Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

German Bishops Rebel Approve Abortion Pill


Recommended Posts

Posted

http://www.npr.org/blogs/health/2013/02/21/172595689/morning-after-pills-dont-cause-abortion-studies-say

If the science cited in this article is indeed true, and it is based upon studies that are more up to date that the Pontifical Academy for Life 2000 statement posted above, which I will also add is also clearly directed at entirely different situations than those of rape) then indeed the German Bishops' position actually makes perfect sense.  It would obviously only be permissible for victims of rape (anyone who had consensual sex using these types of things would be committing contraceptive/sexual sins at the very least), but from what I read in this article, apparently it is strongly indicated that these particular medications operate differently than RU 486.

 

as I was saying before, the real question here is a question of science.  if the scientific indication really is that these particular drugs do not operate as implantation blockers at all, then there is actually zero problem with the German Bishops' statement.  if there is indeed a way to block fertilization that would not directly attack a fertilized egg, as the studies cited in that NPR article indicate, then that is something that would be acceptable for victims of rape.  the Pontifical Academy for Life statement is clearly based upon the scientific understanding of its time, if the science really indicates that these things don't operate that way then I'd actually expect the Vatican to probably end up backing up the German Bishops' position.  the Vatican would likely take a while to evaluate whether there really are reliable studies showing that, we'll see.

 

would anyone argue that if the studies cited there are indeed true and it is not an implantation blocker that the German Bishops' statement wasn't correct?  Or is it, like it appears to be to me, a disagreement over the scientific premise with the German Bishops accepting the argument of these studies that indicate that it does not block implantation?

Posted (edited)

If the NPR article is correct I think the Bishops' action is not wrong (it just sort of looks that way). I think you could make a case that it appears at variance with the way many Catholics will have understood the issue and NEEDS clarification from the Pontiff (the Bible--which is no dead "text"--warns us not to scandalize the weak in faith with even licit actions), but barring some future objection from the Holy Father it appears that the Bishops are within their rights and God's law. And I (the Great, the Perfect, the Quite Correct) have spoken rashly--ah, the burden of being a devilishly handsome young rogue.

Edited by Evangetholic
Posted

Well. Is it necessary that there be zero risk to fetal life for something to be licit? Need it really be that certain? I know the kind of question this might sound like, but that's not what I'm to. It's an honest question from someone who had a poorly catechized Catholic childhood and only came back to the Church two days ago after a ten year absence.

Posted

"but that's not what I'm to." Should read: but that's not what I'm up to.

Basilisa Marie
Posted

Well. Is it necessary that there be zero risk to fetal life for something to be licit? Need it really be that certain? I know the kind of question this might sound like, but that's not what I'm to. It's an honest question from someone who had a poorly catechized Catholic childhood and only came back to the Church two days ago after a ten year absence.

 

Some people would probably say yes, others no. Seems to me like that's why this question is so tough - there's conflicting scientific evidence, and most of the evidence gets spun one way or another anyway depending on the motives of those presenting the data.  

Posted

My conscience says caution, but I guess I'm not a relevant party. Not a doctor. Not a Bishop. Not Pope. Not a woman. Not a baby. Not German.

 

I'll pray.

 

Holy Mary, Great Mother of God, teach us compassion and teach us wisdom.

 

St. Maria Goretti, pray for us.

 

St. Gianna Beretta Molla, pray for us.

 

Bl. Pier Giorgio Frassati, pray for us.

 

(I only mention Blessed Pier Giorgio Frassati, because he and I have become buddies. I prayed to him briefly before my conversion.)

 

KnightofChrist
Posted

Well. Is it necessary that there be zero risk to fetal life for something to be licit? Need it really be that certain? I know the kind of question this might sound like, but that's not what I'm to. It's an honest question from someone who had a poorly catechized Catholic childhood and only came back to the Church two days ago after a ten year absence.


Yes. Think of it like this, I've made you a cake it looks good, smells good and probably tastes good. Onlyone little problemo, it may contain a lethal dose of poison, some studies suggest that it probably will not kill you but their not %100 percent sure, others studies suggest it will likely cause death. How many slices do you want?

Or think about it like this I have a gun filled with what I pretty sure are duds, but I'm not %100 sure. Would you stand in front while I fire off a round or two?

Or going back to my original analogy, you are in charge of imploding a residential building, do you set off the explosives without being %100 sure it is empty of human life?
Posted

Here's an interesting thought experiment:

 

What if the woman was raped by her husband? Can she take the pill within 5 minutes of the rape?

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...