Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1744872' date='Jan 6 2009, 11:56 PM']Well, if you view all religious belief as irrational delusion, you do kinda have to see 'your set' as the only rational, thinking ones.

Doesn't make it any less pretentious, of course.

[b]Hassan[/b], the Christian understanding of other monotheistic religions (such as Judaism and Islam) is that you worship the same God we do. It's not 'our' God vs. Allah. We call the one true God...God. Muslims call him Allah. Jews perfer not to speak his name aloud.

Obviously, we are not agreed on some very key aspects of who this God is and how we relate to him. Christians do not acknowledge Mohammed as a prophet, and Muslims acknowledge Jesus as simply a prophet (not the Son of God). I have no idea what Jews think of both these younger religions, but I suspect they wish we would go away sometimes...

I am just pointing this out, not because I think it is relevant to the current discussion of atheism, but because I think it important to point out that Catholics don't think Muslims are worshipping some demon who set himself up as god or anything messed up like that.[/quote]


Thank you but I am not a Muslim, the "secret Muslim" is a joke. A bit ago a few members became convinced I was secretly a Muslim pretending to be an agnostic (dominicansoul was one of them, now we are friends, get along great and it is just a joke).

I'm sorry for the confusion :)

Edited by Hassan
Ad Majorem Dei Gloriam
Posted

[quote name='Hassan' post='1744570' date='Jan 6 2009, 07:04 PM']Why does anyone listen to Dawkins outside of matters of biology? I still just don't understand that.[/quote]

I think it has to do with the philosophical statements he makes when talking about biology. People get upset with these statements and such and pay attention to him. Also, he does have a doctorate, which nowadays seems to be the only recognized grounds for authority as well as distinguishing between the "correctness" of the opinions espoused by individuals and that is another major reason why people listen to him. His philosophical doctorate lends authority to whatever he says as well as the implications he makes without saying explicitly what he means.

Example: Mr. Richard Dawkins makes the case in his book "The Selfish Gene" that genes are agents of selfishness and look to exclude other alleles/competing traits for the same characteristic. They are selfish in that they compete for their own survival at the expense of other genes. This statement is inherently philosophical in that it labels genes as agents. One of Aristotle's first principles is that all moral agents must act for a purpose. Moral can be taken to mean rational when reading Aristotle, they are interchangeable. Obviously genes are not rational and thus do not have agency in that they do not willfully act but rather have tendencies of function, i.e. are ordered/conditioned to behave in certain ways. To say that genes are where agency resides makes claims upon free will in that one is saying there is no agency but rather simple biological mechanics of a gene which determine one's actions to environmental stimuli (this point is made clear throughout the book). Thus Dr. Dawkins steps out of biology and into Ethics, Metaphysics, Philosophy, Theology, etc.

Statements like these bring him much attention for both ends of the spectrum: acclaim and notoriety. His doctorate gives him authority since there is nothing else in our society to judge things by since we have lost a common ideal of the transcendent and all that matters today seems to be the degree of specialization that one has attained in a specific as well as the memorization of "facts" rather than considering universal questions and the truths to which they speak. Since we have no transcendent/idealistic/higher standard to judge one by, all authority in modern discussions comes from knowledge of "facts" over "truths." These tendencies are why people listen to Mr. Richard Dawkins.

Oh yea and he has some money to contribute to causes that he likes and that can help get your opinion noticed. ;)

Archaeology cat
Posted

The ads have hit here.

Posted

Excerpt from a report in the NY Times:

<<As Ms. Sherine wrote in a follow-up blog post yesterday on The Guardian’s “Comment is free” blog, the response far exceeded her modest expectations:

(Emphasis mine)

.[b]... thanks to many Cif readers, the overall total raised for the Atheist Bus Campaign stands at a truly overwhelming £135,000, breaking our original target of £5,500 by over 2400%[/b]. Given this unexpected amount, I’m very excited to tell you that 800 buses – instead of the 30 we were initially aiming for – are now rolling out across the UK….>>
[i]
That's[/i] what's impressive. In a declining economy in the UK, that much being forked out for the campaign....!

Galloglasses' Alt
Posted

They'll probably never reach the North of Ireland, the Athiest community here is very small, (but unproportionally vocal), I highly doubt the ads would survive in the Two tradionts dominating here.

Posted

How did he calculate this probability?

Posted

Oh, sorry [b]Hassan,[/b] I didn't mean to assign anything to you personally. You were just the one who brought it up. I don't think I even noticed your affiliation ;). I tend to use 'you' very generically, a habit I should probably correct one of these days.

Posted

[quote name='MithLuin' post='1745689' date='Jan 7 2009, 11:33 PM']Oh, sorry [b]Hassan,[/b] I didn't mean to assign anything to you personally. You were just the one who brought it up. I don't think I even noticed your affiliation ;). I tend to use 'you' very generically, a habit I should probably correct one of these days.[/quote]


oh, lol. sorry :D

Posted

[quote name='Hilde' post='1745397' date='Jan 7 2009, 03:54 PM']How did he calculate this probability?[/quote]

He made it up...

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...