Nihil Obstat Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 "As generously as possible" meaning "as few as possible"? Yeah, 200 seems like it'd be impossible anywhere but a huge city with lots of Catholics. Lafayette has a MEF once a month. When I get there, I want to put a lot of work into getting it more often. Not in so many words, but I believe that has been the intention, and I *think* that Universae Ecclesiae also supported a generous interpretation.
Basilisa Marie Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 Well, ideally you'd be shopping around at all the local parishes to get all the people together who want an EF mass, so hopefully you'd get at least a couple dozen. And if a priest was already well versed in it, all you'd need is the okay from the bishop to have one, so you'd probably need even fewer people.
Lil Red Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 Sometimes I feel sad about all the witty comments I must miss when I skip threads. :blush: :pinch: we heard you the first time.
beaverman Posted May 2, 2013 Author Posted May 2, 2013 . . . my priest had to ask permission for us to kneel, otherwise we'd be flouting his authority and that's sinful. . . . . You can't just go over his head and do what you want because that's how they do it in Rome. :) So is whatever the bishop declares as the norm makes it objectively true? If the bishop declared the norm as standing on our heads during the consecration, then should we obey him? What is the bishop basing his beliefs on? Shouldn't it be by the standards of the Vatican and not his personal opinion? Really? Kneeling during the consecration is sinful just because a bishop disagrees with it? I find that a little ridiculous. I can't imagine being in purgatory for kneeling and refusing to stand during the consecration.
Norseman82 Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 Wait... using clay vessels is liturgical abuse? I admit I didn't like it when I saw it, but I didn't know it's verboten. Is it? Because they hold the Body and Blood of Christ, they should be neither porous nor breakable.
jim111 Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 How to Establish theTraditional Latin Mass at Your Parish I am working on this in my home parish. I created Facebook group called Sandusky Latin Mass Society, and already have 28 people singed up. I also work really hard to get people in campus to go to the TLM, few people actually go, but I have a lot of people who gave me there name and email for the signup list. As long as your positive about it, you should be able to easily get 100 signatures.
Basilisa Marie Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 So is whatever the bishop declares as the norm makes it objectively true? If the bishop declared the norm as standing on our heads during the consecration, then should we obey him? What is the bishop basing his beliefs on? Shouldn't it be by the standards of the Vatican and not his personal opinion? Really? Kneeling during the consecration is sinful just because a bishop disagrees with it? I find that a little ridiculous. I can't imagine being in purgatory for kneeling and refusing to stand during the consecration. It doesn't make it objectively true, and kneeling in itself is obviously not sinful. But the fact is that when we disobey our bishops, we're disobeying Christ. EVEN IF we disagree with our bishop's decision. It's not their person or their decision that is holy, it is the authority that is invested in them, the authority that comes from Christ. A bishop has legitimate authority over his own diocese, and if I reside in his diocese, I am bound to obey him. If I don't, I'm placing myself above the Church's authority and effectively saying that apostolic succession doesn't matter. How can we tell others to obey the pope in large things if we can't even handle obeying our own bishop in small things? Don't we tell liberal Catholics to just trust in the Church's authority on matters that the liberal Catholic has trouble understanding? How can we tell them to do that if we can't even handle doing a simple liturgical posture we don't prefer until we get permission to do the one we want?
beaverman Posted May 2, 2013 Author Posted May 2, 2013 But the fact is that when we disobey our bishops, we're disobeying Christ. EVEN IF we disagree with our bishop's decision. It's not their person or their decision that is holy, it is the authority that is invested in them, the authority that comes from Christ. A bishop has legitimate authority over his own diocese, and if I reside in his diocese, I am bound to obey him. If I don't, I'm placing myself above the Church's authority and effectively saying that apostolic succession doesn't matter. But Shouldn't his authority should only be used to reaffirm the traditions and teachings of the Church and not his personal judgments? What bounds does his authority have? "Don't we tell liberal Catholics to just trust in the Church's authority on matters that the liberal Catholic has trouble understanding?" I think that's the point I'm making. The Church has stated that kneeling during the consecration is the norm. Why would anyone want to change that?
GeorgiiMichael Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 But Shouldn't his authority should only be used to reaffirm the traditions and teachings of the Church and not his personal judgments? What bounds does his authority have? "Don't we tell liberal Catholics to just trust in the Church's authority on matters that the liberal Catholic has trouble understanding?" I think that's the point I'm making. The Church has stated that kneeling during the consecration is the norm. Why would anyone want to change that? It doesn't matter why someone would want to change that. If they're your bishop, you need to obey them because of their authority. You can petition them to change it, and you can petition the Vatican to get them to change it, but until the bishop has changed his ruling, you need to obey the bishop.
KnightofChrist Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 It doesn't make it objectively true, and kneeling in itself is obviously not sinful. But the fact is that when we disobey our bishops, we're disobeying Christ. EVEN IF we disagree with our bishop's decision. It's not their person or their decision that is holy, it is the authority that is invested in them, the authority that comes from Christ. A bishop has legitimate authority over his own diocese, and if I reside in his diocese, I am bound to obey him. If I don't, I'm placing myself above the Church's authority and effectively saying that apostolic succession doesn't matter. How can we tell others to obey the pope in large things if we can't even handle obeying our own bishop in small things? Don't we tell liberal Catholics to just trust in the Church's authority on matters that the liberal Catholic has trouble understanding? How can we tell them to do that if we can't even handle doing a simple liturgical posture we don't prefer until we get permission to do the one we want? It is NOT disobedience to kneel during or after communion, even if Bishops say otherwise. Bishops and priests do not have the legitimate authority to require/force the faithful to stand while receiving or after communion. "...while this Congregation gave the recognitio to the norm desired by the Bishops' Conference of your country that people stand for Holy Communion, this was done on the condition that communicants who choose to kneel are not to be denied Holy Communion on these grounds. Indeed, the faithful should not be imposed upon nor accused of disobedience and of acting illicitly when they kneel to receive Holy Communion". - Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments Dubium: In many places, the faithful are accustomed to kneeling or sitting in personal prayer upon returning to their places after individually received Holy Communion during Mass. Is it the intention of the Missale Romanum, editio typica tertia, to forbid this practice? Responsum: Negative, et ad mentem. The mens is that that the prescription of the Institutio Generalis Missalis Romani, no. 43, is intended, on one hand, to ensure within broad limits a certain uniformity of posture within the congregation for the various parts of the celebration of the Holy Mass, and on the other, to not regulate posture rigidly in such a way that those who wish to kneel or sit would no longer be free. Francis Cardinal Arinze Prefecthttp://www.ewtn.com/library/CURIA/CDWCLAR.HTMhttp://www.adoremus.org/0703Kneel.html http://forums.catholic.com/showthread.php?t=2796 -- "There is no rule from Rome that everybody must stand during Holy Communion. There is no such rule from Rome. So, after people have received Communion, they can stand, they can kneel, they can sit. But a bishop in his diocese or bishops in a country could say that they recommend standing or kneeling. They could. It is not a law from Rome. They could -- but not impose it. Perhaps they could propose. But those who want to sit or kneel or stand should be left reasonable freedom." - Francis Cardinal Arinze http://www.adoremus.org/1003Arinze.html -- GIRM 43 "They should, however, sit while the readings before the Gospel and the responsorial Psalm are proclaimed and for the homily and while the Preparation of the Gifts at the Offertory is taking place; and, as circumstances allow, they may sit or kneel while the period of sacred silence after Communion is observed."
ToJesusMyHeart Posted May 2, 2013 Posted May 2, 2013 KnightofChrist, props. I'm out. But major props.
Basilisa Marie Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 (edited) Nope. http://www.catholic.com/quickquestions/can-the-bishop-require-the-congregation-to-stand-after-the-lamb-of-god Full Question The bishop of my diocese said that everyone should remain standing after the Agnus Dei and should continue to stand until everyone has received Communion. Can he do this? Answer There are two separate issues here. First, a bishop in the United States can require that congregations in his diocese remain standing after the Agnus Dei until the reception of Communion. If your bishop has mandated that the congregations should remain standing after the Agnus Dei, then you should stand as has been directed: In the dioceses of the United States of America, they should kneel beginning after the singing or recitation of the Sanctus until after the Amen of the Eucharistic Prayer, except when prevented on occasion by reasons of health, lack of space, the large number of people present, or some other good reason. Those who do not kneel ought to make a profound bow when the priest genuflects after the consecration. The faithful kneel after the Agnus Dei unless the diocesan bishop determines otherwise. (GIRM 43, emphasis added) Second, the bishop does not determine a congregant’s posture after the congregant has received Communion. After each congregant has received Communion, the congregant may choose to stand, sit, or kneel. The congregant does not have to wait for the rest of the congregation to receive before assuming the posture of his choice. If you wish to sit or kneel at this point, the choice is yours. In 2003, the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments (CDW) released a response upholding this. The question-and-answer can be read on the Web site of Adoremus (www.adoremus.org). This response by the CDW has been thought by some to indicate that the bishop cannot mandate that the congregation remain standing after the Agnus Dei. This is not the case. The response was a clarification of number 43 of the GIRM, not a negation of it. This means that while the bishop can mandate standing until the individual reception of Communion, he does not mandate that individuals may not kneel after receiving Communion. Michelle Arnold says I win. :) Edited May 3, 2013 by Basilisa Marie
ToJesusMyHeart Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 (edited) Cardinal Arinze, Prefect for the Congregation for Divine Worship and the Discipline of the Sacraments says otherwise. I speak in reference to the first quote provided by KoC. Edited May 3, 2013 by ToJesusMyHeart
EmilyAnn Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 Maybe I'm missing something but Basilisa Marie isn't actually talking about kneeling for receiving the Eucharist. She's talking about kneeling at other points in the Mass.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 In the US, we have the option of kneeling or standing. If one's bishop says that he wants everyone to do one or the other, we should obey him out of respect for his authority, even if we don't feel like it. So while both are good and holy and acceptable postures according to the Church, a bishop is free and able to make the call about what he wants in his diocese concerning things like this. So, for example, a while ago when my bishop at the time made standing the norm in my diocese, my priest had to ask permission for us to kneel, otherwise we'd be flouting his authority and that's sinful. My bishop gladly gave it, though it made for some strange looks and interesting conversations when my parish's youth group went to a retreat put on by the diocese. Everyone was confused as to why we were kneeling, and we were confused as to why they were standing. :hehe2: Then my priest explained it to us. My point in bringing it up is that when we're figuring out which liturgical posture we want to do we have to take what our own bishop has said about the matter into account (if he's said anything at all). You can't just go over his head and do what you want because that's how they do it in Rome. :) EmilyAnn, that's not what she seems to be implying here. She's speaking in reference to kneeling for reception of Jesus. She asserted that if the bishop forbids the naughty kneeling behavior, we'd have to comply. This is not the case, as KoC provided evidence for.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 Perhaps I misunderstand Basilia though. Hopefully she can clarify what she is arguing. I'm defending the universal right to kneel for reception of Holy Communion. If she is arguing the posture for before and after consecration, then I've been mis-applying her quotations. It is clear from the quote from Cardinal Arinze that bishops cannot mandate standing as the only acceptable posture for reception of Jesus, but seems less clear if they can mandate standing as the only posture before and during the miracle of transubstantiation.
EmilyAnn Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 In her last post at least, she is clearly not talking about the reception of the Eucharist, and in the last post you quoted in the context I think it's about before/after the consecration (as that was . She does quote the GIRM referring to posture after the consecration, where it seems clear that bishops do have authority.
ToJesusMyHeart Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 As long as we all agree that bishops cannot force people to stand for reception of Jesus, then I'm not interested in any other arguments. :)
Basilisa Marie Posted May 3, 2013 Posted May 3, 2013 Well, in honesty, my argument has shifted a bit over the course of the thread. I may or may not had been hoping no one would notice, haha. :) Y'all caught me. My point now is that a bishop DOES have the authority to make a call about liturgical postures at some points in the liturgy of the Eucharist, and when our bishop does exercise that authority, we have to obey him, even if we don't like it. Though personally speaking I think it's crud for a priest to offer "pastoral correction" for someone who wants to kneel to receive, just because it's conspicuous, and I'm glad it's no longer a thing. Question for you guys, though - do you kneel or remain standing after the Sanctus? I can't remember which one I do more often, probably because I should pay attention more. I know I've done both within the last six months, but I've also been in three difference dioceses in the last six months. Does it matter to you guys?
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now