Nihil Obstat Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1753552' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:26 PM']What if a couple were unable to procreate themselves but were very much willing to adopt? -Katie[/quote] Maybe you'd consider what CatherineM said? That's beyond the scope of my understanding though. Can an unmarried couple who are not living in a state of sin adopt responsibly? My gut reaction would be yea, why not, but then again, gut reactions are wrong way too often for me to trust that.
CatherineM Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1753548' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:21 PM']So the Church refuses an impotent man to marry due to something biological that he has no control over?[/quote] Yeah. There was a well publicized case in Brazil a year or so ago. A lot of times, priests just don't ask, but this guy was in a wheelchair, so the priest asked, and once he found out, he couldn't validly marry them. There was a lot of protest about it.
MithLuin Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 (edited) It is true that impotence is considered an impediment to marriage. But somehow I don't think that was the purpose of this thread. This thread was to ask if a couple can use NFP to attempt to postpone having a child for two years while loans are paid off. And the answer is yes, with the caveat that of course you might have a child anyway, and you have to enter into marriage knowing that is a possibility. Two years is an awful lot of abstaining, and you would both have to be willing to make that sacrifice. Here's what the Catechism has to say on the subject: [indent]2366 Fecundity is a gift, an end of marriage, for conjugal love naturally tends to be fruitful. A child does not come from outside as something added on to the mutual love of the spouses, but springs from the very heart of that mutual giving, as its fruit and fulfillment. So the Church, which is "on the side of life," teaches that "it is necessary that each and every marriage act remain ordered per se to the procreation of human life." "This particular doctrine, expounded on numerous occasions by the Magisterium, is based on the inseparable connection, established by God, which man on his own initiative may not break, between the unitive significance and the procreative significance which are both inherent to the marriage act." 2367 Called to give life, spouses share in the creative power and fatherhood of God. "Married couples should regard it as their proper mission to transmit human life and to educate their children; they should realize that they are thereby cooperating with the love of God the Creator and are, in a certain sense, its interpreters. They will fulfill this duty with a sense of human and Christian responsibility." 2368 A particular aspect of this responsibility concerns the regulation of procreation. For just reasons, spouses may wish to space the births of their children. It is their duty to make certain that their desire is not motivated by selfishness but is in conformity with the generosity appropriate to responsible parenthood. Moreover, they should conform their behavior to the objective criteria of morality: [quote]When it is a question of harmonizing married love with the responsible transmission of life, the morality of the behavior does not depend on sincere intention and evaluation of motives alone; but it must be determined by objective criteria, criteria drawn from the nature of the person and his acts criteria that respect the total meaning of mutual self-giving and human procreation in the context of true love; this is possible only if the virtue of married chastity is practiced with sincerity of heart.[/quote] 2369 "By safeguarding both these essential aspects, the unitive and the procreative, the conjugal act preserves in its fullness the sense of true mutual love and its orientation toward man's exalted vocation to parenthood." 2370 Periodic continence, that is, the methods of birth regulation based on self-observation and the use of infertile periods, is in conformity with the objective criteria of morality. These methods respect the bodies of the spouses, encourage tenderness between them, and favor the education of an authentic freedom. In contrast, "every action which, whether in anticipation of the conjugal act, or in its accomplishment, or in the development of its natural consequences, proposes, whether as an end or as a means, to render procreation impossible" is intrinsically evil: [quote]Thus the innate language that expresses the total reciprocal self-giving of husband and wife is overlaid, through contraception, by an objectively contradictory language, namely, that of not giving oneself totally to the other. This leads not only to a positive refusal to be open to life but also to a falsification of the inner truth of conjugal love, which is called upon to give itself in personal totality. . . . The difference, both anthropological and moral, between contraception and recourse to the rhythm of the cycle . . . involves in the final analysis two irreconcilable concepts of the human person and of human sexuality.[/quote] 2371 "Let all be convinced that human life and the duty of transmitting it are not limited by the horizons of this life only: their true evaluation and full significance can be understood only in reference to man's eternal destiny." [/indent] Basically, it's important to keep in mind that the relationship of marriage is meant to be a symbol or sign of the relationship between Jesus and the Church. Just as Jesus brings new life to his Bride, a marriage brings new life into the world. Edited January 17, 2009 by MithLuin
Tinkerlina Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753554' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:27 AM']Maybe you'd consider what CatherineM said? That's beyond the scope of my understanding though. Can an unmarried couple who are not living in a state of sin adopt responsibly? My gut reaction would be yea, why not, but then again, gut reactions are wrong way too often for me to trust that.[/quote] Yeah, this is very confusing. -Katie
havok579257 Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 Don't listen to anyone who says if your not financially ready for a kid, don't get married. That is some of the worst advice ever. If God calls you to be with that person, then marry them. Denying God's plan for you to save up more money is still rejection of God's will. Me and my wife got married when I was still in school. We lived off of a her salary, a teachers salary for over a year. We has lots of debt when school was finally over and we had to tighten out belts during that year. Although Never once did it ever cross my mind to finish school and become better financially set before marrying my sole mate. God wanted me to marry her and I trust him to know whats best for me. God didn't want me to wait a year or two to get my finances in check, he wanted me to marry her and follow HIS plan for me. Also any marriage could always end up the "Walk to Remeber movie" way. Your spouse could die with in a year of marriage. How foolish will it have been then to look at yourself and say, it was so worth it to put off the wedding because that 1 or 2 or 5 years of marriage I could of had is now gone forever, but that's ok because I am financially set now to have a kid. What's more important, God's way and the love of your life or money. Go, marry and I wish you a long and happy time together.
Nihil Obstat Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1753558' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:29 PM']Yeah, this is very confusing. -Katie[/quote] Aren't you glad we've got a Magisterium to help us along? I know I am. I'd be a relativistic prick without the Church's teachings.
HisChildForever Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753550' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:23 AM']More or less. You're looking at it from only one perspective though. The fact is that they cannot have intercouse, therefore cannot be open to life. Same as homosexuals, in one way of looking at it.[/quote] I would not use the homosexual argument, especially since many people believe that homosexuality is not just genetics but environment as well (i.e. not [purely] biological). Also, homosexual attraction is not natural, whereas hetereosexual attraction is. A homosexual CAN get married - just not to the same sex. So a homosexual can get married, but an impotent person can not. This just sounds wrong. [quote name='Slappo' post='1753553' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:26 AM']To put it bluntly, yes. If a man was in a war lets say, and a grenade took the lower half of his body off, I.E waste down... and he couldn't consummate his marriage... he can't be married. As was said before, consummation is a necessary part of marriage. It is the completion of the sacrament. If the sacrament cannot be completed, then it does not take place. I.E they could take vows, but never consummate therefore there would always be grounds for annulment (which means the marriage hasn't happened).[/quote] This is incredibly sad, that because of something they have no control over, they are denied the love of a spouse. Procreation is important but marriage is not just about reproduction. Edited January 17, 2009 by HisChildForever
Tinkerlina Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753563' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:32 AM']Aren't you glad we've got a Magisterium to help us along? I know I am. I'd be a relativistic prick without the Church's teachings.[/quote] Yeah but to be honest sometimes it's hard for me to tell the difference between relativism and conscience. -Katie
Nihil Obstat Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 (edited) [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1753564' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:32 PM']I would not use the homosexual argument, especially since many people believe that homosexuality is not just genetics but environment as well (i.e. not [purely] biological). Also, homosexual attraction is not natural, whereas hetereosexual attraction is. A homosexual CAN get married - just not to the same sex. So a homosexual can get married, but an impotent person can not. This just sounds wrong.[/quote] Fair enough. It wasn't my best analogy. It's been explained better than I could though. [quote]This is incredibly sad, that because of something they have no control over, they are denied the love of a spouse. Procreation is important but marriage is not just about reproduction.[/quote] I'll say again: read what CatherineM said. Keep in mind: while procreation is indeed not the only thing, it is absolutely necessary. That's like saying "being Catholic isn't the only thing necessary to recieve communion at mass." Well yea, that's technically true, but you still can't recieve if you aren't Catholic. There, better analogy? EDIT: To clarify, when I say absolutely necessary, I of course mean the marriage has to be open to life. Just so nobody misunderstands what I meant. Edited January 17, 2009 by Nihil Obstat
Nihil Obstat Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Tinkerlina' post='1753565' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:32 PM']Yeah but to be honest sometimes it's hard for me to tell the difference between relativism and conscience. -Katie[/quote] OMGoodness, me too! My hope is that eventually my wildly innacurate and unreliable conscience will be so innundated with the Church that I won't have to worry anymore.
CatherineM Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 This whole area of when NFP can licitly be used and the reproductive issues, the marriage issues, all fall under moral theology. Very fascinating, and infuriating subject at times. The recent Vatican document on BioEthics took them a long time to formulate, and if anything increased the debate rather than settle it. When it comes to these issues, talk to your priest. He's the one who is going to guide you through the process of getting ready for marriage.
Luthien Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='CatherineM' post='1753573' date='Jan 17 2009, 03:37 AM']This whole area of when NFP can licitly be used and the reproductive issues, the marriage issues, all fall under moral theology. Very fascinating, and infuriating subject at times. The recent Vatican document on BioEthics took them a long time to formulate, and if anything increased the debate rather than settle it. When it comes to these issues, talk to your priest. He's the one who is going to guide you through the process of getting ready for marriage.[/quote] Haha, what she said.
Tinkerlina Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753572' date='Jan 17 2009, 01:36 AM']OMGoodness, me too! My hope is that eventually my wildly innacurate and unreliable conscience will be so innundated with the Church that I won't have to worry anymore.[/quote] Yeah, maybe I'll get there someday... I don't know, though, it's harder for me when the situation is about someone else (even hypothetically). I feel like I can judge myself and what I would/should do in a situation but not someone else. I don't know, though, I honestly don't know any persons with physical disabilities (of a childbearing age, I do have a little cousin) who I could talk to about this. And if I did, you'd better believe I would ask them because my quest for solving all of my conscience/Church conundrums is shameless. -Katie
HisChildForever Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1753570' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:35 AM']I'll say again: read what CatherineM said. Keep in mind: while procreation is indeed not the only thing, it is absolutely necessary. That's like saying "being Catholic isn't the only thing necessary to recieve communion at mass." Well yea, that's technically true, but you still can't recieve if you aren't Catholic. There, better analogy? EDIT: To clarify, when I say absolutely necessary, I of course mean the marriage has to be open to life. Just so nobody misunderstands what I meant.[/quote] It can't be this simple. For example, a couple can claim they are open to life but use NFP as a way to avoid conception [i]and[/i] grave sin - in other words, "cheating the system" (perhaps without realizing that their selfish mentality is sinful). Therefore, being open to life is not exclusively about natural intercourse. It's a mentality, a belief. An impotent man can be very much be open to life, the problem is that he physically can't give life (or himself).
MithLuin Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 (edited) Being impotent = cannot have sex. Being infertile = cannot have babies. The inability to reproduce is not what hinders an impotent person from getting married. The Church will happily marry two 70 year olds, who really aren't going to be having any children together! Marriage is about procreation and unity. If you cannot consummate the marriage (even once), then you do not [i]have[/i] a marriage. You are welcome to find a companion to share your time/house/life with, but you are not able to marry that person in the Church. You [i]are[/i] welcome to develop a very intimate friendship with that person, and you are not considered to be 'living in sin' - there's clearly no sin involved, after all. I agree it's sad, but the difficult/frustrating part is the physical condition itself. It is very sad that that person cannot get married...but 'pretending' to be married wouldn't really change anything. [b]havok[/b], I agree that marriage should not be postponed for those reasons. I don't recall the OP mentioning that he and his girlfriend were engaged, though, so there may be other reasons for them not to rush into the situation. Right now, the potential wedding date is years down the road, so they have time to work things out. Edited January 17, 2009 by MithLuin
HisChildForever Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1753586' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:47 AM']Being impotent = cannot have sex.[/quote] Which is what we are discussing, yes. I am not confused over the definitions. [quote]You are welcome to find a companion to share your time/house/life with, but you are not able to marry that person in the Church. You [i]are[/i] welcome to develop a very intimate friendship with that person, and you are not considered to be 'living in sin' - there's clearly no sin involved, after all.[/quote] How is it not living in sin? The man and the woman may not be sexual, but this is cause for scandal (as I am sure the man is not broadcasting his impotency) - two unmarried people living together.
MithLuin Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 I suppose in that situation they could get a state marriage license, if they wanted to avoid scandal? I'm pretty sure the gov't doesn't care whether or not you consummate your marriage.....
Slappo Posted January 17, 2009 Author Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1753586' date='Jan 16 2009, 09:47 PM'][b]havok[/b], I agree that marriage should not be postponed for those reasons. I don't recall the OP mentioning that he and his girlfriend were engaged, though, so there may be other reasons for them not to rush into the situation. Right now, the potential wedding date is years down the road, so they have time to work things out.[/quote] Earliest possible date would be summer 2010 . Earliest possible engagement would be this coming summer though, and neither of us want a long engagement. I'll probably try to schedule a time to meet with a priest in a week or two to run the idea's around him and see what I can work out for myself. In general though, I think it's a very interesting topic. I love moral theology.
CatherineM Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='MithLuin' post='1753601' date='Jan 16 2009, 11:57 PM']I'm pretty sure the gov't doesn't care whether or not you consummate your marriage.....[/quote] Unless you are applying for Canadian Immigration, then they practically want pictures.
philothea Posted January 17, 2009 Posted January 17, 2009 [quote name='HisChildForever' post='1753591' date='Jan 17 2009, 12:52 AM']How is it not living in sin? The man and the woman may not be sexual, but this is cause for scandal (as I am sure the man is not broadcasting his impotency) - two unmarried people living together.[/quote] This was discussed elsewhere recently. As long as all the parts are there, and the couple has the desire to someday consummate the marriage, I believe the ceremony can be performed. Until the marriage is consummated (and the requirement for this is -- without going into great detail -- very easily achieved) it's not valid. But then, like Catherine said, if it's not consummated, nobody is doing anything wrong and it doesn't matter.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now