Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Israeli Assault Could Last Weeks; 230 Dead


Recommended Posts

Posted

In the heaviest military strike against the Gaza Strip since the 1967 Six Day War, the Israel Air Force bombed over 170 targets on Saturday, killing more than 230 Palestinians, as Israel launched "Operation Cast Lead," aimed at putting a stop to Hamas rocket attacks against the South.

In two waves, over 100 fighter jets and attack helicopters dropped dozens of smart bombs and hundreds of tons of explosives on Hamas training camps, headquarters, weapons storehouses, underground missile silos and command-and-control centers scattered throughout the Gaza Strip.

Palestinian officials said that at least 15 civilians were among the dead in Gaza.

In response, 80 Kassam rockets, Grad-model Katyushas and mortar shells pounded southern Israel throughout the day. One rocket scored a direct hit on an apartment building in Netivot, killing 58-year-old Beber Vaknin and wounding several others.

As ground forces amassed outside Gaza ahead of a possible ground operation, Prime Minister Ehud Olmert and Defense Minister Ehud Barak warned that Saturday's aerial bombardment was just the opening salvo of a long operation that defense officials told The Jerusalem Post would likely last several weeks.

"There is a time for a cease-fire and a time to fight," Barak said. "Now is the time to fight."

Defiant Hamas leaders threatened revenge. Hamas "will continue the resistance until the last drop of blood," vowed spokesman Fawzi Barhoum.

Hamas chief Khaled Mashaal called on West Bank residents to rise up against Israel in a renewed intifada.

Soldiers from the Paratroop and Golani Brigades were deployed along the Gaza border ahead of the possible ground offensive. Defense officials said that anyone and anything identified with Hamas was a potential target.

At least two senior Hamas commanders were killed in the air strikes. One was identified as Maj.-Gen. Tawfiq Jabar, commander of the Gaza Strip police, who was killed at the Gaza Police Academy during a graduation ceremony; 70-80 Hamas operatives were reported killed in that attack.

Officials said that Israel did not plan on conquering the Gaza Strip or toppling the Hamas regime, but would likely continue the air strikes together with limited ground assaults against Hamas infrastructure and Kassam launch sites.

"We will not stop until Hamas halts its rocket attacks and terrorist activity," one senior defense official said.

The operation was given three goals - to stop Hamas's rocket attacks against Israel; to stop the smuggling of weapons into Gaza; and to stop Hamas's terrorist activity against Israel.

"Our purpose is to hit Hamas in such a way that will force it to halt any firing and other hostile activities against Israeli citizens and against the IDF," Barak said. "We will do everything it takes to defend our citizens and bring about a significantly improved situation along our border."

The IDF opened the underground military command-and-control center located at the Kirya military headquarters in Tel Aviv. Chief of General Staff Lt.-Gen. Gabi Ashkenazi manned the post together with several top generals throughout the day. OC Air Force Maj.-Gen. Ido Nehushtan was inside the IAF underground command-and-control center nearby.

"The goal of the operation was to shock, awe and deceive the Palestinians," a senior IDF officer said Saturday, referring to Barak's decision to open the crossings on Friday - done to deceive Hamas into believing that Israel was delaying a military response to the rocket attacks.

Reports that the cabinet planned to convene on Sunday to discuss the situation in Gaza were also aimed at deceiving Hamas.

The air strikes caused widespread panic and confusion in Gaza. Black clouds of smoke rose above the Strip, ruled by Hamas since June 2007. The IDF said it had avoided striking at targets next to schools and inside densely-populated apartment buildings, but urged Gazans to stay away from Hamas infrastructure.

The IDF Central Command also went on high alert out of concern that Hamas terrorists would try to infiltrate Israeli cities to perpetrate suicide bombings. Military sources said there was also worry that Hamas would try to kidnap soldiers in the West Bank and that Hizbullah might attack along the northern border.

Olmert cautioned Israel's enemies against trying to take advantage of the fact that Israel was busy in Gaza.

In a televised speech, Mashaal warned Israel that it would not achieve by fighting what it had been unable to achieve through diplomacy.

While the Damascus-based Hamas leader maintained that his organization was interested in renewing the cease-fire with Israel, he said this would only be possible if Israel and opened all crossings in and out of the Strip.

Mashaal defended his group's actions and the continued rocket attacks on Israel that led to the IAF offensive, saying Israel - and not Hamas - was responsible for the renewed bloodshed.

[url="http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid=1230111718610&pagename=JPost%2FJPArticle%2FShowFull"]http://www.jpost.com/servlet/Satellite?cid...icle%2FShowFull[/url]

Posted

I am always saddened by war, but you can't expect them to remain passive having rockets lobbed at them constantly.

foolishmortal
Posted

What is the Church's take on Israel? I guess some fundamentalists want to see the end of the world. Jews in America might also have some part in being gung-ho for Israel. Nobody, Catholic or otherwise (except certain groups of Muslims), wants to see them dead or the holy sites there get destroyed or turned into mosques by radical Muslims, but there are Christians in Muslim lands also these rocket raids might maim or kill.


[quote name='CatherineM' post='1736999' date='Dec 28 2008, 04:48 PM']I am always saddened by war, but you can't expect them to remain passive having rockets lobbed at them constantly.[/quote]

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1736999' date='Dec 28 2008, 05:48 PM']I am always saddened by war, but you can't expect them to remain passive having rockets lobbed at them constantly.[/quote]

Agreed; constant rockets were Israel's Christmas gift from Hamas, a group which purposefully launches and hides amongst residential areas in its attempts at asymmetric warfare. A pro-Palestinian friend once asked me how the likes of Hamas were not freedom fighters against the Israelis, and my response was simple, "Freedom fighters don't use human shields, fire on purely civilian targets to cause terror and death, do not indoctrinate children with shows that encourage suicide bombings, nor do they threaten to wipe their so-called oppressors off the face of the Earth."

If there was a Mexican group firing rockets daily into the United States, we would react with the same type of force that Israel is. Constant overtures at negotiation met with nothing but violence, begets violence in retaliation.

This is just my opinion on the whole issue of Israel and Palestine, but the true victims are the civilians on both sides (while acknowledging Israel's mandatory service means technically no one over 18 is a civilian). Both have been born to the world they inhabit, a divided land, both of the current generation can not be forced elsewhere because this is where they have grown up and known as home.

Posted (edited)

Morally, Israel has both the Right to perform counterforce* strikes against their enemies and, especially, the Responsability to do so, as defense of the civilian populace is the obligation of a properly-constituted State.

Practically, the Holy Land is better served by being run by Israel than by the Jihadists (Palestinian and Hezbollah) and their Masters (Syria, Iran, Pakistan and Saudi Arabia).
One is a civil democracy that enshrines plurality and the Rule of Law, and attempts to allow people of all 3 Faiths to visit their respective holy places. The others....not at all.

While there are many Palestinian and Lebanese Christians (Catholic and Orthodox), their presence is not a bar to licit strikes against hostile elements in their vicinity. It's unfortunate, but conflict is never a clean business.

I feel it important to note that Israel never started any of this, no matter how far back you go. The "occupied" Territories were aquired as a result of military victories in what was indisputably a defensive War.
I've worked with the IDF, and been to Israel many times. In my opinion, they are obviously the Good guys.

The Opposition (Hamas, Hezbollah, Al-Aqsa Brigades, etc), OTOH, are outright barbarians.


*-the IDF is seeking to attrit the material stockpile (rockets, ammunition, weapons, etc) that Hamas has built up, so as to limit their ability to project harm into the Israeli interior.

Edited by MichaelF
Posted

I doubt many people here will disagree with any of that Michael, though some will. I had surgery during the summer war between Israel and Hezbollah and couldn't do much else than watch the news and roll my eyes at "Israel massacres civilians in one village"; one missed airstrike is a massacre, constant bombardment by Hezbollah on Israeli civilian targets was not. :rolleyes:

Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1737192' date='Dec 28 2008, 09:53 PM']Agreed; constant rockets were Israel's Christmas gift from Hamas, a group which purposefully launches and hides amongst residential areas in its attempts at asymmetric warfare. A pro-Palestinian friend once asked me how the likes of Hamas were not freedom fighters against the Israelis, and my response was simple, "Freedom fighters don't use human shields, fire on purely civilian targets to cause terror and death, do not indoctrinate children with shows that encourage suicide bombings, nor do they threaten to wipe their so-called oppressors off the face of the Earth."

If there was a Mexican group firing rockets daily into the United States, we would react with the same type of force that Israel is. Constant overtures at negotiation met with nothing but violence, begets violence in retaliation.

This is just my opinion on the whole issue of Israel and Palestine, but the true victims are the civilians on both sides (while acknowledging Israel's mandatory service means technically no one over 18 is a civilian). Both have been born to the world they inhabit, a divided land, both of the current generation can not be forced elsewhere because this is where they have grown up and known as home.[/quote]

The difference is that analogy is that America has not reduced Mexico to essentially a massive open air prison. The traditional dynamics of state relations break down in the Israeli-Palestine conflict because we are not talking about a traditional relationship as applied to independent, sovereign states. That is not to say that either side is right or wrong here, but to compare this to Mexico arbitrarily lobbing some rockets at an American city is not an apt analogy.

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1737497' date='Dec 29 2008, 12:33 AM']The difference is that analogy is that America has not reduced Mexico to essentially a massive open air prison. The traditional dynamics of state relations break down in the Israeli-Palestine conflict because we are not talking about a traditional relationship as applied to independent, sovereign states. That is not to say that either side is right or wrong here, but to compare this to Mexico arbitrarily lobbing some rockets at an American city is not an apt analogy.[/quote]

Have you been to Juarez or Tijuana lately?

Posted

[quote name='MichaelF' post='1737236' date='Dec 28 2008, 10:41 PM']I feel it important to note that Israel never started any of this, no matter how far back you go. The "occupied" Territories were aquired as a result of military victories in what was indisputably a defensive War.[/quote]
The Six Day was not an "indisputably a defensive war" as Israel engaged in a preemptive strike to Egypt's aggressive posturing. Moreover this focus on the immediate events ignores the years of buildup that led to the powder keg which was ignited that day. It was, like most wars, a complicated geopolitical event which outside of propaganda circuits does not lend itself to a simply dichotomy of “good guys” and “bad guys”. Moreover, even if Israel were totally blameless in every respect to the origins of the war, that does not give them the right to do which what they please with the captured civilian population indefinitely.

To say "Israel never started any of this" is a bad place to start. To totally absolve one side is both a-historical and detrimental to any hope of a compromise.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1737500' date='Dec 29 2008, 02:39 AM']Have you been to Juarez or Tijuana lately?[/quote]


Nope, but Im sure you have some good point with relation to it so what's your point?

Posted (edited)

[quote name='BG45' post='1737283' date='Dec 28 2008, 11:10 PM']I doubt many people here will disagree with any of that Michael, though some will. I had surgery during the summer war between Israel and Hezbollah and couldn't do much else than watch the news and roll my eyes at "Israel massacres civilians in one village"; one missed airstrike is a massacre, constant bombardment by Hezbollah on Israeli civilian targets was not. :rolleyes:[/quote]

No, one missed airstrike is not a massacre, but what Israel did in South Lebanon ought to be troubling to anyone. Israel's general human rights record in South Lebanon has been lackluster, just ask their lovely former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.

Edited by Hassan
Posted

[quote name='Seven77' post='1736921' date='Dec 28 2008, 04:50 PM']eye for an eye...[/quote]

uhhhh.....

"You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil; but whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also. If anyone sues you to take away your coat, let him have your cloak also. Whoever compels you to go one mile, go with him two. Give to him who asks you, and don't turn away him who desires to borrow from you."

Matthew 5:38-42


I’m not suggesting Israel ought to confine itself to some pietistic pacifism, but I found that a little ironic coming from a Catholic.

Posted

Actually I think the Mexican analogy works well here. The only big difference and it is debatable as to wether or not it is an actual difference is that Hamas does not acknowledge Israel's right to exist.

Posted

[quote name='Mercy me' post='1737517' date='Dec 29 2008, 02:56 AM']Actually I think the Mexican analogy works well here. The only big difference and it is debatable as to wether or not it is an actual difference is that Hamas does not acknowledge Israel's right to exist.[/quote]


How does it work? I'm not sure if Hammas does or does not acknowledge Israel's right to exist.

[url="http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/jun/22/israel"]http://www.guardian.co.uk/world/2006/jun/22/israel[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1737505' date='Dec 29 2008, 12:45 AM']Nope, but Im sure you have some good point with relation to it so what's your point?[/quote]

They are in the midst of open warfare between various drug gangs. We are their main customers. Our hunger for drugs have turned both cities into the "open air prisons" you were talking about. I used to be able to walk across the bridge from El Paso, and wander around Juarez for days without a care. The locals can't walk around freely there today, let alone single white females.

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1737524' date='Dec 29 2008, 03:08 AM']They are in the midst of open warfare between various drug gangs. We are their main customers. Our hunger for drugs have turned both cities into the "open air prisons" you were talking about. I used to be able to walk across the bridge from El Paso, and wander around Juarez for days without a care. The locals can't walk around freely there today, let alone single white females.[/quote]

A town becoming exceptionally dangerous and consequently impairing the local’s ability to move freely is quite different from the relationship between Gaza and Israel. If America blockaded these cities determining what could and could not enter or leave, deciding if citizens would be allowed to leave to perform religious rituals or study abroad and had a history of regular military excursions and martial law then you would be approaching an apt comparison. That is not to say Israel's actions with respect to Gaza are or are not justified, but simply as a matter of fact it is quite distinct from America's relationship with Mexican or an exceptionally dangerous town. Any conceptual model for discussing this which begins with Mexico arbitrarily assaulting an American town is ill conceived as it is just factually unique from the Gaza-Israeli relationship.

Posted (edited)

Hassan, as to the "good guys/bad guys":

One (Israel) follows the accepted parameters of armed conflict, to include a well-ordered military discipline structure (iow, Israeli Soldiers are subject to, and overseen by, a responsible civilian authority) and all [i]due[/i]* care being given to civilian concerns. They do not deliberately target bystanding civilians and provide medical care to both injured civilians and combatants (of either party).

The Other (Hamas, Hezbollah, etc).....does not. They regularly (and openly) deliberately attack unarmed civilians, most often women and children, in non-tactical (iow, the operations have no military value) terror strikes, often using suicide bombers or inaccurate rocket fire (both outlawed activities). They (with some exception) conduct paramilitary operations without clear markings to indicate combatant status (deliberately obscuring the difference between combatant and noncombatant).
They regularly use children in paramilitary and terror operations.
They have conducted assassination and terror campaigns against third-part (non-belligerant) citizens, based solely on their ethnicity.
They have kidnapped and murdered Israeli Soldiers.
The regularly place paramilitary hubs (C4I, logistics, assembly areas) in and around large civilian areas (schools, hospitals, mosques, etc), in total violation of accepted military conduct.
The list goes on.

[b]The excuse that they aren't capable of conducting military operations against Israeli force in the manner dictated by accepted custom is not, itself, acceptable. The rules are there to keep the civilian deathtoll down (by clearly delineating combatants from noncombatants). You play by them, or you are a criminal.[/b]

Added to the historical context:
The same people, and their Arab sponsors, attempted to invade Israel, as soon as they declared Independance.
The same people conducted a mass exodus of the area, so as to make way for the invading Arab armies (and were thus, quite legitimately, deprived of their resident status).
The Arab states then conducted a concerted Pogrom on their domestic Jewish populations.
The surrounding Arab states started 3 out of the 4 major Israeli-Arab wars, and caused the other one (a preemptive strike against an obvious offensive buildup).

Only extreme moral relativism leads to a conclusion that Israel bears any of the guilt. About the only item you can lay on the Israeli doorstep is that they [i]allowed[/i] the Arab states (and their catspaws in the Strip and West Bank) to retain the capability to do anything at all.

Has Israel done some shady things? Absolutely (South Lebanon being a good example). That still does not strip them of the moral high ground, in relation to the people they are fighting, who commit atrocities and then brag about them to the World (and/or pay others to do so).

*-"due care". Civilians are not magically immune from attack. If a primary school is hosting a troop assembly area or a ManPAD nest, it's a legitimate target and the blood is on the cretins who broke the rules and militarized the target, not the ones who took it out.
Likewise, civilian casualties are "acceptable" (in the sense that you aren't a war criminal) [i]so long as it was not intentional and all reasonable care was taken to prevent them[/i]. You don't pack up and go home because an arty round fell short and liquified a nursing home.

Edited by MichaelF
Posted

[quote name='MichaelF' post='1737556' date='Dec 29 2008, 05:34 AM']Hassan, as to the "good guys/bad guys":

One (Israel) follows the accepted parameters of armed conflict, to include a well-ordered military discipline structure (iow, Israeli Soldiers are subject to, and overseen by, a responsible civilian authority) and all [i]due[/i]* care being given to civilian concerns. They do not deliberately target bystanding civilians and provide medical care to both injured civilians and combatants (of either party).[/quote]

That may be the official policy however the official policy does not always correlate nicely with reality. This can be documented with regards to their activities in the Occupied Territories as documented by both foreign humanitarian organizations and Israeli Soldiers, not to mention Palestinian civilian reports and media outlets.

[quote]The Other (Hamas, Hezbollah, etc).....does not. They regularly (and openly) deliberately attack unarmed civilians, most often women and children, in non-tactical (iow, the operations have no military value) terror strikes, often using suicide bombers or inaccurate rocket fire (both outlawed activities). They (with some exception) conduct paramilitary operations without clear markings to indicate combatant status (deliberately obscuring the difference between combatant and noncombatant).
They regularly use children in paramilitary and terror operations.
They have conducted assassination and terror campaigns against third-part (non-belligerant) citizens, based solely on their ethnicity.
They have kidnapped and murdered Israeli Soldiers.
The regularly place paramilitary hubs (C4I, logistics, assembly areas) in and around large civilian areas (schools, hospitals, mosques, etc), in total violation of accepted military conduct.
The list goes on.[/quote]

I am not going to defend Hammas. I would only amend your list by pointing out that these focus only on illegal and immoral actions committed by Hammas against Israel and does not include offenses committed against the civilian population of Gaza by Hammas.

[quote][b]The excuse that they aren't capable of conducting military operations against Israeli force in the manner dictated by accepted custom is not, itself, acceptable. The rules are there to keep the civilian deathtoll down (by clearly delineating combatants from noncombatants). You play by them, or you are a criminal.[/b][/quote]

If that is the object of the rules then they clearly are deficient. The recent war in Lebanon confirms this. Israeli civilian death tolls were about forty four, while Lebanese civilian death tolls were; by the Israeli governments own accounting, in excess of one thousand. Please note that excludes the deaths that will result of the ecological damage and unexploded ordinance from cluster bombs.
[quote]Added to the historical context:
The same people, and their Arab sponsors, attempted to invade Israel, as soon as they declared Independance.
The same people conducted a mass exodus of the area, so as to make way for the invading Arab armies (and were thus, quite legitimately, deprived of their resident status).[/quote]

That popular myth has been refuted by both foreign and Israeli historians who have well documented the ethnic cleansing and forced migration the Israeli army engaged in to move the native Palestinian population. Christopher Hitchens wrote an excellent article refuting this back in the 80's in an anthology edited by Edward Said. I can look it up when I stroll up to the library in a bit. Not to mention the Israeli historians who have investigated this claim.


[quote]The Arab states then conducted a concerted Pogrom on their domestic Jewish populations.
The surrounding Arab states started 3 out of the 4 major Israeli-Arab wars, and caused the other one (a preemptive strike against an obvious offensive buildup).[/quote]

I'm not going to defend the despotic regimes of Egypt, Jordan, or Syria.

[quote]Only extreme moral relativism leads to a conclusion that Israel bears any of the guilt. About the only item you can lay on the Israeli doorstep is that they [i]allowed[/i] the Arab states (and their catspaws in the Strip and West Bank) to retain the capability to do anything at all.[/quote]

That is just refuted by ample historical evidence both with regards to the larger historic conflict and contemporary events. Not to mention settler violence.

[quote]Has Israel done some shady things? Absolutely (South Lebanon being a good example).[/quote]

Facilitating the mass slaughter of over three thousand Palestinian civilians is not "shady". To reference only the most conscious shocking and explicit atrocity committed in the region.

[quote]That still does not strip them of the moral high ground, in relation to the people they are fighting, who commit atrocities and then brag about them to the World (and/or pay others to do so).[/quote]

No. They should do the civilized thing. Force Sharon to remain as an untitled member of the cabinet after he helped facilitate the slaughter of 3,500 civilians in a refugee camps by Lebanese Christian nationalists. Then years later allow him to ascend to the position of Prime Minister for five years until finally being removed by natural circumstances. Israel is not some innately wicked nation nor is it some innately good nation. It is, like most nations, one of lass than morally stellar origins which has a mixed track record. Some wonderful intellectuals, moral agents, and human rights organizations have emerged from Israel. On the other hand it has its share of religious fanatics. Some commit atrocities against other Israelis, such as ultra orthodox Jews throwing acid on immodestly dressed women. Some commit atrocities against Palestinian civilians, such as beating unarmed elderly Palestinians with baseball bats for daring to live on God given Israel and other ethnic exceptionalist nonsense. This same dynamism and nuance exists within Palestinian culture. Declaring Israel as somehow innately superior either morally or with respect to progress is sustainable only as propaganda. It is akin to individuals who can find no fault with the Palestinian side and can only see Israel as a fire breathing monster despite what good deeds it does.

Posted

[quote]If that is the object of the rules then they clearly are deficient. The recent war in Lebanon confirms this. Israeli civilian death tolls were about forty four, while Lebanese civilian death tolls were; by the Israeli governments own accounting, in excess of one thousand. Please note that excludes the deaths that will result of the ecological damage and unexploded ordinance from cluster bombs.[/quote]

Not correct. The rules work (as far as it goes, since only the Israelis observe them). The IDF clearly delineates between their combat forces and Israeli civilians (as that is what they are bound to do), placing military posts away (as far as is possible in such a small area) from civilian population clusters and maintaining clearly observable uniforms and insignia.

IOW, you can tell an Israeli Soldier (or Border Policeman) from an Israeli civilian. Not that anyone cares to make that distinction (save to preferentially target Israeli civilians, those being much easier prospects than armed IDF personnel).

Conversely, Hezbollah (I won't even get into Hamas' behaviour) refuses to wear distinctinve insignia during combat operations, and habitually emplaces its military assets among civilian populations and civic assets (it also uses civilian logistics routes, such as Lebanese bridges, to transport arms, troops and ammunition, making them de jure targets as well, to the cost of civic infrastructure when they are legitimately destroyed by Israel). They also emplace crew-served weapons positions in close proximity to UN (UNIFIL) forces, resulting in UN casualties when Israeli forces legitimately engage them.

IOW, you cannot tell a Hezbollah militant from a Lebanese civilian. This is not accidental.


If the Israeli deathtoll in the 2007 conflict was smaller by far than that of the Lebanese, it is because Israel protects it's civilians and because Israel was conducting an offensive (fighting in someone else's front yard) inside Lebanon. An offensive initiated in [i]response to[/i] Hezbollah provocations (indiscriminate rocket bombardment of Israeli population clusters).

In constrast to what you seem to believe I'm saying, Israel is not a moral paragon (in so far as no State is such). It's done it's fair share of evil. That said, they are light years beyond their opponents, and actually try act in a correct mannner.
While it is inappropriate to try to put the Israelis on a pedestal, they aren't morally equivalent to their enemies (who, incidentally, are enemies general of civilization, on the wider stage).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...