tinytherese Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 From what I've been told. You can't get anywhere with a non-catholic without first refuting sola scriptura.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1737447' date='Dec 29 2008, 01:10 AM']From what I've been told. You can't get anywhere with a non-catholic without first refuting sola scriptura.[/quote] Nah... there are plenty of other routes one could take, the first and most important being living as a faithful witness to God's grace and a disciple of Jesus Christ.
cheryl Posted December 29, 2008 Author Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1736153' date='Dec 27 2008, 01:52 AM']Awesome! I also received the Eucharist before becoming Catholic, though after realizing the necessity of being sacramentally prepared realized that believing and loving aren't enough without sacrificing our pride in Reconciliation. In a sense, Communion without Confession is like sex without marriage vows. There can be love between two people without vows, but the deepest and most real love expects them.[/quote] I'm going to Confession too. I did that first. The only sacrament I haven't received is Confirmation, because I have to wait until RCIA is over. I want to be confirmed so very badly. I know this is where I want to be and I've come to understand why---Christ is there. The last two days I woke up to go to Mass, it felt like my birthday! "It's time to go see Jesus!" I'd say.
Archaeology cat Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='tinytherese' post='1737447' date='Dec 29 2008, 05:10 AM']From what I've been told. You can't get anywhere with a non-catholic without first refuting sola scriptura.[/quote] Yeah, sola scriptura isn't what got me - the Eucharist did.
cheryl Posted December 29, 2008 Author Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1736435' date='Dec 27 2008, 04:14 PM']Ah, true, you cannot use arguements that are not accepted by your audience. Consider, then, how Hebrews 12 opens: Who is this "great cloud of witnesses"? And why are they being mentioned here at all? Hebrews 11 is a catalogue of the faith of the ancients. Abel, Enoch, Noah, Abraham and Sarah, Isaac and Jacob, Joseph, Moses, Rahab, Gideon, etc. Each one of them had faith in God, in a future they did not see (basically, in salvation through the coming of Jesus). They all lived as sojourners in a foreign land, hoping for their true homeland in heaven. [i]This[/i] is the cloud of witnesses in Hebrews 12. [i]These[/i] are the people who bore witness to the truth in their own lives...and continue to bear witness to that truth. For the Bible to say that we are currently surrounded by a great cloud of witnesses does not mean that they are dead in the ground with no awareness until the last day. How could you bear witness then?[/quote] I think most protestants would say that the "cloud" is metaphorical. Just as we don't literally run a race, Paul (I think they would say) is employing an analogy, not to be taken literally. [quote]But why are they mentioned? Specifically because their example spurs us on. We are not the first people to try to follow God. Those who have gone before us have lived in great faith. Their faith, their lives, their examples help us to lead a Christian life. And not just because we can read about them in a book, but because they are active [i]witnesses[/i] of our lives now. [quote]It is possible for people to doubt the resurrection at all. By denying the efficacy of praying to the saints, they seem to be attacking a peculiarly Catholic practice. But they have to be careful not to fall into the error of doubting the resurrection of the body. If the thinking is 'once you're dead, you're dead,' how is that Christian faith at all? And if it truly is just saying that we have to wait until the final judgement on the last day...does that apply to all the Christian dead?[/quote] Many would probably say, "Yes". [quote]Is it wrong to go to your grandmother's gravesite and have a conversation with her? Basically, it is one thing to disagree over precisely what happens after death. But if the reason for the disagreement really stems from an idea of being uncomfortable with considering someone who has died to still be a person...then there is a deeper problem.[/quote] My gentleman friend, following the Lutheran Confessions, would say something like, "They have general knowledge, but not knowledge of particulars. For example, they would pray for the Church as a whole (because they remember what it was like to suffer in this world), but Therese for example, could not help me find my kitty. To go back to the China-Europe example, it's like they conceive of a spatial divide between heaven and earth. I am not accusing this young man of anything - I am sure he is sincere. But I am curious [i]why[/i] he is not comfortable with someone else having a relationship with Our Lady. Is it just because he thinks it is silly and has no scriptural support? Does he not accept the scriptural support of those who have claimed to have such a relationship? Or...is it just because Lutherans reject Catholic teaching on the communion of saints? If it's the last, I really don't see how that can be addressed by arguement. [/quote] It's hard to say. I wish I could understand his objections better. If I asked him, he'd probably say, Scripture doesn't teach it.
cheryl Posted December 29, 2008 Author Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1737537' date='Dec 29 2008, 03:28 AM']Nah... there are plenty of other routes one could take, the first and most important being living as a faithful witness to God's grace and a disciple of Jesus Christ.[/quote] I think it's both. Directly, it does seem like it boils down to "Sola Scriptura". (Although I should add, that for many protestants that usually boils down to Scripture according to the church's interpretation (just not the Catholic Church's) Indirectly though, you're right and I think the best route.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1737626' date='Dec 29 2008, 11:28 AM']I think it's both. Directly, it does seem like it boils down to "Sola Scriptura". (Although I should add, that for many protestants that usually boils down to Scripture according to the church's interpretation (just not the Catholic Church's) Indirectly though, you're right and I think the best route.[/quote] The Bible is a book guarenteed by the Catholic Church, and a complilation made by the Catholic Church.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1737667' date='Dec 29 2008, 01:21 PM']The Bible is a book guarenteed by the Catholic Church, and a complilation made by the Catholic Church.[/quote] Good luck running that by a Baptist seminarian They know their Church history too. History isn't so much unlike Scripture: everyone's got their interpration of how it all went down and what it means.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1737858' date='Dec 29 2008, 04:51 PM']Good luck running that by a Baptist seminarian They know their Church history too. History isn't so much unlike Scripture: everyone's got their interpration of how it all went down and what it means.[/quote] Sorry I was going to write more but my computer froze. They obviously don't know their church history if they think anyone but Christ founded the Catholic Church or that the Church compiled the Scriptures. To learn history is to cease to be anything other than Catholic. Let them talk to Brother Adam who arrived here as a fervant Baptist
cheryl Posted December 29, 2008 Author Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1737858' date='Dec 29 2008, 04:51 PM']Good luck running that by a Baptist seminarian They know their Church history too. History isn't so much unlike Scripture: everyone's got their interpration of how it all went down and what it means.[/quote] Right. Most protestant churches that retain some sort of creed or confession, don't hold to a type of 'sola scriptura' that many catholic mistakenly assume. They very much read Scripture through the lense of their own traditions (and the most serious among them, will claim the authority of the Church Fathers et al). The true divide lies in tradition as being an additional source of doctrine, whereas for many protestants, scripture is the only source for doctrine (albeit understood in the light of tradition). -hence 'scripture alone'. 'Scripture alone' doesn't mean, 'Tradition plays no part in our (protestant) churches, only that does not serve as a distinct source of doctrine'. Or to put it this way, 'scripture alone is the only source of doctrine'. In other words, the issue between said protestants and catholicism, is not tradition versus scripture, but what are the sources of divine revelation after Christ, is it Scripture alone or are there things God wishes us to know, that are not in Scripture, but which has been handed down to us in some other way (what we might term 'Tradition'). I don't know how many catholics are aware of this...so I thought I'd throw it out there. There are protestants who will claim, 'no creed but Christ', but most protestants, Lutherans, Anglicans, Magisterial Reformed ect. hold to tradition in some form.
cheryl Posted December 29, 2008 Author Posted December 29, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1737891' date='Dec 29 2008, 05:16 PM']Sorry I was going to write more but my computer froze. They obviously don't know their church history if they think anyone but Christ founded the Catholic Church or that the Church compiled the Scriptures. To learn history is to cease to be anything other than Catholic. Let them talk to Brother Adam who arrived here as a fervant Baptist [/quote] Most protestants who try and retain in their churches the creeds, declarations of early councils, church fathers ect. hold a view similiar to the Orthodox, when considering the Roman Catholic Church's claim to authority. I don't think any protestant (as described above) doubt that Christ founded what they would say is the 'Catholic Church' or that this 'Catholic Church' compiled the Scriptures. It's just that their definition of 'Catholic', does not include universal papal supremacy and jurisdiction.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 29, 2008 Posted December 29, 2008 (edited) [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1737891' date='Dec 29 2008, 05:16 PM']Sorry I was going to write more but my computer froze. They obviously don't know their church history if they think anyone but Christ founded the Catholic Church or that the Church compiled the Scriptures. To learn history is to cease to be anything other than Catholic. Let them talk to Brother Adam who arrived here as a fervant Baptist [/quote] That view is fine for "The Journey Home" and people who only engage elementary geniuses like reyb in debate. Orthodox theologians know their Church history as well as the best Catholic theologians. If you want to know why they are not Catholic, just ask. As I said before, my friends at the local Southern Baptist seminary study Church history too. They know all the names, councils, and documents that we rattle off. My Baptist pastor preached on Augustine, Tertullian, the Didache. While Catholic priests offer cheesy inspirational thoughts bookended with bad jokes for homilies, the Baptists bring their A-game. They'll tell you why they don't accept St. Jerome's version of the Scriptures. To the casual observer, it's the Catholics who flunked out of history... probably because they were hung over from the parish picnic. I've had my butt handed to me too many times to believe learning history is to cease being Catholic. I go to my Baptist friends [i]to[/i] learn history. Okay, that last sentence is an exaggeration, but what I do know is that there is such a thing as spiritual blindness. People see, read, and hear what they want to see, read, and hear. Only by grace are minds and hearts changed. FWIW, all this is why I consider bad homilies to be the most overlooked and tolerated offense to the Eucharist. The homily is the summit of the Liturgy of the Word just as the Eucharist is the summit of both liturgies, but if the homily sounds like something Father threw together on his way out of bed that morning, why should people believe the latter? These pastors with their wives and kids to care for find hours every week to write lenghty, detailed, and interesting sermons while a priest who is supposed to be 100% committed to his spouse, the Church, somehow can't find the time to sink his heart and mind into good preaching as a labor of love. This really bugs me... if you can't tell. Edited December 29, 2008 by LouisvilleFan
tinytherese Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' post='1737929' date='Dec 29 2008, 05:10 PM']That view is fine for "The Journey Home" and people who only engage elementary geniuses like reyb in debate. Orthodox theologians know their Church history as well as the best Catholic theologians. If you want to know why they are not Catholic, just ask. As I said before, my friends at the local Southern Baptist seminary study Church history too. They know all the names, councils, and documents that we rattle off. My Baptist pastor preached on Augustine, Tertullian, the Didache. While Catholic priests offer cheesy inspirational thoughts bookended with bad jokes for homilies, the Baptists bring their A-game. They'll tell you why they don't accept St. Jerome's version of the Scriptures. To the casual observer, it's the Catholics who flunked out of history... probably because they were hung over from the parish picnic. I've had my butt handed to me too many times to believe learning history is to cease being Catholic. I go to my Baptist friends [i]to[/i] learn history. Okay, that last sentence is an exaggeration, but what I do know is that there is such a thing as spiritual blindness. People see, read, and hear what they want to see, read, and hear. Only by grace are minds and hearts changed. FWIW, all this is why I consider bad homilies to be the most overlooked and tolerated offense to the Eucharist. The homily is the summit of the Liturgy of the Word just as the Eucharist is the summit of both liturgies, but if the homily sounds like something Father threw together on his way out of bed that morning, why should people believe the latter? These pastors with their wives and kids to care for find hours every week to write lenghty, detailed, and interesting sermons while a priest who is supposed to be 100% committed to his spouse, the Church, somehow can't find the time to sink his heart and mind into good preaching as a labor of love. This really bugs me... if you can't tell.[/quote] This is very sad. The Catholic Church really needs to step up in regards to Church History and to look at more intellectual Protestant objections. Dang, apologetics is even more complicated than I though, and I took a class on it years ago.
cheryl Posted December 30, 2008 Author Posted December 30, 2008 (edited) [quote name='tinytherese' post='1738242' date='Dec 29 2008, 09:57 PM']This is very sad. The Catholic Church really needs to step up in regards to Church History and to look at more intellectual Protestant objections. Dang, apologetics is even more complicated than I though, and I took a class on it years ago. [/quote] God forgive me for saying this, but a great deal of the problem is that there are self-proclaimed apologists on both sides that fling nothing but stereotypes and swiss-coagulated milk arguments, (meaning that it is all too easy to punch holes in their logic). And everyone thinks they know what everyone else believes. Oh, that just annoys me. I've learned along time ago, if you want to know about Thomas Aquinas, read Thomas Aquinas, if you want to know about Martin Luther, read Martin Luther. If it proves necessary to read an anti-Aquinas opinion or an anti-Luther opinion, make sure you are well grounded in the real Aquinas or Luther respectively, before engaging their opponents. I realize not everyone has the time or mental energy to undertake such studies, but then they need to opt out of the apologetic game and let legitimate historians and scholars have it out. It's enough for most of us, that we improve on our own sanctification and strive to live in peace with our neighbors. Edited December 30, 2008 by cheryl
cmotherofpirl Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1737903' date='Dec 29 2008, 05:24 PM']Right. Most protestant churches that retain some sort of creed or confession, don't hold to a type of 'sola scriptura' that many catholic mistakenly assume. They very much read Scripture through the lense of their own traditions (and the most serious among them, will claim the authority of the Church Fathers et al). The true divide lies in tradition as being an additional source of doctrine, whereas for many protestants, scripture is the only source for doctrine (albeit understood in the light of tradition). -hence 'scripture alone'. 'Scripture alone' doesn't mean, 'Tradition plays no part in our (protestant) churches, only that does not serve as a distinct source of doctrine'. Or to put it this way, 'scripture alone is the only source of doctrine'. In other words, the issue between said protestants and catholicism, is not tradition versus scripture, but what are the sources of divine revelation after Christ, is it Scripture alone or are there things God wishes us to know, that are not in Scripture, but which has been handed down to us in some other way (what we might term 'Tradition'). I don't know how many catholics are aware of this...so I thought I'd throw it out there. There are protestants who will claim, 'no creed but Christ', but most protestants, Lutherans, Anglicans, Magisterial Reformed ect. hold to tradition in some form.[/quote] It comes down to authority and history: there would be no New testament if the Church hadn't compiled it or declared it inspired by God. Tradition has never been an "additional" source of doctrine it is the only source of doctrine, for Tradition gives us the New testament. THe Church existed for 400 years before the canon was regularized by the Church.
cheryl Posted December 30, 2008 Author Posted December 30, 2008 [quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1738346' date='Dec 29 2008, 10:37 PM']It comes down to authority and history: there would be no New testament if the Church hadn't compiled it or declared it inspired by God. Tradition has never been an "additional" source of doctrine it is the only source of doctrine, for Tradition gives us the New testament. THe Church existed for 400 years before the canon was regularized by the Church.[/quote] Notice what I said: [b]In other words, the issue between said protestants and catholicism, is not tradition versus scripture, but what are the [u]sources of divine revelation after Christ[/u], [u]is it Scripture alone[/u] or are there things God wishes us to know, [u]that are not in Scripture, but which has been handed down to us in some other way (what we might term 'Tradition')[/u].[/b] I don't think we're disagreeing. I think this is just an argument over semantics. I agree that Scripture should be considered a part of Tradition. But usually 'Tradition' is used to refer to the oral deposit of faith. It is in this latter sense, that I used the term. Sorry for the confusion.
cmotherofpirl Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1738394' date='Dec 29 2008, 10:58 PM']Notice what I said: [b]In other words, the issue between said protestants and catholicism, is not tradition versus scripture, but what are the [u]sources of divine revelation after Christ[/u], [u]is it Scripture alone[/u] or are there things God wishes us to know, [u]that are not in Scripture, but which has been handed down to us in some other way (what we might term 'Tradition')[/u].[/b] I don't think we're disagreeing. I think this is just an argument over semantics. I agree that Scripture should be considered a part of Tradition. But usually 'Tradition' is used to refer to the oral deposit of faith. It is in this latter sense, that I used the term. Sorry for the confusion.[/quote] I don't think we are either. My point is that Scripture is a product of Tradition, and doesn't stand alone as something with which to judge Tradition, which is the protestant approach.
LouisvilleFan Posted December 30, 2008 Posted December 30, 2008 [quote name='cheryl' post='1738310' date='Dec 29 2008, 10:22 PM']if you want to know about Martin Luther, read Martin Luther.[/quote] Luther convinced me of the sacramental nature of Baptism. I wasn't yet sure whether I should trust a Catholic source, so I went back to my own roots... read Luther... read Calvin... and Luther's argument was the simplest. Baptism is Word + water. If you trust the Word and you know that's water in the bowl, doubting your Baptism amounts to doubting the Word of God. I wasn't about to take that risk! [quote name='cheryl' post='1738310' date='Dec 29 2008, 10:22 PM']It's enough for most of us, that we improve on our own sanctification and strive to live in peace with our neighbors.[/quote] Amen! To be sure, we should have a reason for our hope, as St. Paul says. But the point is to know our limits and be wise in tag-teaming a higher authority when we find ourselves overpowered. And in everything, trust God and rely on his grace, because it is very easy to begin trusting our knowledge and arguments to trick ourselves into thinking we are good disciples.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now