Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Clapping After Homily


Recommended Posts

Posted
This happened today during Mass, and I for one think it is completely inappropriate during the liturgy. It is way too distracting and takes the focus off of the sacrifice that is about to happen.

The deacon gave his homily, and came down into the pew area and talked to a little girl, and told her a story, and then addressed the rest of us, still standing "across the border," if that makes sense.

I'm not trying to start a huge debate (else I'd have posted in the debate board), but I am wondering what y'all think. Everyone is entitled to their opinion.

Should clapping ensue after what one may perceive as a particularly good homily, or not?

I just don't think we should be exalting the servant of God, but rather focus on the exaltation of God Himself, which happens on the altar.

If this needs to move to the debate board, I apologize.

 

Woa!  Not Cool!

PadrePioOfPietrelcino
Posted
Had exactly the same problem with a serious bad back problem at one point.

I would have never expected I would spend the entire holy Mass flat on my BACK on the floor... and be grateful when I could sit. And I hope and pray no one knew what it cost to just drag myself to the Church (and I mean drag, because I couldn't ride the bus and I don't drive.... so it was a very slow, very painful walk....)

It is hard to sit during a Mass... when all around you are kneeling and when you have a pretty good suspicion that others are wonderring....

And we don't know if someone has some other kind of hidden disability.... we just don't know. so I try to be respectful of that, and of healthy-looking people in the senior/disabled seats on buss.... we just don't know.

I head injuries which prevented kneeling as well...plus, I always remember when I was joining the Church, there were times in which I didn't kneel during Mass, because I didn't understand what was going on, so I didn't feel comfortable doing it. Point is there are indeed many reasons that "inappropriate" behavior happens during the liturgy, we sometimes need to stay charitable among ourselves.
Groo the Wanderer
Posted

Always have to keep in mind that the abuses and other weirdness we see in Mass that irk the heck out of us are generally due to ignorance, not a desire to innovate.  That helps to keep me more charitable.  There is one guy at our 945 Mass that loves to go up and down the main aisle at the sign of peace.  He's a very friendly dude and is doing out of love of neighbor. He likely has never been properly catechized about how this is a disruption and how he needs to be singing the Agnus Dei along with the rest of us instead of being on the return leg of his trip shaking hands.

 

 

Posted
Always have to keep in mind that the abuses and other weirdness we see in Mass that irk the heck out of us are generally due to ignorance, not a desire to innovate.  That helps to keep me more charitable.  There is one guy at our 945 Mass that loves to go up and down the main aisle at the sign of peace.  He's a very friendly dude and is doing out of love of neighbor. He likely has never been properly catechized about how this is a disruption and how he needs to be singing the Agnus Dei along with the rest of us instead of being on the return leg of his trip shaking hands.

 

You should set bear traps.

eagle_eye222001
Posted

Mass is set up to be a sacred prayerful reverent liturgy.  Since there is nothing sacred, reverent, or prayerful in applause, it can only detract from the intentions of the liturgy.  If it adds anything, it adds the wrong attitude.

 

I do not think people clap maliciously, but rather it is a subconscious sign of the ignorant lackadaisical attitude towards the Mass.

 

 

 

 

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)

i don't like clapping after a homily at mass or singing happy b'day, i went to a mass where the priest got everyone to sing happy b'day to an elderly member after his homily before the gifts came and she died a week later, probably of shock i fear :( But in that i do goto a caresmatic mass sometimes and i like clapping to the beat during there modern hyms. They use alot of guitar,drum type music.

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Posted

Not a fan of the clapping inside of Mass. I do not and instruct my children not to clap.

Posted (edited)

This happens quite a bit at my parish. Last Sunday, the people who were going to our sister parish in Haiti were called up to be blessed and then Fr. asked for us to applaud. Then some people gave them a standing ovation and the rest of the parish followed. (I stood up to blend in so that nobody in my family would notice me being different because conversations about the liturgy and morality don't go well with them. I didn't clap though.)

 

I'm also tired of lay people raising their hands in blessing at mass like what happened last Sunday. I've talked to my mom about how that's not an appropriate hand gesture, but to her, what the priest says goes.

 

Our new priest makes jokes throughout the mass and comments on things in a comical manner which is also inappropriate. Occasional jokes in the homily are one thing, but constantly making jokes throughout the mass is irreverent. I appear to be the only one who thinks that though. I don't want to talk about it because I'll be told to "Lighten up."

 

 

 

 

 

 

Edited by tinytherese
Posted
I'm also tired of lay people raising their hands in blessing at mass like what happened last Sunday. I've talked to my mom about how that's not an appropriate hand gesture, but to her, what the priest says goes.

Frankly, I think that is even worse than clapping during Mass.

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted (edited)
This happens quite a bit at my parish. Last Sunday, the people who were going to our sister parish in Haiti were called up to be blessed and then Fr. asked for us to applaud. Then some people gave them a standing ovation and the rest of the parish followed. (I stood up to blend in so that nobody in my family would notice me being different because conversations about the liturgy and morality don't go well with them. I didn't clap though.)

 

I'm also tired of lay people raising their hands in blessing at mass like what happened last Sunday. I've talked to my mom about how that's not an appropriate hand gesture, but to her, what the priest says goes.

 

Our new priest makes jokes throughout the mass and comments on things in a comical manner which is also inappropriate. Occasional jokes in the homily are one thing, but constantly making jokes throughout the mass is irreverent. I appear to be the only one who thinks that though. I don't want to talk about it because I'll be told to "Lighten up."

Yes "lighten up." To me it is a classic i don't care that much reverse psychology tool. Lighten up is up there with my most hated comments, is that thread still running.?

Edited by Tab'le Du'Bah-Rye
Posted

I get the classic rolling of the eyes with the "Good grief!!" from my family when I point such things out.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...