Aloysius Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 If this is true then why was the drug refused in the first place?? Why are they called "abortion pills"? Case of people confusing rigorism and orthodoxy? These are serious questions. they don't do anything to implanted zygotes I believe, but to zygotes before implantation, so a fertilized egg could still be killed. of course to be fair, many fertilized eggs naturally die without making it to implantation in the first place (some try to argue on this basis that implantation is the beginning of life, but just like birth that's just a change-of-environment move so one can't really justify implantation as a good philosophical start of life IMO), but to directly intend for that to happen would indeed be abortive. if you intend to kill a fertilized egg, whether it's implanted yet or it's frozen in some laboratory, that's killing a nascent human life. the fact that there is the possibility of a fertilized egg that has not yet been implanted that this plan B pill could kill is the problematic "demolishing a building where there might be someone in it" scenario.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 Aloysius, I think you outline the great difficulty in this - how do we respond to women in a way that is Christ-like without compromising our pro-life values? The Church believes life begins at conception (sperm meets egg) because we don't know when the soul is fused with the body, so we go with the earliest possible moment just to be safe. We don't know when conception occurs after sex (I've seen anything from a few minutes to a few days - but then, these stats are from the same people who say that you can literally get pregnant at any time in your cycle, so...really the answer is probably closer to somewhere inbetween). I'm with Slappo on this one - and I would come down on the side of getting a rape victim the pill during the first 24 hours after her attack, the sooner the better. If the fertilized egg implants anyway, the pill wouldn't do anything to harm it. I dunno, I just find the way most people talk about this issue to be extremely callous - you guys are doing a pretty good job here so kudos to you - but most people arguing about it seem like they've never had to console a rape victim before, never had it happen to themselves or one of their friends. Most people seem to defend the right of the new child to live at all costs...but have absolutely no ideas of how we go about helping the woman recover from her trauma, or often even mention it. And thus the pro-choice lobby becomes the one women go to, because they're the only ones who offer any kind of "support". We need to find some way to reach out to these women.
Aloysius Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 I agree with your posts--the only disagreement I've had is the one line I quoted. (Tone is hard to get on the internet, but I think you think I think something's wrong with how you think. :P ) :cool: I get ya, no worries :smokey::
KnightofChrist Posted February 22, 2013 Author Posted February 22, 2013 For me this touches on matters of Faith and prudence, and not a matter of politics. This action of the German bishops seems to challenge both matters of faith and prudence.
Aloysius Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 Basilia, personally I feel the question of "when the soul is fused" puts it in too dualistic of terms. a unique human life has a unique human soul, if it's alive and has a unique fully human genetic code (ie once an egg is fertilized), physically being alive is synonymous with having a spirit in my view, and the moment of a unique genetic code is the moment that such spirit is an eternal human soul rather than the spirit of some microscopic human bio matter. of course, saying that leaves me open to the critique of splitting into twins after fertilization and whether that "splits" the soul per se, but I'm willing to go pretty far in a non-dualistic fashion that yes, those twins at one time shared the same soul because they were a single physical human being, and when they split they became two unique human souls. the practical point of that is that I don't think it's just being-overly-cautious that leads us to call conception the beginning of life, it's necessitated by the scientific facts applied to our view of the soul as the life force of the body, not some dualistic ghost in the machine. ultimately, I definitely agree with your point about the overly theoretical callousness the issue often gets treated with.
Didacus Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 reuters :hehe: They'll do anything to get attention...
KnightofChrist Posted February 22, 2013 Author Posted February 22, 2013 New forms of interception and contragestation 23. Alongside methods of preventing pregnancy which are, properly speaking, contraceptive, that is, which prevent conception following from a sexual act, there are other technical means which act after fertilization, when the embryo is already constituted, either before or after implantation in the uterine wall. Such methods are interceptive if they interfere with the embryo before implantation and contragestative if they cause the elimination of the embryo once implanted. In order to promote wider use of interceptive methods,[43] it is sometimes stated that the way in which they function is not sufficiently understood. It is true that there is not always complete knowledge of the way that different pharmaceuticals operate, but scientific studies indicate that the effect of inhibiting implantation is certainly present, even if this does not mean that such interceptives cause an abortion every time they are used, also because conception does not occur after every act of sexual intercourse. It must be noted, however, that anyone who seeks to prevent the implantation of an embryo which may possibly have been conceived and who therefore either requests or prescribes such a pharmaceutical, generally intends abortion. When there is a delay in menstruation, a contragestative is used,[44] usually one or two weeks after the non-occurrence of the monthly period. The stated aim is to re-establish menstruation, but what takes place in reality is the abortion of an embryo which has just implanted. As is known, abortion is “the deliberate and direct killing, by whatever means it is carried out, of a human being in the initial phase of his or her existence, extending from conception to birthâ€.[45] Therefore, the use of means of interception and contragestation fall within the sin of abortion and are gravely immoral. Furthermore, when there is certainty that an abortion has resulted, there are serious penalties in canon law.[46] DIGNITAS PERSONAE Source: http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/congregations/cfaith/documents/rc_con_cfaith_doc_20081208_dignitas-personae_en.html
Aloysius Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 this by no means clearly settles the German bishop's treatment of possibly the first 24 hours after rape, as the example given in DH that references the use after a missed period (clearly the whole scenario being discussed in that part is also extremely different than the rape scenario). I haven't exactly sided with Basilia and Slappo and the German Bishops, but we are talking about something that is really bringing up issues in the realm of the science and philosophy here much different than the passage in DH you quoted I think (though yes it's the interceptive idea, the scenario of rape makes the abortive intentionality far less clear cut IMO). trying to prevent implantation is abortive, the German bishops even affirmed that, they suggested as the scientific scenario something which truly prevents conception immediately after a rape. if there were a truly scientifically established understanding of doing that, of knowing there was not yet conception or of truly being able to only do something that could prevent the conception without the possibility of killing a fertilized egg, then there would be no problems with the German Bishops position. as it is, there is a high degree of lack of certitude, conception can occur anywhere from half an hour to five days after sex. the analogy I think you yourself gave early on of demolishing a building when you're not sure if someone's inside it or not is very apt I think. the desperation of the situation and the consideration of there possibly not yet being anyone inside that building are at the very least mitigating factors in this kind of scenario, factors that we should not take lightly.
ImageTrinity Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 I'm not sure I'd call the Bishops' action a revolt. This particular situation is the subject of hot debate among moral theologians.
Evangetholic Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 I would and indeed did. The fact that it is "debatable" and involves the potential of dead babies makes me think the word is not uncalled for.
Basilisa Marie Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 I would and indeed did. The fact that it is "debatable" and involves the potential of dead babies makes me think the word is not uncalled for. Yeah, but we're also talking about rape victims. I won't go into details, but I was an RA at a college for three years, and dealt with my share of rape and assault incidents. Those experiences changed how I talk about situations like these, because although it's crucial to speak for the unborn, we must make sure we are also showing charity toward the rape victim. We can't be callous.
KnightofChrist Posted February 22, 2013 Author Posted February 22, 2013 The fact that it is "debatable" and involves the potential of dead babies makes me think the word is not uncalled for. And that is why this is at least an act against prudence. Which isn't exactly moral. The fact there is no real way to confirm that babies will not be killed, means that this an act of imprudence. So far most at least seem to agree with that, though that may change now that I said most agree on that much.
Slappo Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 I'd be far more comfortable with the idea of some sort of injection of a sperm killer that cannot affect the sperm and the egg once they unite as this would negate the possibility of any medicine/contraceptive acting as an abortificient in cases of rape. I think the German bishops tread a thin line, but I don't see where they have overstepped morally as they have still specifically disallowed for anything that would act as an abortificient.
Evangetholic Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 Yeah, but we're also talking about rape victims. I won't go into details, but I was an RA at a college for three years, and dealt with my share of rape and assault incidents. Those experiences changed how I talk about situations like these, because although it's crucial to speak for the unborn, we must make sure we are also showing charity toward the rape victim. We can't be callous. I'm a survivor of sexual abuse. I understand the severity of the damage that can be done by it. I'm not trying to be callous and I'll go ahead and say what no one else here will say: I cannot imagine that this would ever subjectively be a mortal sin for the women concerned (as a result of the severe mental/spiritual damage). Still though, a hospital belonging to the Church that invented the phrase "culture of death" should not be involved in handing these pills out unless and until it's clear that deaths of children won't happen.
KnightofChrist Posted February 22, 2013 Author Posted February 22, 2013 (edited) I'd be far more comfortable with the idea of some sort of injection of a sperm killer that cannot affect the sperm and the egg once they unite as this would negate the possibility of any medicine/contraceptive acting as an abortificient in cases of rape. I think the German bishops tread a thin line, but I don't see where they have overstepped morally as they have still specifically disallowed for anything that would act as an abortificient. I think it's real great they've said they disallow for anything that would act as an abortificient. But the pill they've approved is an abortificient, and they have no way of knowing for sure it will not act as one in certain cases. So I strongly disagree that this doesn't cross the line and isn't at least a little immoral. Edited February 22, 2013 by KnightofChrist
Didacus Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 The fact that the debate is used in order to set a <trap> for whole of the Catholic Church certainly does nothing to add value to the debate.
Apotheoun Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 (edited) , , , if science were to advance to the point where we can know with certainty whether conception has occurred yet, the German Bishops' principle would be absolutely sound. You can engage in a contraceptive defense during or after rape, the sexual sin of contraception only applies to sex you are engaging in by your will. considering that the minimum time is 30 minutes, it might even be possible to grant certitude to a moral position that one could take a plan B pill as long as it was less than 30 minutes after the rape. but it would be difficult to really establish such a time limit, it would seem callous and strange and be rather untenable, but where we should go from there is by no means easily certain. It must take time after swallowing the pill for it to become effective (i.e., to diffuse throughout the body), and so the 30 minute window is not real. I suppose if the woman took the pill before being raped it could be effective in preventing conception, but otherwise I think it likely that the pill in many cases will be working as an abortifacient. I think the German bishops have moved in the wrong direction, but hopefully the Vatican will clarify the matter in time. Edited February 22, 2013 by Apotheoun
Evangetholic Posted February 22, 2013 Posted February 22, 2013 http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2013/02/21/172595689/morning-after-pills-dont-cause-abortion-studies-say
KnightofChrist Posted February 22, 2013 Author Posted February 22, 2013 PONTIFICAL ACADEMY FOR LIFE STATEMENT ON THE SO-CALLED "MORNING-AFTER PILL" … 1. The morning-after pill is a hormone-based preparation (it can contain oestrogens, oestrogen/progestogens or only progestogens) which, within and no later than 72 hours after a presumably fertile act of sexual intercourse, has a predominantly "anti-implantation" function, i.e., it prevents a possible fertilized ovum (which is a human embryo), by now in the blastocyst stage of its development (fifth to sixth day after fertilization), from being implanted in the uterine wall by a process of altering the wall itself. The final result will thus be the expulsion and loss of this embryo. Only if this pill were to be taken several days before the moment of ovulation could it sometimes act to prevent the latter (in this case it would function as a typical "contraceptive"). However, the woman who uses this kind of pill does so in the fear that she may be in her fertile period and therefore intends to cause the expulsion of a possible new conceptus; above all, it would be unrealistic to think that a woman, finding herself in the situation of wanting to use an emergency contraceptive, would be able to know exactly and opportunely her current state of fertility. 2. The decision to use the term "fertilized ovum" to indicate the earliest phases of embryonic development can in no way lead to an artificial value distinction between different moments in the development of the same human individual. In other words, if it can be useful, for reasons of scientific description, to distinguish with conventional terms (fertilized ovum, embryo, fetus, etc.) different moments in a single growth process, it can never be legitimate to decide arbitrarily that the human individual has greater or lesser value (with the resulting variation in the duty to protect it) according to its stage of development. 3. It is clear, therefore, that the proven "anti-implantation" action of the morning-after pill is really nothing other than a chemically induced abortion. It is neither intellectually consistent nor scientifically justifiable to say that we are not dealing with the same thing. Moreover, it seems sufficiently clear that those who ask for or offer this pill are seeking the direct termination of a possible pregnancy already in progress, just as in the case of abortion. Pregnancy, in fact, begins with fertilization and not with the implantation of the blastocyst in the uterine wall, which is what is being implicitly suggested. 4. Consequently, from the ethical standpoint the same absolute unlawfulness of abortifacient procedures also applies to distributing, prescribing and taking the morning-after pill. All who, whether sharing the intention or not, directly co-operate with this procedure are also morally responsible for it. 5. A further consideration should be made regarding the use of the morning-after pill in relation to the application of Law 194/78, which in Italy regulates the conditions and procedures for the voluntary termination of pregnancy. Saying that the pill is an "anti-implantation" product, instead of using the more transparent term "abortifacient", makes it possible to avoid all the obligatory procedures required by Law 194 in order to terminate a pregnancy (prior interview, verification of pregnancy, determination of growth stage, time for reflection, etc.), by practising a form of abortion that is completely hidden and cannot be recorded by any institution. All this seems, then, to be in direct contradiction to the correct application of Law 194, itself debatable. 6. In the end, since these procedures are becoming more widespread, we strongly urge everyone who works in this sector to make a firm objection of moral conscience, which will bear courageous and practical witness to the inalienable value of human life, especially in view of the new hidden forms of aggression against the weakest and most defenceless individuals, as is the case with a human embryo. Vatican City, 31 October 2000.http://www.vatican.va/roman_curia/pontifical_academies/acdlife/documents/rc_pa_acdlife_doc_20001031_pillola-giorno-dopo_en.html
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now