are valid things to worry about in considering devotion to the saints. I am not saying you can't go wrong. I am merely saying that abuse of the cult of the saints does not mean it is by definition wrong and untenable.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 24, 2008 Posted December 24, 2008 (edited) I haven't been through the same experience as you, but seems I do relate to much of it. For one, I also come from a Lutheran background, and also felt a lot of that "back-and-forth" as I read a Catholic argument that made sense causing me to lean that way, only to read a Lutheran argument or a Calvinist argument that would make even more sense and cause me to shift that direction. [quote name='cheryl' post='1733791' date='Dec 22 2008, 11:31 AM']The thing is, this, 'working together' has turned into trying to persuade me to his 'side'. And I have contributed to that out of fear. I am afraid that if I don't come to agree with the lutheran confessions et al, I will loose him and my heart is breaking.[/quote] This obviously isn't healthy. There are many marriages of mixed denominations and religions and even though they are more difficult, they can work, but definitely not like this. FWIW, it seems the mixed marriages I've heard of working involve one spouse (or both) who is only nominally affiliated with their faith. Two people who are convinced of two different things are almost sure to butt heads. Regardless of whether you choose to believe in the Lutheran Confessions, the Catholic Church, or whatever, you have to do it because you are striving to follow Christ, not to please anyone else. [quote name='cheryl' post='1733791' date='Dec 22 2008, 11:31 AM']To top matters off, as I mentioned before, he is a walking encyclopedia and I am no match for him. I can't argue sufficiently, I don't have the bible verses he needs to back up my assertions, and I am just at a lost.[/quote] I decided early on in my wandering among Catholic-Lutheran-Baptist-Etc apologetics that there are a lot of people in every denomination and religion (and atheism) who are a lot smarter than me who could kick my brain's butt any day of the week. That can only mean one thing: discerning the Truth has nothing to do with one's intelligence or debating abilities! That's' why I love the story of St. Bernadette. [quote name='cheryl' post='1733791' date='Dec 22 2008, 11:31 AM']For example, we got to discussing (arguing really) over whether or not the saints in heaven are aware of our particulars.[/quote] See, I love exchanging arguments and debating, but only when it's a friendly debate. If it starts to get ugly, you have ceased discussing whatever you started discussing. From that point, it's just an ego rush to "win" at any cost. The only way to win is to bow out. One point Chemnitz seems to miss is that Christians in Europe and China are still in one place called earth, in God's creation of time and space. Angels, saints, and the Holy Trinity are not subject to time and space. I don't understand any more beyond that... it's a great mystery how all those Hail Mary's get to Mary and on to God. Another point I found helpful is that all prayer, whether directed to God, a Person of the Trinity, or a saint, ultimately goes to God. If you accidentally prayed to St. Anthony to sell your house and St. Joseph to find a lost purse, you're not going to end up with a sold purse and a lost house. God hears every prayer and he knows our hearts and true intentions. [quote name='cheryl' post='1733791' date='Dec 22 2008, 11:31 AM']In the past, he's also quoted the verse which goes, "But you are our Father, though Abraham does not know us or Israel acknowledge us; you, O LORD, are our Father, our Redeemer from of old is your name. " (Is 63:16). I've found this verse as a proof-text bothersome for awhile now. It doesn't strike me as saying anything about whether or not we can talk to the saints in heaven, but I can't really put my finger on why....something just doesn't seem right.[/quote] Pretty sure that passage is saying God is Father of all people, regardless of how God's chosen nation behaves or interacts with other peoples. A similar passage comes from Psalm 27: "If my father and mother forsake me, the Lord will take me up." [quote name='cheryl' post='1733791' date='Dec 22 2008, 11:31 AM']It's too close to Christmas to talk to my priest. And I've been so down that I haven't been to Mass or Confession. I don't even know if I'll make it to Mass on Christmas. All I want to do is sleep and cry (but most of the time the tears won't come).[/quote] I think you would feel a lot better if you make a commitment to go to Mass for Christmas. Not because your are supposed to, but just to be there with Christ and other Christians and be present to him as he is present to you at the Mass. No need to come up with answers and solutions... just be there and pray. [quote name='cheryl' post='1734312' date='Dec 23 2008, 10:27 AM']I know. I suppose I keep hoping that somehow things will work out. And because I don't have the answers he needs, I'm starting to doubt things myself and yet it offends me greatly when Scripture is slung back and forth-each 'side' having their own 'proof-texts' as it were. He says it's not, but a part of my arguments with him seem to be reduced to what I have termed, 'biblicalism'. It doesn't matter what's in my heart, what others have told me, ect. -I feel as if I can't 'prove' something from Scripture to another's satisfaction (at the moment, his) then I'm sunk. Maybe it's pride-wanting to come up with an answer to every objection I come across-maybe a feeling of inadequacy (as if I'm always having to 'prove' myself). Maybe both...I don't know.[/quote] Some people are just plain stubborn, not matter how brilliant of an argument were presented before them. Ultimately, the arguments and Scripture quotes don't satisfy the deeper longings of the human heart. They can point the way, but in themselves they do not satisfy. [quote name='cheryl' post='1733791' date='Dec 22 2008, 11:31 AM']I need to do what I need to do--he's partaking of Communion--for the most part I've been deprived of the Eucharist---I can't deal anymore. It isn't fair. And yet in becoming catholic--which I need to do quickly--even if he agrees to consider it--I don't want to sin by abandoning him. How can I go forward without him, and not abandon him?[/quote] Even though we'd all love for you and your friend to become Catholic (regardless of what he currently thinks), it isn't good to rush these decisions. In the sacrament of Confirmation, you will be making a vow that you believe everything the Church believes and teaches to be true. If that sounds a bit intimidating, it should be, if you take vows seriously. Rest in knowing that you are a Christian and for now that's all you need to be. Pray, grow in humility, patience, and other virtues, and the rest will somehow come together in due time. Edited December 24, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
cheryl Posted December 25, 2008 Author Posted December 25, 2008 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1734442' date='Dec 23 2008, 04:36 PM']I know it hurts - a lot - to have a relationship brought to an end like this. But I think that what you need is a break from him right now. You might not be able to see what direction God is calling you in at the moment, but there is a way to move forward. It is not surprising that this young man wants you to come around to his way of thinking - wouldn't it be happier and easier for you if he came around to yours? The reality, though, is that each of you would have to give up a lot to 'come around' so working out a compromise is going to be fraught with a lot of pain and heartache - for you both.[/quote] Yep. It's understandable that he would want a 'lutheran girl.' I couldn't raise my children lutheran and he couldn't raise his catholic. In his words, 'we'd be miserable' and he's right. [quote]Bible verses are the Word of God. Semantics and exegesis are important, but the Word of God is living - Jesus Christ. If reading the Bible becomes about 'proving' things rather than seeking God's will and truth, we are misusing it. We might want to use scripture for apologetics, but that isn't the only (or even the primary) use of it. We should be using it to deepen our relationship with God, and bring our own thinking more in line with His. I am not saying that you and your boyfriend aren't doing this, just that it seems that your arguments might be getting in the way of that. You may want to refer him to a friend to work out some of these arguments rather than continuing to argue about them together.[/quote] I know I can't argue with him anymore and ultimately it's not good for him either. I think we would both want to say that we are seeking God's will in the matter, and not trying to 'prove' things to each other. But the reality is, is that we are doing more of the latter than the former. [quote]As for the communion of saints - there is a difference between our relationship with God in this life and in the next. Now, we see as in a mirror darkly. Then, we will see face to face. The saints in heaven are already experiencing this communion with God, and so it is not surprising that their relationship with Christians on earth is going to be different from our relationships with each other. I do not know your heart, and can not read it from here. But in heaven? Will my heart be hidden from you? Or will we share in a much greater knowledge and intimacy with one another because we will both be fully known by God...and fully open to Him?[/quote] I made similar comments to him and others. The reply has usually been that the verse you allude to as well as everything else, will only come about at the physical resurrection. [quote]Some saints experience this (to a lesser extent) on earth. I realize that interpretting the Bible and learning about Padre Pio are two totally different things, but it is sometimes good to look at what is meant by ideas when they are lived out.[/quote] He doesn't consider the Catholic Church "safe" and has told me that I am getting mixed up with a "bad group" (something to that effect). So considering the life of a catholic saint would not be acceptable to him (as an 'authority'). [quote]To suggest that Mary doesn't know you, when her Son said, from the cross, "Behold, your mother," is to cut off and deny a valid part of many people's spirituality. It is a negation, and for what purpose? To strengthen our relationship with God? No; if we truly have a relationship with Mary, she does nothing but lead us to Jesus. Seeing that fruit, it becomes clear that [i]denying[/i] any posibility of a relationship with the community of saints does not strengthen our faith in God, but rather weakens it by taking away some of our supports. Now, does this mean every good Christian needs to have a special devotion to the saints? Does it mean you can't have a relationship with Jesus without them? No. But to deny them, and to say that being in heaven is no different from being dead would call into question some other important tenets of faith.[/quote] For me it does...it makes the resurrection something that will occur entirely in the future and as such gives me no joy in the present moment, except that allowed by faith and hope in good things to come. As for Christ's gift of his mother to us, most protestants do not believe that His words indicate any such thing. Whatever verses come to mind, unless one believes in the authority of the Church, I doubt there are many verses which are safe from a multitude of interpretations, not because Scripture is unclear, but because we ourselves are so muddled. [quote]Don't get me wrong; there are valid things to worry about in considering devotion to the saints. I am not saying you can't go wrong. I am merely saying that abuse of the cult of the saints does not mean it is by definition wrong and untenable.[/quote] In most of Protestantism (as you know), you're dealing with an attitude toward Scripture, that makes every proposition of Faith subject to, "Where is it in Scripture?" in order to be considered true. So unless a catholic can demonstrate that say, "King David addressed Abraham in his prayers", for example, everything else is a moot point. It all boils down to an issue of authority.
cheryl Posted December 25, 2008 Author Posted December 25, 2008 [quote name='princessgianna' post='1734338' date='Dec 23 2008, 12:36 PM']gee cheryl that really really stinks! My prayers for you.[/quote] Thanks. [quote]Just always remember "Whatever God calls us to do-He ll provide the gut and grace to do so"!! God will always be with you if you allow Him. Prayers and Pax princessgianna[/quote] And yet even that is of grace. Thanks be to God!
cheryl Posted December 25, 2008 Author Posted December 25, 2008 [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1734321' date='Dec 23 2008, 11:02 AM']I will pray for you, cheryl. And for him.[/quote] Thanks.
cheryl Posted December 25, 2008 Author Posted December 25, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1734547' date='Dec 23 2008, 08:18 PM']I haven't been through the same experience as you, but seems I do relate to much of it. For one, I also come from a Lutheran background, and also felt a lot of that "back-and-forth" as I read a Catholic argument that made sense causing me to lean that way, only to read a Lutheran argument or a Calvinist argument that would make even more sense and cause me to shift that direction.[/quote] Exactly! And the confusion that seems to come with it (for me)! [quote]This obviously isn't healthy. There are many marriages of mixed denominations and religions and even though they are more difficult, they can work, but definitely not like this. FWIW, it seems the mixed marriages I've heard of working involve one spouse (or both) who is only nominally affiliated with their faith. Two people who are convinced of two different things are almost sure to butt heads. Regardless of whether you choose to believe in the Lutheran Confessions, the Catholic Church, or whatever, you have to do it because you are striving to follow Christ, not to please anyone else.[/quote] Yes. And I know I'd be miserable in the Lutheran Church. If I gave in, a part of me would die. But how do I know I'm not just pleasing myself? For example, how do I know that my desire to become Catholic is because I want the Catholic faith to be true, and not that it actually is, and that in so choosing to become Catholic I am actually turning my back on the truth! I suppose a part of me is scared to let God have full control because I'm not quite certain he wants me to be Catholic. I know I want me to be Catholic. [quote]I decided early on in my wandering among Catholic-Lutheran-Baptist-Etc apologetics that there are a lot of people in every denomination and religion (and atheism) who are a lot smarter than me who could kick my brain's butt any day of the week. That can only mean one thing: discerning the Truth has nothing to do with one's intelligence or debating abilities! That's' why I love the story of St. Bernadette. [/quote] How do I discern the truth then? [quote]See, I love exchanging arguments and debating, but only when it's a friendly debate. If it starts to get ugly, you have ceased discussing whatever you started discussing. From that point, it's just an ego rush to "win" at any cost. The only way to win is to bow out. One point Chemnitz seems to miss is that Christians in Europe and China are still in one place called earth, in God's creation of time and space. Angels, saints, and the Holy Trinity are not subject to time and space. I don't understand any more beyond that... it's a great mystery how all those Hail Mary's get to Mary and on to God. Another point I found helpful is that all prayer, whether directed to God, a Person of the Trinity, or a saint, ultimately goes to God. If you accidentally prayed to St. Anthony to sell your house and St. Joseph to find a lost purse, you're not going to end up with a sold purse and a lost house. God hears every prayer and he knows our hearts and true intentions.[/quote] That's where my train of thought tends to lead, but like I said, it always proves insufficient. It's like Chemnitz (God bless his soul) can make an argument based on logic, but I can't [quote]Pretty sure that passage is saying God is Father of all people, regardless of how God's chosen nation behaves or interacts with other peoples. A similar passage comes from Psalm 27: "If my father and mother forsake me, the Lord will take me up."[/quote] The former passage begins with "though" whereas the latter passage begins with, "If".Do you know the original term(s) being translated? [quote]I think you would feel a lot better if you make a commitment to go to Mass for Christmas. Not because your are supposed to, but just to be there with Christ and other Christians and be present to him as he is present to you at the Mass. No need to come up with answers and solutions... just be there and pray.[/quote] I did! Thanks to my sister. Mom and I were both very tired and depressed and I had expressed numerous times that I didn't want to go. But sis decided she was going (and she couldn't go by herself) so mom and I went with her. It was beautiful (not just on the surface, but God was there, especially during the consecration of the bread and wine. It was as if you could almost see Christ literally, physically descending down from heaven (the sense of holiness that filled the Church was that strong). And although it may not have been technically allowed, the priest (who knows me personally) gave us all Holy Communion and I am immensely grateful to him and God that he did, I can't tell you what it did for me. I have such a love for the Eucharist! I think it is the Eucharist more than anything that ties me to the Church--that says, 'Yes, Christ is here!'. [quote]Some people are just plain stubborn, not matter how brilliant of an argument were presented before them. Ultimately, the arguments and Scripture quotes don't satisfy the deeper longings of the human heart. They can point the way, but in themselves they do not satisfy.[/quote] Heart to heart--J. Newman? I think that's true for any argument, even 'catholic' ones. Ultimately conversion must be the assent of the whole person, body, mind, heart, and soul. [quote]Even though we'd all love for you and your friend to become Catholic (regardless of what he currently thinks), it isn't good to rush these decisions. In the sacrament of Confirmation, you will be making a vow that you believe everything the Church believes and teaches to be true. If that sounds a bit intimidating, it should be, if you take vows seriously. Rest in knowing that you are a Christian and for now that's all you need to be. Pray, grow in humility, patience, and other virtues, and the rest will somehow come together in due time.[/quote] For me it isn't a rush (and I wouldn't want to rush him). I have been drawn to the Catholic Church in some form since I was itty-bitty. When I said that I needed to become Catholic quickly, it was because I hunger for it so greatly-especially the Eucharist. In the western rite of Confirmation, I thought it was the Apostle's Creed one had to assent to? I don't know if I could say, "Yes, I believe everything the Catholic Church teaches". I would always strive to bring myself in conformity to her teaching, but there are a lot of things I don't understand and some things I struggle with. To be Catholic for me, is a continual process of conversion. Just as we, so long as we are sinners, will never come to grasp or internalize (make our own) the truth that is constantly presented before us in this life, so too, in regards to the Church's teaching, we will always face struggles (because we are ignorant), things we don't know, or never heard of. I want to become Catholic, not because I can or will ever in this life, reach a point where I could 'make my own' all that she teaches. Such a promise would be very presumptuous on my part. But I want to become Catholic, because I know Christ is there, and because I believe in her. I believe in her authority and her legitimacy.
journeyman Posted December 25, 2008 Posted December 25, 2008 The Eucharist drew me into the Church as well It may be one of those hair splitting things, but can you make the profession of faith with a clear conscience by putting the emphasis on the latter half of the proclamation? “I believe and profess all that the holy Catholic Church believes, teaches, and proclaims to be revealed by God.“ not a personal belief of ALL the Church believes, teaches and proclaims (I knew I didn't know ALL, and cannot conceive of any typical RCIA candidate who would know all 2000 years of teaching and proclamation) . . . but that what the Church believes, teaches and proclaims was revealed by God Given the Church's reliance on sacred Scripture and sacred Tradition in its teachings, I think that is not as huge a leap as it might first appear. Respect for the Magisterium's teaching office, arising from respect for their years of study, and the traditions governing their exercise of that teaching authority, leads to a personal assent.
Archaeology cat Posted December 26, 2008 Posted December 26, 2008 [quote name='journeyman' post='1735349' date='Dec 25 2008, 11:02 PM']The Eucharist drew me into the Church as well It may be one of those hair splitting things, but can you make the profession of faith with a clear conscience by putting the emphasis on the latter half of the proclamation? “I believe and profess all that the holy Catholic Church believes, teaches, and proclaims to be revealed by God.“ not a personal belief of ALL the Church believes, teaches and proclaims (I knew I didn't know ALL, and cannot conceive of any typical RCIA candidate who would know all 2000 years of teaching and proclamation) . . . but that what the Church believes, teaches and proclaims was revealed by God Given the Church's reliance on sacred Scripture and sacred Tradition in its teachings, I think that is not as huge a leap as it might first appear. Respect for the Magisterium's teaching office, arising from respect for their years of study, and the traditions governing their exercise of that teaching authority, leads to a personal assent.[/quote] Exactly. When I was confirmed as an adult, I certainly didn't know about every single thing the Church teaches. I still don't. But I submit to Her. I trust that what the Church teaches has been revealed by God, and I strive to understand those things I don't understand. That is what I promised at my Confirmation, and what I continue to strive for.
cheryl Posted December 26, 2008 Author Posted December 26, 2008 [quote name='journeyman' post='1735349' date='Dec 25 2008, 07:02 PM']The Eucharist drew me into the Church as well It may be one of those hair splitting things, but can you make the profession of faith with a clear conscience by putting the emphasis on the latter half of the proclamation? “I believe and profess all that the holy Catholic Church believes, teaches, and proclaims to be revealed by God.“ not a personal belief of ALL the Church believes, teaches and proclaims (I knew I didn't know ALL, and cannot conceive of any typical RCIA candidate who would know all 2000 years of teaching and proclamation) . . . but that what the Church believes, teaches and proclaims was revealed by God Given the Church's reliance on sacred Scripture and sacred Tradition in its teachings, I think that is not as huge a leap as it might first appear. Respect for the Magisterium's teaching office, arising from respect for their years of study, and the traditions governing their exercise of that teaching authority, leads to a personal assent.[/quote] Yes, I can do that. I'd never say, "you're wrong!"
cheryl Posted December 26, 2008 Author Posted December 26, 2008 [quote name='Archaeology cat' post='1735700' date='Dec 26 2008, 07:41 AM']Exactly. When I was confirmed as an adult, I certainly didn't know about every single thing the Church teaches. I still don't. But I submit to Her. I trust that what the Church teaches has been revealed by God, and I strive to understand those things I don't understand. That is what I promised at my Confirmation, and what I continue to strive for.[/quote] Then maybe I misunderstood what you were asking. My apologies!
LouisvilleFan Posted December 26, 2008 Posted December 26, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']Exactly! And the confusion that seems to come with it (for me)![/quote] Yes, it can be confusing. Of course, as I'm sure you know, many who become Catholic are drawn to the faith precisely because of its clarity in the midst of a confusing morass of Christian theologies and philosophies. I'm in the middle of replying to your other questions... it's busy visiting my folks for Christmas, and I have to go now, so I'll finish tonight or tomorrow! God bless, Jason
LouisvilleFan Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']Yes. And I know I'd be miserable in the Lutheran Church. If I gave in, a part of me would die. But how do I know I'm not just pleasing myself? For example, how do I know that my desire to become Catholic is because I want the Catholic faith to be true, and not that it actually is, and that in so choosing to become Catholic I am actually turning my back on the truth! I suppose a part of me is scared to let God have full control because I'm not quite certain he wants me to be Catholic. I know I want me to be Catholic.[/quote] This decision is like discerning any other decision... we can be attracted to any good thing for the wrong reasons (or even a bad thing for the right reasons). A few months ago while cleaning out my desk, I found a short prayer I wrote a few years ago asking God for guidance in choosing whether or not to become Catholic and what to make of the homosexuality issue. For me, it eventually came down to being able to explain and understand my reasons for being Catholic in my own words, but I also questioned if I didn't like Catholicism more for material reasons (the sacramental experience, incense, global presence, etc.) than because it is indeed the Truth. Everybody's journey is different, but I firmly believe that we all need reserved time for daily prayer and occasional extended hours of silence to honestly seek God and encounter the Person who is Truth. In other words, to offer an example, it's one thing to believe the Immaculate Conception is true because you read it in the Catechism, but quite another when when our eyes see its beauty and our hearts fall in love with it. [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']How do I discern the truth then?[/quote] Pray... in silence... alone with God. FWIW, sounds like you're on the right track. [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']That's where my train of thought tends to lead, but like I said, it always proves insufficient. It's like Chemnitz (God bless his soul) can make an argument based on logic, but I can't [/quote] Logic is only one part of the equation, but regardless you can find plenty of Catholic theologians with PhD's who bring the logic right back around on Chemnitz and anyone else out there. We don't have to reinvent the wheel when it comes to apologetics. [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']The former passage begins with "though" whereas the latter passage begins with, "If".Do you know the original term(s) being translated?[/quote] I don't know the original terms. Sounds to me like Psalm 27 is referring in general terms to the possibility that one's parents may turn away from them while Isaiah 63:16 is speaking of that becoming a reality for whoever "we" and "us" are. [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']I did! Thanks to my sister. Mom and I were both very tired and depressed and I had expressed numerous times that I didn't want to go. But sis decided she was going (and she couldn't go by herself) so mom and I went with her. It was beautiful (not just on the surface, but God was there, especially during the consecration of the bread and wine. It was as if you could almost see Christ literally, physically descending down from heaven (the sense of holiness that filled the Church was that strong). And although it may not have been technically allowed, the priest (who knows me personally) gave us all Holy Communion and I am immensely grateful to him and God that he did, I can't tell you what it did for me. I have such a love for the Eucharist! I think it is the Eucharist more than anything that ties me to the Church--that says, 'Yes, Christ is here!'.[/quote] Awesome! I also received the Eucharist before becoming Catholic, though after realizing the necessity of being sacramentally prepared realized that believing and loving aren't enough without sacrificing our pride in Reconciliation. In a sense, Communion without Confession is like sex without marriage vows. There can be love between two people without vows, but the deepest and most real love expects them. [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']Heart to heart--J. Newman? I think that's true for any argument, even 'catholic' ones. Ultimately conversion must be the assent of the whole person, body, mind, heart, and soul.[/quote] Had to google for what you were talking about: "Cor a cor loquitor" or "Heart speaks to heart." I can't argue with John Cardinal Newman... and neither can Chemnitz [quote name='cheryl' post='1735284' date='Dec 25 2008, 03:53 PM']In the western rite of Confirmation, I thought it was the Apostle's Creed one had to assent to?[/quote] Oh yeah, I remember what you're thinking about. That might be the renewal of baptismal vows that you're thinking of, or it may be a part of the Rite of Confirmation. Either way, the sacrament includes the words someone quoted in an earlier post where you assent, "I do," to everything the Catholic Church teaches to be true. It doesn't mean you have to know everything. Even St. Thomas Aquinas, widely considered the Church's greatest theologian, was blown away speechless by the things God revealed to him shortly before death. This is why trust, love, and godly virtues are more fundamental that theological knowledge. When you come to trust the Church, the knowledge part will become much easier. Besides, living out the truth is always far more difficult that knowing it.
MithLuin Posted December 27, 2008 Posted December 27, 2008 Ah, true, you cannot use arguements that are not accepted by your audience. Consider, then, how Hebrews 12 opens: [quote]Therefore, since [u]we are surrounded by such a great cloud of witnesses,[/u] let us throw off everything that hinders and the sin that so easily entangles, and let us run with perseverance the race marked out for us. Let us fix our eyes on Jesus, the author and perfecter of our faith, who for the joy set before him endured the cross, scorning its shame, and sat down at the right hand of the throne of God. Consider him who endured such opposition from sinful men, so that you will not grow weary and lose heart.[/quote] Who is this "great cloud of witnesses"? And why are they being mentioned here at all? Hebrews 11 is a catalogue of the faith of the ancients. Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham and Sarah, Isaac and Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Rahab, Gideon, etc. Each one of them had faith in God, in a future they did not see (basically, in salvation through the coming of Jesus). They all lived as sojourners in a foreign land, hoping for their true homeland in heaven. [i]This[/i] is the cloud of witnesses in Hebrews 12. [i]These[/i] are the people who bore witness to the truth in their own lives...and continue to bear witness to that truth. For the Bible to say that we are currently surrounded by a great cloud of witnesses does not mean that they are dead in the ground with no awareness until the last day. How could you bear witness then? But why are they mentioned? Specifically because their example spurs us on. We are not the first people to try to follow God. Those who have gone before us have lived in great faith. Their faith, their lives, their examples help us to lead a Christian life. And not just because we can read about them in a book, but because they are active [i]witnesses[/i] of our lives now. It is possible for people to doubt the resurrection at all. By denying the efficacy of praying to the saints, they seem to be attacking a peculiarly Catholic practice. But they have to be careful not to fall into the error of doubting the resurrection of the body. If the thinking is 'once you're dead, you're dead,' how is that Christian faith at all? And if it truly is just saying that we have to wait until the final judgement on the last day...does that apply to all the Christian dead? Is it wrong to go to your grandmother's gravesite and have a conversation with her? Basically, it is one thing to disagree over precisely what happens after death. But if the reason for the disagreement really stems from an idea of being uncomfortable with considering someone who has died to still be a person...then there is a deeper problem. I am not accusing this young man of anything - I am sure he is sincere. But I am curious [i]why[/i] he is not comfortable with someone else having a relationship with Our Lady. Is it just because he thinks it is silly and has no scriptural support? Does he not accept the scriptural support of those who have claimed to have such a relationship? Or...is it just because Lutherans reject Catholic teaching on the communion of saints? If it's the last, I really don't see how that can be addressed by arguement.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 28, 2008 Posted December 28, 2008 (edited) [quote name='MithLuin' post='1736435' date='Dec 27 2008, 04:14 PM']I am not accusing this young man of anything - I am sure he is sincere. But I am curious [i]why[/i] he is not comfortable with someone else having a relationship with Our Lady. Is it just because he thinks it is silly and has no scriptural support? Does he not accept the scriptural support of those who have claimed to have such a relationship? Or...is it just because Lutherans reject Catholic teaching on the communion of saints? If it's the last, I really don't see how that can be addressed by arguement.[/quote] If he's like most Protestants, it's probably largely due to the culture of Catholicism being so different from Protestantism along with the lack of a clear and indisputable biblical basis for the practice. With most beliefs, they aren't so much convinced that Scripture condemns what Catholics believe and do. They just aren't sure it's recommended either. Edited December 28, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now