ToJesusMyHeart Posted November 27, 2012 Author Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1353981095' post='2517342'] ToJesusMyHeart, do you happen to be a recent convert or revert? [/quote] I reverted 4 years ago. Is that considered recent? [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1353981095' post='2517342'] Remember that the people in this parish are like little children in God's eyes. Small ones are often eager to express joy and love but often they don't do it quite the proper way, I remember one time around my birthday I came home and one of my little cousins had made me a surprise party - there were streamers everywhere, glitter everywhere, the kids weren't tall enough to hang the banners up high so they were taped at about stomach height on me... it was a big mess but they had good intentions! They needed to be taught the BEST way to celebrate but in the meantime if I expressed disdain I would have been very hurtful, and there's no point getting angry about it either. You just clean up the mess and show them the tidy way to do it in the future So yes write to the priest but don't do it in a finger-shaking way. And work on that anger, bring it to confession and/or spiritual direction if need be. [/quote] That was a really helpful analogy. Thank you. And I have told my spiritual director about this; she basically said what you said, but without the cool analogy. I have come to understand that these people usually don't know that what they are doing is problematic, and I recognize their dignity as children of God, but I'm still upset when the sanctity of the liturgy is disturbed and disrupted by unnecessary clapping for human achievements. Sigh.
Winchester Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Maggie' timestamp='1353981095' post='2517342'] I don't know, spontaneous applause at Mass is probably not the hill to die on. [/quote] I will not die on the hill. I will stand at the top of the hill, drenched in blood, surrounded by corpses.
TheresaThoma Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 I dislike applause* during mass. The one time I think it is somewhat ok is during the Rite of Welcoming and Reception. At the end of the Rite Father will invite the congregation to welcome the new candidates and catechumens with applause. Which I think is a good way of showing the new candidates and catechumens support. Applause after a homily...though, not cool. *note I said applause not clapping.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted November 27, 2012 Author Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='TheresaThoma' timestamp='1353989330' post='2517433'] *note I said applause not clapping. [/quote] Please explain the difference with regards to appropriateness during Mass.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='LouisvilleFan' timestamp='1353977905' post='2517296'] True that. I am curious, though, about the situation where applause breaks out in the liturgy because of a divine achievement? A Baptism is one case that seems very appropriate to me, not because of anything the baptized person has done, but out of joy for what God has done to them. [/quote] IMO, it could be worse, but it is not ideal. I think we as a Church have better ways of praising God, for instance some of our most beautiful chanted hymns.
Selah Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 [quote name='Nihil Obstat' timestamp='1353994946' post='2517519'] IMO, it could be worse, but it is not ideal. I think we as a Church have better ways of praising God, for instance some of our most beautiful chanted hymns. [/quote] Yesh. http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=mS_6RAEtdXI
DiscerningCatholic Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 (edited) [quote name='Winchester' timestamp='1353876457' post='2516386'] No clapping in Mass. Ever. I've seen the idiots applaud the choir. It's not a performance, you jackasses. I don't like applause for the Veterans, or the married couples who have withered into prunes together, either. No applause. You want applause, go to one of those stupid auditorium non-denominational churches. [/quote] Herp derp. This happened on Sunday. Our choir did a fantastic version of the Latin Gloria (for Christ the King) and some old dude decided to try and get everyone to clap. One other person joined in and the rest of the congregation just stood there awkwardly. They clap after the Communion song about 50% of the time. The choir just stands there, not sure exactly how to respond. It's super awkward though, because our church is super traditional and we use Latin and our priest faces the tabernacle for the majority of the Mass and we have a huge pipe organ and our Communion songs are usually songs like "Adoramus Te" or "Panis Angelicus" or "Adoro Te" and other songs of that nature. It's just wrong to have these old f.arts clapping after the Communion song. The Mass isn't some kind of choral exhibition where you show up just to hear the a.wesome choir (our choir really is a.wesome). ETA: I don't think I've ever seen applause after the homily. Also, this is my first post in this board! Edited November 27, 2012 by DiscerningCatholic
elizabeth09 Posted November 27, 2012 Posted November 27, 2012 At my parish, at the noon time mass, it seems that every one claps. My family and I never clap. We never been to a mass that people clap for a while.
jumpfrog Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 Maybe they did it cause the deacon was talking to the little girl...likely they just wanted to applaud her for doing a good job talking to him or whatever. I thought Maggie really answered this spot on...anyway, as a visitor, maybe just give them the benefit of the doubt that applause is not a regular occurrence.
Maggyie Posted November 29, 2012 Posted November 29, 2012 Herp derp. This happened on Sunday. Our choir did a fantastic version of the Latin Gloria (for Christ the King) and some old dude decided to try and get everyone to clap. One other person joined in and the rest of the congregation just stood there awkwardly. They clap after the Communion song about 50% of the time. The choir just stands there, not sure exactly how to respond. It's super awkward though, because our church is super traditional and we use Latin and our priest faces the tabernacle for the majority of the Mass and we have a huge pipe organ and our Communion songs are usually songs like "Adoramus Te" or "Panis Angelicus" or "Adoro Te" and other songs of that nature. It's just wrong to have these old f.arts clapping after the Communion song. The Mass isn't some kind of choral exhibition where you show up just to hear the a.wesome choir (our choir really is a.wesome). ETA: I don't think I've ever seen applause after the homily. Also, this is my first post in this board! :w00t: Now, do you think Jesus is more displeased by applause for the choir that sings His praise, or by you referring to these elderly people who have kept the faith for so many years as "these old f.arts." The external things about your parish are lovely but you must understand that pipe organs, Latin and other things like that are empty and meaningless if they are only externals! With age comes rigidity, stubbornness and often senility... and perhaps no one has ever explained to the two, why applause is frowned upon. It could be that the senior man is advanced in the spiritual life, and draws close to the heart of Jesus, although he is liturgically illiterate. Be gentle as Jesus is gentle :)
DiscerningCatholic Posted November 29, 2012 Posted November 29, 2012 With age comes rigidity, stubbornness and often senility... and perhaps no one has ever explained to the two, why applause is frowned upon. It could be that the senior man is advanced in the spiritual life, and draws close to the heart of Jesus, although he is liturgically illiterate. Be gentle as Jesus is gentle :) Fr. Brown only explains that he doesn't want clapping and why he doesn't want clapping almost every other week... These are the same people who stand up during the Eucharistic prayer, though, so it really shouldn't surprise me. :|
PadrePioOfPietrelcino Posted December 5, 2012 Posted December 5, 2012 http://www.patheos.com/blogs/deaconsbench/2012/12/when-its-appropriate-to-clap-at-mass-a-handy-list/ Thought this might fit in with this discussion good ;)
Jacen Marx Posted January 3, 2013 Posted January 3, 2013 Clapping during Mass is ridiculous. Even more so when you are clapping for a homily or a choir. Excuse me but aren't we at Mass to worship God? We are not there to honor some other person. If the homily was good or if the singing was good tell them after Mass, it's what I do.
cmaD2006 Posted January 3, 2013 Posted January 3, 2013 (edited) These are the same people who stand up during the Eucharistic prayer, though, so it really shouldn't surprise me. :| Did you consider that maybe these people do have a hard time kneeling? If you can't kneel, technically you are supposed to stand. There are times that for me kneeling becomes painful (and at that point so does prolonged standing). I then do the next logical thing -- sit. It isn't a sign of my irreverence, it is a sign of my physical weakness. At least even through the pain I am at Mass, so that should count for something ;) We can be so judgmental at times that the other person is forgotten. Mercy is always called for -- it is easy to judge without knowing all of the facts. It is true -- some people may choose to stand because of laziness, or even worse a lack of reverence for the Blessed Sacrament. Some may stand because of ignorance (and lack of catechesis). Others may stand (or even sit) for a perfectly valid reason. So I play it safe -- unless I know the person, (or can tell that the person is new, or never has been at Mass, etc) I let it be. And if the person is new, then I with a smile on my face and with gentleness let them know that they should kneel. They usually follow along. Edited January 3, 2013 by cmariadiaz
Quietfire Posted January 3, 2013 Posted January 3, 2013 I gotta be honest here. I've heard some smokin' homilies before. Ya know, like Cure of Ars homilies where you wanna jump up afterword shouting "AMEN!!" and clapping hard. Instead I always thank the priest afterward for such a fantastic homily. Their humility is always refreshing, giving thanks to God. Still..... :clap: AMEN!!!!!
Lil Red Posted January 3, 2013 Posted January 3, 2013 I gotta be honest here. I've heard some smokin' homilies before. Ya know, like Cure of Ars homilies where you wanna jump up afterword shouting "AMEN!!" and clapping hard. Instead I always thank the priest afterward for such a fantastic homily. Their humility is always refreshing, giving thanks to God. Still..... :clap: AMEN!!!!! First: QUIETFIRE!!!!! :woot: :w00t: Second: I love those homilies - and I do make it a point to tell my priest he did a great job on the homily. :)
Apotheoun Posted January 3, 2013 Posted January 3, 2013 There is no place for applause during the divine liturgy. If people want to clap they should do so in the parish hall after the service has ended.
AnneLine Posted January 3, 2013 Posted January 3, 2013 (With tongue FIRMLY in cheek... I am not serious so don't set up the fire bazookas, ok....) The ONLY place for clapping during Mass would be when God transforms ordinary bread into the Body and Blood of Jesus. THAT is worth whatever praise, acknowledgement and love we can muster..... (and I am with you on not liking the clapping, but tend to try to look at the quality of love (the children analogy of a few weeks ago) that is intended.....)
MissScripture Posted January 4, 2013 Posted January 4, 2013 Did you consider that maybe these people do have a hard time kneeling? If you can't kneel, technically you are supposed to stand. There are times that for me kneeling becomes painful (and at that point so does prolonged standing). I then do the next logical thing -- sit. It isn't a sign of my irreverence, it is a sign of my physical weakness. At least even through the pain I am at Mass, so that should count for something ;) We can be so judgmental at times that the other person is forgotten. Mercy is always called for -- it is easy to judge without knowing all of the facts. It is true -- some people may choose to stand because of laziness, or even worse a lack of reverence for the Blessed Sacrament. Some may stand because of ignorance (and lack of catechesis). Others may stand (or even sit) for a perfectly valid reason. So I play it safe -- unless I know the person, (or can tell that the person is new, or never has been at Mass, etc) I let it be. And if the person is new, then I with a smile on my face and with gentleness let them know that they should kneel. They usually follow along. This. A thousand times this. I've had the lovely experience of being beaned over the head with the Holy 2x4 for my judgement. With the kneeling stuff- it always bothered me, not so much with older people, but younger, healthy looking people. And then I developed a heart condition and nearly passed out every time I kneeled down or stood for too long. So, there I was, at 23 years old, looking healthy as could be on the outside, but sitting on my butt. Talk about a nice dose of humility!
AnneLine Posted January 4, 2013 Posted January 4, 2013 Had exactly the same problem with a serious bad back problem at one point. I would have never expected I would spend the entire holy Mass flat on my BACK on the floor... and be grateful when I could sit. And I hope and pray no one knew what it cost to just drag myself to the Church (and I mean drag, because I couldn't ride the bus and I don't drive.... so it was a very slow, very painful walk....) It is hard to sit during a Mass... when all around you are kneeling and when you have a pretty good suspicion that others are wonderring.... And we don't know if someone has some other kind of hidden disability.... we just don't know. so I try to be respectful of that, and of healthy-looking people in the senior/disabled seats on buss.... we just don't know.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now