Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope Francis (can We Have A Sensible Discussion?)


Recommended Posts

franciscanheart
Posted

Papal traditions don't appear to matter to him, so I can't imagine why Fransiscan traditions should.

Maybe he's not following a Franciscan tradition. It seems that was just an assumption by another phatmass poster, not a reason from the Pontiff himself. I can't understand your harsh criticisms of his decisions, as if you'd make a better Pope. As if his choice of a gold-plated ring instead of a solid gold ring is SO SCANDALOUS and SO WRONG.

It just seems... unnecessarily negative.
Posted (edited)

I'm a traditional Catholic. I'm a Latin Mass, Rosary in Latin, Douay-Rheims reading Catholic. That doesn't mean I'm going to flip out in despair and agony because the Pope has a silver ring and not a gold one.

I had an Orthodox friend of mine recently ask me, "Why doesn't your pope just wear regular street clothes instead of white robes?" And I really couldn't answer his question, because you know what, if the pope can just arbitrarily drop all sorts of traditions, why not that one too? Tradition is the passing on of what has been received, and Tradition no longer exists the moment you begin to alter things. As an Orthodox priest pointed out in an apologetic text I read yesterday:

 

Roman Catholic statement: "The absence of a pope from Eastern Orthodoxy clearly had negative effects."

 
Orthodox Response: "Yes, the Orthodox communion now has a weak primate, in part as an unavoidable over-reaction to the excesses of the Papal system. However, there are also negative effects to having one head which 'no one can judge' (Roman Catholic Canon Law) and who can change the Liturgy with a single signature..."
 
Eastern Orthodox Christians will never accept this idea, because it ultimately destroys Tradition.
Edited by Apotheoun
Lilllabettt
Posted

the offertory procession can be omitted for good reason. same with the sign of peace. I have seen it done often and in very formal, traditional environments too. the cardinals have each individually already pledged their loyalty to the pope - this go round is for the public to see. The chief celebrant does not have to distribute communion, etc. and it has often been the case when the Pope is celebrating.

 

People are reading into things, more than what is there.

franciscanheart
Posted

You are taking great offenses at nothing. It's a ring. Do you think Saint Peter had a ring, a funny hat, and a cape? He didn't. Was he a heretical Pope because he didn't follow man-made traditions?

You make excellent points. (But St Peter couldn't follow traditions that hadn't been made. But I SEE YOUR POINT. AND I SUPPORT IT.) ;)
Noel's angel
Posted

There is this thing we use here on Phatmass. It is called "sarcasm". Some are incapable of understanding it, but generally, when someone says "heresy" or uses such language as "flipped out in despair and agony" they are being overly-dramatic in order to make fun of a ridiculous conversation.

 

If it's ridiculous, don't partake in it. Sarcasm and melo-drama are two different things. The former doesn't translate well via text.

PhuturePriest
Posted (edited)

I had an Orthodox friend of mine recently ask me, "Why doesn't your pope just wear regular street clothes instead of white robes?" And I really couldn't answer his question, because you know what, if the pope can just arbitrarily drop all sorts of traditions, why not that one too? Tradition is the passing on of what has been received, and Tradition no longer exists the moment you begin to alter things. As an Orthodox priest pointed out in an apologetic text I read yesterday:

 

Roman Catholic statement: "The absence of a pope from Eastern Orthodoxy clearly had negative effects."

 
Orthodox Response: "Yes, the Orthodox communion now has a weak primate, in part as an unavoidable over-reaction to the excesses of the Papal system. However, there are also negative effects to having one head which 'no one can judge' (Roman Catholic Canon Law) and who can change the Liturgy with a single signature..."
 
Eastern Orthodox Christians will never accept this idea, because it ultimately destroys Tradition.

 

Wearing street clothes is way different. That's taking away his clear identity as the Pope. A ring is not a clear identity of who he is, Bishops wear the same hat he does, and I honestly never even noticed the Pope wear a cape.

Edited by FuturePriest387
Posted

You make excellent points. (But St Peter couldn't follow traditions that hadn't been made. But I SEE YOUR POINT. AND I SUPPORT IT.) ;)

He makes the same kinds of points Martin Luther made.  :shocking:

 

Why not just dump all the papal traditions and signs of authority? Why only get rid of some of them or alter some to make them more modern? Just dump them all and be done with it.

franciscanheart
Posted

The bottom line, NA, is that when you look for reasons to discredit the Pope, the faithful at phatmass are not likely to support and/or agree with you. It's their right to not agree and to engage you in discussion on a public message board.

Further, I would expect that if you really wanted a healthy discussion about the implications of the Pope's recent actions, you would not post one- or two-line posts citing things he's done contrary to tradition, but explain why you have an issue with it and what significance you think this has in regards to the universal Church.

I may not agree with Apotheoun, but at least he's providing logical, respectful, significant reasons for his disagreements.

Posted (edited)

Wearing street clothes is way different. That's taking away his clear identity as the Pope. A ring is not a clear identity of who he is, Bishops wear the same hat he does, and I honestly never even noticed the Pope wear a cape.

Actually wearing the ring would be more important than wearing the clothes, because like with the sacrament of marriage, a woman rarely wears her wedding dress again.

 

But why not dump all the papal traditions? Why only some of them?

Edited by Apotheoun
Lilllabettt
Posted (edited)

well the ring is actually a very important part of the clear identity thing. His ring will be destroyed when his reign is over. It makes no difference whether it is silver or gold, but it is important that it is uniquely his. It is traditional for Franciscans to use silver.

 

Actually I am kind of amused at upset over the offertory being omitted because that is when a lot of the fru-fru stuff can happen in a bad liturgy. Dancing nuns bringing up incense, etc.  The EF does not have an offertory procession.

 

 

Edited by Lilllabettt
PhuturePriest
Posted

well the ring is actually a very part of the clear identity thing. His ring will be destroyed when his reign is over. It makes no difference whether it is silver or gold, but it is uniquely his. And it is traditional for Franciscans to use silver.

 

Actually I am kind of amused at upset over the offertory being omitted because that is when a lot of the fru-fru stuff can happen in a bad liturgy. Dancing nuns bringing up incense, etc.  The EF does not have an offertory procession.

 

Bazinga.

Posted

well the ring is actually a very part of the clear identity thing. His ring will be destroyed when his reign is over. It makes no difference whether it is silver or gold, but it is uniquely his. And it is traditional for Franciscans to use silver.

 

Actually I am kind of amused at upset over the offertory being omitted because that is when a lot of the fru-fru stuff can happen in a bad liturgy. Dancing nuns bringing up incense, etc.  The EF does not have an offertory procession.

I'm not upset about the offertory, or even about the ring. Nevertheless, I can sympathize with traditional Roman Catholics who take papal customs seriously.  :)

PhuturePriest
Posted

Actually wearing the ring would be more important than wearing the clothes, because like with the sacrament of marriage, a woman rarely wears her wedding dress again.

 

But why not dump all the papal traditions? Why only some of them?

 

I'm all for tradition. I loved Pope Benedict XVI and how traditional he was, and how he brought some traditions back. But when you make tradition more important than anything else, problems happen. It's not like he's deciding not to wear a ring. He's still wearing a ring specially made for him, and it's still going to be destroyed just like the rest of them. It's not going to be a five dollar mood ring, it's going to be freakin' silver. Stop taking offenses at everything he does and perhaps trust that the Holy Spirit knows better than we do.

Posted (edited)

Bazinga.

Why is the pope continuing some traditions, while getting rid of others, and how does altering traditional practices safeguard those very practices?

 

Isn't the pope is supposed to be the primary guardian of tradition in the Roman Church?

Edited by Apotheoun
Noel's angel
Posted

The bottom line, NA, is that when you look for reasons to discredit the Pope, the faithful at phatmass are not likely to support and/or agree with you. It's their right to not agree and to engage you in discussion on a public message board.

Further, I would expect that if you really wanted a healthy discussion about the implications of the Pope's recent actions, you would not post one- or two-line posts citing things he's done contrary to tradition, but explain why you have an issue with it and what significance you think this has in regards to the universal Church.

I may not agree with Apotheoun, but at least he's providing logical, respectful, significant reasons for his disagreements.

 
I may not like the Pope, but one thing you cannot accuse me of is being unfaithful to him. I said at the start of the thread that this would be a place for everyone to note their hopes and fears. That is what I have done. I noted in my first post that I fear he is lowering the office of Pope to meet his own private standards. Following on from that, my posts have sown examples of why I think this.
franciscanheart
Posted

He makes the same kinds of points Martin Luther made.  :shocking:
 
Why not just dump all the papal traditions and signs of authority? Why only get rid of some of them or alter some to make them more modern? Just dump them all and be done with it.

You sound rather dramatic. I think that's the biggest problem with this discussion. I can understand the idea that you really do feel a sense of emergency about this, some level of importance that the rest of us don't see. But when you relate the pope to Martin Luther? It comes off as a bit ... dramatic. And emotional. Unnecessarily critical of a man who has simply shirked material, unnecessary non-requirements.

Does his taking of a gold-plated silver ring and not wearing red shoes and a cape really have that great of an implication? Perhaps in some's eyes it does. Clearly for you and NA, this is way bigger a deal than what the rest of us consider more important things. I am actually proud of him for leaving behind some of those things. I don't find I have any less respect for him or that he's taken away from his office in any way. There's plenty of gold surrounding his person, I don't think it matters if his ring isn't pure gold.

I also think my franciscan heart leads me to feel very differently about many things in the Church. I don't say that in pride, just as a statement of fact. My priorities and views on living life are very different than some others, clearly.
Noel's angel
Posted

I'm all for tradition. I loved Pope Benedict XVI and how traditional he was, and how he brought some traditions back. But when you make tradition more important than anything else, problems happen. It's not like he's deciding not to wear a ring. He's still wearing a ring specially made for him, and it's still going to be destroyed just like the rest of them. It's not going to be a five dollar mood ring, it's going to be freakin' silver. Stop taking offenses at everything he does and perhaps trust that the Holy Spirit knows better than we do.

 

As far as I am aware, the ring WAS NOT made specially for the occasion of his installation as Pope.

Posted (edited)

I'm all for tradition. I loved Pope Benedict XVI and how traditional he was, and how he brought some traditions back. But when you make tradition more important than anything else, problems happen. It's not like he's deciding not to wear a ring. He's still wearing a ring specially made for him, and it's still going to be destroyed just like the rest of them. It's not going to be a five dollar mood ring, it's going to be freakin' silver. Stop taking offenses at everything he does and perhaps trust that the Holy Spirit knows better than we do.

You do see why Orthodox Christians see the Roman Church and Protestantism as two sides of the same coin - Right? Did you read the comment by the Orthodox priest about the pope being able to arbitrarily change the liturgy? That could not happen in Eastern Orthodoxy, because hierarchs are servants of liturgical tradition, not the creators of it.

Edited by Apotheoun
PhuturePriest
Posted

I may not like the Pope, but one thing you cannot accuse me of is being unfaithful to him. I said at the start of the thread that this would be a place for everyone to note their hopes and fears. That is what I have done. I noted in my first post that I fear he is lowering the office of Pope to meet his own private standards. Following on from that, my posts have sown examples of why I think this. 

 

You're wrong: This has not been a thread for people to post their hopes and fears. This has been a thread for people (Namely you) to post your fears and judgements on the Pope and his decisions on traditions (Traditions with a lower-case 't' and not an upper-case 'T').

PhuturePriest
Posted

You sound rather dramatic. I think that's the biggest problem with this discussion. I can understand the idea that you really do feel a sense of emergency about this, some level of importance that the rest of us don't see. But when you relate the pope to Martin Luther? It comes off as a bit ... dramatic. And emotional. Unnecessarily critical of a man who has simply shirked material, unnecessary non-requirements.

Does his taking of a gold-plated silver ring and not wearing red shoes and a cape really have that great of an implication? Perhaps in some's eyes it does. Clearly for you and NA, this is way bigger a deal than what the rest of us consider more important things. I am actually proud of him for leaving behind some of those things. I don't find I have any less respect for him or that he's taken away from his office in any way. There's plenty of gold surrounding his person, I don't think it matters if his ring isn't pure gold.

I also think my franciscan heart leads me to feel very differently about many things in the Church. I don't say that in pride, just as a statement of fact. My priorities and views on living life are very different than some others, clearly.

 

He didn't say the Pope makes the same arguments as Martin Luther. He said I did. I was offended at first, but now I find it kind of funny. :hehe:

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...