Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Israeli Assault Could Last Weeks; 230 Dead


Recommended Posts

Posted

It's not unusual for the winning side in a war to have fewer casualties.

Galloglasses' Alt
Posted

Especially not when it is severely handicapping its opponents artillery. (IE, Israli Forces are decimating Hamas' rocket launching capabilities)

puellapaschalis
Posted

All the Europeans I know are condemning Israel. All the USAns I know are condemning Hezbollah. I don't know what to think.

Posted

The Pope said, "The native land of Jesus cannot continue to be witness to so much bloodshed, repeating itself without end. I implore an end to that violence, which must be condemned in every manifestation and for a renewal of the truce in the Gaza Strip." I'd say he's against violence from both sides, but I suspect he considers what Israel is doing as an escalation. He just has to be very careful in what he says.

Posted

my bad...i gotta stop posting those one-liners like that.

what i meant was the Palestinian-Israeli conflict is a vicious cycle perpetuated and based on "eye for an eye"...they ought read the NT (without "confining themselves to some pietistic pacifism")...

[quote name='Seven77' post='1736921' date='Dec 28 2008, 04:50 PM']eye for an eye...[/quote]

[quote name='Hassan' post='1737515' date='Dec 29 2008, 02:53 AM']uhhhh.....

"You have heard that it was said, 'An eye for an eye, and a tooth for a tooth.' But I tell you, don't resist him who is evil; but whoever strikes you on your right cheek, turn to him the other also. If anyone sues you to take away your coat, let him have your cloak also. Whoever compels you to go one mile, go with him two. Give to him who asks you, and don't turn away him who desires to borrow from you."

Matthew 5:38-42


I’m not suggesting Israel ought to confine itself to some pietistic pacifism, but I found that a little ironic coming from a Catholic.[/quote]

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[quote name='puellapaschalis' post='1737980' date='Dec 29 2008, 06:42 PM']All the Europeans I know are condemning Israel. All the USAns I know are condemning Hezbollah. I don't know what to think.[/quote]
Really? How can anyone defend Hezbollah? If someone starts bombing your country sooner or later you retaliate. Hamas broke the peace accord, not Israel.

puellapaschalis
Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1738003' date='Dec 30 2008, 02:08 AM']Really? How can anyone defend Hezbollah? If someone starts bombing your country sooner or later you retaliate. Hamas broke the peace accord, not Israel.[/quote]

The 'defence' is wrapped up under layers of transparency; words like 'killing innocent Palestinians' - which I don't think many people will entirely disagree with - but very, VERY little mention of the casualties of Hezbollah et al's terrorism.

Can we even call it terrorism? I just don't know.

Posted

this excessive, eye for an eye bloodshed makes me sick

Posted

[quote name='cmotherofpirl' post='1738003' date='Dec 29 2008, 07:08 PM']Really? How can anyone defend Hezbollah? If someone starts bombing your country sooner or later you retaliate. Hamas broke the peace accord, not Israel.[/quote]
I don’t think they defend Hezbollah in general; however, they may recognize that Hezbollah reflects legitimate grievances towards Israel and their disturbing behavior in Lebanon. I believe Jean Paul Sartre expressed this general view succinctly when he said in response to the Munich attacks, “[terrorism] is a terrible weapon but the oppressed poor have no others." Not to mention that Hezbollah is not an entirely military organization. They also provide a number of social services for civilians in Lebanon. I am not endorsing these views.

Posted (edited)

So Hassan, as you defend this terrorist organization that is recognized as such by most of the world's civilized countries, you continue to claim to not be a "Secret Muslim"? ;) Admit it man, someone had to make the standard line, at least I could do it in a joking manner. :saint:

[quote name='Hassan' post='1737513' date='Dec 29 2008, 02:50 AM']No, one missed airstrike is not a massacre, but what Israel did in South Lebanon ought to be troubling to anyone. Israel's general human rights record in South Lebanon has been lackluster, just ask their lovely former Prime Minister Ariel Sharon.[/quote]

Now we both know Ariel Sharon can not be asked because he is still in a deep coma; funny you should bring him up though. It was Ariel Sharon who offered to restore the UN borders and help Arafat create a Palestinian state, the Palestinian Authority, at the time the unified government of the Palestinian people rejected the plan. A pity that the Palestinian leadership was so greedy, men who now live on in the governments of both Hamas and Al Fatah...one a recognized terrorist group, the other the so called legitimate government, but both descended from the Palestinian Liberation Organization, a terrorist group.

As for human rights records...no one's is particularly clean. Canadian forces took part in the firebombing of Dresden and colonists did horrible things to the natives, the same goes for the United States. The United Kingdom had a global empire where abuses would occur, so did France and the Netherlands, so did Spain and Portugal. So have a myriad of other nations around the world...none of us is innocent of human rights violations; including the Palestinians. A nation is not allowed under international law to indoctrinate children to become soldiers to a cause and shows with a rip off Mickey Mouse encouraging the Intifada and "suicide warrior" songs does just that.


[quote]The difference is that analogy is that America has not reduced Mexico to essentially a massive open air prison. The traditional dynamics of state relations break down in the Israeli-Palestine conflict because we are not talking about a traditional relationship as applied to independent, sovereign states. That is not to say that either side is right or wrong here, but to compare this to Mexico arbitrarily lobbing some rockets at an American city is not an apt analogy.[/quote]

But as CatherineM already stated, it pretty much is in the border towns. Not just on the Mexican side of the border either; the Mexican military in the employee of drug cartels violates our sovereign territory all the time. Effectively in most border zones the Mexican government does not exist or is impotent to what amounts to the drug warlords aka small terrorist groups which control territory much like Hamas who are caught between the United States on one side and the loyal Mexican armed forces on the other, effectively imprisoning them in their fiefdoms.

Edited by BG45
Posted

[quote]Not correct. The rules work (as far as it goes, since only the Israelis observe them). The IDF clearly delineates between their combat forces and Israeli civilians (as that is what they are bound to do), placing military posts away (as far as is possible in such a small area) from civilian population clusters and maintaining clearly observable uniforms and insignia.[/quote]

Again, this is contradicted by the reports of respected human rights organizations.
[url="http://www.hrw.org/en/node/11265/section/2"]http://www.hrw.org/en/node/11265/section/2[/url]


[quote]Conversely, Hezbollah (I won't even get into Hamas' behaviour) refuses to wear distinctinve insignia during combat operations, and habitually emplaces its military assets among civilian populations and civic assets (it also uses civilian logistics routes, such as Lebanese bridges, to transport arms, troops and ammunition, making them de jure targets as well, to the cost of civic infrastructure when they are legitimately destroyed by Israel). They also emplace crew-served weapons positions in close proximity to UN (UNIFIL) forces, resulting in UN casualties when Israeli forces legitimately engage them.[/quote]
When Hezbollah does that it is a serious violation of international law, and there is nothing else to say. Hezbollah commits their fair share of illegal activities. The above report directly disputes your accounting.

[quote]IOW, you cannot tell a Hezbollah militant from a Lebanese civilian. This is not accidental.


If the Israeli deathtoll in the 2007 conflict was smaller by far than that of the Lebanese, it is because Israel protects it's civilians and because Israel was conducting an offensive (fighting in someone else's front yard) inside Lebanon. An offensive initiated in response to Hezbollah provocations (indiscriminate rocket bombardment of Israeli population clusters).[/quote]
That ignores Israel’s provocative actions preceding the war. One immediate example that comes to mind is their fence construction on the Lebanese border and it’s adverse affects on Lebanese civilians. Moreover it absolves Israeli actions that show disregard for civilian life. When they expel almost 90% of all their spent cluster munitions in the last 72 hours of the war after a resolution had been reached that is a serious problem. Such munitions disproportionately affect children, as the relevant statistic of Lebanese civilians killed by such unexploded ordinance bears out. Israel’s illegal and morally questionable actions towards the Lebanese civilian population were well documented and there is ample evidence for it.

[quote]In constrast to what you seem to believe I'm saying, Israel is not a moral paragon (in so far as no State is such). It's done it's fair share of evil.[/quote]
You say that but then add comments that suggest some sort of Israeli exceptionalism.


[quote]That said, they are light years beyond their opponents, and actually try act in a correct mannner.[/quote]
That is contrary to a mass of documented evidence with regards to actual Israeli practice in its various engagements. They may have lovely normative practices laid out in official documents, so does Hezbollah.

[quote]While it is inappropriate to try to put the Israelis on a pedestal, they aren't morally equivalent to their enemies (who, incidentally, are enemies general of civilization, on the wider stage).[/quote]

What makes them morally superior? You mention particular examples like distinguishing civilians from soldiers, but I don’t understand your conceptual framework for determining party X to be morally superior to party Y.

dominicansoul
Posted

this is so sad...

...it's beyond trying to figure out who's to blame, or who started it...

...we just know the fuel is hatred...bitter hatred between the Arabs and the Jews

Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1738094' date='Dec 29 2008, 08:35 PM']So Hassan, as you defend this terrorist organization that is recognized as such by most of the world's civilized countries, you continue to claim to not be a "Secret Muslim"? ;) Admit it man, someone had to make the standard line, at least I could do it in a joking manner. :saint:[/quote]

:topsy:

I was wondering when that would come up :D

I want to be clear though, I am not defending Hezbollah or Hammas. They engage in serious human rights violations and illegal activities both towards Israeli civilians and their own populations.



[quote]Now we both know Ariel Sharon can not be asked because he is still in a deep coma; funny you should bring him up though.[/quote]

There is nothing to ask. He should have stood trial at the Hague for his crimes.

[quote]It was Ariel Sharon who offered to restore the UN borders and help Arafat create a Palestinian state, the Palestinian Authority, at the time the unified government of the Palestinian people rejected the plan. A pity that the Palestinian leadership was so greedy, men who now live on in the government[/quote]

You need to mention what specific proposal you are talking about.

[quote]s of both Hamas and Al Fatah...one a recognized terrorist group, the other the so called legitimate government, but both descended from the Palestinian Liberation Organization, a terrorist group.[/quote]

We recognized the Israeli government when it was headed by Sharon.



[quote]As for human rights records...no one's is particularly clean. Canadian forces took part in the firebombing of Dresden and colonists did horrible things to the natives, the same goes for the United States. The United Kingdom had a global empire where abuses would occur, so did France and the Netherlands, so did Spain and Portugal. So have a myriad of other nations around the world...none of us is innocent of human rights violations; including the Palestinians.[/quote]

I agree, yet Israel is rarely if ever held accountable for their atrocities. Very few people have a problem, in America, of admitting that Hammas is a terrorist organization, yet Israel is depicted as some archetype of decency and moral fortitude. Most of your referenced actions were before the advent of international law and the United Nations.

[quote]A nation is not allowed under international law to indoctrinate children to become soldiers[/quote]

Really? So when military recruiters came to my class that was illegal?

[quote]to a cause and shows with a rip off Mickey Mouse encouraging the Intifada and "suicide warrior" songs does just that.[/quote]

I'm not going to defend such indoctrination its disgusting, but I don't know what specific law you are talking about.


[quote]But as CatherineM already stated, it pretty much is in the border towns. Not just on the Mexican side of the border either; the Mexican military in the employee of drug cartels violates our sovereign territory all the time.[/quote]

That is unfortunate, but it is not comparable to the occupied territories. If America controlled these towns, had a blockade around them etc then we would have something to talk about.

[quote]Effectively in most border zones the Mexican government does not exist or is impotent to what amounts to the drug warlords aka small terrorist groups which control territory much like Hamas who are caught between the United States on one side and the loyal Mexican armed forces on the other, effectively imprisoning them in their fiefdoms.[/quote]

I don't see how this analogy works. Can you specifically point to how this is analogous to Gaza?

Posted

I know Hassan, but had to bring it up, even jokingly. In no particular order because I'm chatting and watching a DVD:

1) The international laws in question are those that forbid the use of children as soldiers, and by extension the usage of propaganda to indoctrinate them. "The Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflicts", the optional addenda to said piece of international legislation entitled, "The Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Involvement of Children in Armed Conflicts", "Resolution 1261" of the United Nations Security Council on the condemnation of indoctrination and usage of child soldiers, and "The Amman Declaration on Child Soldiers" as well as the so-called "Capetown Principles" to name a few.

2) The deal Arafat turned down was proposed by the then President of the United States, Bill Clinton. At the time it was put on the table at Camp David between Ehud Barak (now Defense Minister) and Yasser Arafat and then later by the election of Ariel Sharon. Arafat flat out refused the deal, and as Sharon came into power he offered to resume negotiations if Arafat was willing to deal...Arafat's response was an Intifada.

3) We are willing to deal with the Israeli government and Sharon is not on trial because he is not recognized as a terrorist by the international community.

4) Military recruiters in school are a step into a grey area. I've had them in my classrooms as well; that said do they force you to only watch United States propaganda of some sort in exclusion to all other programming? Do they tell you it's a glorious thing to kill the enemies of the United States? No.

5) Israel has been under various embargoes for its actions, including weapons embargoes from some of its top suppliers like the USA. We refused to sell them the exocet missiles during one such embargo.

6) It's a small area of land occupied by a mix of terrorists, drug lords, etc. and such while encircled by more powerful factions on all sides. The people are prisoners that are unable to escape those Mexican cities. The so called occupied territories, it is worth noting, aren't actually occupied by the Israelis; there are border guards and wall yes, just like the section of the U.S./Mexican border that is being referenced.

The "refugee camps" I have seen footage of are apartment complexes that are nicer than my neighborhood. :idontknow:

Posted

My son entered the US Navy at 17. He had never been on a date, and never driven a car, but he went. He was still a child under many people's definition. It wasn't easy to sign those permission papers, but at least they had to get my permission, and didn't just come and take him away.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1738154' date='Dec 29 2008, 09:03 PM']this is so sad...

...it's beyond trying to figure out who's to blame, or who started it...

...we just know the fuel is hatred...bitter hatred between the Arabs and the Jews[/quote]


It is NOT bitter hatred between the Arabs and the Jews. It is bitter hatred OF the Jews BY the Arabs. The Jews are only defending their land of nearly 4,000 years. Anyone would do the same in their position. The Jews stand to gain absolutely NOTHING by hating the Arabs and in general have no reason to. If it were not for Arab violence against them, the whole world would see Israel as the most warm, peaceful and loving of nations. The Jews have already broken off pieces of their land and given it to the Muslims as gestures of peace and time and time again, they have gotten nothing in return for their overtures but bombs and blood. I said here at PM and have said to numerous others that Israel would come to see their dreadful mistake in giving Gaza to the Muslims. From day one that Gaza was given to them, they started firing rockets from Gaza into Israel. Actually, I take that back...it wasn't from day one. It was from week one. They spent the first week destroying Gaza land and THEN began firing rockets. The Israeli politicians who are responsible for these ridiculous and fruitless overtures towards the Muslims will rue the day for their irresonsible actions. Already, the incoming PM was on TV yesterday bemoaning the fact that the Arabs have only used Gaza to gain closer proximity to fire rockets into Israeli territory. It makes my blood boil to watch her carrying on like she and her cohorts didn't know this could happen. Appalling.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='Seven77' post='1738046' date='Dec 29 2008, 07:50 PM']this excessive, eye for an eye bloodshed makes me sick[/quote]


Israel is a tiny nation the size of New Jersey. They are surrounded on three sides by people who hate them, and on the fourth side is the sea. The Israelis HAVE NOWHERE TO RUN. For this reason, their defensive assaults on the Arabs are always ten times worse than what the Arabs dole out to them. Excessive? You bet. My actions in defense of my life, my family and my nation would also be excessive where I in their position. What is the message in Israel's behavior? "Don't mess with the Jews". It's that simple. I really don't think most people can begin to even understand or comprehend their predicament. This is why it's easy to judge and criticize them.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1737993' date='Dec 29 2008, 06:58 PM']The Pope said, "The native land of Jesus cannot continue to be witness to so much bloodshed, repeating itself without end. I implore an end to that violence, which must be condemned in every manifestation and for a renewal of the truce in the Gaza Strip." I'd say he's against violence from both sides, but I suspect he considers what Israel is doing as an escalation. He just has to be very careful in what he says.[/quote]

I don't read it that way at all. As an escalation, I mean. I agree he laothes the violence in the Holy Land and that he has to be diplomatic with his words. But I don't see him necessarily under-handedly blaming the Israelis for an escalation. It can easily be interpreted as a condemnation of the Arabs who broke the truce in the first place. Just because he said violence in the Holy Land must stop, doesn't mean he's handing the blame to the Israelis. I see it as a condemnation of the violence being committed against the Holy Land. I just can't wrap my head around how ANYONE can condemn or criticize Israel for defending itself!!

Posted

[quote name='BG45' post='1738227' date='Dec 29 2008, 09:52 PM']I know Hassan, but had to bring it up, even jokingly. In no particular order because I'm chatting and watching a DVD:[/quote]

Sure

[quote]1) The international laws in question are those that forbid the use of children as soldiers, and by extension the usage of propaganda to indoctrinate them. "The Convention on the Rights of the Child on the involvement of children in armed conflicts", the optional addenda to said piece of international legislation entitled, "The Optional Protocol to the Convention on the Involvement of Children in Armed Conflicts", "Resolution 1261" of the United Nations Security Council on the condemnation of indoctrination and usage of child soldiers, and "The Amman Declaration on Child Soldiers" as well as the so-called "Capetown Principles" to name a few.[/quote]

Good.

[quote]2) The deal Arafat turned down was proposed by the then President of the United States, Bill Clinton.[/quote]

Which specific deal are you talking about?

[quote]At the time it was put on the table at Camp David between Ehud Barak (now Defense Minister) and Yasser Arafat and then later by the election of Ariel Sharon. Arafat flat out refused the deal, and as Sharon came into power he offered to resume negotiations if Arafat was willing to deal...Arafat's response was an Intifada.[/quote]

Are you talking about Campt David II? In what respect was this some magnanimous concession on Israel’s part only torn asunder by Palestinian greed?

[quote]3) We are willing to deal with the Israeli government and Sharon is not on trial because he is not recognized as a terrorist by the international community.[/quote]

He should have been on trial for war crimes not terrorism.

[quote]4) Military recruiters in school are a step into a grey area. I've had them in my classrooms as well; that said do they force you to only watch United States propaganda of some sort in exclusion to all other programming? Do they tell you it's a glorious thing to kill the enemies of the United States? No.[/quote]

You should hear some of the cadences at JROTC summer camp.

[quote]5) Israel has been under various embargoes for its actions, including weapons embargoes from some of its top suppliers like the USA. We refused to sell them the exocet missiles during one such embargo.[/quote]

And that is a good thing. Bush Sr. tried to reign in the settlements.

[quote]6) It's a small area of land occupied by a mix of terrorists, drug lords, etc. and such while encircled by more powerful factions on all sides.

The people are prisoners that are unable to escape those Mexican cities.[/quote]
Why are they unable to leave?

[quote]The so called occupied territories, it is worth noting, aren't actually occupied by the Israelis; there are border guards and wall yes, just like the section of the U.S./Mexican border that is being referenced.[/quote]

The US can prevent the Mexican nationals from entering the US. Israel has every right to prevent people from entering their nation. The US does not control movement in and out of the the city. We cannot prevent Mexican students of this city from studying abroad in foreign nations.


[quote]The "refugee camps" I have seen footage of are apartment complexes that are nicer than my neighborhood. :idontknow:[/quote]

Sure, and when I watched China on the Olympics it seemed like a wonderful place.

Madame Vengier
Posted

[quote name='puellapaschalis' post='1737980' date='Dec 29 2008, 06:42 PM']All the Europeans I know are condemning Israel.[/quote]

No surprise there. Europe is the continent solely responsible for the largest amount of Jews in history emigrating out of the continent into Israel. Just this past summer I read that currently the most spoken foreign language (that is, not Hebrew) on the streets of Tel Aviv is French. There are and have lately been massive amounts of Jews leaving France. Already there are two entire generations of Germans, Russians and assorted other Europeans Jews who are native-born Israelis. These droves of Jews leaving Europe are NOT a result of the Holocaust. It is much more recent than that.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...