Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Nfp, Babies, And College Students


Recommended Posts

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1753480' date='Jan 16 2009, 10:23 PM']Also, if the only purpose of marriage was procreation, it wouldn't matter if you loved the person you were marrying, it wouldn't matter who you married as long as it was the opposite sex and they were willing to raise kids with you. Other things do matter and do take importance in choosing a spouse.[/quote]


Yep, and that would mean old fogies like us couldn't get married at all. The church marries older people all the time, and infertile ones (not impotent), that can't have kids. Being open to life is the requirement.

Posted

I think it needs to be known that St. Therese's parents abstained was because they were trying to live a Josephite marriage, because they believe that was the high road. They originally wanted to live in a religious life, so when they got married they abstained. Later on a priest advised them to refrain from abstaining(lol).

Also, I think that it is odd how one would say that marriage isn't JUST for pro-creation, so you can avoid it and focus on the unitive aspect, but if one were to seperate the procreative aspect from the unitive, they are seen as nothing but loveless breeders. Im not trying to be confrontational, just trying to spread a thought.

Babies are a huge responsibility, there is no question. But lots of "poor" people have children, people that still have student loans, and work at Home Depot. I know of 3 couples in this type of situation. Its hard, but its definantly doable. There are reasons for NFP, like illness, dire financial situations, or mental health of the parents. I would definantly talk to a solid priest about this, because I don't think anyone here is qualified to tell you what you should do in your situation.

I do want to add (Im not sure if you saw this in my topic) that my husband and I are currently expecting our first, with no health insurance (applying for state coverage) and no job. We didn't plan it, we also have not been able to get pregnant our whole marriage (April '07) but God chose the most inopportune time to bless us with a child. We did not expect, nor did we plan for this to happen. I also could not be happier, or more hopeful.

I hope you don't take this post as an attack, I really just want to help. :)

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1753490' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:31 PM']Yep, and that would mean old fogies like us couldn't get married at all. The church marries older people all the time, and infertile ones (not impotent), that can't have kids. Being open to life is the requirement.[/quote]

Wait, an impotent man cannot get married?

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1753518' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:57 AM']Wait, an impotent man cannot get married?[/quote]

Good point, what about people with sexual dysfunction? -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1753521' date='Jan 16 2009, 10:58 PM']Good point, what about people with sexual dysfunction? -Katie[/quote]
From what I've read, true impotence that absolutely cannot be fixed/treated to an acceptable degree is exceedingly rare and maybe nonexistent.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753523' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:00 AM']From what I've read, true impotence that absolutely cannot be fixed/treated to an acceptable degree is exceedingly rare and maybe nonexistent.[/quote]

Ok-there are other sexual disorders though (male and female) that cause painful intercourse that cannot always be cured-I'd feel bad to see someone not able to marry for something that they couldn't control. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1753529' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:04 PM']Ok-there are other sexual disorders though (male and female) that cause painful intercourse that cannot always be cured-I'd feel bad to see someone not able to marry for something that they couldn't control. -Katie[/quote]
I guess technically they could still have sexual intercourse... just wouldn't very often.
Of course I may be wrong.
The question arises though: do you really want to get married if that's the case? I dunno. I probably wouldn't. Or maybe I would. I haven't thought about it.

Posted

canon law is clear that if no consummation is possible, there can not be a marriage in the church. I had a client who was paraplegic, and he had to get a letter from his doctor that he could still consummate with assistance. They basically had their wedding night at the doctor's office. They ended up having a couple of kids that way. I didn't want a lot of the details.

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753532' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:07 AM']I guess technically they could still have sexual intercourse... just wouldn't very often.
Of course I may be wrong.
The question arises though: do you really want to get married if that's the case? I dunno. I probably wouldn't. Or maybe I would. I haven't thought about it.[/quote]

Yeah, maybe if there was enough hope of adequate treatment. I don't really know if I'd want to get married personally in that case, but I guess I just don't see it as fair to deny a couple who had worked through things and wanted more of a companionship marriage. I'll have to think about this one, I didn't know that about impotence, etc. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1753533' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:09 AM']canon law is clear that if no consummation is possible, there can not be a marriage in the church. I had a client who was paraplegic, and he had to get a letter from his doctor that he could still consummate with assistance. They basically had their wedding night at the doctor's office. They ended up having a couple of kids that way. I didn't want a lot of the details.[/quote]

It just seems so sad-paraplegia is a good example of a case where someone may be unable to have intercourse-that they have to be alone. -Katie

Posted

[quote name='Luthien' post='1753514' date='Jan 16 2009, 08:54 PM']I think it needs to be known that St. Therese's parents abstained was because they were trying to live a Josephite marriage, because they believe that was the high road. They originally wanted to live in a religious life, so when they got married they abstained. Later on a priest advised them to refrain from abstaining(lol).[/quote]

The principle still stands though... although the primary purpose of marriage is pro-creation, it isn't necessary for marriage... Josephite marriages existed.

[quote name='Luthien' post='1753514' date='Jan 16 2009, 08:54 PM']Also, I think that it is odd how one would say that marriage isn't JUST for pro-creation, so you can avoid it and focus on the unitive aspect, but if one were to seperate the procreative aspect from the unitive, they are seen as nothing but loveless breeders. Im not trying to be confrontational, just trying to spread a thought.[/quote]

I agree, which is why contraception is not okay and NFP is. Contraception avoids and even removes the pro-creative aspect, NFP allows for it. They cannot be separated which is why NFP can't even be used with a contraceptive mindset EVEN if the situation is one where NFP would be permitted.


[quote name='Luthien' post='1753514' date='Jan 16 2009, 08:54 PM']Babies are a huge responsibility, there is no question. But lots of "poor" people have children, people that still have student loans, and work at Home Depot. I know of 3 couples in this type of situation. Its hard, but its definantly doable. There are reasons for NFP, like illness, dire financial situations, or mental health of the parents. I would definantly talk to a solid priest about this, because I don't think anyone here is qualified to tell you what you should do in your situation.

I do want to add (Im not sure if you saw this in my topic) that my husband and I are currently expecting our first, with no health insurance (applying for state coverage) and no job. We didn't plan it, we also have not been able to get pregnant our whole marriage (April '07) but God chose the most inopportune time to bless us with a child. We did not expect, nor did we plan for this to happen. I also could not be happier, or more hopeful.

I hope you don't take this post as an attack, I really just want to help. :)[/quote]

I'm not at all against being "poor" and having children, and I disagree with using NFP for the purpose of getting OUT of debt. However I would think that an astronomical amount of loan money (which many college students these days are stuck with) could hinder the fiscal responsibilities of children, and therefore a decision to lessen them to a more reasonable level before the pursuit of a family begins could be acceptable. Quite honestly, I'd go right from using NFP to reach financial reasonableness, to using it to conceive. By all means I want children, but I also want fiscal responsibleness.

The question is, if it isn't fiscally responsible to conceive a child at that time, although if one arose, by necessity parents could provide, is it okay for a couple to get married and practice NFP.


I want to talk to one of the friars here on campus who is a moral theologian about my particular situation, but I also think it is an interesting topic that would promote intellectual conversation (one that I may present my seminar for theology on).

Posted

[quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1753536' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:11 PM']It just seems so sad-paraplegia is a good example of a case where someone may be unable to have intercourse-that they have to be alone. -Katie[/quote]

They don't have to be alone, they just can't get married in the church. If they can't have sex, then they can't sin by living together, and if they can have sex, they can get married. My mother has lived for over 20 years with a man without being married to him. He's on heart medicine so they "can't." Thanks so much mom for sharing.

TotusTuusMaria
Posted

[quote name='Luthien' post='1753514' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:54 AM']I think it needs to be known that St. Therese's parents abstained was because they were trying to live a Josephite marriage, because they believe that was the high road. They originally wanted to live in a religious life, so when they got married they abstained. Later on a priest advised them to refrain from abstaining(lol).

Also, I think that it is odd how one would say that marriage isn't JUST for pro-creation, so you can avoid it and focus on the unitive aspect, but if one were to seperate the procreative aspect from the unitive, they are seen as nothing but loveless breeders. Im not trying to be confrontational, just trying to spread a thought.

Babies are a huge responsibility, there is no question. But lots of "poor" people have children, people that still have student loans, and work at Home Depot. I know of 3 couples in this type of situation. Its hard, but its definantly doable. There are reasons for NFP, like illness, dire financial situations, or mental health of the parents. I would definantly talk to a solid priest about this, because I don't think anyone here is qualified to tell you what you should do in your situation.

I do want to add (Im not sure if you saw this in my topic) that my husband and I are currently expecting our first, with no health insurance (applying for state coverage) and no job. We didn't plan it, we also have not been able to get pregnant our whole marriage (April '07) but God chose the most inopportune time to bless us with a child. We did not expect, nor did we plan for this to happen. I also could not be happier, or more hopeful.

I hope you don't take this post as an attack, I really just want to help. :)[/quote]

I think this post is great.

I also want to say that I don't think St. Therese's parents actions of abstaining are to be held up as a reason why it should be ok to go into a marriage with the idea of trying to abstain. There reasons were very different, and in the end they were told they shouldn't be doing it.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1753539' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:14 AM']They don't have to be alone, they just can't get married in the church. If they can't have sex, then they can't sin by living together, and if they can have sex, they can get married. My mother has lived for over 20 years with a man without being married to him. He's on heart medicine so they "can't." Thanks so much mom for sharing.[/quote]

Yeah, I suppose I can understand that, to some extent. I've known a few older couples who lived together as companions, I suppose it could be comparable to that. I think I still feel a little sad, though, that maybe a person would still wish to be married and have that "officiality" and such. Church marriage requirements are more complex than I had thought. -Katie

Edited by Tinkerlina
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1753539' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:14 PM']They don't have to be alone, they just can't get married in the church. If they can't have sex, then they can't sin by living together, and if they can have sex, they can get married. My mother has lived for over 20 years with a man without being married to him. He's on heart medicine so they "can't." Thanks so much mom for sharing.[/quote]
Wow, that actually never occurred to me!
Is this the way lawyers think? ;) :lol_roll:

For whatever reason, this just made my day.

HisChildForever
Posted

[quote name='CatherineM' post='1753533' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:09 AM']canon law is clear that if no consummation is possible, there can not be a marriage in the church. I had a client who was paraplegic, and he had to get a letter from his doctor that he could still consummate with assistance. They basically had their wedding night at the doctor's office. They ended up having a couple of kids that way. I didn't want a lot of the details.[/quote]

So the Church refuses an impotent man to marry due to something biological that he has no control over?

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1753548' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:21 PM']So the Church refuses an impotent man to marry due to something biological that he has no control over?[/quote]
More or less.
You're looking at it from only one perspective though.
The fact is that they cannot have intercouse, therefore cannot be open to life.
Same as homosexuals, in one way of looking at it.

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' post='1753538' date='Jan 17 2009, 03:13 AM']The principle still stands though... although the primary purpose of marriage is pro-creation, it isn't necessary for marriage... Josephite marriages existed.[/quote]

I guess I was just clarifying their situation. Just think of it, if they had continued their lifestyle, St. Therese would never had been born! :o



[quote]I agree, which is why contraception is not okay and NFP is. Contraception avoids and even removes the pro-creative aspect, NFP allows for it. They cannot be separated which is why NFP can't even be used with a contraceptive mindset EVEN if the situation is one where NFP would be permitted.[/quote]

I know, I just thought I'd throw it out there.

[quote]I'm not at all against being "poor" and having children, and I disagree with using NFP for the purpose of getting OUT of debt. However I would think that an astronomical amount of loan money (which many college students these days are stuck with) could hinder the fiscal responsibilities of children, and therefore a decision to lessen them to a more reasonable level before the pursuit of a family begins could be acceptable. Quite honestly, I'd go right from using NFP to reach financial reasonableness, to using it to conceive. By all means I want children, but I also want fiscal responsibleness.

The question is, if it isn't fiscally responsible to conceive a child at that time, although if one arose, by necessity parents could provide, is it okay for a couple to get married and practice NFP.[/quote]

Get a good job, and pay off the loans piece-meal. The thing is, hundreds of thousands of dollars of loans will not be cut substatially in just 2 years. I know people who are in their mid-30's still paying off their loans. I agree with getting on your feet financially, but within reason. Loans are just a fact of life these days.


[quote]I want to talk to one of the friars here on campus who is a moral theologian about my particular situation, but I also think it is an interesting topic that would promote intellectual conversation (one that I may present my seminar for theology on).[/quote]

Yeah, I like this topic, Im just attempting to bring a slightly different viewpoint to the table. ;)

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753550' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:23 AM']More or less.
You're looking at it from only one perspective though.
The fact is that they cannot have intercouse, therefore cannot be open to life.
Same as homosexuals, in one way of looking at it.[/quote]

What if a couple were unable to procreate themselves but were very much willing to adopt? -Katie

Posted

[quote name='HisChildForever' post='1753548' date='Jan 16 2009, 09:21 PM']So the Church refuses an impotent man to marry due to something biological that he has no control over?[/quote]

To put it bluntly, yes.

If a man was in a war lets say, and a grenade took the lower half of his body off, I.E waste down... and he couldn't consummate his marriage... he can't be married.

As was said before, consummation is a necessary part of marriage. It is the completion of the sacrament. If the sacrament cannot be completed, then it does not take place. I.E they could take vows, but never consummate therefore there would always be grounds for annulment (which means the marriage hasn't happened).

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...