Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

cmotherofpirl
Posted

[url="http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/science/sc0101.htm"]http://www.catholiceducation.org/articles/science/sc0101.htm[/url]

Posted (edited)

Read it a while back.
a very good article
for those interested in this subject.
The late Cardinal presents a balanced view.

Edited by kafka
Posted

I have never been able to wrap my head around the problem. It always seemed to me evolution didn't explain the origin of life, so it didn't really matter.

Posted (edited)

Christoph Cardinal Schonborn's "Chance or Purpose" was a concise and lucid examination of the issue. I thoroughly enjoyed it.

Intestingly, it was made clear to me in my biology degree senior synthesis course entitled "Organic Evolution" that Evolution Theory assumes as a starting point that Life exists by ANY MEANS. That is, life must exist for evolution to work upon it as a means of selecting variation within a given population of pre-existing living creatures. So really, a "creator" is not all that out of line with Evolution Theory; it just assumes that the Creator stays out of the process wants the ball is rolling. Old error, New Label as Fulton Sheen would say...

Edited by Veridicus
  • 3 weeks later...
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' post='1801886' date='Mar 9 2009, 07:17 PM']I have never been able to wrap my head around the problem. It always seemed to me evolution didn't explain the origin of life, so it didn't really matter.[/quote]

Agreed.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Evolution can explain fairly acceptably "how". Like a large portion of science though, it doesn't do a lot for why, and nor can it predict.

Even if it got to the point where it could accurately predict (making it a scientific Law), it still wouldn't have a shadow of a hope of describing why.

Honestly, the how doesn't affect me. It never will. The why, on the other hand, is somewhat immanently important to me, and all of us. At least that's what we believe as theists.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1817673' date='Mar 27 2009, 01:48 AM']Evolution can explain fairly acceptably "how". Like a large portion of science though, it doesn't do a lot for why, and nor can it predict.

Even if it got to the point where it could accurately predict (making it a scientific Law), it still wouldn't have a shadow of a hope of describing why.

Honestly, the how doesn't affect me. It never will. The why, on the other hand, is somewhat immanently important to me, and all of us. At least that's what we believe as theists.[/quote]
fair enough, yet I would suggest to you that the how and the why are not seperate. At this point in time for a Christian to deny the truth that all history and all human knowledge (science) do not have a single source and single end who is God, would be short-sighted. God is One-Divine Eternal Act. Any sort of valid scientific knowledge may in a way illuminate Divine Revelatary knowledge, and any Divine Revelatory knowledge may illuminate scientific knowledge. To separate the two would in mind be fideism.

Edited by kafka
Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1817684' date='Mar 27 2009, 02:58 AM']fair enough, yet I would suggest to you that the how and the why are not seperate. At this point in time for a Christian to deny the truth that all history and all human knowledge (science) do not have a single source and single end who is God, would be short-sighted. God is One-Divine Eternal Act. Any sort of valid scientific knowledge may in a way illuminate Divine Revelatary knowledge, and any Divine Revelatory knowledge may illuminate scientific knowledge. To separate the two would in mind be fideism.[/quote]
Well at the core they're one and the same, but at the level that we as humans can penetrate, we can't find God through the how. We can certainly understand it in a religious sense, and knowing more about the world around you is very important to a Christian living in today's world, but when we get to the debate about evolution, right now I think it's mostly irrelevant. Understanding it with a religious perspective, obviously we catch a glimpse of God's incomparable design, and this is awesome for us who understand it that way, but in a scientific sense we don't see much of anything.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1817747' date='Mar 27 2009, 09:53 AM']Well at the core they're one and the same, but at the level that we as humans can penetrate, we can't find God through the how. We can certainly understand it in a religious sense, and knowing more about the world around you is very important to a Christian living in today's world, but when we get to the debate about evolution, right now I think it's mostly irrelevant. Understanding it with a religious perspective, obviously we catch a glimpse of God's incomparable design, and this is awesome for us who understand it that way, but in a scientific sense we don't see much of anything.[/quote]
God has used the 'how' to help trigger conversion experiences for people such as Avery Dulles. We're plunged into a historical situation so in one sense we experience God through our material situation and that includes natural science. Once one has accepted the gift of faith or perhaps accepts grace to a limited extent natural science is better guided by its source, end, and limitations in view.

I'm not aware of any major debate anymore among mature adults. Scientists have discovered enough verifiable data about evolution that it cannot be dismissed by any mature Christian adult. The ones who debate the existance or usefullness of evolution are the extremists who tend to pure Creationists who deny any gradual evolution (who deny verifiable truths), or pure evolutionists who deny a Creator who is the source and guider of evolution (who make evolution their idol). At least this is how I see things.

The only problem is scientists havent broken through to a complete all encompassing theory (and perhaps never will), hence you have different models of evolution from different schools of scientists.

I kind of see what you are getting at by a pure scientific sense yet I'm not sure how many scientists or non-scientists for that matter view natural science apart from at least some sort of theology or at least an implicit idea of God. Some professional scientists may publicly present their science apart from theology but it seems impossible to practice this personally and constantly over a matter of time.

Edited by kafka
Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1817829' date='Mar 27 2009, 01:43 PM']The only problem is scientists havent broken through to a complete all encompassing theory (and perhaps never will), hence you have different models of evolution from different schools of scientists.[/quote]
what I meant to say was all encompassing theory proven as a law. I'm not familiar with all the technical terms used in natural science so tend to limp a bit when it comes to them.

When I get home tonight I'll post a couple more articles on God and evolution that I've either read or am reading.

Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1817829' date='Mar 27 2009, 01:43 PM']I'm not aware of any major debate anymore among mature adults. Scientists have discovered enough verifiable data about evolution that it cannot be dismissed by any mature Christian adult. The ones who debate the existance or usefullness of evolution are the extremists who tend to pure Creationists who deny any gradual evolution (who deny verifiable truths), or pure evolutionists who deny a Creator who is the source and guider of evolution (who make evolution their idol). At least this is how I see things.[/quote]
:twothumbsup:

Flat out denying the existence of evolutionary processes would make gaining converts nearly impossible, too. I think some radical Creationist sects are going to find themselves going extinct...

Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='kafka' post='1817829' date='Mar 27 2009, 12:43 PM']God has used the 'how' to help trigger conversion experiences for people such as Avery Dulles. We're plunged into a historical situation so in one sense we experience God through our material situation and that includes natural science. Once one has accepted the gift of faith or perhaps accepts grace to a limited extent natural science is better guided by its source, end, and limitations in view.

I'm not aware of any major debate anymore among mature adults. Scientists have discovered enough verifiable data about evolution that it cannot be dismissed by any mature Christian adult. The ones who debate the existance or usefullness of evolution are the extremists who tend to pure Creationists who deny any gradual evolution (who deny verifiable truths), or pure evolutionists who deny a Creator who is the source and guider of evolution (who make evolution their idol). At least this is how I see things.

The only problem is scientists havent broken through to a complete all encompassing theory (and perhaps never will), hence you have different models of evolution from different schools of scientists.

I kind of see what you are getting at by a pure scientific sense yet I'm not sure how many scientists or non-scientists for that matter view natural science apart from at least some sort of theology or at least an implicit idea of God. Some professional scientists may publicly present their science apart from theology but it seems impossible to practice this personally and constantly over a matter of time.[/quote]
I think by and large we're on the same page with this, actually. Just coming at it from different angles.

[quote]I'm not aware of any major debate anymore among mature adults.[/quote]
I'm most definitely not a young-earth Creationist, but there are certainly still parts that haven't been worked out. I'd be willing to bet that the general idea is in place and solid, as well as many specifics, but it's far from a closed case.

Not being a geneticist or anything like that though, I'm quite content to wait and see what happens. :)

Posted (edited)

[quote name='philothea' post='1817844' date='Mar 27 2009, 02:29 PM']:twothumbsup:

Flat out denying the existence of evolutionary processes would make gaining converts nearly impossible, too. I think some radical Creationist sects are going to find themselves going extinct...[/quote]
The radical Creationists are in a sense just as bad as the radical atheist evolutionists in that both factions deny truth. Obviously the atheist evolutionists are much worse for their explicit denial of God and exultation of natural science as their idol, yet the radical Creationists are in a sense implicitly denying God who is the source of creation and all science by replacing verifiable scientific evidence with their own false version of history and science or perhaps by falling into the error of fideism .

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1817981' date='Mar 27 2009, 06:02 PM']I'm most definitely not a young-earth Creationist, but there are certainly still parts that haven't been worked out. I'd be willing to bet that the general idea is in place and solid, as well as many specifics, but it's far from a closed case.

Not being a geneticist or anything like that though, I'm quite content to wait and see what happens. :)[/quote]
Yes there are problems that need to be worked out concerning a theory of evolution. I'm not sure the scientists will ever come to a complete understanding of it in this life (even in the future) since the gap in time seems to great to overcome.

That is why the above Avery Dulles' article was interesting for me to read in the sense that he analyzes the different models of evolution by the respected Christian and non-Christian scientists.

I'm not a scientist either but in general I find evolution fascinating to study as a recreation. I even think it is implied in the some verses of Genesis. Maybe I'll post some more later tonight, including some links to articles by other theologians.

Edited by kafka
Nihil Obstat
Posted

Honestly, once we've got evolution reconciled to theism, it seems significantly more astounding than everything popping up out of nowhere. Looking at the fractal-esque complexity is just mind-boggling.

Posted (edited)

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1818271' date='Mar 27 2009, 09:55 PM']Honestly, once we've got evolution reconciled to theism, it seems significantly more astounding than everything popping up out of nowhere. Looking at the fractal-esque complexity is just mind-boggling.[/quote]

Actually fractal-type organization would make sense evolutionarilly speaking since natural selection can only work on extant traits; thus we could expect repeating patterns of complexity...

It's an especiially prevalent theme in proteomics and genomics where genes are "copied" within a length of DNA and then selection works upon these extra copies to produce new variants of related "protein families" with differing functions. Hemoglobin genes are a prime example...

Edited by Veridicus
Nihil Obstat
Posted

[quote name='Veridicus' post='1818327' date='Mar 27 2009, 10:32 PM']Actually fractal-type organization would make sense evolutionarilly speaking since natural selection can only work on extant traits; thus we could expect repeating patterns of complexity...

It's an especiially prevalent theme in proteomics and genomics where genes are "copied" within a length of DNA and then selection works upon these extra copies to produce new variants of related "protein families" with differing functions. Hemoglobin genes are a prime example...[/quote]
Yes! :) I didn't quite catch that last bit, but I'm sure I agree.
Fractals seem to be like a microcosm for the universe, actually. That's why I used it as an analogy.

Our universe is one giant fractal on God's computer simulation. :smokey:

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1819336' date='Mar 28 2009, 11:47 PM']Yes! :) I didn't quite catch that last bit, but I'm sure I agree.
Fractals seem to be like a microcosm for the universe, actually. That's why I used it as an analogy.

Our universe is one giant fractal on God's computer simulation. :smokey:[/quote]


Haha... :smokey: <<What's that you're smoking up there? Most of the people I have met that are REALLY into fractal art are drug-users...

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1819336' date='Mar 28 2009, 11:47 PM']Yes! :) I didn't quite catch that last bit, but I'm sure I agree....[/quote]

[url="http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homology_(biology)"]http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Homology_(biology)[/url]

Check out the part on "Homology of Sequences in Genetics: Parology"...it talks about hemoglobin and myoglobin and gene duplications; which is what I was trying to explain in 1 sentence...

Posted (edited)

both of you are beyond me at this point. I'm more interested in the theological/philosophical aspects of evolution. In Avery Dulles article above there seem to be three basic models of evolution Christian theologians fall into, namely Theistic Darwinism, Intellegent Design and the Teleoligical view.

I mentioned I'd post some more links. Here is a good and succint article on the Catholic view of Evolution, summarizing the basic aspects of evolution a Catholic may aspect and the ones that he must reject. Also summarizes what Catholics should believe about Adam and Eve:
[url="http://www.catholicplanet.com/articles/instruction005.htm"]http://www.catholicplanet.com/articles/instruction005.htm[/url]

Here is a more in depth article by Karl Rahner called Hominisation. The first section is excellent since he goes into the official Church teaching on Man in relation to the theory of evolution. Also he goes into the relationshiop between theology and natural science:
[url="http://www.religion-online.org/showchapter.asp?title=3367&C=2765"]http://www.religion-online.org/showchapter...3367&C=2765[/url]

Here are some verses and short commentary from the Book of Genesis which may be attributed to a sort of evolution:

{1:2} But the earth was empty and unoccupied, and darknesses were over the face of the abyss; and so the Spirit of God was brought over the waters.
{1:5} And he called the light, ‘Day,’ and the darknesses, ‘Night.’ And it became evening and morning, one day.

~ The first day is not a day as we count time, but merely the first period of time, of unspecified length, in the universe. Science agrees that first the Universe was created, and there was no life in the first time period, for the Universe was void and unoccupied. And when the earth first became, it was void and lifeless.

{1:11} And he said, “Let the land spring forth green plants, both those producing seed, and fruit-bearing trees, producing fruit according to their kind, whose seed is within itself, over all the earth.” And so it became.

~ Notice that God commands the earth to produce plant-life (‘herbam virentem’). He miraculously created heaven and earth out of nothing, but he causes the plant-life to be produced out of what already exists, the land. This text supports the idea, found in science, that life developed from existing inanimate matter. But the text also clearly teaches the truth that the entire process of creation and the development of creation is caused by God and is under His Providence.

{1:20} And then God said, “Let the waters produce animals with a living soul, and flying creatures above the earth, under the firmament of heaven.”

~ In this next step within the development of creation, God creates the first creatures that have living souls (but not immortal souls) within the sea. Again, science agrees, teaching that the first animals were in the water, not on the land.

{1:24} God also said, “Let the land produce living souls in their kind: cattle, and animals, and wild beasts of the earth, according to their species.” And so it became.

~ So, plants were the first life created, then moving creatures of the sea, then moving creatures of the land. This is the same order of development in creation taught by science (although Scripture omits mention of microscopic organisms, with which the ancients were unfamiliar).


We know that the immortal human souls of Adam and Eve were created miraculously and immediately by God. The question that ticks me is whether or not the formation of Adam's was a summit of God's providential evolution or it was somehow miraculously and immediately created by God using the elements of the Earth. I really dont know but I like to think about it. In either case man is a magnificent creature since he is only complete in the unity of soul and body. An immortal soul directly infused by God at conception, and a material body somehow formed by God from the elements of the Universe.

Edited by kafka
Posted (edited)

[quote name='kafka' post='1819439' date='Mar 29 2009, 05:13 AM']both of you.....elements of the Universe[/quote]


Excellent Post.

Edited by Veridicus

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...