Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Hey There! So... Wanna Talk?


Recommended Posts

MissScripture
Posted

[quote name='ContemporaryCaflicCrusader' timestamp='1350436680' post='2494129']
You guys got this all wrong that makes her look desperate. I'm no social juggernaut but every time I've known a girl to make the first step in towards being more than in "The friend zone" it goes to pot. Either he rejected it (Me included) or it went to his head. This guy doesn't seem likely to let it go to his head but he might take it as creepy or something. It's been the center of more than one romantic dramedy where the guy is ridiculously oblivious to her being this into him. If this is really God's plan it'll work out and maybe you'll make it a novel while your second one with him is in the oven. A technique I used in high school for a different situation that could work here I don't know it might not, is to tell the gossip queen socially. Then everyone knows you like him.
[/quote]
Well, it worked for me. I told a guy I liked him and now I'm married to him. :|

Posted

[IMG]http://i1068.photobucket.com/albums/u443/hilpthop/asdf_zps11d49ad7.jpg[/IMG]

Posted

[quote name='MissScripture' timestamp='1350437239' post='2494132']
Well, it worked for me. I told a guy I liked him and now I'm married to him. :|
[/quote]
THAT JUST HAPPENED! DID THAT BLOW YOUR MIND?

Basilisa Marie
Posted

If you want to begin a grown-up relationship, you don't start it by playing by high-school rules.

Posted

I say you never ever ask him...

That way, you'll never know...

And you can always wonder what could have been.

Communicating feelings is so hard, anyways....

To Jesus Through Mary
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1350430204' post='2494093']
You appear to be obsessing. I obsess, sometimes. It's perfectly human. [b]Have you anyone who isn't an internet acquaintance to consult[/b]?
[/quote]

This.

Annie- you have posted about this dude several times seeking the same bit of advice. Yet you never take or even like the advice that is offered. Maybe you should talk to your friends at school. Maybe you might like their advice better. Since you feel like God is telling you not to tell him, as I see it you are pretty much left with two options.

1- follow the earlier advice. Get busy, have fun, enjoy life. It is meant to be it will be. He will be far more attracted to you the more confident you are with being just you.
2. Or two, continue to fixate on this guy and let it smell of elderberries all of the fun out of your life. You can continue to be super concerned with what he thinks and "social suicide". (which really, everyone is far to concerned about how they appear socially to be concerned about how anyone else looks)

Enjoy these carefree times now. They do not last forever... well until we get to heaven, Lord willing. Then I guess they will last forever. Then all the things we cling to will seem so silly. ;)

Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1350430171' post='2494092']
AC I've actually tried that... doesn't work....[s] God[/s] I doesn't want me to tell him... I've prayed about it....

[/quote]


fxd.

Posted

[mod]Edited for profanity. - dUSt[/mod]

Posted

Let's try this again with less cursing.

I met this girl once. We made out. I asked her if she wanted to get lunch the next day. We did. We had a very nice lunch with lots of talking and clicking. Then she explained to me that she had just broken up with her boyfriend and wanted to focus on getting through this breakup rather than on a long term relationship. Did that rejection sting a little? Sure. When I broke up with my girlfriend she cried. A lot. Did that sting her? Yep. People get hurt and get rejected all the time. And we all learn to get over it. So you have a win-win situation here. You can talk to this boy and get this boy or you can talk to this boy and start down the wonderful road of learning to deal with rejection. It's not social suicide. You're friends will also get rejected and dumped. This boy will also get rejected and dumped. In fact, maybe someday he'll even get dumped by you once you realize that he's just a guy and not some transcendent being. And nobody should know about it, anyway. Unless this guy is a total cretin or you pronounce your love in public.


Also, get a sassy gay friend.

Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1350430431' post='2494097']
This was not the answer I expected.... oh dear me! I think I could use prayers more than anything right now... PLEASE!!!
[/quote]

then you're not "all ears".


smell of elderberries it up and tell him how you feel

Posted

Everyone can shut the Hell up; Hasan won this thread.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

Here's my advice:

Hide in a closet....and the situation will magically resolve itself.





:|









Is that the advice you want?


You can keep the status quo and the following two likely scenarios happen:

[b]A.[/b] He meets another girl, introduces her to you, leaving you crashing and burning.
[b]B.[/b] He moves on with life leaving you dying in a world of unstable emotions.

[b]Conclusion:[/b] You spend the rest of your life asking yourself "what would have happened if I had said something...." Can you live with this result?


or...

You can bet the current relationship for a higher payoff with the following likely results.

[b]1.[/b] He rejects you. Painful result. But this begins the road to healing....so in that respect, this scenario loses in the short term but wins in the long term.

[b]2.[/b] He doesn't reject you. Touchdown St. Louis! All systems go.

[b]3.[/b] Social Suicide (this may apply to both scenarios 1 and 2. This assumes that you can always keep all relationships in harmony. This is false. Life happens. People come and go. You can't freeze life....and if you could.....the life would be a false one. Throw a social grenade before someone else does. At least this way, you get to cause chaos.


Roll the beaver dam dice. It's the quickest way to healing for whatever happens. [b]The chances for success if you stay quiet are next to zero.[/b]

Posted

Prayer isn't everthing when you are "discerning" something. The word discernment is thrown around so willy nilly. God gave us an intellect, He gave us reason, and He gave us the cardinal virtues. Use those.

Prudence, fortitude, temperance, and justice. Is constantly thinking about this guy prudent or temperant? Is not bringing it up to him prudent? Are you practicing fortitude in your patience and ability to set aside what you know to be irrational emotions? Stop praying about a particular guy and start praying for the grace to better use and grow in the cardinal virtues.

God never sent a butterfly and told me to marry my wife. I prayed and [b]had peace [/b]about the [u]decision that I made[/u], and decided that it was a [u]prudent decision [/u]to move our relationship beyond courtship and into a lifelong commitment.

Posted

[quote name='Basilisa Marie' timestamp='1350436121' post='2494127']
You're confusing what you want with what you think God wants. Your desires are clouding your ability to see what God wants. You're also idolizing this guy. Not a good way to start any relationship.

Come on, dear, what did you expect? :) You need to stop obsessing over him. Honestly, even if you WERE going to start a relationship with him, you need to become more comfortable with yourself, around him, and STOP putting him on the "perfect holiness" pedestal, otherwise it'd end in disaster.

So in order to stop obsessing over him, I'd recommend telling him how you feel. Either he won't reciprocate your feelings and you can get a start on getting over the crush, or he'll reciprocate your feelings and you can get starting on really getting to know each other as real people. Either result would be good for you. :)
[/quote]
sorry but I'm not idolizing him... this whole thing has brought me deeper in my prayer life. You don't know the whole story since you are sitting at your computer at home (or where ever)... I don't do anything like this without praying about it A LOT! So, I will have to disagree with you here. I'm gonna tell him... I just need to get up the courage...

Posted

FYI my questions were honest rhetorical questions for you to think about. There wasn't some sort of passive-aggressive hint at anything :).

Posted

[quote name='Slappo' timestamp='1350516114' post='2494234']
Prayer isn't everthing when you are "discerning" something. The word discernment is thrown around so willy nilly. God gave us an intellect, He gave us reason, and He gave us the cardinal virtues. Use those.

Prudence, fortitude, temperance, and justice. Is constantly thinking about this guy prudent or temperant? Is not bringing it up to him prudent? Are you practicing fortitude in your patience and ability to set aside what you know to be irrational emotions? Stop praying about a particular guy and start praying for the grace to better use and grow in the cardinal virtues.

God never sent a butterfly and told me to marry my wife. I prayed and [b]had peace [/b]about the [u]decision that I made[/u], and decided that it was a [u]prudent decision [/u]to move our relationship beyond courtship and into a lifelong commitment.
[/quote]


This is where I would leave a prop...




...IF I HAD ANY!


[img]http://farm7.static.flickr.com/6060/6351501945_8c3a2fcb5b.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='MIkolbe' timestamp='1350438100' post='2494141']
I say you never ever ask him...

That way, you'll never know...

And you can always wonder what could have been.

Communicating feelings is so hard, anyways....
[/quote]


where arethe props?

Posted

would I come off as unstable if I told him I prayed 2 rosaries a day for him for the past month? or do you think that he would find this to be sweet?

Posted

[quote name='Annie12' timestamp='1350518085' post='2494244']
would I come off as unstable if I told him I prayed 2 rosaries a day for him for the past month? or do you think that he would find this to be sweet?
[/quote]
In most contexts that would come off as sounding kind of clingy and/or desperate. Unless [i]perhaps[/i] you already had a primarily spiritual, very close relationship. And even then...

Posted

Annie, I do not think there is any advice that people can give you. You have started multiple threads about this guy, and each time you've been given similar advice, only to go and open another thread. It's as if you're hoping that one day everyone will give you the answers you want.

This is obsessive. Certain things that you write about this guy, especially your question about the rosaries, suggests that you don't really know him at all. How would we know whether he finds the idea of being prayed for in that way sweet or creepy? We've never met him. If you knew him well, you'd be able to answer the question. But you don't know. And this is what people mean when they say you seem to be idolising this guy: you are building up a fantasy of marriage around him without actually knowing him at all.

This to me looks like a teenage crush. They often involve obsession. They're often painful. I had a bad one myself, only in my case the guy was actually a close friend and we hung out together a lot. And I practically drove my poor friends crazy by wanting to analyse his every word and move with them to try and work out if maybe he liked me too. I spent hours thinking about it. My friends told me that I would eventually get over it, and I felt really hurt. They just didn't understand - this wasn't any old crush, this was real love, I was sure! Eventually I plucked up the courage to tell him how I felt. He didn't reciprocate. It hit me like a ton of bricks at the time. I felt embarrassed and foolish, but I picked myself up and moved on and my friends were right. I got over it. Today he and I are still good friends.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...