Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

 

 

If you read my whole post, you'll note that I said that I'm not convinced getting rid of the standing army (unlike my anarchist/libertarian brethren).  However, it's undeniable that a population made up of armed and trained citizen-soldiers would be much harder to conquer or subjugate.  It would make our country stronger, not weaker.

 

 

Right-libertarians are not anarchists.  

Posted
Right-libertarians are not anarchists.  

 

you are a unique flower

Posted (edited)
You've admitted that  laws are quite ineffective in keeping guns out of the hands of murderous criminal gangs, who often obtain their weapons illegally.

 

All your favored "gun control" laws would do is disarm millions of law-abiding citizens, and render them completely helpless against aggression.

 

I haven't admitted that. Guns are no different from bombs. The fact that terrorist groups are able to get bombs doesn't mean there should be no regulation of bombs.

 

 

While you may think a world in which only violent criminal gangs and governments have weapons and the means to defense - and ordinary citizens are completely helpless and at their mercy - is a wonderful thing, I do not.  But, as you say, different worldviews.

 

 

I don't believe that, but I recognize what violence is. It's not some glorious safeguard of society. You talk about "the majority [that] is quite happy to trample on the rights of the minority when it suits them." Malcolm X was defending the right of minorities to defend themselves "by any means necessary" against a racist society decades ago. And where is Malcolm X today? Shot dead, assassinated by the paramilitary group he helped build.

 

I do not condemn Malcolm X's calls for self-defense. What I have a problem with is the fantasy that the militarization of society is going to lead to a free and peaceful society. Where were the Central American gangs born? In Los Angeles among militarized immigrants from the civil war in El Salvador.

 

You want to militarize society. That is what we disagree about. I am able to sympathize with helplessness. I sympathize with the Russian Revolution. I sympathize with Latin American gangs. I sympathize with the militant activism of someone like Malcolm X. What I don't do, however, is glorify the violence as a good in itself. The Russian revolution didn't lead to a peaceful Russia. Malcolm X didn't transform the ghettos of America. But violence is the only resort of the powerless, and they will always be consumed by it. The more violent the powerless are, the more it consumes them.

 

You believe that militarization empowers people. I don't. That's what we will never agree on.

 

What is the opposite of gun control? At birth, every American child should be afforded a Bible, a copy of the US Constitution, and a Glock 9. Anyone should be able to buy guns and ammo at Walgreens, no questions asked, and brandish their arms as openly as they brandish their iPod. Anything less is gun control.

Edited by Era Might
Posted
What is the opposite of gun control? At birth, every American child should be afforded a Bible, a copy of the US Constitution, and a Glock 9.

No such thing. :|

Posted (edited)
No such thing. :|

 

Shaddup. :viking:

Edited by Era Might
Posted
I haven't admitted that. Guns are no different from bombs. The fact that terrorist groups are able to get bombs doesn't mean there should be no regulation of bombs.

 

Bombs are different than guns, as (if large enough) they kill large numbers of people indescriminately, whereas firearms are more precise and can be used more effectively to take out individual aggressors.  And bombs/explosives can be easily made from easily-obtainable legal materials, and are thus hard to regulate.  But that's moving into another debate.

 

You've still provided no compelling reason for forcibly depriving law-abiding citizens of the means for self-defense.

 

 

 

 

I don't believe that, but I recognize what violence is. It's not some glorious safeguard of society. You talk about "the majority [that] is quite happy to trample on the rights of the minority when it suits them." Malcolm X was defending the right of minorities to defend themselves "by any means necessary" against a racist society decades ago. And where is Malcolm X today? Shot dead, assassinated by the paramilitary group he helped build.

 

I do not condemn Malcolm X's calls for self-defense. What I have a problem with is the fantasy that the militarization of society is going to lead to a free and peaceful society. Where were the Central American gangs born? In Los Angeles among militarized immigrants from the civil war in El Salvador.

 

You want to militarize society. That is what we disagree about. I am able to sympathize with helplessness. I sympathize with the Russian Revolution. I sympathize with Latin American gangs. I sympathize with the militant activism of someone like Malcolm X. What I don't do, however, is glorify the violence as a good in itself. The Russian revolution didn't lead to a peaceful Russia. Malcolm X didn't transform the ghettos of America. But violence is the only resort of the powerless, and they will always be consumed by it. The more violent the powerless are, the more it consumes them.

 

You believe that militarization empowers people. I don't. That's what we will never agree on.

Ownership of guns or other weapons for self-defense need not equal violence.

In fact, possession of guns and the ability to use them can often be (and often is) a strong deterrent to violent aggression.  

In many places with high gun-ownership, robberies and such are rare.

 

There's a difference between a person owning guns to be used against another only in self-defense, and violent thugs committing acts of violent aggression.

 

Forcibly disarming citizens, as you advocate, only renders the former helpless and at the mercy of the latter.

 

Just as a de-militarized country is vulnerable to the aggression of other countries.

 

 

 

What is the opposite of gun control? At birth, every American child should be afforded a Bible, a copy of the US Constitution, and a Glock.

That, my good sir, is a most excellent idea.

Posted (edited)
Bombs are different than guns, as (if large enough) they kill large numbers of people indescriminately, whereas firearms are more precise and can be used more effectively to take out individual aggressors.

 

That's a fine argument, with distinctions found nowhere in the Second Amendment.

Edited by Era Might
Posted
you are a unique flower

 

In the spirit of Georgia O'Keeffe.

Posted (edited)
Bombs are different than guns, as (if large enough) they kill large numbers of people indescriminately, whereas firearms are more precise and can be used more effectively to take out individual aggressors.  And bombs/explosives can be easily made from easily-obtainable legal materials, and are thus hard to regulate.  But that's moving into another debate.

 

Guns can kill indiscriminately.  Bombs can be precise (Maybe you've heard of smart bombs?).   Guns are also made out of easily and legally obtainable materials.  Several men in my family make their own bullets.  And it's really not a separate debate.  At least it isn't if you actually take your own argument seriously.  In fact, if you really believe your own argument about the true function of the second amendment then it's really hard to see why bombs, tanks, fighter jets et cetera shouldn't be available to private citizens.  An AR-15 with a high capacity magazine is great for executing a lot of kids quickly but it doesn't much stand up to the army of a nation that is as technologically advanced and well funded as America's.  

Edited by Hasan
Groo the Wanderer
Posted (edited)

what does magazine size have to do with it?  takes less than 3 seconds to reload if you are at all competent.  10 rounds, 30 rounds...only diff is 6 seconds - you can still only pull the trigger so fast 

 

and why an ar-15?  its a semi-auto rifle just like all the other semi-autos out there commercially available.  one pull, one shot.  must be cause its usually painted black.   racist anti-gun twerds

Edited by Groo the Wanderer
Groo the Wanderer
Posted
Guns can kill indiscriminately.   Guns are also made out of easily and legally obtainable materials.  Several men in my family make their own bullets. 

 

No guns do not kill indiscriminately.  they only kill what people aim them at  (i dangled that participle just for you).  what does the material matter?  the avg joe can not make a reciever that will withstand the stresses of firing a gun, nor can they rifle the barrel correctly.  lame argument.

 

they do not 'make' bullets.  they assemble bullets, likely using a reloader.  i doubt they mix the powder themselves, make the primers themselves, cast the slugs themselves, nor craft the jackets themselves.

 

words matter.

Posted (edited)
Guns can kill indiscriminately.  Bombs can be precise (Maybe you've heard of smart bombs?).   Guns are also made out of easily and legally obtainable materials.  Several men in my family make their own bullets.  And it's really not a separate debate.  At least it isn't if you actually take your own argument seriously.  In fact, if you really believe your own argument about the true function of the second amendment then it's really hard to see why bombs, tanks, fighter jets et cetera shouldn't be available to private citizens.  An AR-15 with a high capacity magazine is great for executing a lot of kids quickly but it doesn't much stand up to the army of a nation that is as technologically advanced and well funded as America's.  

 

I never said that bombs and such are not protected by the second amendment.  I think there may be some legitimate debate as to how far it extends (I've heard libertarians claim that the second amendment covers nukes and "biological weapons").

 

But whatever you might think about an extreme case like a guy with a nuclear warhead in his basement, I don't think there can be any serious doubt that any personal firearms  (as those being discussed in the current "gun control" debates) would be protected.  Restrictions on caliber, magazine size, and such, are completely arbitrary.

 

 

My point about people being able to easily make bombs has absolutely nothing to do with whether they are protected by the second amendment - I was simply pointing out how it is quite easy to kill a lot of people without purchasing any firearms.

 

 "Gun control" laws are no magic protection against depraved acts of mass-slaughter - you can blow up a classroom full of kids, burn an orphanage down, or drive a bus full of kids over a cliff.  The whole argument that "gun control" laws are "necessary" to protect innocent lives is utterly bogus.

Edited by Socrates
Posted (edited)
 "Gun control" laws are no magic protection against depraved acts of mass-slaughter - you can blow up a classroom full of kids, burn an orphanage down, or drive a bus full of kids over a cliff.  The whole argument that "gun control" laws are "necessary" to protect innocent lives is utterly bogus.

 

No laws are magic protection against anything.

Edited by Era Might
Posted
No laws are magic protection against anything.

 

In this case,  the harm (depriving citizens of constitutional rights, and the means to self-defense) outweighs the actual good.

Posted
In this case,  the harm (depriving citizens of constitutional rights, and the means to self-defense) outweighs the actual good.

 

Arbitrary argument.

Posted
I never said that bombs and such are not protected by the second amendment.  I think there may be some legitimate debate as to how far it extends (I've heard libertarians claim that the second amendment covers nukes and "biological weapons").

 

But whatever you might think about an extreme case like a guy with a nuclear warhead in his basement, I don't think there can be any serious doubt that any personal firearms  (as those being discussed in the current "gun control" debates) would be protected.  Restrictions on caliber, magazine size, and such, are completely arbitrary.

 

 

My point about people being able to easily make bombs has absolutely nothing to do with whether they are protected by the second amendment - I was simply pointing out how it is quite easy to kill a lot of people without purchasing any firearms.

 

 "Gun control" laws are no magic protection against depraved acts of mass-slaughter - you can blow up a classroom full of kids, burn an orphanage down, or drive a bus full of kids over a cliff.  The whole argument that "gun control" laws are "necessary" to protect innocent lives is utterly bogus.

 

 

Fair enough.  

Posted
Arbitrary argument.

 

Your face is arbitrary.

Posted
Me and my Friend Michael Francis Lopez have started a Catholic/Christian militia. It's called "Saint Michael Militia of America". We are enlisting, prayer warriors and patriots. http://www.facebook.com/pages/Saint-Michael-Militia-of-America/277801632341922?ref=hl#!/pages/Saint-Michael-Militia-of-America/277801632341922

 

Given how moderate your group is you have a lot of interesting pictures posted there by the administrator:


184462_443609902360711_1165178595_n.jpg

 

 

406576_190722597732846_79787044_n.jpg

 

 

407956_452462258154770_121550717_n.jpg

 

 

 

Hmmmm....

Posted

 

Interesting discussion for a prayer group or whatever you were presenting this as last.

    Americans are arming for war

Lock and load, friends. The darkest chapter in American history is fast approaching. Meanwhile, Americans are arming up like never before. As the Washington Free Beacon is reporting today, "Folks are grabbing just about any gun they can get their hands on..."

Keep in mind the simple fact that Americans are NOT buying guns just so they can turn them in. Record gun sales everywhere across the country are a sign that Americans are arming for WAR against the radical left.

Over ten million firearms were purchased in December alone, and today there's hardly a gun left on any store shelf anywhere in the country. Ammo inventories have also been wiped out nearly everywhere. Same story with rifle magazines. Bottom line? Over the last 30 days, the American people purchased and took home nearly every handgun, rifle, shotgun, magazine and bullet that was for sale across the entire country.

To repeat: These items were NOT purchased just to turn them in to the government. They were purchased to defend the Republic against anti-American traitors and tyrants. We cannot help but conclude America is headed into civil war if the criminals in Washington actually try to ban guns.

 

 

Hmmmmm.  So, Akalyte, I'm on the far left.  I'd love to hear more about your war plans against me and other people whose opinions you dislike.  

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...