Guest Posted February 22, 2009 Posted February 22, 2009 (edited) [quote name='nunsense' post='1788003' date='Feb 22 2009, 04:20 AM']I understand that you are sharing in Christ's suffering, and that is a beautiful thing. For us to embrace the Cross is truly loving Jesus. But to allow your heart to fill with hate for anyone or anything actually dishonors Jesus in a way - because His whole message was one of love. That is not to say that you have to love Satan - absolutely not. But even St Michael would not rebuke him - that is why in the prayer to St Michael we ask God to rebuke Satan - so, if it isn't appropriate for St Michael to do it - it certainly is not appropriate for us to do it either. We can ask that God thrust him into hell along with all his evil spirits, but we mustn't carry hate in our hearts towards him (and thus do him honor). Any time we use one of Satan's weapons, we are honoring him - that is why lying is so bad - he is the Prince of Lies, whereas Our Lord Jesus is the Truth Incarnate. Every lie honors Satan, every act of hatred honors him. As disciples of Jesus, we honor Our Lord through loving obedience to His Will. You are right in that love is expressed in many ways. Once I asked a priest how I could love my neighbors, when the man was a convicted child molester (recently released from prison) and his "wife" was a bigamist. The priest told me that compassion is also a form of love, and certainly I should have compassion for such people. This helped me a lot. So I am not saying that any of us should feel any love towards Satan - but neither should we allow ourselve to be consumed by hatred either. Jesus is God. He knew what He was doing when He created the universe, and Satan, and us, and allowed free will in his creatures. He also knew what He was doing whan He offered Himself as a sacrifical lamb for our salvation. His Cross was His greatest triumph, and through it, He has given meaning to all mankind's sufferings. Should we feel pain at His suffering? Yes. Should we excuse our own sins by blaming Satan? No. We are sinners in our hearts, but are saved sinners, through Our Lord. And He did this through His suffering and His Cross. Feel His pain, but also rejoice at His triumph over death and Satan![/quote] Thanks for that reply. It was helpfull. Godbless Edited February 22, 2009 by Guest
kafka Posted February 22, 2009 Posted February 22, 2009 (edited) First off read this: "When the angels were first created, they did not have the Beatific Vision. They had a dwelling place in the heavens, but it was not the Heaven in Eternity with the Beatific Vision. For anyone who has the Beatific Vision cannot sin or fall from grace; and we know that many angels did fall. Then God tested the angels, to see if they were worthy of Heaven, for no one can enter heaven except through the Son of God. So they were shown Jesus Christ, the Son of God, on the Cross, suffering and weak and humiliated. And they were told to worship Him. Most obeyed, accepting this command out of faith and love and hope, not fully understanding its meaning. But many angels turned away from God because they refused to worship someone who was seemingly less then themselves. The reason that some angels refused to worship God-made-man is that human nature includes a physical part (the body), making human beings inferior to the angels, who are pure spirit. This refusal to worship Christ came from pride: so pride goes before a fall. They relied on their high intellect, which could not fully understand this mystery, rather than relying on grace and faith. Their pride in their own power caused them to reject Jesus Christ in his humility. So these angels forever lost the grace of God, becoming fallen angels (also called devils or demons). Then they were barred by God from the Heaven of Eternity and the Beatific Vision. But they were allowed for a time to roam the heavens and the earth. (When Scripture describes fallen angels as being in heaven, it means the heavens and the spiritual realm in general, but not the Heaven which is in Eternity and which includes the Beatific Vision of God.)" {8:6} You reduced him to a little less than the Angels; you have crowned him with glory and honor, The reason the fallen angels could not repent after they had rejected Christ and the gift of grace is that they are pure spiritual beings. They grasp truth clearly and purely unlike men who grasp truth through symbols, in a shadow type way. Therefore once the angels made their choice it was forever, unlike humans who (thankfully) have the choice many times in their lives to choose Christ and grace and repentance, and a new life, and accept the merciful covenant God offers to men. And only at the moment of our deaths, is our final choice forever. As Rahner taught, "Death is Judgment." God hates Satan (meaning adversary) and the fallen angels because of what they have done just as God in a sense hates the unjust for what they have done even though in their fundamental being angels and men are created in God's image and likeness. Therefore it is o.k. to hate the fallen angels, and hate the unjust, in so far one hates them because of their evil deeds. Just as it is o.k. to hate the sins of ones own past yet it is not o.k. to hate one's own self. This all being said I find it erroneous for Catholics to place to much weight on the temptations of Satan and the fallen angels. There is an aspect of Christ being crucified because of Satan and the fallen angels yet this is secondary, to the true reason of the Cross. Notice Christ in the desert easily defeated the temptations of Satan, even before his public ministry and His Passion and Death. It is us, and our sinfullness that Christ died on the Cross for. It primarily had nothing to do with Satan and the fallen angels, for they were already lost. Yet we were not and Christ, by His death merited for us salvific grace, which transcends our falleness. God permits the fallen angels to tempt us only on occasion. I repeat only on occasion. For our real battle is concupiscience (the remants of original sin), and the influences of the fallen-sinful world. Christ is the King. Christ has "sent forth His Spirit" and is renewing the face of the earth, in spite of the fact that He permits fallen angels to still roam the earth and tempt men (only) on occasion. And that occasion is for His and our greater glory. Amen. Praise and glory be to Jesus Christ, Who is meek, mild, bold and powerful. Who is renown, and shall be renown, The King of all. Now and even forever! Edited February 22, 2009 by kafka
Guest Posted February 22, 2009 Posted February 22, 2009 (edited) Ok thank you for that bro as it was a very good read. It made sence to so again thank you. I think I agree with everything you said except for the part about why Christ died. I understand that he died because of our fall and our seperation from God through adam and eve. But here's my thing, if it wasn't for satan we wouldn't of fell correct ? God had to know that satan would be able to decieve us. Satan was an angel that was closest to God so surely this wouldn't be much of a task. Sorta like me being able to trick a 5 year old day after day into getting into my car. Now I am not saying that makes me angry at God in any sort of way because we still did have free will and adam and eve could of chose to listen to God and not give in to satan. That is why I have so much hatred for satan. Because if it wasn't for satan adam and eve wouldn't have fell. And then Jesus wouldn't have had to do what He did for us. I mean I know Jesus chose to but things that stick out to me are him bleeding sweat, him asking God if were possible for him not to have to go through with this, him hanging on the cross asking "God why have you forsaken me? " So often times I am troubled when people make it seem like this was something Jesus was looking forward to doing or something. I mean I know he chose to and I dont know how He did. (other then He's God) But still if it wasn't for satan hating God there would have been no fall for us. (at least i think not mabey im wrong) Edited February 22, 2009 by Guest
kafka Posted February 22, 2009 Posted February 22, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1788059' date='Feb 22 2009, 04:50 AM']Ok thank you for that bro as it was a very good read. It made sence to so again thank you. I think I agree with everything you said except for the part about why Christ died. I understand that he died because of our fall and our seperation from God through adam and eve. But here's my thing, if it wasn't for satan we wouldn't of fell correct ? God had to know that satan would be able to decieve us. Satan was an angel that was closest to God so surely this wouldn't be much of a task. Sorta like me being able to trick a 5 year old day after day into getting into my car. Now I am not saying that makes me angry at God in any sort of way because we still did have free will and adam and eve could of chose to listen to God and not give in to satan. That is why I have so much hatred for satan. Because if it wasn't for satan adam and eve wouldn't have fell. And then Jesus wouldn't have had to do what He did for us. I mean I know Jesus chose to but things that stick out to me are him bleeding sweat, him asking God if were possible for him not to have to go through with this, him hanging on the cross asking "God why have you forsaken me. " So often times I am troubled when people make it seem like this was something Jesus was looking forward to doing.[/quote] First off. Satan was not closest to God. He was not the greatest of all angels. Not even close, not at all. That is a false and naive idea based on a verse of Isaiah whom the ancients saw the planet Venus as a symbol of Satan (I hope to write a blog on this later this week). Satan rejected God before He could even become close to God in the Beautific Vision. As opposed to Saint Michael who accepted Jesus Christ and become the greatest of all the holy angels seeing God face to face in Heaven, and is assigned some of the greatest tasks ever, in salvation history (past, present and future). Satan was not primarly instrumental in Adam and Eve's fall. You have to get that out of your mind. Adam and Eve were in communion with God. They knew better. As you said they chose freely. They were tested, as God desires to test everyone's love, and to see if they are silver tested by fire as the Psalm reveals: {11:7} The eloquence of the Lord is pure eloquence, silver tested by fire, purged from the earth, refined seven times. There is a theological theory that the Son of God would still have Incarnated Himself even if the fall would not have occured. Perhaps He still would have died somehow in pure love of the Father in order to manifest to all of creation the truth of what it means to participate in the life of the Holy Trinity. You must concede that some of the things we are discussing here are mysteries. And I dare say even in Heaven we shall not fully fathom them. Yet slowly we will come to understand them even deeper and deeper for all eternity. Edited February 22, 2009 by kafka
Guest Posted February 22, 2009 Posted February 22, 2009 Good good stuff. thank you for your time. I again want to state i am in no way angry at God. I love God, He gave us life, He died for us. I always thought satan was Gods closest angel. I dont know where I got that from. I also thought it was mostly satans fault for the fall of mankind. Although your perspective makes sence. Alright dude time to pass out. Godbless !
Nunsense Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='kafka' post='1788041' date='Feb 22 2009, 02:19 AM']First off read this: "When the angels were first created, they did not have the Beatific Vision. They had a dwelling place in the heavens, but it was not the Heaven in Eternity with the Beatific Vision. For anyone who has the Beatific Vision cannot sin or fall from grace; and we know that many angels did fall. Then God tested the angels, to see if they were worthy of Heaven, for no one can enter heaven except through the Son of God. So they were shown Jesus Christ, the Son of God, on the Cross, suffering and weak and humiliated. And they were told to worship Him. Most obeyed, accepting this command out of faith and love and hope, not fully understanding its meaning. But many angels turned away from God because they refused to worship someone who was seemingly less then themselves. The reason that some angels refused to worship God-made-man is that human nature includes a physical part (the body), making human beings inferior to the angels, who are pure spirit. This refusal to worship Christ came from pride: so pride goes before a fall. They relied on their high intellect, which could not fully understand this mystery, rather than relying on grace and faith. Their pride in their own power caused them to reject Jesus Christ in his humility. So these angels forever lost the grace of God, becoming fallen angels (also called devils or demons). Then they were barred by God from the Heaven of Eternity and the Beatific Vision. But they were allowed for a time to roam the heavens and the earth. (When Scripture describes fallen angels as being in heaven, it means the heavens and the spiritual realm in general, but not the Heaven which is in Eternity and which includes the Beatific Vision of God.)" {8:6} You reduced him to a little less than the Angels; you have crowned him with glory and honor, The reason the fallen angels could not repent after they had rejected Christ and the gift of grace is that they are pure spiritual beings. They grasp truth clearly and purely unlike men who grasp truth through symbols, in a shadow type way. Therefore once the angels made their choice it was forever, unlike humans who (thankfully) have the choice many times in their lives to choose Christ and grace and repentance, and a new life, and accept the merciful covenant God offers to men. And only at the moment of our deaths, is our final choice forever. As Rahner taught, "Death is Judgment." God hates Satan (meaning adversary) and the fallen angels because of what they have done just as God in a sense hates the unjust for what they have done even though in their fundamental being angels and men are created in God's image and likeness. Therefore it is o.k. to hate the fallen angels, and hate the unjust, in so far one hates them because of their evil deeds. Just as it is o.k. to hate the sins of ones own past yet it is not o.k. to hate one's own self. This all being said I find it erroneous for Catholics to place to much weight on the temptations of Satan and the fallen angels. There is an aspect of Christ being crucified because of Satan and the fallen angels yet this is secondary, to the true reason of the Cross. Notice Christ in the desert easily defeated the temptations of Satan, even before his public ministry and His Passion and Death. It is us, and our sinfullness that Christ died on the Cross for. It primarily had nothing to do with Satan and the fallen angels, for they were already lost. Yet we were not and Christ, by His death merited for us salvific grace, which transcends our falleness. God permits the fallen angels to tempt us only on occasion. I repeat only on occasion. For our real battle is concupiscience (the remants of original sin), and the influences of the fallen-sinful world. Christ is the King. Christ has "sent forth His Spirit" and is renewing the face of the earth, in spite of the fact that He permits fallen angels to still roam the earth and tempt men (only) on occasion. And that occasion is for His and our greater glory. Amen. Praise and glory be to Jesus Christ, Who is meek, mild, bold and powerful. Who is renown, and shall be renown, The King of all. Now and even forever![/quote] This was great - thank you. There is still one point that I would like to clarify however, and that is the difference between hating the sin and the sinner. I would be hesitant to say, as you did, that God hates Satan. I found this on another forum (emphasis is mine)... [i]Satan is not sin. Satan is a fallen angel who chose to turn away from God. When God created the angels, he created them good and gave them the free will to choose to love him or to choose to turn away from him. Because of their purely spiritual natures and their greater intellect, the choice of the angels was one irrevocable choice for God or for self. The fallen angels chose self. [b]While God loves every being he has created[/b], he will not force his love on anyone and will allow them to choose against him. Michelle Arnold, Apologist Catholic Answers[/i] and [i]To love the good is to hate its opposite: evil. To the degree that there is good in Satan, it is possible to love that. Metaphysically he has goodness. [b]His act of existing shows forth God’s goodness as does all that exists[/b]. [u]But that which is evil about him we must hate[/u]. It is of great importance that we understand this. [b]We must love the sinner, but hate the sin[/b]. To love the sin would be the worst thing that we can do for the sinner. Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.[/i] The reason I like to clarify this is to make sure that we are not filling our hearts with a personal form of hatred. To hate sin is good but to put our focus on Satan is to take it away from God, so even spending time hating him (or other evil spirits) is counter-productive to our souls. I agree with you though kafka, that Satan was not the reason for Christ's suffering and death. Although Satan tempted Eve, she chose, of her own free will, to disobey God, just as Satan chose to defy Him. God allows Satan to tempt us to test us and strengthen us, but He does this out of love, and if we obey Him, we will not be tested beyond our strength, we will only grow in faith and love. We are responsible for our own actions and we are responsible for Christ's sacrifice - He didn't die to save Satan, who was beyond redemption, He died to save mankind from its sins. We are the cause of His death, but we are also the beneficiaries of His total act of self-giving. We are truly blessed and loved beyond our ability to comprehend.
Guest Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 (edited) [quote name='nunsense' post='1789025' date='Feb 23 2009, 12:30 AM']This was great - thank you. There is still one point that I would like to clarify however, and that is the difference between hating the sin and the sinner. I would be hesitant to say, as you did, that God hates Satan. I found this on another forum (emphasis is mine)... [i]Satan is not sin. Satan is a fallen angel who chose to turn away from God. When God created the angels, he created them good and gave them the free will to choose to love him or to choose to turn away from him. Because of their purely spiritual natures and their greater intellect, the choice of the angels was one irrevocable choice for God or for self. The fallen angels chose self. [b]While God loves every being he has created[/b], he will not force his love on anyone and will allow them to choose against him. Michelle Arnold, Apologist Catholic Answers[/i] and [i]To love the good is to hate its opposite: evil. To the degree that there is good in Satan, it is possible to love that. Metaphysically he has goodness. [b]His act of existing shows forth God’s goodness as does all that exists[/b]. [u]But that which is evil about him we must hate[/u]. It is of great importance that we understand this. [b]We must love the sinner, but hate the sin[/b]. To love the sin would be the worst thing that we can do for the sinner. Fr. Vincent Serpa, O.P.[/i] The reason I like to clarify this is to make sure that we are not filling our hearts with a personal form of hatred. To hate sin is good but to put our focus on Satan is to take it away from God, so even spending time hating him (or other evil spirits) is counter-productive to our souls. I agree with you though kafka, that Satan was not the reason for Christ's suffering and death. Although Satan tempted Eve, she chose, of her own free will, to disobey God, just as Satan chose to defy Him. God allows Satan to tempt us to test us and strengthen us, but He does this out of love, and if we obey Him, we will not be tested beyond our strength, we will only grow in faith and love. We are responsible for our own actions and we are responsible for Christ's sacrifice - He didn't die to save Satan, who was beyond redemption, He died to save mankind from its sins. We are the cause of His death, but we are also the beneficiaries of His total act of self-giving. We are truly blessed and loved beyond our ability to comprehend.[/quote] I just dont agree with the part where you say we should try to love the good in satan. What good is there in satan ? If the Bible is true and I am to believe it I see no good in satan. Satan knew what would happen if he tempted adam and eve. Look at the world we live in. People are starving, people are murdered brutally everyday, and on top of that Christ was beaten on a cross because of the fall of mankind which came from satan. Satan hated us or he wouldn't have introduced death into the world. Yes adam and even disobeyed but it was a result of a temptation by satan. If satan never would of did what he did then he would have never been there to tempt us. I see no love in him and therefore find it impossible to love the good in him. Edited February 23, 2009 by Guest
kafka Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 I see what you are getting at nunsense, yet here is a more balanced view: Hate is used in different ways in the Bible. Yet here we are talking about a hate which stems from God hating the evil of sin. Now God loves sinners because human nature and angelic nature as created by God is inherently good; it is a reflection of God himself. God can no more hate human nature and angelic nature than he can hate himself. Still, God hates sinners in that He hates sin. If someone has abandoned good and embraced evil (like the fallen angels and sinners who die in final unrepentance), it can truly be said, in a limited sense, that God hates those persons, since they have chosen to live evil, despite having a good nature. It is a refined and balanced way at seeing things. All acts proceed from personhood (the very root and origin of our beings) therefore acts are in a sense connected to who and what we are. Consider these verses of the Psalms which is Christ speaking to us: {138:19} O God, if only you would cut down sinners. You men of blood: depart from me. {138:20} For you say in thought: They will accept your cities in vain. {138:21} [b]Have I not hated those who hated you, Lord, and wasted away because of your enemies?[/b] {138:22} [b]I have hated them with a perfect hatred, and they have become enemies to me.[/b] {138:23} Examine me, O God, and know my heart. Question me, and know my paths. {138:24} And see if there might be in me the way of iniquity, and lead me in the way of eternity.
Nunsense Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='kafka' post='1789076' date='Feb 22 2009, 10:01 PM']I see what you are getting at nunsense, yet here is a more balanced view: Hate is used in different ways in the Bible. Yet here we are talking about a hate which stems from God hating the evil of sin. Now God loves sinners because human nature and angelic nature as created by God is inherently good; it is a reflection of God himself. God can no more hate human nature and angelic nature than he can hate himself. Still, God hates sinners in that He hates sin. If someone has abandoned good and embraced evil (like the fallen angels and sinners who die in final unrepentance), it can truly be said, in a limited sense, that God hates those persons, since they have chosen to live evil, despite having a good nature. It is a refined and balanced way at seeing things. All acts proceed from personhood (the very root and origin of our beings) therefore acts are in a sense connected to who and what we are. Consider these verses of the Psalms which is Christ speaking to us: {138:19} O God, if only you would cut down sinners. You men of blood: depart from me. {138:20} For you say in thought: They will accept your cities in vain. {138:21} [b]Have I not hated those who hated you, Lord, and wasted away because of your enemies?[/b] {138:22} [b]I have hated them with a perfect hatred, and they have become enemies to me.[/b] {138:23} Examine me, O God, and know my heart. Question me, and know my paths. {138:24} And see if there might be in me the way of iniquity, and lead me in the way of eternity.[/quote] kafka - Thank you. I would like to see more quotes from the New Testament in Our Lord's reported words, but I do get your point. My slant here though is that we need to focus on our love for God, not on any hatred for Satan. Not only did St Michael refuse to rebuke Satan, but we are also told that only God has the right to judge - not us. St John the Apostle says [i]"This is what we have heard from him and are declaring to you: God is light, and there is no darkness in him at all. "[/i] If God does hate (you say: "Yet here we are talking about a hate which stems from God hating the evil of sin."), then He does it in a way that we can't do, because in Him there is no darkness, whereas hatred in us is very dark indeed. You say your way is more balanced, but to me, I think sometimes that Jesus' words are not taken literally enough (as unbalanced as this might seem)... Jesus said, [i]"You have heard that it was said, `You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.' But I say to you, [b]love your enemies[/b], bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who spitefully use you and persecute you, that you may be sons of your Father in heaven; for [u]He makes His sun to rise on the evil [/u]and on the good, and [u]sends rain on the just and on the unjust[/u]. For if you love those who love you, what reward have you? Do not even the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet your brethren only, what do you do more than others? Do not even the tax collectors do so? Therefore you shall be perfect, just as your Father in heaven is perfect"[/i] (Matthew 5:43-48). So how can we follow Our Lord's teachings if we are spending our time hating, even Satan? When Jesus was with the Apostle's before His Passion, he told them that Satan was coming but He also said, [i]"I shall not talk to you much longer, because the prince of this world is on his way. [b]He has no power over me, but the world must recognise that I love the Father [/b]and that I act just as the Father commanded. Come now, let us go. "[/i] (John:14:30-31) He didn't focus on Satan or express any hatred towards him, he was more intent on letting everyone know that He loved the Father! This is my model, as much as is possible for me.
kafka Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='nunsense' post='1789133' date='Feb 23 2009, 01:01 AM']kafka - Thank you. I would like to see more quotes from the New Testament in Our Lord's reported words, but I do get your point. My slant here though is that we need to focus on our love for God, not on any hatred for Satan. Not only did St Michael refuse to rebuke Satan, but we are also told that only God has the right to judge - not us. St John the Apostle says [i]"This is what we have heard from him and are declaring to you: God is light, and there is no darkness in him at all. "[/i] If God does hate (you say: "Yet here we are talking about a hate which stems from God hating the evil of sin."), then He does it in a way that we can't do, because in Him there is no darkness, whereas hatred in us is very dark indeed. You say your way is more balanced, but to me, I think sometimes that Jesus' words are not taken literally enough (as unbalanced as this might seem)... Jesus said, [i]"You have heard that it was said, `You shall love your neighbor and hate your enemy.' But I say to you, [b]love your enemies[/b], bless those who curse you, do good to those who hate you, and pray for those who spitefully use you and persecute you, that you may be sons of your Father in heaven; for [u]He makes His sun to rise on the evil [/u]and on the good, and [u]sends rain on the just and on the unjust[/u]. For if you love those who love you, what reward have you? Do not even the tax collectors do the same? And if you greet your brethren only, what do you do more than others? Do not even the tax collectors do so? Therefore you shall be perfect, just as your Father in heaven is perfect"[/i] (Matthew 5:43-48). So how can we follow Our Lord's teachings if we are spending our time hating, even Satan? When Jesus was with the Apostle's before His Passion, he told them that Satan was coming but He also said, [i]"I shall not talk to you much longer, because the prince of this world is on his way. [b]He has no power over me, but the world must recognise that I love the Father [/b]and that I act just as the Father commanded. Come now, let us go. "[/i] (John:14:30-31) He didn't focus on Satan or express any hatred towards him, he was more intent on letting everyone know that He loved the Father! This is my model, as much as is possible for me.[/quote] You make good points. I agree with your slant. My point was to show that both you and Delivery Boy are expressing truth in differnt ends of the spectrum. Here when I am speaking about hating like God it is directed toward fallen angels and damned men who can no longer repent, who have made their final choice and not towards our fellow living men and ourselves who are all sinners. Personally I dont spend anytime hating fallen angels and damned men or even thinking about them, yet there is a latent aspect where it is just to hate them, and that is where I think Delivery Boy was coming from. God is the Judge, yet the just will share in His judgment at the General Judgment even judging the fallen angels. So there is that other aspect, but I agree with you, we shouldnt focus on it at all. We have enough on our plates
Guest Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='kafka' post='1789155' date='Feb 23 2009, 02:34 AM']yet there is a latent aspect where it is just to hate them, and that is where I think Delivery Boy was coming from.[/quote] yep, i should spend less time on it though and more time on improving myself.
Nunsense Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 (edited) [quote name='Delivery Boy' post='1789059' date='Feb 22 2009, 09:47 PM']I just dont agree with the part where you say we should try to love the good in satan. What good is there in satan ? If the Bible is true and I am to believe it I see no good in satan. Satan knew what would happen if he tempted adam and eve. Look at the world we live in. People are starving, people are murdered brutally everyday, and on top of that Christ was beaten on a cross because of the fall of mankind which came from satan. Satan hated us or he wouldn't have introduced death into the world. Yes adam and even disobeyed but it was a result of a temptation by satan. If satan never would of did what he did then he would have never been there to tempt us. I see no love in him and therefore find it impossible to love the good in him.[/quote] deliveryboy -- I guess we have a different opinion on why there is so much suffering in the world. You put it all on Satan, and none of it on the nature of fallen mankind! Yet, even Jesus called us evil when He said... [i]"Is there anyone among you who would hand his son a stone when he asked for bread? Or would hand him a snake when he asked for a fish? If you, then, [b]evil as you are[/b], know how to give your children what is good, how much more will your Father in heaven give good things to those who ask him!" (Matt 7:7-11)[/i] There is much evil and suffering in today's world that is caused by selfishness and greed. Satan might be tempting people, but don't we have a choice? God allows temptation to help strengthen us in the virtues of faith and hope and charity, but if we refuse to choose what is right, then we are responsible for our choices, and the effect these choices have on the world around us. To deny our responsibility is like a child blaming others for what they have done! This is not to say that Satan isn't evil - of course he is. But God allows his existence to continue, and God is all good, so that means that we are not constrained to do evil just because we are tempted. That is what free will is all about. We are free to choose evil or to choose good. If you read Job, you will see that God allowed Satan to test Job to the limits of his endurance, but as Job said... [i]"And yet he knows every step I take! Let him test me in the crucible: I shall come out pure gold." (Job 23:10)[/i] So instead of wasting your time hating Satan, spend your time loving God and praising Him, and striving to do only His will -- much more pleasant too Besides, nothing would be more irritating to someone who is full of pride, than to be ignored. Ignore Satan or scorn him, but don't pander to his pride by making him important enough to hate! Just my perspective of course. Edited February 23, 2009 by nunsense
Nunsense Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 You guys are too quick for me - by the time I have one post done, you have already replied with more! deliveryboy - you have a passion for justice - that is beautiful. and kafka, you have a great wealth of knowledge - thank you. Call me a romantic - I just find love so much more pleasant than any of the alternatives Thanks guys!
Guest Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 (edited) [quote name='nunsense' post='1789161' date='Feb 23 2009, 02:43 AM']deliveryboy -- I guess we have a different opinion on why there is so much suffering in the world. You put it all on Satan, and none of it on the nature of fallen mankind! Yet, even Jesus called us evil when He said... [i]"Is there anyone among you who would hand his son a stone when he asked for bread? Or would hand him a snake when he asked for a fish? If you, then, [b]evil as you are[/b], know how to give your children what is good, how much more will your Father in heaven give good things to those who ask him!" (Matt 7:7-11)[/i] [font="Arial Black"]There is much evil and suffering in today's world that is caused by selfishness and greed. Satan might be tempting people, but don't we have a choice? [/font]God allows temptation to help strengthen us in the virtues of faith and hope and charity, but if we refuse to choose what is right, then we are responsible for our choices, and the effect these choices have on the world around us. To deny our responsibility is like a child blaming others for what they have done! This is not to say that Satan isn't evil - of course he is. But God allows his existence to continue, and God is all good, so that means that we are not constrained to do evil just because we are tempted. That is what free will is all about. We are free to choose evil or to choose good. If you read Job, you will see that God allowed Satan to test Job to the limits of his endurance, but as Job said... [i]"And yet he knows every step I take! Let him test me in the crucible: I shall come out pure gold." (Job 23:10)[/i] So instead of wasting your time hating Satan, spend your time loving God and praising Him, and striving to do only His will -- much more pleasant too Besides, nothing would be more irritating to someone who is full of pride, than to be ignored. Ignore Satan or scorn him, but don't pander to his pride by making him important enough to hate! Just my perspective of course.[/quote] Hey Godbless, I see what you are saying and you make sence. But what I am saying is this, If satan never tempted us we would of never fell. God didnt tempt us satan did. If satan was obedient to God I would assume we would still be all one happy family. But no satan hated God and therefore hated us and caused us to sin and bring death into the world. I agree that we choose to sin if we do. And we all do at times. But it still doesnt change the fact that this world is a ugly cold place sometimes because of satan tempting us to begin with.(adam and eve and original sin) I live a good life and God has blessed me beyond my wildest dreams. But I also know there are peoople who suffer who dont deserve to suffer. These people dont suffer because God wants to test them (in my humble opinon) They suffer becasue this world is gone astray and satan is the God of it. So by satan tempting us at the very start and us falling innocent people suffer the way they do today. Edited February 23, 2009 by Guest
kafka Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 (edited) [quote name='nunsense' post='1789161' date='Feb 23 2009, 01:43 AM']deliveryboy -- I guess we have a different opinion on why there is so much suffering in the world. You put it all on Satan, and none of it on the nature of fallen mankind! Yet, even Jesus called us evil when He said... [i]"Is there anyone among you who would hand his son a stone when he asked for bread? Or would hand him a snake when he asked for a fish? If you, then, [b]evil as you are[/b], know how to give your children what is good, how much more will your Father in heaven give good things to those who ask him!" (Matt 7:7-11)[/i] There is much evil and suffering in today's world that is caused by selfishness and greed. Satan might be tempting people, but don't we have a choice? God allows temptation to help strengthen us in the virtues of faith and hope and charity, but if we refuse to choose what is right, then we are responsible for our choices, and the effect these choices have on the world around us. To deny our responsibility is like a child blaming others for what they have done! This is not to say that Satan isn't evil - of course he is. But God allows his existence to continue, and God is all good, so that means that we are not constrained to do evil just because we are tempted. That is what free will is all about. We are free to choose evil or to choose good. If you read Job, you will see that God allowed Satan to test Job to the limits of his endurance, but as Job said... [i]"And yet he knows every step I take! Let him test me in the crucible: I shall come out pure gold." (Job 23:10)[/i] So instead of wasting your time hating Satan, spend your time loving God and praising Him, and striving to do only His will -- much more pleasant too Besides, nothing would be more irritating to someone who is full of pride, than to be ignored. Ignore Satan or scorn him, but don't pander to his pride by making him important enough to hate! Just my perspective of course.[/quote] Now you are being to harsh on Delivery Boy. You should not presume to teach him. He is an adult man and you are an adult women. Mary who is the perfect adult woman never taught Jesus when he was an adult man. Delivery Boy brings up some profound questions, which are very good. Do not use them to correct him. You are beating a dead horse, I dont think D-Boy is too much over-emphasizing Satan. He is seriously considering this aspect of the world where Satan and the fallen angels do in fact roam the earth and tempt and influence men in spite of themselves. And because this world today is very sinful God in His justice allows Satan and the fallen angels to have a greater influence. Therefore his considerations are important. Edited February 23, 2009 by kafka
Guest Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 (edited) [quote name='kafka' post='1789170' date='Feb 23 2009, 02:55 AM']He is seriously considering this aspect of the world where Satan and the fallen angels do in fact roam the earth and tempt and influence men in spite of themselves. And because this world today is very sinful God in His justice allows Satan and the fallen angels to have a greater influence. Therefore his considerations are important.[/quote] Yes and the fact that satan tempted mankind to begin with. He hated us from the start or he wouldnt of tempted us and introduced death to us. God tried to save us yet He couldnt take our free will away. But yet satan already knew the choice he made in heaven to hate God and start this eternal war. He saw us (humans) and decided to bring us into the war also. Yes we chose to let original sin infect us yet that still doesnt change the fact that for satan is was probally like luring a 5 year old with candy to kidnap him. Again I look at the world today and see all the suffering and killing. I know indivigual people choose to sin everyday. But still this is a result from the garden and satan tempting us to begin with. Satan has no love in him or he wouldnt of started this war with God. Edited February 23, 2009 by Guest
Nunsense Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='kafka' post='1789170' date='Feb 22 2009, 11:55 PM']Now you are being to harsh on Delivery Boy. You should not presume to teach him. He is an adult man and you are an adult women. Mary who is the perfect adult woman never taught Jesus when he was an adult man. Delivery Boy brings up some profound questions, which are very good. Do not use them to correct him. You are beating a dead horse, I dont think D-Boy is too much over-emphasizing Satan. He is seriously considering this aspect of the world where Satan and the fallen angels do in fact roam the earth and tempt and influence men in spite of themselves. And because this world today is very sinful God in His justice allows Satan and the fallen angels to have a greater influence. Therefore his considerations are important.[/quote] Wow! And I thought this conversation was going so well until I read this post! Now I think you are being harsh to me! You accuse me of being presumptious and then tell me that Our Blessed Mother did not presume to teach Jesus! Where did this come from?? I should certainly never compare myself in any way to Our Lady, nor do I believe that deliveryboy would compare himself to Our Lord! What a non sequitur. I certainly didn't intend to do anything more than support my own personal views with quotes from the Bible, just as you did. If teaching occurs, then it does so, but not because I felt any desire to teach or preach, but because I saw things slightly differently than deliveryboy did and wanted to express myself on this forum. I thought we were having a discussion and exchanging ideas with the intention to learn from each other. It appears that I am mistaken. I will withdraw from this discussion now because it seems to be evoking a distinct unpleasantness. I still believe that both of you are focusing on Satan too much -- I may be beating a dead horse or not, but the tone of your last post shows me that focusing on evil doesn't breed charity.
Guest Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='nunsense' post='1789187' date='Feb 23 2009, 03:35 AM']Wow! And I thought this conversation was going so well until I read this post! Now I think you are being harsh to me! You accuse me of being presumptious and then tell me that Our Blessed Mother did not presume to teach Jesus! Where did this come from?? I should certainly never compare myself in any way to Our Lady, nor do I believe that deliveryboy would compare himself to Our Lord! What a non sequitur. I certainly didn't intend to do anything more than support my own personal views with quotes from the Bible, just as you did. If teaching occurs, then it does so, but not because I felt any desire to teach or preach, but because I saw things slightly differently than deliveryboy did and wanted to express myself on this forum. I thought we were having a discussion and exchanging ideas with the intention to learn from each other. It appears that I am mistaken. I will withdraw from this discussion now because it seems to be evoking a distinct unpleasantness. I still believe that both of you are focusing on Satan too much -- I may be beating a dead horse or not, but the tone of your last post shows me that focusing on evil doesn't breed charity. [/quote] Dont leave the thread ! I aprreciate your view and where you are coming from. Godbless.
kafka Posted February 23, 2009 Posted February 23, 2009 [quote name='nunsense' post='1789165' date='Feb 23 2009, 01:48 AM']You guys are too quick for me - by the time I have one post done, you have already replied with more! deliveryboy - you have a passion for justice - that is beautiful. and kafka, you have a great wealth of knowledge - thank you. Call me a romantic - I just find love so much more pleasant than any of the alternatives Thanks guys![/quote] Well I guessed I missed this post. Sorry. Still there is nothing with comparing oneself with Jesus and Mary since ultimately we must imitate them and live up to their examples in some way, in our our own unique ways, in our own participation of salvation.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now