brianthephysicist Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [url="http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_SUPREME_COURT_HEALTH_CARE?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2012-06-28-10-17-22"]http://hosted.ap.org/dynamic/stories/U/US_SUPREME_COURT_HEALTH_CARE?SITE=AP&SECTION=HOME&TEMPLATE=DEFAULT&CTIME=2012-06-28-10-17-22[/url] Sad day. We've got even [i]more[/i] praying to do now.
Clare~Therese Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 But Congress could still overturn it or whatever, right? That's what my brother said. But [u]yes we should keep praying[/u]. And if it just continues to be upheld into the future, then like the Apostles in jail we could "[i]rejoice for they had been found worthy to suffer for the Name of Jesus[/i]."
Papist Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 Judge Roberts sided with the Libs. Again, Bush failed us.
Annie12 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 i was SO surprised to hear that because I though since he was the conservative one, he would know better.
Papist Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [img]http://sphotos.xx.fbcdn.net/hphotos-ash4/428416_10151078604420530_1718378406_n.jpg[/img]
eagle_eye222001 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 This is greatly troubling for the future of America. It seems this was largely upheld due to Congress's ability to tax, however has the American people ever been taxed on the absence of something? Also the ruling makes Obama a HUGE LIAR on raising taxes. He claimed he wouldn't. Well here you go Mr. President. A whole Supreme Court ruling stating that you raised taxes. Robert's said in the ruling that [quote]We do not consider whether the Act embodies sound policies. That judgment is entrusted to the Nation’s elected leaders. We ask only whether Congress has the power under the[/quote] Also, [quote]Congress may also “lay and collect Taxes, Duties, Imposts and Excises, to pay the Debts and provide for thecommon Defence and general Welfare of the United States.†U. S. Const., Art. I, §8, cl. 1. Put simply, Congress may tax and spend.[/quote] ------ The ruling does seem correct. I am not sure how to argue against the power of Congress to tax. However this huge expansion of the federal government is quite troubling.
PhuturePriest Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 Of course we can overturn it, but will we? We have been trying to overturn Roe vs. Wade since it was first parseed over forty years ago. It's not a matter of can we, it's a matter of will it even be possible? Overturning things requires a lot, and it seems every time we try it doesn't work.
PhuturePriest Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 The worst part is it came down to an apparently devout and pious Catholic guy and he [i]voted it in!!!! [/i]Oh, what a proud day to be thrown in the group of "American Catholics"...
Brother Adam Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 I have been trying to figure out why I didn't feel as angry as I thought I should have when the announcement was made this morning. I think I agree with this: [url="http://www.redstate.com/erick/2012/06/28/im-not-down-on-john-roberts/"]http://www.redstate....n-john-roberts/[/url] 1. The individual mandate is a tax, even though Obama said it is not. 2. Roberts called him out on his lie and told us it is a tax, but because it is a tax it is constitutional. 3. Obama just gave middle class Americans one of the biggest tax increases in history. 4. Democrats lost one of their main rallying points to keep Obama in office if the courts struck down the ACA. 5. This is still a hugely unpopular bill. How do you get rid of a hugely unpopular bill? Vote for new executive and legislative leaders. Ideally we will see a GOP run house, senate, and executive branch in November. That in itself though will have problems because: The Catholic Church is not opposed to health care reform. As Catholics we are not opposed to the ACA as reform, except for its significant problematic portions that need to be struck out of the law. Roberts is forcing the American people to deal with that. I'm still forming my opinion on this though and [color=#ff0000]admit I could be completely wrong on the reasoning in the article. We need time to digest this.[/color]
Seven77 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1340899529' post='2449980'] Judge Roberts sided with the Libs. [i]Again, Bush failed us.[/i] [/quote] epically so.
4588686 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [quote name='Papist' timestamp='1340899529' post='2449980'] Judge Roberts sided with the Libs. Again, Bush failed us. [/quote] Bush didn't fail you. This is one of the most conservative courts in decades. Maybe not every law that you dislike is unconstitutional.
cmotherofpirl Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [url="http://www.usccb.org/news/2012/12-119.cfm"]http://www.usccb.org/news/2012/12-119.cfm[/url]
eagle_eye222001 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 (edited) [size=4][quote name='eagle_eye222001' timestamp='1340903078' post='2450006'] ..... The ruling does seem correct. I am not sure how to argue against the power of Congress to tax. However this huge expansion of the federal government is quite troubling. [/quote] Actually I know exactly how to argue against it. [url="http://www.supremecourt.gov/opinions/11pdf/11-393c3a2.pdf"]And I quote the dissent[/url] [quote]This case is in one respect difficult: it presents two questions of first impression. The first of those is whether failure to engage in economic activity (the purchase of health insurance) is subject to regulation under the Commerce Clause. Failure to act does result in an effect on commerce, and hence might be said to come under this Court’s “affecting commerce†criterion of Commerce Clause jurisprudence. But in none of its decisions has this Court extended the Clause that far. The second questionis whether the congressional power to tax and spend, U. S. Const., Art. I, §8, cl. 1, permits the conditioning of a State’s continued receipt of all funds under a marseive state-administered federal welfare program upon its acceptance of an expansion to that program. [b]Several of our opinions have suggested that the power to tax and spend [/b] [b]cannot be used to coerce state administration of a federal program, but we have never found a law enacted under [/b] [b]the spending power to be coercive.[/b] Those questions are difficult. ...The case is easy and straightforward, however, in another respect. What is absolutely clear, affirmed by the text of the 1789 Constitution, by the Tenth Amendment ratified in 1791, and by innumerable cases of ours in the 220 years since, is that there are structural limits upon federal power—upon what it can prescribe with respect to private conduct, and upon what it can impose upon the sovereign States. Whatever may be the conceptual limits upon the Commerce Clause and upon the power to tax and spend, they cannot be such as will enable the Federal Government to regulate all private conduct and to compel the States to function as administrators of federal programs. That clear principle carries the day here. [b] The striking case of Wickard v. Filburn, 317 U. S. 111 (1942), which[/b] [b]held that the economic activity of growing wheat, even for one’s own consumption, affected commerce sufficiently[/b] [b]that it could be regulated[/b], always has been regarded as the ne plus ultra of expansive Commerce Clause jurisprudence. To go beyond that, and to say the failure to grow wheat (which is not an economic activity, or any activity at all) nonetheless affects commerce and therefore can be federally regulated, is to make mere breathing in and out the [b]basis for federal prescription and to extend federal power to virtually all human activity.[/b] [/quote][/size] Edited June 28, 2012 by eagle_eye222001
eagle_eye222001 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1340906092' post='2450020'] Bush didn't fail you. This is one of the most conservative courts in decades. Maybe not every law that you dislike is unconstitutional. [/quote] Have you bought your quota of broccoli today? Or are you going to pay the tax so you don't have to?
4588686 Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [quote name='eagle_eye222001' timestamp='1340906790' post='2450028'] Have you bought your quota of broccoli today? Or are you going to pay the tax so you don't have to? [/quote] Seriously, could you shut the little Sean Hannity dwelling in you head up for like five floopying seconds and act like grown up? The constituion is not a logically perfect model. There are a number of really difficult issues at stake here and there was no totally clear solution to this suit. I do not like Obamacare. And I took the constitutional arguments against it far more seriously than almost any other communist pinko pansy that I know. This bill was arguably unconstitutional. It was also arguably constitutional. The USSC did a good job here. As Bro Adam pointed out they called a spade a spade in showing that this was basically a tax. By doing so they avoided the sticky issue of how the commerce clause is limited. They made a very reasonable ruling out of a very complicated issue. Just because you dislike it doesn't mean that Roberts failed you. His job as a judge, and this is something conservatives used o know, is not to be a reflexively partisan figure. That's not to say that Scalia is a reflexively partisan actor. His concerns are also very reasonable. My complaint isn't with any of the conservative justices here. It's with people like you.
filius_angelorum Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 If there were not conditions under which an ordinary individual could be exempt from the tax, e.g., the mandate would not have been upheld. I would have liked to see this law struck down on religious liberty grounds, but these were not before the court today. Roberts has also successfully maneuvered into the position of being to dictate the interpretation of the Health Care Law, which is a good thing if a religious liberty issue comes before the court on this law. The conservatives will be united in any ruling that limits the impact of ObamaCare.
Slappo Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 As one of the other judges stated. The Administration made great effort to phrase the monetary payment as a penalty not a tax. It should have been overturned and the Administration required to start back at square 1 and rephrase it as a tax for it to parse.
Papist Posted June 28, 2012 Posted June 28, 2012 [quote name='Hasan' timestamp='1340906092' post='2450020'] Bush didn't fail you. This is one of the most conservative courts in decades. Maybe not every law that you dislike is unconstitutional. [/quote] I doubt it.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now