Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope Francis (can We Have A Sensible Discussion?)


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

I do not know. I don't know what you really meant, only you know.

I meant exactly what I said. If you think of some way for me to clarify, I'd be happy to.
KnightofChrist
Posted

Regardless; you are missing the point. Traditions change/were started by someone. 

 

A lot of people in these threads are behaving as if the traditions he isn't following were started by St Peter himself.

 

It's still an important fact. Pope Saint Pius V didn't start the tradition, it grew slowly over time. Traditions grows slowly through out time, and should not be suddenly lost. I don't believe anyone is behaving in the manner you accuse.

Posted


love this, BG. :)

 


Thanks!  i do feel as if I did a bit of a disservice to Belisarius though.  He nearly reunited the Roman Empire and probably would have, had Justinian and Theodora not continually sacked him from his position every time they got scared with the thought of their army being more loyal to him than them.  Even so, time after time, he would take up his sword once more in defense of his leaders and his empire.  When Constantinople came under siege, he drove back the enemy forces with a much smaller army and pushed them far into their own territory before stopping.  In him, there was a man that Justinian rightly feared, for the throne could have easily been his, but he was too loyal to ever think of taking it.

 

But then he just had to depose Pope Silverius... :|  (Who died later btw, he refused to kill the deposed Pope.)

KnightofChrist
Posted

I meant exactly what I said. If you think of some way for me to clarify, I'd be happy to.

 

I suppose it doesn't really concern me greatly who the ignorant would be in your statement because we are all God's fools.
 

Posted (edited)

You know, I am reminded of a story as the disagreements continue to abound on both sides of the issue.  One, which really shows how the papacy transforms the man who takes the office, for good or for ill. 

 

General Belisarius was a Byzantine General, acting on orders from Emperor Justinian and Empress Theodora, who deposed Pope Silverius when recapturing Rome from the Goths and installed Pope Vigilius instead. Vigilius had schemed with Theodora and her fellow heretics in exchange for being crowned Pope (elected at sword point) and had sworn to defend the heresy Theodora was involved in and to make it official Church doctrine. The moment he ascended to the papacy, he turned his back on the heresy he had been supporting and outlawed its practices throughout the Church.

 

Perhaps everyone should stop worrying and let God know the heart of His Servant of Servants and pray for the Holy Father to do the will of our Heavenly Father.

It should be borne in mind that although Pope Vigilius did not end up supporting the Monophysite heretics as Empress Theodora desired, he did have Nestorian leanings, which is practically speaking the opposite heresy of the one endorsed by Theodora. Not only that, he also initially rejected the canons of the Fifth Ecumenical Council because they condemned certain Nestorian texts and authors, but was later - reluctantly - forced to accept the canons and under pressure finally condemned the Three Chapters, and several other theological texts that promoted the Nestorian error. Of course today the Fifth Ecumenical Council is docilely accepted in all the Catholic Churches, both of the West and the East.

Edited by Apotheoun
Posted

It should be borne in mind that although Pope Vigilius did not end up supporting the Monophysite heretics as Empress Theodora desired, he did have Nestorian leanings, which is practically speaking the opposite heresy of the one endorsed by Theodora. Not only that, he also initially rejected the canons of the Fifth Ecumenical Council because they condemned certain Nestorian texts and authors, but was later - reluctantly - forced to accept the canons and under pressure finally condemned the Three Chapters, and several other theological texts that promoted the Nestorian error. Of course today the Fifth Ecumenical Council is docilely accepted in all the Catholic Churches, both of the West and the East.

 

Good point, sorry that I forgot to include his Nestorian leanings in there.  Appreciate the expansion of how his views continued to change, grudgingly or not, as his papacy progressed. :)
 

MissScripture
Posted


It's still an important fact. Pope Saint Pius V didn't start the tradition, it grew slowly over time. Traditions grows slowly through out time, and should not be suddenly lost. I don't believe anyone is behaving in the manner you accuse.


But all these traditions started somewhere with someone. 500 years from now, Catholics could well be freaking out in the same way they are now because a tradition started by Pope Francis is being changed. While there is importance in traditions, they are not the be-all-end-all the way some people are acting as if they are. He is not changing any Traditions. If people want to get their pantries in a bind because the Pope is not acting the way they would prefer, they can go ahead and do that, but to act like the faith is going to be destroyed because the Pope has chosen not to wear red shoes is a bit drama-queen-ish.
Posted

Tradition is all, because even scripture is a part of Tradition.

franciscanheart
Posted

Tradition vs tradition.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

Tradition is all, because even scripture is a part of Tradition.

I have a feeling that John the Apostle, Polycarp, and Irenaeus would all agree with this statement. :)

Lilllabettt
Posted

fiddler on the roof

Posted (edited)

Tradition vs tradition.

But that only follows if you accept that faulty and modern Western distinction, and I don't subscribe to it. What you call little "t" traditions I call the Apostolic paradosis and kerygma. For example: Is praying facing East a dispensable tradition according to the Church Fathers? Modern Westerners seem to think it is, but if you read the Fathers you will see that they hold is is a tradition coming to us from the Apostles. Heck, that is why the Church traditionally has buried Christians with their feet facing East, so when they were resurrected, they would be facing the Lord.

Edited by Apotheoun
KnightofChrist
Posted

But all these traditions started somewhere with someone. 500 years from now, Catholics could well be freaking out in the same way they are now because a tradition started by Pope Francis is being changed. While there is importance in traditions, they are not the be-all-end-all the way some people are acting as if they are. He is not changing any Traditions. If people want to get their pantries in a bind because the Pope is not acting the way they would prefer, they can go ahead and do that, but to act like the faith is going to be destroyed because the Pope has chosen not to wear red shoes is a bit drama-queen-ish.

 


I think the reason we are seeing such concerns is because for the last 50 years Catholic Tradition and traditions have been thrown to the curb for the most part as outdated and too flashy. Then Benedict rises to the Papacy and against great opposition, reminds us all the big things even the 'little things' in the Church's traditions are very important. Now we have Pope Francis not adopting some of those traditions. Yes, some peoples reaction has been panic, and despair. But some truly wish to have a sensible discussion about their concerns (concerns that may be based on legitimate reasons). I think we should be careful with hyperbolic labeling of those that have concerns, and hear these souls out. It really isn't going to help anyone to label them and accuse them of this or that. That type of thing will only help to push that person away.

Posted

I have thought for some time now about re-posting comments made by Eastern Orthodox Christians at various fora and other sites I visit, because their comments might help to reveal to my Roman Catholic co-religionists just how their Church is perceived by the members of the other ancient Apostolic Churches. Phatmass is such an insular place.

Posted

That would be true if signs were held to be empty tokens, but that idea is Protestant and not Catholic.

 


Yes, that's the only possible option. Either one accepts that red shoes are inherently holy and must never be abandoned once taken on, or one regards the symoblism (symbols not having inherent meaning, thus being symbols in the first place), or one regards them as empty tokens.

Posted


Yes, that's the only possible option. Either one accepts that red shoes are inherently holy and must never be abandoned once taken on, or one regards the symoblism (symbols not having inherent meaning, thus being symbols in the first place), or one regards them as empty tokens.

The red shoes, according to Catholic tradition, manifest (i.e., make present) the authority of the office of the pope, they signify that authority - along with the other vestments he wears - and the idea that they are simply empty or can be dumped because the current office holder isn't personally interested in them is detrimental to tradition. You may not a agree, but at least the position I am advocating is historically Catholic (and Orthodox for that matter).

Posted

fiddler on the roof

 


One of the best musicals ever!

MissScripture
Posted

So, why is it okay years later that some traditions have been altered (or created), but its not okay for them to be altered now? How can traditions develop if there is no room for things to be changed in the slightest? Why were the people who introduced these traditions okay to do that, but Pope Francis is not okay to do things slightly different from his predecessors?

MissScripture
Posted


One of the best musicals ever!

But The Sound of Music is better.
Posted (edited)

All this talk about tradition has made me think again about an article I saw in NCR that was written by a priest in the diocese of Oakland (CA) where he lamented how the Roman Catholic "traditionalists" were playing dress up because bishops and priests were celebrating the older Roman Rite wearing "costumes" from fifty years ago (i.e., the pre-Vatican II era). All I could think about was how this priest would be shunned in the Eastern Orthodox and Eastern Catholic Churches, because in the Churches of the East (especially the Orthodox ones) bishops and priests continue to wear the same style of vestments that they have worn for uncounted centuries. Tradition is about handing on what you have received unchanged. Once that is lost it cannot be easily retrieved, and the holistic nature of the Orthodox Catholic faith is corrupted.

Edited by Apotheoun
Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...