Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Pope Francis (can We Have A Sensible Discussion?)


Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)


 I feel the need to point out he has only been pope for about three days. We don't really know enough to speculate about a lot of things. 

 

I did not say you are emotional. I simply suggested that if this thread troubles you, perhaps it is not the right place for you to be.


I've seen far more troubling threads on Phatmass.
 

Edited by EmilyAnn
Posted

Era, I think distinguishing between the individual and the office is, in fact, a good thing, in the sense of the positionality of the symbolic items that go with the priesthood or the papacy (vestments, clerics, habits, etc) and I don't think having the office overshadowing the individual in any way detracts from one's ability to make great signs of humility.  the vestments any priest puts on are not ornate for the sake of the individual priest, they're like a painting or an icon they cover themselves with and hope to get lost within.  trying to get rid of those symbolic trappings or trying to simplify them and get rid of ones with artistic quality is not necessarily humbling to oneself as an individual IMO.  it's a fine line and there are certainly ways to dramatically express humility by which one can be seen as a humble man overshadowed by the spiritual mantle of the papacy's role on earth.  the symbol of the pope should be larger than life, and completely distinct from the individual, because the symbol itself is the symbol of unity and of the Apostles.  you can express dramatic humility without minimizing that symbol.

 

I agree, I'm not against symbols or ritual, but I think it's a question of the context. The Liturgy IMO is something different from the Apostolic ministry. I think you would agree that much of Papal tradition has its roots in the worldly place of the papacy. Putting that aside, I don't think one has to renounce an appreciation for symbol in order to sort of recontextualize something like the papacy. But I disagree about the pope having to be "larger than life." St. Peter never interacted that way with the other Apostles. I think there is certainly a time and a place to express the spiritual respect and veneration for what St. Peter represents, but I don't think that has to be done in the manner in which the papacy does it. For me, I would like to see less "theatre" not more. I am more interested in the Pope as a man and a witness to Jesus Christ, rather than a cultural and institutional relic.

 

Just to use a personal example, I do not really like wedding rings. Not because I am against the symbol of a ring, but I have an intense dislike of having a commercial symbol on my finger...the ring, for me, is an economic object, and it becomes a sort of noose reminding me every day of my slavery to our industrial economy. If I had the ability and material to make my own ring, then THAT would be very meaningful to me, because it is not the symbol or the gold in itself that bothers me. It's all a matter of context.

Nihil Obstat
Posted


I've seen far more troubling threads on Phatmass. 

Undoubtedly. I do not think you met JimR_OCDS though.
My suggestion has nothing to do with other threads. If this one troubles you, such that you think the discussion itself is ridiculous, then I simply suggested that you need not trouble yourself with it. I think it has been a reasonable discussion thus far.

Posted

I apologize if this gets all garbled. I'm trying to respond from my phone.

My Cardinal Archbishop was interviewed before he entered the conclave about the "coffee discussions" that preceded the cardinals all arriving in Rome and he was asked if in these conversations a frontrunner was starting to come into view. He responded that there was not a frontrunner as much as a profile of a Pope that was becoming clear. One of the key characteristics of this Pope would be his ability to address this world in spite of the media and around the media, using the means available to him, getting the Gospel out in a new way without letting the media distort it as it has before.

Watch Pope Francis and see if he doesn't in fact fit this profile. His radical simplicity and preference for the poor in a credible way, following faithfully the model laid out by Benedict, takes away the media's voice of criticism against this man. Watch how quickly it has happened. How can they criticize him the way they used Benedict? The radical simplicity is my guess exactly why he's in office right now and exactly what the cardinals expected from him in the first place.

Posted

he is the pope, and he will do as he wishes, but when he eschews some simple traditional symbols of the papacy I don't view that as a good thing necessarily, I just feel like we all lose out on those symbols that so many of us look to and find comfort in.  these things are not for the individual man's sake, they're for the Church's sake.  when we throw a mozzetta over our Pope (or I guess the MC throws it over him, but it's like we're all doing it really) or we throw a white cassock over him or an ornate miter over him, or red shoes onto his feet, in those moments we the Church are painting an iconographic image that aids us in our experience of the papacy.

I admit that I am torn on the issue of papal traditions.

 

I am a traditionalist, and so I do not like to see traditions broken in either the East or the West, but I can - as a person who wants to see the restoration of communion between the Catholic Churches (Roman and Eastern) and the Eastern Orthodox Churches - see the weakening of the signs of power around the pope as a good thing, because the Orthodox think the pope has too much power at the present time. So I am torn. I suppose I will have to wait and see what Pope Francis decides to do during his pontificate. 

Posted

Undoubtedly. I do not think you met JimR_OCDS though.
My suggestion has nothing to do with other threads. If this one troubles you, such that you think the discussion itself is ridiculous, then I simply suggested that you need not trouble yourself with it. I think it has been a reasonable discussion thus far.


It doesn't trouble me. I agree it has been reasonable. What I don't understand is why you seem so set on me leaving it. 

Posted

true enough, Era, I personally view the mozzetta as being something more liturgical, it's a choir dress vestment I think, and I would've liked to have seen him wear it on the Balcony for the urbi et orbi even if he maybe chose to wear it in less situations later.  even for some of the symbols that might not be directly liturgical, I think a liturgical metaphor would apply to the position of those symbols in the expression of the papacy.

 

and I don't think the pope himself, as an individual, needs to be larger than life.  I think the papacy needs to be.  I definitely would like to see the Pope himself in close humble contact with his fellow bishops and with the people and all that, but the symbols themselves are meant to overshadow him, to be that iconographic painting that has been draped over him so we see this transcendent principle of unity of the papacy in the Pope's visible symbolic image even while he acts as a humble apostle of the Lord.  I think it makes it all the more dramatic when the symbols are present upon a man exuding humility by his actions.

 

and I think those things are witnesses to the Lord in ways, just like paintings and icons and statues are witnesses to our Lord.

Posted

Liturgical activities do not just happen during mass. All of life can be seen as an extension of the liturgy, and a Christian hierarch acts as a hierarch at all times. Being a bishop is not a 9 to 5 job.

Posted

I admit that I am torn on the issue of papal traditions.

 

I am a traditionalist, and so I do not like to see traditions broken in either the East or the West, but I can - as a person who wants to see the restoration of communion between the Catholic Churches (Roman and Eastern) and the Eastern Orthodox Churches - see the weakening of the signs of power around the pope as a good thing, because the Orthodox think the pope has too much power at the present time. So I am torn. I suppose I will have to wait and see what Pope Francis decides to do during his pontificate. 

don't Eastern Patriarchs still wear their crowns?  :cyclops: granted, the tri-regnum of the papacy holds a different history so I'm not necessarily suggesting a return to that, but I would think that the symbols of the Pope would be expected to equal the symbols of the other patriarchs.

PhuturePriest
Posted


It doesn't trouble me. I agree it has been reasonable. What I don't understand is why you seem so set on me leaving it. 

 

You were quite obviously confounded (Or perhaps disgusted, even) at the subject of the shoes, so he recommended that if it bothered you that much you should not trouble yourself with it. It was a suggestion because he (From what I gather) found the conversation interesting or perhaps could be useful in some way, so there was no need to be rid of it just because one person didn't like it.

Posted

You were quite obviously confounded (Or perhaps disgusted, even) at the subject of the shoes, so he recommended that if it bothered you that much you should not trouble yourself with it. It was a suggestion because he (From what I gather) found the conversation interesting or perhaps could be useful in some way, so there was no need to be rid of it just because one person didn't like it.


Don't worry, I've got the message. I won't bother giving my opinion again. 

Posted


Don't worry, I've got the message. I won't bother giving my opinion again. 

 

:rolleyes:

 

Isn't PM Drama Queen Jason's gig?

Posted (edited)

don't Eastern Patriarchs still wear their crowns?   :cyclops: granted, the tri-regnum of the papacy holds a different history so I'm not necessarily suggesting a return to that, but I would think that the symbols of the Pope would be expected to equal the symbols of the other patriarchs.

Yes, they do.  Of course, crowns are the miters of Eastern hierarchs. 

 

I will say this. Eastern Orthodox Christians are usually quite pleased when the pope does something that weakens his office (e.g., when he stops wearing garments that traditionally have signified his unique position), but they would not be happy to see their hierarchs (bishops, archbishops, metropolitans, or patriarchs) stop wearing the garments that signify their office. Perhaps that should give Roman Catholics a moment to pause and think.

Edited by Apotheoun
PhuturePriest
Posted


Don't worry, I've got the message. I won't bother giving my opinion again. 

 

I don't think having an opinion was the issue. They wanted to discuss it, you didn't. If you were in a circle of friends and everyone was talking about something you all thought was interesting, and then a friend walked into the circle and said "This conversation is stupid. Talk about something more important." would you all just stop, or would you ask your friend to leave if the conversation bothered them that much?

Evangetholic
Posted (edited)

I like the Pope. He hasn't given me cause not to yet. And even when he does he'll still be the highest spiritual and temporal authority on the earth. So I'll still have to obey.

 

Viva Papa Francisco!

 

Vive Pape Francois!

 

Viva Papa Francesco!

 

Long live Pope Francis!

 

:)

 

At Mass today, we prayed for the Pope, with no mention of shoes.

Edited by Evangetholic
Posted

anyway....

Posted

I don't think the "carnival is over" statement is probably true. It came originally from Polish media and was picked up by the BBC... and I doubt that the BBC did any additional fact-checking. Obviously he was offered the mozetta and refused it.

 

But Francis doesn't seem the type to be actively rude and insulting, not just to the Papal MC, but also to his predecessor, just before being going on the balcony to be presented to Rome and the world as the new pope.

 

What is really irritating is Cardinal Mahoney... he of the letters helpfully warning pedophiles not to return to CA so as to escape the law. these are some of his recent tweets:


 

So long, Papal ermine and fancy lace! Welcome, simple cassock, and hopefully, ordinary black shoes! St. Francis must be overjoyed!!

 

At our meeting today with Pope Francis, I noted that is still wearing his older black shoes. I pray that he keeps them as a sign for us all

 

Mass with Pope Francis: moving from HIGH Church to LOW and humble Church! What a blessing that we are encountering Jesus without trappings!

 

More or less openly making odious comparisons to the former holy father... This man is a disgrace in every respect, and how is it that Archbishop Gomez's silencing of him doesn't apply to twitter and his blog?

Posted (edited)

I rather like him too... I had been hoping someone would take the name Leo XIV after the Pope of Rerum Novarum for these difficult economic times, but Francis was probably a better choice.

 

Maggie, I agree, aside from some of the rash over reactions of some traditionalists out there predicting doom and gloom, the thing that has so far made me most sick was seeing Mahoney's tweets. Clear and open disrespect for Benedict, personally I don't think Pope Francis would approve of those tweets. 

Edited by Aloysius
Posted

Mahony seems to be a sad and bitter fellow. Prayers for him.

homeschoolmom
Posted

:popcorn: I knew it. :|

Guest
This topic is now closed to further replies.
×
×
  • Create New...