Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Atheist ads hit London buses
by Maria Mackay
Posted: Tuesday, January 6, 2009, 8:51 (GMT)

As atheist adverts hit London’s buses on Tuesday, one faith-based think tank says they will only get people thinking more about God.

The British Humanist Association’s adverts carry the slogan “There’s probably no God. Now stop worrying and enjoy your life.”, and will appear on 30 of London’s bendy buses.

The posters are the atheist answer to a number of high profile Christian advertising campaigns on London buses and billboards, notably the Alpha Course, whose posters ask, "Is this it?" and "If God did exist, what would you ask him?"

They have been publicly endorsed and partially financed by prominent atheist Professor Richard Dawkins, who told the BBC that the ad campaign was designed to make people think, an action he said was “anathema to religion”.

The public theology think tank Theos has welcomed the campaign, saying it will encourage more people to think about the existence of God.

"We think that the campaign is a great way to get people thinking about God. The posters will encourage people to consider the most important question we will ever face in our lives,” said Theos Director Paul Woolley.

"The slogan itself is a great discussion starter. Telling someone "there's probably no God" is a bit like telling them that they've probably remembered to lock their front door. It creates the doubt that they might not have done so.”

Mr Woolley said that a new Theos research study due to be published next month had revealed that there were as many people finding God in Britain today as there were losing people losing their faith.

“So this campaign is speaking into a very live debate,” he said.

Mike Elms, a fellow of The Marketing Society and former chief executive of ad agencies Ogilvy & Mather and Tempus/CIA, said that the campaign could play a role in the revival of Christianity.

"For too long, the British public has been able to dodge the 'God choice' - is there or isn't there? - by scribbling ‘C of E’ on their hospital admission form,” he said.

“But now atheists are challenging us to make that choice one way or another. The atheist campaign opens the door toward a very public debate on the existence and nature of God."

The head of Church Army, Mark Russell, has also previously expressed his support for the adverts in his blog, ‘Mark Russell’s reflections’.

"I love that the advert says 'probably'," he wrote, "so it seems the atheists are not sure if there is a God or not!! I hope people will take time out from the busyness of their everyday lives and think openly about the issues."

Article from Christian Today:
[url="http://www.christiantoday.com/article/atheist.ads.hit.london.buses/22249.htm"]http://www.christiantoday.com/article/athe...buses/22249.htm[/url]

Posted

I suspect they are right that it will get people thinking about God, and that can only be a plus. I'm glad to see he's putting all his book royalty money to good use.

Lounge Daddy
Posted

"There's probably no God" doesn't sound very convincing. Gosh, where's the conviction?

Posted

I think that's the point. For someone like Mr. Dawkins, the question of God is something he'd like to represent as 'not a big deal.' Of course, if it really doesn't matter one way or another...then why pay for the ad? I thought it was very amusing that the article didn't quote any Christians expressing outrage over this ;) It was all very enthusiastic, great, thanks for doing our job for us!

Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1744521' date='Jan 6 2009, 04:56 PM'][snip]
Of course, if it really doesn't matter one way or another...then why pay for the ad?
[snip][/quote]

:lol_roll:

Gotta love it!

That is one of my favorites arguments against atheists; why should it bother them that we believe, their position is a position of indifference.

Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
Posted (edited)

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1744498' date='Jan 6 2009, 05:24 PM']"There's probably no God" doesn't sound very convincing. Gosh, where's the conviction?[/quote]

It has nothing to do with conviction and everything to do with logic. You cannot prove a negative such as God does not exist. Empirically you cannot do it because science only speaks to probability. A scientist even if he does an experiment a thousand times and he does it one more time he can only say that it will "probably" turn out a certain way, due to the nature of empirical belief and inductive reasoning. Mr. Dawkins knows this and says so in one of his books and thus concludes their cannot be a completely convinced atheist but only agnostics because of this. If he is intellectually honest as he claims to be, then he can only use the word "probably" and not make a universal claim because he discounts universal claims through empiricism and inductive reasoning.

But yes, I agree this phrasing is very counter productive for achieving their desired goals, are better at achieving honest discussion, prompts people to search their hearts, and maybe it will even snap people out of what Pope John Paul II called a "practical materialism." Funny how only the religious view affords conviction and a certain degree of certainty. The conviction they desire resides in faith! Haha.

Edited by Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
eagle_eye222001
Posted

[quote name='Lounge Daddy' post='1744498' date='Jan 6 2009, 03:24 PM']"There's probably no God" doesn't sound very convincing. Gosh, where's the conviction?[/quote]


There is none. There is only a daring hope there is no God to judge them at the end times.

----------------
Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/creed/track/with+arms+wide+open"]Creed - With Arms Wide Open[/url]
via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url]

Posted

[quote name='eagle_eye222001' post='1744546' date='Jan 6 2009, 05:26 PM']There is none. There is only a daring hope there is no God to judge them at the end times.

----------------
Now playing: [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/artist/creed/track/with+arms+wide+open"]Creed - With Arms Wide Open[/url]
via [url="http://www.foxytunes.com/signatunes/"]FoxyTunes[/url][/quote]


It's no more daring hope than the one you hold that your God is real and you won't have to taste Allah's chastisement when the interiogating angle demands to know "Who is your Lord and What is your faith" and you, being an errant monotheist give only confused answers and thus must reside to the fires whose fuel is "stones and men".

Why don't you (I assume) lay awake at night worrying about this? Probably because there is very little evidence that this is a serious possibility. The same goes for your God.

That's not to say that your beliefs are false but to say it is a "daring hope" on the part of non Christians is really just hyperbole.

Posted

Also, I would say it is better to have little conviction than absolute conviction on a "leap of faith".

Posted

[quote name='Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam' post='1744540' date='Jan 6 2009, 05:14 PM']It has nothing to do with conviction and everything to do with logic. You cannot prove a negative such as God does not exist. Empirically you cannot do it because science only speaks to probability. A scientist even if he does an experiment a thousand times and he does it one more time he can only say that it will "probably" turn out a certain way, due to the nature of empirical belief and inductive reasoning. Mr. Dawkins knows this and says so in one of his books and thus concludes their cannot be a completely convinced atheist but only agnostics because of this. If he is intellectually honest as he claims to be, then he can only use the word "probably" and not make a universal claim because he discounts universal claims through empiricism and inductive reasoning.

But yes, I agree this phrasing is very counter productive for achieving their desired goals, are better at achieving honest discussion, prompts people to search their hearts, and maybe it will even snap people out of what Pope John Paul II called a "practical materialism." Funny how only the religious view affords conviction and a certain degree of certainty. The conviction they desire resides in faith! Haha.[/quote]

Exactly. I mean I think he is way off but the above seems to be about what he believes.

Why does anyone listen to Dawkins outside of matters of biology? I still just don't understand that.

Posted

The ad sounds more agnostic then atheistic.

Posted

A bus worth waiting for
This campaign is the antithesis of the 'shouty atheism' so beloved of religious caricaturists
Comments (…)



"You wait ages for an atheist bus and then 800 come along at once," said Ariane Sherine at the culmination of her campaign to put anti-faith slogans on the sides of UK buses. Throughout, she has been the antithesis of the shrill, dogmatic and shouty atheist that is so beloved of religious caricaturists. She is charming, smiley and wonderfully unintimidating and her campaign has captured the imagination of thousands of people.

Last summer, she was irritated by an advert on a bus from a religious organisation that expressed a profoundly threatening message (essentially, think what we think or "you spend all eternity in torment in hell"). She wondered if there was a classier and more thoughtful way of putting the opposing point of view.

The result – thanks to £135,000 raised mainly through small donations – is a national fleet of 800 buses with the words "There's probably no God, now stop worrying and enjoy your life" on the side, plus a series of adverts on the London Underground. The phrase is a genius of understatement. They are the weary words of so many of us who have had to listen tight-lipped to endless wild-eyed preachers presuming to tell us we were born sinful and are destined for eternal damnation. Those silent millions have suddenly found a voice.

With the low December sun glistening off the gold of the Albert memorial in the background, the atheist bus campaign's press launch felt at times more like a Church of England coffee morning. There were warm greetings, hugs between old friends and purposeful-looking people marching back and forth with clipboards looking stressed about whether the catering would be adequate. The cast was a mini-Who's Who of British atheists: evolutionary biologist Professor Richard Dawkins; the philosopher AC Grayling; president of the British Humanist Association Polly Toynbee; comedian Robin Ince. Even Stephen Fry sent a goodwill message from New Zealand (not enough cash yet for a live video link up).

Ince, who hosted the event, pointed out that the buses were not technically atheist, but agnostic. "That is the scientific viewpoint because we can't ultimately prove that there is no God. But I'm taking the risk," he said.

Dawkins is another man who is taking the risk. "I would have chosen a slightly stronger slogan," he confided, "but I wouldn't have wanted to say there's definitely no God just as I wouldn't want to say there's definitely no Father Christmas."

All in all, Sherine's campaign has been a magnificent and surprising achievement. The original fundraising target of £5500 was reached in just 3 hours – and at its peak, the campaign's Just Giving website was clocking up £17 per minute. The site has continued to attract new donors on every single day since its launch.

For my money, it is Sherine's amusing and charming slogan that has prompted so many people to part with her hard-earned cash. Pledging support was a way for non-believers to make a statement about what they didn't believe – and in the process, to make some other people smile and perhaps think a bit on their way to work. Atheists are by definition free-thinkers who don't follow the crowd. The atheist bus gave us a way of speaking with a single voice – and it feels great. As Sherine put it, "I don't feel alone anymore." :huh:

[url="http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/2009/jan/06/atheism-religion-bus-dawkins/print"]http://www.guardian.co.uk/commentisfree/20...s-dawkins/print[/url]

Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1744567' date='Jan 6 2009, 06:01 PM']That's not to say that your beliefs are false but to say it is a "daring hope" on the part of non Christians is really just hyperbole.[/quote]
Strawman. We're talking about atheists, not all non-Christians.

we aren't really risking much by believing in a God. If there is no God, then worst case scenario, we waste our lives. Who cares, we'll all be dead in a hundred years anyways.

RandomProddy
Posted

[quote name='Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam' post='1744540' date='Jan 6 2009, 10:14 PM']It has nothing to do with conviction and everything to do with logic. You cannot prove a negative such as God does not exist.[/quote]

There is no such thing as a square prime number.

..ok that's only negative dpeending on your point of view i suppose..

Posted

[quote name='"Ariane Sherine"']Atheists are by definition free-thinkers...[/quote]

Whatever you say, Missy

Posted

[quote name='XIX' post='1744595' date='Jan 6 2009, 06:33 PM']Strawman. We're talking about atheists, not all non-Christians.

we aren't really risking much by believing in a God. If there is no God, then worst case scenario, we waste our lives. Who cares, we'll all be dead in a hundred years anyways.[/quote]

It's not a straw man and you should read more carefully. He claimed that that atheism has no certainty but simply "There is only a daring hope there is no God to judge them at the end times."

I was pointing out how silly this description was. Atheism or agnosticism is no more a "daring hope" than Christianity is a "daring hope" that Islam is false.

You loose nothing in believing in God so long as you believe in the right God or the one who is real accepts you. If Muhammad was a true prophet your very soul could be in grave danger. Is your atheism with regards to Allah a "daring hope that he's not real and you won't have to suffer his judgments? Obviously not.
As Robert’s said “I contend that we are both atheists. I just believe in one fewer god than you do. When you understand why you dismiss all the other possible gods, you will understand why I dismiss yours.”


This would be one reason why Pascal's Wager breaks down

dominicansoul
Posted

hassan, there are no virgins waiting for you on the other side...


...just thought i'd throw this in to the discussion! :topsy:

Posted

[quote name='T-Bone _' post='1744609' date='Jan 6 2009, 06:56 PM']Whatever you say, Missy[/quote]


It’s absurd. Just like that little cult always parroting Dawkins, as though the embrace of atheism made one some purely rational entity. The pretentiousness is astounding.

Posted

[quote name='dominicansoul' post='1744861' date='Jan 6 2009, 11:47 PM']hassan, there are no virgins waiting for you on the other side...


...just thought i'd throw this in to the discussion! :topsy:[/quote]


Obviously not. I'm a secret Muslim, so there are secret virgins waiting for me. What would I want with regular, run of the mill virgins silly? :topsy:

Posted

Well, if you view all religious belief as irrational delusion, you do kinda have to see 'your set' as the only rational, thinking ones.

Doesn't make it any less pretentious, of course.

[b]Hassan[/b], the Christian understanding of other monotheistic religions (such as Judaism and Islam) is that you worship the same God we do. It's not 'our' God vs. Allah. We call the one true God...God. Muslims call him Allah. Jews perfer not to speak his name aloud.

Obviously, we are not agreed on some very key aspects of who this God is and how we relate to him. Christians do not acknowledge Mohammed as a prophet, and Muslims acknowledge Jesus as simply a prophet (not the Son of God). I have no idea what Jews think of both these younger religions, but I suspect they wish we would go away sometimes...

I am just pointing this out, not because I think it is relevant to the current discussion of atheism, but because I think it important to point out that Catholics don't think Muslims are worshipping some demon who set himself up as god or anything messed up like that.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...