Slappo Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 (edited) We might refer to Pope Benedict's speculation in that interview book of his, where he said that the use of condoms by AIDS-infected men might be... what are the words he used? A first step of moral awakening? It does not mean, obviously, that the use of condoms is moral. It does mean that the person is at least making a preliminary effort to understand the moral dimension of their choices. A recognition that their agency does not exist in a vacuum, and that in fact they have a responsibility for others as well as themselves. To re-iterate, it does not mean that the condom use, or in our case use of hormonal birth control, becomes moral because it mitigates harm. It means that the person is coming to understand that their poor choices have serious consequences. I think the difference is condom use between two homosexuals is not an act of contraception. The use of a condom between two homosexuals is at worst a morally neutral act (the sexual acts they engage in would have their own moral weight). The use of a condom between a hetrosexual couple is an act of contraception which is an intrinsically evil act. Edit: Assuming the heterosexual couple is engaging in a sexual act which could result in pregnancy... a condom used during a sexual act which cannot result in pregnancy (non-coital) is morally neutral. Edited November 28, 2012 by Slappo
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 Where I foresee this thread going: Too soon. :sad: I think the difference is condom use between two homosexuals is not an act of contraception. The use of a condom between two homosexuals is at worst a morally neutral act (the sexual acts they engage in would have their own moral weight). The use of a condom between a hetrosexual couple is an act of contraception which is an intrinsically evil act. I thought about that. It has been a while since I read that passage, but from what I remember it sounded like his remarks could be applied to heterosexual couples as well, to a certain extent. I think that the main point, the 'moral awakening' thesis, applies in both cases. Perhaps in different degrees, but the point remains.
Mark of the Cross Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 (edited) I would say no. You may not do evil so good may come from it. That really doesn't fly though.There are situations where apparently sinful acts are unavoidable. Confession includes actions we neglected to take. If we refrain from a sinful act and it results in a greater sin, we are still culpable of sin by our neglect to counter that sin (catch 22). Imo better to choose the lesser. In fact the countering of sin by sin may not even be a sin. A soldier killing an enemy is apparently not a sin??? Maybe we just need to make a choice and leave it to God. It's possibly not an act but the motive that makes an act sinful or not. It's very easy to say to people "Don't have sex if you don't want baby!" It's a pity that some of the saints like Augustus or St.Paul aren't still around to tell of their struggles with their sexuality. If an alcoholic or a drug user doesn't want the issues of their habit then stop abusing. Very easy to say for a non alcoholic or non drug addicted user!!! My wife hemorrhaged badly and it was touch and go when my son was born. Then after an emergency Cesarian nearly losing both mother and daughter we decided that was it for the babies. My wife even though tiny had developed Hypertension and diabetes. At mid 30's we weren't about to consider celibacy . With her health I never considered having her corrupted in any way so I opted for vasectomy. When I was considering becoming a Catholic, knowing what the Church teaching was, I asked the RCIA leader if I was still able to become a Catholic. Her comment was "We'll put in a good word for you Mark!" So here I am. Mortal sinner? Probably the least of my worries, but then I'm not alone. Edited November 28, 2012 by Mark of the Cross
Mark of the Cross Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 (edited) Why is the Phorum trolling me? Half my post is missing! Fixed It's the emo's. Evil emo's are trolling me. Text between two emo's gets deleted. Edited November 28, 2012 by Mark of the Cross
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 That really doesn't fly though. :hehe2: . With her health I never considered having her corrupted in any way so I opted for vasectomy. When I was considering becoming a Catholic, knowing what the Church teaching was, I asked the RCIA leader if I was still able to become a Catholic. Her comment was "We'll put in a good word for you Mark!" So here I am. Mortal sinner? Probably the least of my worries, but then I'm not alone. It is not our place to judge your intention or culpability, or anything of the sort, but what Kolbe says is basically self-evidently true. We cannot do evil so that good may come of it. That is simply a foundation of Catholic morality.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 We have to judge an act according to the three fonts of morality: Intention, Object, Circumstances. If the object is evil, the entire action is objectively evil.
Mark of the Cross Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 It is not our place to judge your intention or culpability, or anything of the sort, but what Kolbe says is basically self-evidently true. We cannot do evil so that good may come of it. That is simply a foundation of Catholic morality. The full post is there now. The text between two emo's was missing. What I'm saying is that if the motive of an act is to prevent sin then it may not be a sin.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 The full post is there now. The text between two emo's was missing. What I'm saying is that if the motive of an act is to prevent sin then it may not be a sin. Culpability for the action may be mitigated through intention, perhaps even entirely, but objectively speaking the action remains evil if the object is evil.
Aloysius Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 (edited) Where I foresee this thread going: ahhh young padawan, you shall learn to be a phatmass master yet! the degree of morality on all issues is of course always measured on a scale of 1 to Hiroshima on Phatmass :smokey: let me see what I can do to survey the field of morality here to its wildest connections... it is not moral to contracept, it is never moral to abort. contraception is a sexual sin, abortion is the sin of murder; the murder of innocents is one of the four sins that cry to heaven for vengeance (and yes, the blood of the innocents that was spilled at Hiroshima and Nagasaki certainly cried to Heaven for vengeance). the only sexual sin that cries to heaven for vengeance is "sodomy", the reason for that is that it perverts sexuality against life-giving procreation, which is bad, but it mostly cries to heaven for vengeance when it is tied to rape/coercion as was the case in Sodom, so I think it'd be a stretch to say contraception cries to heaven for vengeance, with the lack of a victimized party (I said mostly earlier but sodomy has a victimized party even in consensual sodomy, because someone's human dignity is being violated even if it's being done willingly)... but no, I don't see contracepting as crying to heaven for vengeance. But does that mean that a person who would otherwise get an abortion should instead be advised to contracept instead? I don't think we can tenably hold that position. I don't think engaging in one sinful act to avoid being placed in a situation wherein you might commit another sinful act has any moral basis in Catholic moral thought. it'd be like if someone said "when I'm bored, I kill people, so I should steal this video game so I don't get bored, because stealing isn't as bad as killing"... it is true that stealing isn't as bad as killing, but there is no moral argument to be made that could advise someone that we'd rather they steal than kill. On the grand demographic level if we saw an increase in stealing and a decrease in murder, we'd likely be relatively happy about those demographics to some degree, but I don't think I'd ever be able to advise anyone that they should steal rather than murder, or that they should contracept rather than murder. Edited November 28, 2012 by Aloysius
Mark of the Cross Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 Culpability for the action may be mitigated through intention, perhaps even entirely, but objectively speaking the action remains evil if the object is evil. I agree, I think! A while back there was a thread about this with the hypothetical case of Mr Godwin knocking at the door and you being given the choice to lie and say no there are no Jews hiding in the attic or saying yes and give support to the evil gestapo. Can't remember the outcome of that!
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 I agree, I think! A while back there was a thread about this with the hypothetical case of Mr Godwin knocking at the door and you being given the choice to lie and say no there are no Jews hiding in the attic or saying yes and give support to the evil gestapo. Can't remember the outcome of that! We argued that you gun down the Gestapo and go out in a blaze of glory. :proud:
Mark of the Cross Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 We argued that you gun down the Gestapo and go out in a blaze of glory. :proud: But you have to do the same as in the movies and let them go for their guns first so it's not murder and becomes a good win!
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 But you have to do the same as in the movies and let them go for their guns first so it's not murder and becomes a good win! Nah, I think it is entirely justified in that case to shoot first.
Mark of the Cross Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 Nah, I think it is entirely justified in that case to shoot first. I suppose! As long as the gun is paid for and not stolen from the dead body of a German soldier.
Nihil Obstat Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 I suppose! As long as the gun is paid for and not stolen from the dead body of a German soldier. I guess strictly speaking, if you kill a German soldier the gun rightly belongs to his surviving family. On the other hand, seizure of his weapons might be justified if we argue that by using it aggressively, he forfeited his right to it. I am leaning towards the latter.
Noel's angel Posted November 28, 2012 Posted November 28, 2012 Everyone should use contraception if they're having sex and are not in a position to have and raise a(nother) child. Oh, and before someone says "oh, well the best way to make sure you don't have a baby is not to have sex in the first place," let me preemptively explode that argument. The best way to make sure I don't break my leg while skiing is to not go skiing in the first place, but that's not a realistic argument. What is the purpose of skiing? The purpose of sex is to unite two people and to pro-create.
ardillacid Posted November 29, 2012 Posted November 29, 2012 ahhh young padawan, you shall learn to be a phatmass master yet! the degree of morality on all issues is of course always measured on a scale of 1 to Hiroshima on Phatmass :smokey: That is clearly Nagasaki. You're slipping.
Ash Wednesday Posted November 29, 2012 Posted November 29, 2012 Sex is like skiing? This changes everything.
dUSt Posted November 29, 2012 Author Posted November 29, 2012 Sex is like skiing? This changes everything. I've always wondered why I was so bad at skiing.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now