r2Dtoo Posted April 6, 2012 Posted April 6, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1333725833' post='2413660'] I actually think that we shouldn't rip into anyones faith. It's just wrong. radical [u]I[/u]slam however wants to physically injure people in a very destructive way.If it didn't aim to hurt anyone I would say it was fine. Catholicism is about faith, love and charity; very different from radicle islam. And Islam is a fine religion, its just that the [b]extremists[/b] want to blow everyone up. Also, the church isn't defined by the people like may other denominations. [u]The Church[/u] is the teachings and doctrines inspired by the Holy Spirit and passed down to the faithful from the apostle who Jesus christ taught Himself. People make mistakes. God doesn't so to insult or "critique" his church is very offensive to him and those who love him. [b]You can learn about history all you want, but to take history and morph it into a politically charged argument against a given religion is just WRONG!! Didn't yo mama teach you manners[/b]!!!!! [/quote] You can jump up and down and try to cry that people are just morphing history for some sort of undetermined political agenda but you'd be wrong. Fact: Spanish dictators during WWII allied with Hitler and forced Catholic morals upon their population. Fact: Hitler's anti-Semitism was, in part, inspired by the old school blood libels first thought of by Catholic clergymen. Yes, German nationalism could not have risen without the Protestant Reformation, but the Catholic Church is far from blameless in the matter. As for your insistence that the Catholic Church isn't people, any faith group can claim that. Protestants will say their faith is based on the Bible, Muslims will claim the Quran, you claim teachings supposedly handed down from Christ himself. It's all the same. Doesn't let your religion off the hook for past events.
4588686 Posted April 6, 2012 Posted April 6, 2012 [quote name='Lisa' timestamp='1333716988' post='2413626'] Hm, I might disagree a little, if "intellectual criticism" is used in the way it should be. There are events in the Church's history that should be criticized. Even if they hurt, they are true. Only the truth will help us address these changes (as many of them have!). For instance, when people bring up the sexual abuse crisis in a challenging but respectful way- not making sweeping generalizations or punitive remarks about all priests, but rather, asking because they believe what happened was a violation of those people's God-given dignity by those that should have been there to lead them closer to heaven- I think it's our duty to address those calmly and prayerfully. That's not anti-Catholicism. It's a criticism that hurts, but it's something that needs to be talked about. Fr. Ron Rolheiser came to our parish last year and talked a little bit about this. Sometimes we're so sick of hearing about it that every comment feels more like a jab, but this has and continues to purify our Church. Hopefully this situation never happens again, but sadly, if that exterior criticism wasn't there, the disgusting behavior may have continued. So, long rambling paragraph to say that a criticism (especially ones that are still respectful) isn't necessarily anti-Catholic. Even if it hurts, we shouldn't cry "discrimination." Now, when someone generalizes the whole Church as pedophiles, that's anti-Catholicism... which should still be addressed prayerfully and calmly. Edit: sorry about the massive run-on sentences. Don't have time to fix them. Got to go! [/quote] I just don't take this claim seriously. That's probably because of certain posters here and Bill Donahue. There have been sever instances of anti-Catholicism in the world and there still are. But a substantive number of Catholics in America, often those most eager to trumpet the superiority of Catholicism, seem to cry foul at any criticism of the Church as an institution or it's teachings. The Church's behavior in the former Yugoslavia was appalling. Many of the more vocal posters here are quite eager to point to the Islamists movements as proof or evidence of the corrupting influence of Islam on the lives of its adherents. But when it is pointed out that the Catholic Church had disgusting relationships with, for example, the Ustashi fascists in Yugoslavia, suddenly that is 'anti-Catholic garbage.'
Guest Posted April 6, 2012 Posted April 6, 2012 (edited) Hasan why aren't you catholic anymore ? Are you still christian ? Edited April 6, 2012 by Guest
4588686 Posted April 6, 2012 Posted April 6, 2012 [quote name='Delivery Boy' timestamp='1333743526' post='2413735'] Hassan why aren't you catholic anymore ? Are you still christian ? [/quote][url="http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/86623-my-fall-from-grace/page__hl__%2Bfall+%2Bfrom+%2Bgrace__fromsearch__1"]http://www.phatmass.com/phorum/topic/86623-my-fall-from-grace/page__hl__%2Bfall+%2Bfrom+%2Bgrace__fromsearch__1[/url]
cmotherofpirl Posted April 6, 2012 Posted April 6, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1333743127' post='2413732'] The Church's behavior in the former Yugoslavia was appalling. Many of the more vocal posters here are quite eager to point to the Islamists movements as proof or evidence of the corrupting influence of Islam on the lives of its adherents. But when it is pointed out that the Catholic Church had disgusting relationships with, for example, the Ustashi fascists in Yugoslavia, suddenly that is 'anti-Catholic garbage.' [/quote] If people in the Church violated Church teaching then they should be called out, but that is totally different from saying Church teaching is wrong OR saying people who believe are mindless sheep etc.
Annie12 Posted April 7, 2012 Author Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1333738431' post='2413719'] so then, is the intellectual criticism of protestants, gay issues, islam, liberals here, actually Anti-(all those things?) because most people here say other wise. [/quote] Well, I find it interesting the only reasonable people here are catholic. I mean common! Do you really not understand what I am saying here! [b]IF YOU SAY SOMETHING OFFENSIVE ABOUT CATHOLICISM, THEN YOU ARE BEING ANTI-CATHOLIC. Also, I AM ONLY TALKING ABOUT ANTI-CATHOLICISM AND ALL THE NON-CATHOLICS ARE TRYING TO SWAY THE CONVERSATION. [/b]And there is a difference in what you mean by intellectual criticism. When it is applied to a religious belief (weather it Catholic, protestant or Islam), then it is just wrong and offensive. I am just restating myself here so I will refer you to my previous posts! (P.S. gay issues is a political topic and therefore I think it is okay to have your own thoughts on the matter. I don't hate Gay people, I just don't like Gay activity and they have a God given vocation if you get my drift). [b]But any who, we are getting off topic, we are talking about anti-Catholicism.[/b] And also, stop being so relative. If your are rational, then you can rationalize anything. There are facts and weather or not you accept them they still exist.
Jesus_lol Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1333773573' post='2413898'] Well, I find it interesting the only reasonable people here are catholic. I mean common! Do you really not understand what I am saying here! [b]IF YOU SAY SOMETHING OFFENSIVE ABOUT CATHOLICISM, THEN YOU ARE BEING ANTI-CATHOLIC. Also, I AM ONLY TALKING ABOUT ANTI-CATHOLICISM AND ALL THE NON-CATHOLICS ARE TRYING TO SWAY THE CONVERSATION. [/b]And there is a difference in what you mean by intellectual criticism. When it is applied to a religious belief (weather it Catholic, protestant or Islam), then it is just wrong and offensive. I am just restating myself here so I will refer you to my previous posts! (P.S. gay issues is a political topic and therefore I think it is okay to have your own thoughts on the matter. I don't hate Gay people, I just don't like Gay activity and they have a God given vocation if you get my drift). [b]But any who, we are getting off topic, we are talking about anti-Catholicism.[/b] And also, stop being so relative. If your are rational, then you can rationalize anything. There are facts and weather or not you accept them they still exist. [/quote] Are you kidding me? seriously? "intellectual criticism is ok unless its about religion, then it is automatically OFFENSIVE ANTI RELIGION HATE SPEECH"?? and then you have the nerve to say [b]I [/b]am being "relative". Your cognitive dissonance is frankly impressive.
r2Dtoo Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1333774773' post='2413903']Your cognitive dissonance is frankly impressive.[/quote] What I found most impressive was when Annie first quoted Hassan, wrote a paragraph on his quote, and managed to avoid everything that he said. She's one smooth politician yo. Edited April 7, 2012 by r2Dtoo
Papist Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [color=#282828][font=helvetica, arial, sans-serif]Intellectual criticism is stupid.[/font][/color]
Sister Marie Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 I agree with what Lisa said about criticism. It is GOOD that we are criticized. Intellectual criticism, whether it be about actions the Church has been a part of or of doctrines and teachings, is a way to purify, grow in holiness, and realize our sinfulness and need for God. Right now in my archdiocese a trial is going on because of the sexual abuse of minors by clergy and because of the moving of those abusers from parish to parish. Are some of the people involved in this trial "anti-catholic"? Probably. Is the trial itself "anti-catholic"? No. It would be unjust for this trial not to happen. It wouldn't be happening to begin with if nothing wrong had been done by our hierarchy. I say this with a lot of love for the Church. The only way wounds are healed and sins forgiven is for them to be brought out into the light so that God can transform us. We sometimes think we are above criticism and the truth is that we are not. We should allow it to purify us. In the light of eternity - Christ gained our eternal life by suffering and dying. Why should we not also suffer and die? In this case it is a death of pride and of status... but it is still a death. In that sense, I do not see anti-Catholicism as something to fight against. Yes, we should protect our rights. No, we shouldn't be trying to get everyone to respect us. Jesus wasn't respected when he was nailed to the cross. The Church has always flourished where it is most difficult to practice the faith. When it becomes difficult to be Catholic is when we are usually the most faithful and when our holiness grows. It's good to work to make sure that we are treated justly, like when unjust laws are passed, but to put us above criticism is a waste of time better spent uniting ourselves to Jesus.
Annie12 Posted April 7, 2012 Author Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1333742955' post='2413731'] You can jump up and down and try to cry that people are just morphing history for some sort of undetermined political agenda but you'd be wrong. Fact: Spanish dictators during WWII allied with Hitler and forced Catholic morals upon their population. Fact: Hitler's anti-Semitism was, in part, inspired by the old school blood libels first thought of by Catholic clergymen. Yes, German nationalism could not have risen without the Protestant Reformation, but the Catholic Church is far from blameless in the matter. As for your insistence that the Catholic Church isn't people, any faith group can claim that. Protestants will say their faith is based on the Bible, Muslims will claim the Quran, you claim teachings supposedly handed down from Christ himself. It's all the same. Doesn't let your religion off the hook for past events. [/quote] Your in denial and your wrong.
Annie12 Posted April 7, 2012 Author Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Jesus_lol' timestamp='1333774773' post='2413903'] Are you kidding me? seriously? "intellectual criticism is ok unless its about religion, then it is automatically OFFENSIVE ANTI RELIGION HATE SPEECH"?? and then you have the nerve to say [b]I [/b]am being "relative". Your cognitive dissonance is frankly impressive. [/quote] Yes. You never should attack beliefs that people are willing to die for; beliefs that they love more than their own lives. If you do, prepare for battle "Intellectual criticisms" should only be applied to politics. Religion doesn't go by the dirty rules politics does.. Plus, you wouldn't want your beliefs to be torn apart supported by only misconceptions. So, why do it to others? I have an example. If you make a racist comment about someone, you could just say that it was just words and therefore,could not have possibility hurt anyone by words. However, in truth, you hurt someone deeply and made them feel more distance from the people you represent (what ever that may be, religion, race, political party etc.). You may think this example is too distant from what we are talking about, but the truth is, people define themselves by what they believe, and when that is attacked, it feels like a personal attack on their character. And BTW, I said you can have your own beliefs about homosexuality last night. I was tired and while I still do think we have the right to belief what we want. I think that unless it goes against your morals to keep your mouth closed, then you really should try not to hurt anyone. Also, I have a few Gay friends so I'm not speaking from a far. I'm speaking from personal experience. I believe all people are loved by God and have a vocation that God himself has given them which would not be the way of life many homosexual people are living right now. Someones vocation is the happiest place where they could be in their lives. So, by turning down or not discovering their vocation, Homosexuals are really cheating themselves out of something unimaginably beautiful.
Anomaly Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1333804161' post='2413936'] Your in denial and your wrong. [/quote]Just thought I'd help you out with your debate here. Please don't consider it as intellectual criticism. Weather is rain, you need to use whether You're is the contraction for "you are". Your is a posessive pronoun. Since I'm non-catholic and you are, did I just commit an "anti-catholic" act?
Annie12 Posted April 7, 2012 Author Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Sister Marie' timestamp='1333803031' post='2413929'] I agree with what Lisa said about criticism. It is GOOD that we are criticized. Intellectual criticism, whether it be about actions the Church has been a part of or of doctrines and teachings, is a way to purify, grow in holiness, and realize our sinfulness and need for God. Right now in my archdiocese a trial is going on because of the sexual abuse of minors by clergy and because of the moving of those abusers from parish to parish. Are some of the people involved in this trial "anti-catholic"? Probably. Is the trial itself "anti-catholic"? No. It would be unjust for this trial not to happen. It wouldn't be happening to begin with if nothing wrong had been done by our hierarchy. I say this with a lot of love for the Church. The only way wounds are healed and sins forgiven is for them to be brought out into the light so that God can transform us. We sometimes think we are above criticism and the truth is that we are not. We should allow it to purify us. In the light of eternity - Christ gained our eternal life by suffering and dying. Why should we not also suffer and die? In this case it is a death of pride and of status... but it is still a death. In that sense, I do not see anti-Catholicism as something to fight against. Yes, we should protect our rights. No, we shouldn't be trying to get everyone to respect us. Jesus wasn't respected when he was nailed to the cross. The Church has always flourished where it is most difficult to practice the faith. When it becomes difficult to be Catholic is when we are usually the most faithful and when our holiness grows. It's good to work to make sure that we are treated justly, like when unjust laws are passed, but to put us above criticism is a waste of time better spent uniting ourselves to Jesus. [/quote] I completely agree with most of what you are saying, but anti-catholic comments aimed to hurt people, means that people are sinning. When someone says something knowingly and blatantly false about the church, then they are lying. I don't think we should encourage that because we would only be encouraging people to sin. I do think however that God permits anti-Catholicism as a way of helping the faithful grow stronger in their faith. However, I don't think God would encourage such behavior.
Sister Marie Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 Annie, no offense, but neither you nor I are in any position to decide the sinfulness of the actions of another person. Neither of us know what is in their heart and mind... only God does. You are obviously feeling very defensive about an incident which you haven't described to us in this thread and when people feel that way they often "demonize" the other. Instead of thinking about the other person as a human being; someone complex, with varied experiences, and on a journey just like the rest of us, that person becomes the bad guy, or the sinner, or the mean one. That is also a sin because it denies the dignity of the individual. It's also really counterproductive because you leave no room for dialogue. If I were someone who thought Catholics were crazy... none of your posts would make me feel differently or make me feel like I could ask questions or have a meaningful conversation with you. Your posts, to me, communicate "Don't say anything I don't like because it's a sin." People generally don't say things that they know are blatantly false. They may be false but most people who say them think there is some truth in their statements. No one said anything about encouraging ignorance... in fact, I stated that we should protect our rights. I'm sure God would not encourage such behavior but I'm also just as sure that he wouldn't encourage us to respond in this way either. If you would like to share what this is really about maybe all of us could help instead of debating the issue.
r2Dtoo Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1333804161' post='2413936'] Your in denial and your wrong. [/quote] What's so easy for you to say, is so easy for me to disprove. http://www.myjewishlearning.com/holidays/Jewish_Holidays/Passover/History/Medieval/Blood_Libels.shtml http://www.iiipublishing.com/religion/catholic/popes/pius_xi_franco.html So who is in denial now?
Annie12 Posted April 7, 2012 Author Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Sister Marie' timestamp='1333806414' post='2413942'] Annie, no offense, but neither you nor I are in any position to decide the sinfulness of the actions of another person. Neither of us know what is in their heart and mind... only God does. You are obviously feeling very defensive about an incident which you haven't described to us in this thread and when people feel that way they often "demonize" the other. Instead of thinking about the other person as a human being; someone complex, with varied experiences, and on a journey just like the rest of us, that person becomes the bad guy, or the sinner, or the mean one. That is also a sin because it denies the dignity of the individual. It's also really counterproductive because you leave no room for dialogue. If I were someone who thought Catholics were crazy... none of your posts would make me feel differently or make me feel like I could ask questions or have a meaningful conversation with you. Your posts, to me, communicate "Don't say anything I don't like because it's a sin." People generally don't say things that they know are blatantly false. They may be false but most people who say them think there is some truth in their statements. No one said anything about encouraging ignorance... in fact, I stated that we should protect our rights. I'm sure God would not encourage such behavior but I'm also just as sure that he wouldn't encourage us to respond in this way either. If you would like to share what this is really about maybe all of us could help instead of debating the issue. [/quote] There is no indecent rather I live in a very secular/ anti-catholic place and I am one of maybe 4 young adult in my parish and there are no youth groups and I am also one of 2 Catholics in my school the other being my brother. I am feeling like no one is hearing me. Of course I know God is the only one who can know what is really on the hearts and minds of others but I am just getting frustrated by some of the users here who insist that anti-Catholicism doesn't exists in the way I am describing it and instead want to say that it is an "intellectual criticism" . I guess what I am saying isn't coming across like I meant it. my apologies if that is the case . I didn't want to turn this post into a debate, hence the open mic forum. Furthermore, I didn't want to sound Mad. Sorry if I do. I literally just wanted to know how do we confront anti-Catholicism. However, somehow we got off topic and started trying to define anti-Catholicism. But any who, how do we confront it? All year long in my history class for example I have come up against hurtful statements uttered by my teacher or a classmate . I just want to know what can I do instead of sounding like I'm about to choke someone (which, for the record I wound never do). I would like some feedback from Catholics so I don't start a useless debate again. Thanks. And for the record I am not mad I am very happy right now! lol!
r2Dtoo Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1333809578' post='2413952'] There is no indecent rather I live in a very secular/ anti-catholic place and I am one of maybe 4 young adult in my parish and there are no youth groups and I am also one of 2 Catholics in my school the other being my brother. I am feeling like no one is hearing me. Of course I know God is the only one who can know what is really on the hearts and minds of others but I am just getting frustrated by some of the users here who insist that anti-Catholicism doesn't exists in the way I am describing it and instead want to say that it is an "intellectual criticism" . I guess what I am saying isn't coming across like I meant it. my apologies if that is the case . I didn't want to turn this post into a debate, hence the open mic forum. Furthermore, I didn't want to sound Mad. Sorry if I do. I literally just wanted to know how do we confront anti-Catholicism. However, somehow we got off topic and started trying to define anti-Catholicism. But any who, how do we confront it? All year long in my history class for example I have come up against hurtful statements uttered by my teacher or a classmate . I just want to know what can I do instead of sounding like I'm about to choke someone (which, for the record I wound never do). I would like some feedback from Catholics so I don't start a useless debate again. Thanks. And for the record I am not mad I am very happy right now! lol! [/quote] If that's all you wanted than you should have said so from the beginning. No one here is psychic and knows what you meant by anti-Catholicism.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='Sister Marie' timestamp='1333806414' post='2413942'] Annie, no offense, but neither you nor I are in any position to decide the sinfulness of the actions of another person. Neither of us know what is in their heart and mind... only God does. [/quote] Sister, I respectfully take issue with this. We judge actions, not hearts.Culpability and Judgement are determined by God ( and the court system if applicable) but we are certainly capable of saying an action such as murder or rape or theft is a sin.
cmotherofpirl Posted April 7, 2012 Posted April 7, 2012 [quote name='r2Dtoo' timestamp='1333809720' post='2413953'] If that's all you wanted than you should have said so from the beginning. No one here is psychic and knows what you meant by anti-Catholicism. [/quote] Ah no. Sometimes what we want to discuss is floating around in our mind and it takes a discussion to clarify precisely the issue at hand. There is no need to chastise the OP while she herself is working it out. A bit of charity is in order from you.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now