Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Clapping After Homily


Recommended Posts

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted (edited)

This happened today during Mass, and I for one think it is completely inappropriate during the liturgy. It is way too distracting and takes the focus off of the sacrifice that is about to happen.

The deacon gave his homily, and came down into the pew area and talked to a little girl, and told her a story, and then addressed the rest of us, still standing "across the border," if that makes sense.

I'm not trying to start a huge debate (else I'd have posted in the debate board), but I am wondering what y'all think. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

Should clapping ensue after what one may perceive as a particularly good homily, or not?

I just don't think we should be exalting the servant of God, but rather focus on the exaltation of God Himself, which happens on the altar.

If this needs to move to the debate board, I apologize.

Edited by ToJesusMyHeart
ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

I don't know if I put this in the right phorum. I need to study phatmass rules more.

Open Mic? Debate Table? Who knows... :cry:

Posted

No clapping in Mass. Ever. I've seen the idiots applaud the choir. It's not a performance, you jackasses. I don't like applause for the Veterans, or the married couples who have withered into prunes together, either. No applause. You want applause, go to one of those stupid auditorium non-denominational churches.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1353876457' post='2516386']
No clapping in Mass. Ever. I've seen the idiots applaud the choir. It's not a performance, you jackasses. I don't like applause for the Veterans, or the married couples who have withered into prunes together, either. No applause. You want applause, go to one of those stupid auditorium non-denominational churches.
[/quote]

Have I told you how much I love you?

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1353876457' post='2516386']
No clapping in Mass. Ever. I've seen the idiots applaud the choir. It's not a performance, you jackasses. I don't like applause for the Veterans, or the married couples who have withered into prunes together, either. No applause. You want applause, go to one of those stupid auditorium non-denominational churches.
[/quote]

You rock. It's like fingernails on a chalkboard for me (to put it extremely mildly) when people applaud in Mass. I've never before experienced clapping after the homily, but my home parish (when I'm not at school), ALWAYS claps after the choir sings the Recessional song at the end of mass. Sometimes it makes me angry...other times I pray the "forgive them, Lord, they know not what they do," and scurry to the quiet chapel for thanksgiving.

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

Would it be inappropriate for me to talk to the priest about this, though? I only hesitate because it's not my home parish; I was just visiting.

Also, I have visited this parish before (sometime last year), and in their bulletin, it had an alarming section on "How to receive Communion."

It said in there (not verbatim), but something along the lines of "The proper posture for Communion is to stand. It is not appropriate to kneel for Communion in the United States."

I was very upset to read that, because it is false. I prayed about it, but did not write any letters. Thankfully, when I checked the bulletin today, they had removed that section, and had nothing mentioning how to receive the Sacrament. So maybe just praying about the applause would be the best course of action.

I have a feeling I put this in the wrong phorum.

Posted

To quote [url="http://theoniondome.com/category/father-vasiliy/"]Fr. Vasily Vasileivich[/url], "IS OUTRAGE!" Yep. That pretty much sums up my thoughts toward the matter.

Posted

[quote name='ToJesusMyHeart' timestamp='1353877640' post='2516397']
Would it be inappropriate for me to talk to the priest about this, though? I only hesitate because it's not my home parish; I was just visiting.

[/quote]
It might not be welcomed, but oh well.

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted

In the United States I would say that clapping is not appropriate within the liturgy, I would accept that in some cultural parishes there MAY be a place for clapping most commonly during the music. I don't see how after the homily it is appropriate.

Posted

I would never applaud a homily and I would feel uncomfortable at a parish where that happened. It isn't a speech and the focus shouldn't be on the priest anyway. At my church the opposite happens: after the homily there is always a short silence before we rise to pray the Creed, to give people time to reflect on what was said.

When people are baptised and confirmed, however, at the end of the Mass (just before the blessing) Father will say, "Let's welcome them," and then we applaud. That has never felt bad to me, although I know others might disagree.

Posted

Me. I disagree. Welcome them like a Catholic: stare at them, and then try to run them down in the parking lot.

Posted

[quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1353883909' post='2516445']stare at them, and then try to run them down in the parking lot.
[/quote]

What??? I thought initiation ought to consist of assigning them to some sort of parish volunteer project reserved for such cases.

Posted

I am surprised this has not been posted yet. But glad that I get to do it.

[img]http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_RofyIEoc2xA/TBbB65WedcI/AAAAAAAAAIQ/DX7ew6mfLbg/s1600/Applause+quote+-+Benedict+XVI.jpg[/img]

Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353884729' post='2516461']
I am surprised this has not been posted yet. But glad that I get to do it.

[img]http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_RofyIEoc2xA/TBbB65WedcI/AAAAAAAAAIQ/DX7ew6mfLbg/s1600/Applause+quote+-+Benedict+XVI.jpg[/img]
[/quote]

You beat me to it good sir.

Posted

[quote name='ToJesusMyHeart' timestamp='1353877183' post='2516394']

You rock. It's like fingernails on a chalkboard for me (to put it extremely mildly) when people applaud in Mass. I've never before experienced clapping after the homily, but my home parish (when I'm not at school), ALWAYS claps after the choir sings the Recessional song at the end of mass. Sometimes it makes me angry...other times I pray the "forgive them, Lord, they know not what they do," and scurry to the quiet chapel for thanksgiving.
[/quote]

Unless I'm mistaken, after the recessional wouldn't be terrible. Still wouldn't be something I'd join in or like, but I think the Mass would already be over. Iunno though, there's people here who are much more knowledgeable than I here.

FutureCarmeliteClaire
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353884729' post='2516461']
I am surprised this has not been posted yet. But glad that I get to do it.

[img]http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_RofyIEoc2xA/TBbB65WedcI/AAAAAAAAAIQ/DX7ew6mfLbg/s1600/Applause+quote+-+Benedict+XVI.jpg[/img]
[/quote]
Bu-bu-bu-t I was gonna post this! :)

ToJesusMyHeart
Posted

Thank you guys very much.

I think I should email that image to the priest/deacon. That way they can be mad at Papa Bene, instead of a silly visiting college kid who wants to take us back to the stone ages.

Posted

That is so sad. When we worship God, it should never be like a performance. It's not about us, or entertainment. It's about God.

LouisvilleFan
Posted

[quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353884729' post='2516461']
I am surprised this has not been posted yet. But glad that I get to do it.

[img]http://2.bp.blogspot.com/_RofyIEoc2xA/TBbB65WedcI/AAAAAAAAAIQ/DX7ew6mfLbg/s1600/Applause+quote+-+Benedict+XVI.jpg[/img]
[/quote]


True that. I am curious, though, about the situation where applause breaks out in the liturgy because of a divine achievement? A Baptism is one case that seems very appropriate to me, not because of anything the baptized person has done, but out of joy for what God has done to them.

Posted

I don't know, spontaneous applause at Mass is probably not the hill to die on. We had a couple celebrating 70 years together at Mass last Sunday and honestly it didn't bother me when people applauded, although I never do clap in church. If someone wanted to make a big stink about it, it would just come off like they were a joyless liturgy shrew going around looking for violations so they can have the pleasure of writing a ticket.

ToJesusMyHeart, do you happen to be a recent convert or revert? When I was a baby Catholic I was much more intolerant of human weakness in celebrating the liturgy. And yes, all the small mistakes and inaccuracies made me angry and to be honest I took pleasure in my anger, as it made me feel very superior. As I matured in faith I grew to understand that the liturgy on earth was given to men, not angels and therefore it will never be celebrated as perfectly as the heavenly liturgy. Yes you are correct about these details but don't allow these small things to actually disturb your peace. This can become a real spiritual problem if you let it.

Remember that the people in this parish are like little children in God's eyes. Small ones are often eager to express joy and love but often they don't do it quite the proper way, I remember one time around my birthday I came home and one of my little cousins had made me a surprise party - there were streamers everywhere, glitter everywhere, the kids weren't tall enough to hang the banners up high so they were taped at about stomach height on me... it was a big mess but they had good intentions! They needed to be taught the BEST way to celebrate but in the meantime if I expressed disdain I would have been very hurtful, and there's no point getting angry about it either. You just clean up the mess and show them the tidy way to do it in the future :) So yes write to the priest but don't do it in a finger-shaking way. And work on that anger, bring it to confession and/or spiritual direction if need be.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...