Veridicus Posted April 1, 2009 Posted April 1, 2009 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' post='1821686' date='Apr 1 2009, 01:23 AM']So the way I see science and faith I guess, is that conflict is impossible, and when it looks like there is, it's because we don't know enough about one or the other.[/quote] That's the one. I know some brilliant scientists who's minds are just so closed or brainwashed into ever considering a spiritual reality that they just cannot be part of a theological discussion. And likewise, I know brilliant people of faith who are so set in their mindset that they can't open up and look at the data and see how to two truths can coincide. There aren't enough moderate minded people really exploring this issue. I think the scientists are afraid that religion will 'weaken the science' and the religious are afraid that giving an inch to science will lead to a 'diluting of faith and tradition.' Truth cannot contradict Truth.
kafka Posted April 1, 2009 Posted April 1, 2009 [quote name='Veridicus' post='1821267' date='Mar 31 2009, 06:56 PM']The problem is that I have seen NO scientific reason to believe that every animal on the planet was created through a sort of theistic evolution, but then man was outside this process. Obviously I do not wholly base my faithlife on what science can tell me, but there is NO apparent reason to speculate otherwise in physiological terms. Could God have built us de novo and given us DNA that is 99.3% identical to chimpanzees and made us a morphology distinctly primate mammal? Of course...but I do not see this as being necessary. Either some sort of guided evolution explains it all, or we shouldn't be trying to jive Christian Theology with Macro-evolution at ALL. There is no serious scientific reason to separate Man from this same proces for the diversity of life on earth. What you think?[/quote] First off, I think your speculative scenario is well thought out and valid. I see nothing wrong with your explanation, and find it quite interesting, and I suggested (above) that there is nothing wrong with that hypothetical, and I didnt mean to sound like I was arguing negatively against it, since I wasnt. My model is following a more teleological view. An evolution occurs in each grade, namely inanimate matter, vegetative life, and animal life. When each grade reaches a sort of finality and can no longer transcend itself, then God by a special creative act uses the nature of the grade which has reached its finality and creates the beginnings of a whole new grade which is higher in nature, and then this new grade undergoes its evolution, (in the case of plants and animals it would be what is termed macro-evolution). Now when animals reached there finality in the high primates, the cosmos reached a horizontal plane which had no purpose other than to renew its own cycle of life. In concrete sense the cosmos taken alone has no transcendent purpose above and beyond itself. Prescinding from an ultimate purpose of glorifying God, the cosmos seems to have no purpose other than survival at this point in history. Then God created Man, and suddenly the whole cosmos has 'found' its purpose in this utterly unique creature. Everything that God created (prescinding from ultimate purpose) beginning with Deep Space, to the Sun, to the Earth, to plants, to animals all find their purpose in serving Man. God created the Universe for Man. And this truth is absolutely, and irrevocably established, verified and confirmed at the event of the Incarnation. Man is Lord of the cosmos. He has been given everything by God, and this is expressed in numerous verses of Scripture to in varying degrees and ways. And this Lordship of Man over Cosmos found its definitive fulfillment in the entire event of Jesus Christ. And it will find its definitive fulfillment in all of the Saints in the totality and unity of their human nature (soul-body) who have followed Christ in death, the resurrection, and ascension and will reign with Christ forever in the New Heaven and New Earth. So this truth of Man as Lord of cosmos and the cosmos as servant of Man suggests to me that Man in his totality was not derived via evolution his servant the animals, yet created independent of him. The aspects Man as summit and lord of the cosmos shares with the animals, plants, and inanimate matter is indirect, and not a direct derivitative. Now there is another argument and that is found in the purpose of Man. The purpose of Man is to know and to love God in a supernaturally modified state of grace built into his original essence. This state finds its fulfillment in immediate vision of God in eternal life, yet it must first be actualized concretely by doing good works since Man is plunged into an historical situation. Therefore this transcendent and unique purpose of knowing and loving God which sets us above and beyond the cosmos, is not limited to his immortal soul, it encompasses the totality and unity of his being (soul/body). Man in his totality is transcendent and unique beyond all animals, plants, element, etc. If this purpose were limited to his immortal soul (as you suggested) then we would be Angels, and our bodies would be like puppets and have no real value or meaning. Or we would fall into the error of Platonic/gnostic dualism. Man would be an immortal creature trapped in a body roaming the earth. Yet this is not the case since Man is complete only after the general resurrection, and in fact God creates a New Heaven for the resurrected Saints who are complete after the resurrection. So from this viewpoint it doesnt seem to me that Man would in any way have an evolutionary connection to the cosmos. Every aspect of Man he shares with the cosmos is in a way unique and transcendent of the cosmos, therefore indirect implying to direct evolutionary connection. I guess that is another point. The resurrected bodies of men are created anew by God. The only reason our bodies corrupt and die is the fallen state of original sin, and not because of any direct tie to the Earth as is the case in animals and plants. So that is my speculative answer. I havent put a whole lot of thought into these ideas so please forgive any incompleteness or lack of logical progression etc and please point out where I may have fallen short or not made sense Veridicus. Thanks.
kafka Posted April 4, 2009 Posted April 4, 2009 I just reread this last post of mine. A few grammar errors and mis-spellings, and misnomers. I was pretty beat up by work when I wrote it so forgive me. Still I wouldnt mind anyone sharing their own thoughts in reaction to what I posted.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now