Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

German Bishops Rebel Approve Abortion Pill


Recommended Posts

Posted

Excellent.

Posted

There's nothing wrong here...

 

In a case of non consensual sex where fertilization has not occured, taking a drug to prevent the invading sperm (as it was non consensual) from causing a pregnancy is morally licit. It isn't a contraceptive in such a case, it is a form of self defense. The woman is defending her eggs from the attacking sperm. It can only be viewed this way in cases of rape though.

Posted

The real crux of the problem is that there's no way (that I know of) to prove without a doubt that:

A. Pregnancy has not already occured

B. Pregnancy will not occur in the time between when the pill is swallowed and has time to prevent pregnancy from occuring in which case the pill then acts as an abortificient.

KnightofChrist
Posted

The real crux of the problem is that there's no way (that I know of) to prove without a doubt that:

A. Pregnancy has not already occured

B. Pregnancy will not occur in the time between when the pill is swallowed and has time to prevent pregnancy from occuring in which case the pill then acts as an abortificient.

 

Bingo Bango, that's the problem. It's akin to giving approval of the destruction of a residential building without knowing whether or not it is in fact empty of persons.

KnightofChrist
Posted

There's nothing wrong here...

 

In a case of non consensual sex where fertilization has not occured, taking a drug to prevent the invading sperm (as it was non consensual) from causing a pregnancy is morally licit. It isn't a contraceptive in such a case, it is a form of self defense. The woman is defending her eggs from the attacking sperm. It can only be viewed this way in cases of rape though.

 

You're rationalizing the fact that the German Bishops have at least approved the use of the abortifacient 'morning after' pill as a form of contraception for rape victims. 

Posted

Have things really reached such a radical level of revolt that Bishops may openly advocate things like this?  (Not immoral, secretive, "pastoral" decisions, but public cooperation in evil from the men who are to guide us. Shades of Anglicanism.)

Posted

Have things really reached such a radical level of revolt that Bishops may openly advocate things like this?  (Not immoral, secretive, "pastoral" decisions, but public cooperation in evil from the men who are to guide us. Shades of Anglicanism.)

 

The bishop's aren't allowing anything immoral as their directives still expressly forbid anything that would act as an abortificient. The directive is that one can intentially prevent conception in cases of rape as in this case the male sperm were not consensually allowed to enter the woman's body and are part of an attack. In non-consensual sex there's no requirement to be open to life. If life however does result from the rape, that life must be given all the dignity and respect worthy of a human person.

Posted

How would you ever establish in the very first moments after conception that it had occurred?

KnightofChrist
Posted

How would you ever establish in the very first moments after conception that it had occurred?


You cannot, which is why this allowance is negligence and immoral.
Posted

The bishop's aren't allowing anything immoral as their directives still expressly forbid anything that would act as an abortificient. The directive is that one can intentially prevent conception in cases of rape as in this case the male sperm were not consensually allowed to enter the woman's body and are part of an attack. In non-consensual sex there's no requirement to be open to life. If life however does result from the rape, that life must be given all the dignity and respect worthy of a human person.

 


This is bad though because Its preventing God's creation from existing. Its not a kids fault he was created. God made him, even if it was though an immoral act. God can turn bad things into good (i.e. creating a human being in the womb of a rape victim). If God wants to do it I don't see how we can justify stopping it.

Posted (edited)

our standard mix of science, morals, and theology has generally opposed this viewpoint on the basis of the potential for abortion, the analogy of demolishing a building while being uncertain whether anyone was in it at the time applies to that viewpoint that we have developed based upon our understanding of the science interpreted theologically and morally.  the way the bishops expressly disallow that it could be ever done after conception occurs is a way to technically uphold the same principles, in which case the debate here centers around science and degrees of certitude and whether this could ever imaginably be permitted, under some principle of double effect and the mitigation of the uncertainty as to when the conception actually has occurred.

 

scientifically, conception can occur between 30 minutes after sex and FIVE DAYS after sex (according to Discovery Health, which made me click through a couple pages of random practical information about fertilization not realizing I was seeking more philosophical answers).  A huge degree of uncertainty exists during that time period.

 

if science were to advance to the point where we can know with certainty whether conception has occurred yet, the German Bishops' principle would be absolutely sound.  You can engage in a contraceptive defense during or after rape, the sexual sin of contraception only applies to sex you are engaging in by your will.  considering that the minimum time is 30 minutes, it might even be possible to grant certitude to a moral position that one could take a plan B pill as long as it was less than 30 minutes after the rape.  but it would be difficult to really establish such a time limit, it would seem callous and strange and be rather untenable, but where we should go from there is by no means easily certain.

 

These are just some thoughts, they are by no means an endorsement of the German Bishops' position, which I do indeed disagree with.  But it is not an idle thought.  the whole abortion issue is based on a confluence of science, morals, and theology by which we have had to stand up for life based on the overwhelming scientific fact of its unique existence at the moment of conception, this question here involves all facets of that basis for our position, and should be approached very thoroughly especially considering the gravity of the situations we are discussing.  Of course, there is no question that an existing child, even if conceived in rape, cannot be killed at any stage of life starting with conception, because the circumstances of conception cannot be blamed on the child.  I would advise a discussion going on along these lines among all sides of the issue, those who would agree with the German Bishops and those that would vehemently disagree with them, ie those like me who would disagree with them for the love of life but remain unsettled and prayerfully not certain... treating it politically as a 'rebellion' of the German bishops strikes me as a bad way to deal with it...

Edited by Aloysius
Posted

"treating it politically as a 'rebellion' of the German bishops strikes me as a bad way to deal with it"

 

And how has not calling spades spades worked out for the Church over the last fifty years or so? :)

Posted

hmm... I'm really not out to be the most practical force on the earth, so while it is indeed impractical for me to say that, and would be ineffectual not to deal with this harshly and politically as a breach of the towing of the line (and I certainly think that even if something could be imagined towards these lines where we could have more scientific certitude, it would definitely be politically weakening to the overall goal of defending life to come up with a way to allow for it; just like Pope Benedict's comments about condoms and gay prostitutes that got the world all crazy were politically inexpedient to the practical success of our overall message)... so yeah, I don't know, you might be right, but I prefer to deal with the issue in an in depth and considered way, even if that's not the most expedient way of accomplishing goals, perhaps motivated out of sympathy for the victims of rape and acknowledgment that to not really treat it in depth when it revolves around the type of emotionally shattering crisis in their lives just because I'm afraid x, y, or z is going to become emboldened in their mission against our pro-life anti-contraception moral positions would not really be a good explanation to such a distraught woman.

 

I suppose I could be painted as being too wishy washy here, though don't get me wrong I have definitely affirmed that I think that this position is wrong, I'm just throwing out thoughts.  the situation for these individual victims of rape is too grave not to at least allow for some consideration that treats the deep philosophical, theological, moral, and scientific depths of our pro-life position.  I think brushing it off too easily on the basis of the practicalities of the politics of moral teaching would be too callous from my perspective, but I acknowledge that my posts are not really the right comprehensive answers because I am leaving too many openings to my questions, perhaps someone can gracefully tie all my loose knots here in a way that's a good in-depth moral-theology response.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

There's nothing wrong here...

 

In a case of non consensual sex where fertilization has not occured, taking a drug to prevent the invading sperm (as it was non consensual) from causing a pregnancy is morally licit. It isn't a contraceptive in such a case, it is a form of self defense. The woman is defending her eggs from the attacking sperm. It can only be viewed this way in cases of rape though.

 

And for the record, these drugs don't destroy any fertilized zygote if it's already implanted in the uterus.  

Posted

It is potentially true that I am a pastoral disaster as result of running to fortress Roma to escape "compassion" that leads to cooperation in evil. Women who have been raped deserve sympathy. Homosexuals deserve sympathy (and apart from revelation I don't see the big deal tbh). Everyone deserves sympathy. I (and I know you'll agree Aloysius, I've been reading and admiring you) however may not cooperate in things Jesus Christ considers sinful. And if I am cooperating in such evil, then I still dare not and be publicly disobedient to the Church or use high sounding words that are hollow and only intended to enable people to violate Church Teaching.



And for the record, these drugs don't destroy any fertilized zygote if it's already implanted in the uterus.  

 


If this is true then why was the drug refused in the first place?? Why are they called "abortion pills"? Case of people confusing rigorism and orthodoxy? These are serious questions.

Posted

My intention is certainly not to allow people to violate Church teaching or to cooperate in the evils of abortion no matter what the circumstances of their conception were, I was trying to contextualize the German Bishops' position while at the same time largely disagreeing with it.  honestly, if there were a scientific way to know for certain that a conception had not yet occurred, then the German bishop's position would probably be acceptable.  if there were a way to ensure that you were just killing off the sperm and were not threatening the life of a fertilized egg, the position would probably be acceptable.  the position of the German Bishops here is basically making that kind of assumption, it is in the realm of our scientific questions and certitudes here.

 

anyway, I appreciate your position and like I said, somebody does need to come in and tie the loose knots I've left in what I've said here.  I suppose I'm not properly joining in the battle of the politics of moral theology and actually that is a definite weakness of my posts in this thread.  I'm not trying to justify it, just trying to discuss it with the depth I think that it deserves I suppose.

Posted

My intention is certainly not to allow people to violate Church teaching or to cooperate in the evils of abortion no matter what the circumstances of their conception were, I was trying to contextualize the German Bishops' position while at the same time largely disagreeing with it.  honestly, if there were a scientific way to know for certain that a conception had not yet occurred, then the German bishop's position would probably be acceptable.  if there were a way to ensure that you were just killing off the sperm and were not threatening the life of a fertilized egg, the position would probably be acceptable.  the position of the German Bishops here is basically making that kind of assumption, it is in the realm of our scientific questions and certitudes here.

 

anyway, I appreciate your position and like I said, somebody does need to come in and tie the loose knots I've left in what I've said here.  I suppose I'm not properly joining in the battle of the politics of moral theology and actually that is a definite weakness of my posts in this thread.  I'm not trying to justify it, just trying to discuss it with the depth I think that it deserves I suppose.

 


 I agree with your posts--the only disagreement I've had is the one line I quoted. (Tone is hard to get on the internet, but I think you think I think something's wrong with how you think. :p )

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...