Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Since We've Been Talking About Lgbtq Stuff A Lot Lately...


Recommended Posts

LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

I love the "Q," as if considering the possibility of being attracted to someone of the same sex qualifies you as a member of a minority group in need of support.

 

Your comment seriously bothers me, because it comes off as insensitive and the sarcasm wasn't necessary.

 

I put the 'Q' in there for a reason (and it should be there), for those who SERIOUSLY are questioning their sexuality and how it can affect their life in a drastic way. The Q means something to those people, to be able to talk, ask questions and find SUPPORT when they aren't sure of themselves. There are many questioning people who can't talk about their sexuality without being shunned, ridiculed, called disordered, etc. because they are struggling with something they don't even understand themselves. The 'B' is in LGBTQ for a reason too, because there are people with both inclinations and attractions to both sexes. It's confusing, it's difficult, and it's something that's very sensitive to those who are questioning.

 

I'm not denying that there are people who take advantage of the 'Q' in LGBTQ. But be charitable to those who truly are questioning themselves and their sexuality. They're still human beings, and they are no less than you or me.

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I thought the Q stood for "Qwerty". I have heard of people identifying as that rather than as gay or lesbian or whatever. Not quite sure what it means.

LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

I thought the Q stood for "Qwerty". I have heard of people identifying as that rather than as gay or lesbian or whatever. Not quite sure what it means.

 

http://www.depts.ttu.edu/scc/Virtual_Library/lgbtq.php

 

L stands for lesbians – women whose primary emotional, romantic, sexual, or affectional attractions are to other women. 

G stands for gay men – men whose primary emotional, romantic, sexual, or affectional attractions are to other men. 

B stands for bisexuals – men or women whose primary emotional, romantic, sexual, or affectional attractions are to both women and men. 

T stands for transgendered – a broad term that includes cross-dressers, transsexuals, and people who live substantial portions of their lives as other than their birth gender. A transgendered person is someone whose gender identity and/or expression differ from conventional expectations for their physical birth sex. Gender identity refers to the internal sense of being male or female, while gender expression refers to how someone presents his or her gender to the world through style of dress, mannerisms, and so on. A transitioning transgender person is one who is modifying her or his physical characteristics and manner of expression to – in effect –satisfy the standards for membership in another gender. Transgender people can be straight, gay, lesbian or bisexual. 

Q stands for questioning – someone who is questioning their sexual and/or gender orientation. Sometimes, the Q stands for “queer,” a term reclaimed by some LGBTs for political reasons. 

What people in these groups all have in common is that they challenge the heterosexist norms of mainstream society and are stigmatized as a result; otherwise, the LGBTQ community is very diverse with respect to ethnic and cultural backgrounds, physical ability, religion, personality traits, socioeconomic class, and many other attributes

 

 

It can mean both, but it was originally put in for those who are questioning.

Little Flower
Posted

I am confused by the purpose of this topic. Are we attempting to condone homosexuality?

 

 

You know, attractions for people of the same gender is really no different than for example attractions to young boys or something like that. They are all disordered passions, and although those who have them certainly have a heavy cross to carry, that does not mean that we should condone the actions that these attractions tempt them to. I doubt there is a single American who thinks that because pedophiles are sexually attracted to children, that that is OK to act on because "that is just how they are." However, people use that line of reasoning to justify homosexuality, which is just another kind of disordered affection. It is a disorder that should be treated, not something that we should all just accept and condone.

 

Just to be clear, I don't want to come across as judgmental; I believe that we should always treat others with love and respect no matter who they are or what they have done. LGBTQ people are no different. However, there is a difference between loving the sinner and condoning the sin.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I understand what you mean... the desire itself is not correct: because if consented to, it's a sin. I think what people sometimes say is that - we shouldn't treat homosexuals like a special class of people that we pick on, and ignore other sins. I think that all grave sins are serious: for example, fornication is serious too. It's also wrong to do that. But - there's the other extreme of also treating homosexual people like a separate group but in the opposite way: going beyond treating them with charity as persons (and recognizing that we are sinners too), - and actually supporting the homosexual attractions or actions. I don't really know what the people in this thread mean, since it's a Catholic forum I assume everyone who's Catholic agrees that homosexuality (as a behavior) is sinful... but just putting this out there :)

 

Maybe the reason people react differently to another desire that's against natural law - like pedophilia - is because there, we can easily see someone (the child) be hurt. In homosexuality, we often hear the argument that "no one gets hurt". Of course, sin hurts us though, in a deeper way that maybe others can observe. It hurts our souls. It's maybe just more hidden to other people, and sometimes ourselves, if we numb our conscience enough. There's always hope to turn to God though... we should never despair, but pray to repent and come back. Also, homosexuality affects society, and in turn, children, who grow up being taught it's okay.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
Lilllabettt
Posted

I have seen similar "experiments" where people pretend to be fat, black, hijab-wearing Muslim women for a day/week/month.

They are offensive.

It is offensive for someone to put on a costume and "play" a role for awhile, and then take off the costume and go on to presume to talk about the lived experience of real people who are not wearing a costume at all.  This guy does not know what its like to be gay. He knows what its like to pretend to be gay. Thats it.

LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

I am confused by the purpose of this topic. Are we attempting to condone homosexuality?

 

Just to be clear, I don't want to come across as judgmental; I believe that we should always treat others with love and respect no matter who they are or what they have done. LGBTQ people are no different. However, there is a difference between loving the sinner and condoning the sin.

 

I never said anything about condoning homosexuality. I was just pointing out that the comment was insensitive to those who are honestly struggling and questioning themselves and their sexuality. That's where treating others with love and respect comes in.
 

You know, attractions for people of the same gender is really no different than for example attractions to young boys or something like that. They are all disordered passions, and although those who have them certainly have a heavy cross to carry, that does not mean that we should condone the actions that these attractions tempt them to. I doubt there is a single American who thinks that because pedophiles are sexually attracted to children, that that is OK to act on because "that is just how they are." However, people use that line of reasoning to justify homosexuality, which is just another kind of disordered affection. It is a disorder that should be treated, not something that we should all just accept and condone.

 

 

In my opinion this is not a logical comparison at all, because there's a huge difference between the two. Pedophiles who purposefully go after innocent children WITH criminal intentions and sexual abuse is completely different from a person who is gay and has the capacity to love like heterosexuals do WITHOUT criminal intentions and abuse. Out of the many people I know who are gay, NONE of them have any desire to go after a person of the same sex and commit a crime. Comparing the two is disrespectful, especially to the people who are gay that are trying to live a chaste lifestyle. Yes, there are chaste gays out there too, and one of them happens to be my very Catholic best friend.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I agree that homosexuals don't have an intention to do something like pedophiles do, I think maybe the point is just that - both desires go against natural law... am I correct that this is what was meant? 

 

I think on one hand, it's true that the intention might be different, on another hand, I don't think that "wanting to love" excuses sin because we should love God first. I think a person who has SSA and chooses to remain celibate for the sake of following Christ, shows love.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

I agree that homosexuals don't have an intention to do something like pedophiles do, I think maybe the point is just that - both desires go against natural law... am I correct that this is what was meant? 

 

Yep, wasn't disagreeing with you on that.
 

I think on one hand, it's true that the intention might be different, on another hand, I don't think that "wanting to love" excuses sin because we should love God first.

 

I'm not sure what you mean by "wanting to love"? Can you clarify?

 

I think a person who has SSA and chooses to remain celibate for the sake of following Christ, shows love.

 

Amen. :amen: :notworthy2:

franciscanheart
Posted

I am confused by the purpose of this topic. Are we attempting to condone homosexuality?


You know, attractions for people of the same gender is really no different than for example attractions to young boys or something like that. They are all disordered passions, and although those who have them certainly have a heavy cross to carry, that does not mean that we should condone the actions that these attractions tempt them to. I doubt there is a single American who thinks that because pedophiles are sexually attracted to children, that that is OK to act on because "that is just how they are." However, people use that line of reasoning to justify homosexuality, which is just another kind of disordered affection. It is a disorder that should be treated, not something that we should all just accept and condone.

Just to be clear, I don't want to come across as judgmental; I believe that we should always treat others with love and respect no matter who they are or what they have done. LGBTQ people are no different. However, there is a difference between loving the sinner and condoning the sin.

I don't know who you are or where you're from but homosexuality is not a disorder that needs treating like diabetes or cancer or something. What an ignorant thing to say!

It is not a sin to be gay. How dare you suggest that homosexuals are sinners simply because they are. And how dare you suggest they are in need of some kind of help!

If this is not at all what you meant to imply, perhaps you will rethink how you present your opinions on the matter.
MarysLittleFlower
Posted

Yep, wasn't disagreeing with you on that.
 

 

I'm not sure what you mean by "wanting to love"? Can you clarify?

 

 

Amen. :amen: :notworthy2:

 

when I said "wanting to love", I meant how sometimes people say that homosexual people should be in relationships because "they love one another".

I don't know who you are or where you're from but homosexuality is not a disorder that needs treating like diabetes or cancer or something. What an ignorant thing to say!

It is not a sin to be gay. How dare you suggest that homosexuals are sinners simply because they are. And how dare you suggest they are in need of some kind of help!

If this is not at all what you meant to imply, perhaps you will rethink how you present your opinions on the matter.

I don't think the poster was saying that it's a sin to BE gay, I think they were talking about the homosexual desires... if I'm correct :)

 

as for it being disordered, - the Catechism does say that homosexual desires are "intrinsically disordered", if I remember. (someone correct me if I'm misattributing the quote). It's talking about the desires btw. (I think the poster meant that too?)

 

as for homosexual people needing help - don't we all need help to avoid sin, whatever our weakness is? I think we wouldn't really help people with SSA if we didn't, as a Church, provide them with some sort of help in dealing with SSA :) to help them be celibate etc..since it could be difficult.. I don't think that's an insult. I need help too, to avoid my sins.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)
double post...
Edited by MarysLittleFlower
LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

when I said "wanting to love", I meant how sometimes people say that homosexual people should be in relationships because "they love one another".

 

I think it's unfair to say that. God intended for all human beings to have a right to love. Wanting to love someone is human nature.

 

Relationships, however, are a totally different ball game. There are so many different aspects that contribute to them physically, mentally, and emotionally. They're very personal and sensitive, and every relationship is different in its own way whether it's a gay or straight relationship, and everyone has different experiences and interpretations on them. Therefore, I don't feel like I can comment on them effectively without pissing someone off in some way, which I really don't want to do.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I think it's unfair to say that. God intended for all human beings to have a right to love. Wanting to love someone is human nature.

 

Relationships, however, are a totally different ball game. There are so many different aspects that contribute to them physically, mentally, and emotionally. They're very personal and sensitive, and every relationship is different in its own way whether it's a gay or straight relationship, and everyone has different experiences and interpretations on them. Therefore, I don't feel like I can comment on them effectively without pissing someone off in some way, which I really don't want to do.

 

Lina, I don't think I really understand what you're saying. I'm going to clarify what I mean and maybe that would help :)

 

what I'm saying specifically is that I don't think it goes with Catholic teaching to approve of gay relationships because "the people want to love one another". The same goes for any sin. It would not even be truly charitable to tell the homosexual people this: because true charity wants the highest good for another, which is salvation. If someone brings another person into sin because they "love them", - what's actually happening is they're putting the person into a sin that would put them in hell. This is one of the reasons perhaps why our conscience needs to be properly informed. My whole point is that I disagree with saying things like "the two men love one another, let them be 'married' and it's okay..." or "the two unmarried love one another, who cares if they 'wait till marriage'".. etc. This makes love something removed from truth and God's law, but truth and love go together :) and love of God is the first Commandment.

 

I know someone might be angry reading my post, but I'm just trying to say what the Church teaches, not to annoy someone. I can't change what the Church teaches, and neither can anyone for that matter.

 

I think that wanting to love another person can be expressed well through sacrificing something you want (like a relationship with them) in order to help them get to Heaven. It's not expressed well through putting them in hell, even if it seems like love here on earth. It won't end well. It won't help them. Also if a person feels the need to BE loved, and so they want to be in a relationship, that could be found in God, much more than in any creature.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

Lina, I don't think I really understand what you're saying. I'm going to clarify what I mean and maybe that would help :)

 

what I'm saying specifically is that I don't think it goes with Catholic teaching to approve of gay relationships because "the people want to love one another". The same goes for any sin. It would not even be truly charitable to tell the homosexual people this: because true charity wants the highest good for another, which is salvation. If someone brings another person into sin because they "love them", - what's actually happening is they're putting the person into a sin that would put them in hell. This is one of the reasons perhaps why our conscience needs to be properly informed. My whole point is that I disagree with saying things like "the two men love one another, let them be 'married' and it's okay..." or "the two unmarried love one another, who cares if they 'wait till marriage'".. etc. This makes love something removed from truth and God's law, but truth and love go together :) and love of God is the first Commandment.

 

I know someone might be angry reading my post, but I'm just trying to say what the Church teaches, not to annoy someone. I can't change what the Church teaches, and neither can anyone for that matter.

 

I think that wanting to love another person can be expressed well through sacrificing something you want (like a relationship with them) in order to help them get to Heaven. It's not expressed well through putting them in hell, even if it seems like love here on earth. It won't end well. It won't help them. Also if a person feels the need to BE loved, and so they want to be in a relationship, that could be found in God, much more than in any creature.

 

Yeah I think you missed my point.

 

The reason why I didn't want to comment on relationships is because every relationship is unique. I can't make a generalization about them that anyone can fully agree with.

 

Like franciscanheart said, being gay is not a sin. Loving another person is not a sin either. Since there's diversity in the way people view relationships, combined with being gay and loving someone not being sins, that's why I said that relationships are a completely different ball games. Being in a relationship doesn't automatically mean marriage either. And once again, marriage is another ball game entirely.

 

For example: there's two women who go to my church. They're both lesbian, and they've considered themselves to be in a relationship because they honestly love each other. They've been together for at least 15 years. But here's the catch, they're not engaging in any type of sinful activity with each other. They are chaste, they don't live together, they are not legally married, they aren't putting each other into sin because they love one another, and they try to love and follow Christ as much as you and I do. They go to church together, they volunteer together, they are faithful companions to one another, they've been through thick and thin, they find ways to be together that won't jeopardize their love and faithfulness to Christ.

Is it difficult? Absolutely. Have they failed sometimes? Probably, we all fail at some point. Is it possible? They make it work somehow.

 

That's the point I was trying to make. I think it's unfair to say that those who are gay can't be in a relationship. Not all relationships involve premarital sex or any other sexual activity that can lead to sin, and its unfair to assume that for both straight and gay relationships. We can't automatically assume these things, we can't see things as black and white because there's so much grey in between. Ultimately, God is the one to judge us, we can't judge our own or anyone elses salvation by things that are automatically assumed. Is it honestly fair to judge the two women I described above to go to hell because they're in a gay relationship without fully knowing the lengths they go through together to be faithful Christians? It goes the same way for a man and a woman who are in a relationship.

 

That's what I meant when I said this

 

I think it's unfair to say that. God intended for all human beings to have a right to love. Wanting to love someone is human nature.

 

Relationships, however, are a totally different ball game. There are so many different aspects that contribute to them physically, mentally, and emotionally. They're very personal and sensitive, and every relationship is different in its own way whether it's a gay or straight relationship, and everyone has different experiences and interpretations on them. Therefore, I don't feel like I can comment on them effectively without pissing someone off in some way, which I really don't want to do.

 

 

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

Yeah I think you missed my point.

 

The reason why I didn't want to comment on relationships is because every relationship is unique. I can't make a generalization about them that anyone can fully agree with.

 

Like franciscanheart said, being gay is not a sin. Loving another person is not a sin either. Since there's diversity in the way people view relationships, combined with being gay and loving someone not being sins, that's why I said that relationships are a completely different ball games. Being in a relationship doesn't automatically mean marriage either. And once again, marriage is another ball game entirely.

 

For example: there's two women who go to my church. They're both lesbian, and they've considered themselves to be in a relationship because they honestly love each other. They've been together for at least 15 years. But here's the catch, they're not engaging in any type of sinful activity with each other. They are chaste, they don't live together, they are not legally married, they aren't putting each other into sin because they love one another, and they try to love and follow Christ as much as you and I do. They go to church together, they volunteer together, they are faithful companions to one another, they've been through thick and thin, they find ways to be together that won't jeopardize their love and faithfulness to Christ.

Is it difficult? Absolutely. Have they failed sometimes? Probably, we all fail at some point. Is it possible? They make it work somehow.

 

That's the point I was trying to make. I think it's unfair to say that those who are gay can't be in a relationship. Not all relationships involve premarital sex or any other sexual activity that can lead to sin, and its unfair to assume that for both straight and gay relationships. We can't automatically assume these things, we can't see things as black and white because there's so much grey in between. Ultimately, God is the one to judge us, we can't judge our own or anyone elses salvation by things that are automatically assumed. Is it honestly fair to judge the two women I described above to go to hell because they're in a gay relationship without fully knowing the lengths they go through together to be faithful Christians? It goes the same way for a man and a woman who are in a relationship.

 

That's what I meant when I said this

 

Thanks for clarifying. I was talking about relationships where sexual activity or intent of sexual activity is part of it. (including kissing and such).

 

I am thinking about the example that you provided... then is it just friendship? If their feelings are more than friendship, I'd wonder if this presents an occasion of sin for them? (I don't know but that's a question I got in my mind after reading this). If I had feelings for a married man, for example, I'd be worried about being around him all the time cause then I'd be tempted to impure thoughts (which would be wrong) or even actions. I am not commenting on their particular case cause I don't know them, but on the whole concept of such a relationship.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

Thanks for clarifying. I was talking about relationships where sexual activity or intent of sexual activity is part of it. (including kissing and such).

 

I am thinking about the example that you provided... then is it just friendship? If their feelings are more than friendship, I'd wonder if this presents an occasion of sin for them? (I don't know but that's a question I got in my mind after reading this). If I had feelings for a married man, for example, I'd be worried about being around him all the time cause then I'd be tempted to impure thoughts (which would be wrong) or even actions. I am not commenting on their particular case cause I don't know them, but on the whole concept of such a relationship.

 

I've known these women for a long time, pretty much all my life, and I'm sure it's not just a friendship. They are very much attracted to one another, they have been in a relationship for over 15 years after all. But they are also more willing, with God's grace, to be faithful Christians. And they are making it work.

 

See, I'm sure that they struggle with their purity just like you and I do with our own. But they turn to God for His grace. God still loves them just as he loves you and I and anyone else.

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

There was never a question about God loving them.........

 

I'm just wondering, if such an arrangement would present an occasion of sin for someone. I think it would for me, that's why I said that. Not talking about their situation only, but just such relationships generally or hypothetically speaking.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower
LinaSt.Cecilia2772
Posted

There was never a question about God loving them.........

 

I'm just wondering, if such an arrangement would present an occasion of sin for someone. I think it would for me, that's why I said that. Not talking about their situation only, but just such relationships generally or hypothetically speaking.

 

I see what you mean. But realistically if you think about it, there are occasions for sin all the time. It's almost impossible to completely avoid it. We can do our best to avoid it, but truthfully it all comes down to the will of someone to not give in. I bet if the women I talk about weren't in a relationship, they would still struggle. It's the same way for those who are straight.

 

I'm glad that things were clarified. I think that this was a good discussion to have. :)

MarysLittleFlower
Posted (edited)

I see what you are saying Lina, but based on everything I've read or heard about Catholic teaching, it's a sin for us to put ourselves in an occasion of sin. There's a difference between us coming across them when we're not looking for them, and putting ourselves into situations where we know we may be tempted. If a person is just trying to fulfill their duties, let's say going to work, and they come across something that tempts them, - their intention had nothing to do with it. But if a person goes into a situation knowingly, from what I read, that is already a sin...... so I guess then it depends, if a certain situation is an occasion of sin, if the person knows it is, etc. Sometimes our only solution... is to give up something, even if we care a lot about it. I know it's hard. Regarding this particular couple - that's something God and them know about.

Edited by MarysLittleFlower

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...