Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

KnightofChrist
Posted

I don't support or not support it. I'm just interested in the situation and understanding why the decision is being made. I think the president and everyone involved are smart people, and have reasons for doing what they do. That's why they're in government. Only history will prove if they were good reasons or not.

 

Our recent discussion on the conflict in Egypt lead me to believe you did not support these types of 'crusades'.
 

Posted

Our recent discussion on the conflict in Egypt lead me to believe you did not support these types of 'crusades'.
 

 

The Egypt thread was not about foreign policy.

Posted

I am also undecided as to where I stand. 

 

Posted

I'm standing against it because our government has not done enough to assure any of us that this is just. They don't have a plan beyond some bombing, at least not that they want to tell us about. They won't say what, exactly, they intend to bomb. We don't have a clear plan on how to get out once the job is done, and the scope of the job is nebulous and undefined. Why in heck would I trust someone who didn't care to properly explain their plans when their plans involve warplanes and high explosives?

KnightofChrist
Posted

The Egypt thread was not about foreign policy.

 

The type of weak US interest arguments could have been used for Egypt. But even most of the pro/friendly Obama media that I've read agrees the argument for a strike against Syria based on US Interest is very weak. Both are internal conflicts in foreign nations that will not much effect the United States. I am against intervention in Syria, epically if empirical evidence cannot be produced proving that Assad's regime was behind the WMD attack. I see no good coming out of a strike, I see more problems being created if it does strike.

Posted (edited)

The type of weak US interest arguments could have been used for Egypt. But even most of the pro/friendly Obama media that I've read agrees the argument for a strike against Syria based on US Interest is very weak. Both are internal conflicts in foreign nations that will not much effect the United States. I am against intervention in Syria, epically if empirical evidence cannot be produced proving that Assad's regime was behind the WMD attack. I see no good coming out of a strike, I see more problems being created if it does strike.

 

I don't look at things "pro" or "against" Obama. He's the president of the United States. But putting that aside, all that is fine area for discussion. I don't think one has to question the American investigation or have a general distrust of things in order to analyze this critically. There are a lot of legitimate questions this raises, such as to what is the strategic endgame, etc.

 

"US interest" is kind of broad. There could be any number of strategic reasons that the U.S. acts. Some of it could be posturing, which is an important part of international relations. During the Taiwan Straight Crises in the 50's China made a big military show toward Taiwan, but they sent subtle signals that it was all show, they had to posture in order to defend their status as a country that will not be bullied. That's just one example of a million different things that we have no idea is going on. It's fine for the American people to have their say, but in reality most of us have no clue what is or is not in American interests, except on an armchair level. And that's fine, and I think moral objections have their place in society. But the people who actually make decisions are going to make decisions based on their large base of knowledge, both theoretical and actual.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Another idiotic war that is completely outside any of the authority granted to the Federal government. 

Nihil Obstat
Posted

I am saying that the US could be both wrong AND lying, and have been before, and in any case, even if they did start a war in good faith, the US has a long history of committing horrifying atrocities in war that rival the ones they claim to combat.

Smart man.
Posted

Another article, this one on the Middle East dynamics:

 

http://www.foreignpolicy.com/articles/2013/08/27/how_assad_united_the_middle_east_against_him

 

The administration's case for military action against Assad is being bolstered by help from Israel, which provided intelligence that was reportedly vital to the United States in its quick determination that the Syrian regime launched the chemical weapons attack in the eastern Damascus suburbs. Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu has been equally adamant that this attack cannot go unanswered: He said that the use of chemical weapons "must not continue," and linked the struggle against the Assad regime with Israel's long-running cold war against Iran. "Assad's regime has become a full Iranian client and Syria has become Iran's testing ground," he said. "Iran is watching and it wants to see what would be the reaction on the use of chemical weapons."
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

Well I guess theoretically anything is possible, who knows what is going on behind the scenes. But is there any circumstantial reason why the U.S. would want to get involved in Syria under false pretense? And is there legitimate evidence that the U.S. is wrong in its conclusions about the chemical weapons? Are you saying the U.S. may be wrong, or that it may be lying?

 

I don't know... America could be lying about chemical weapons but if it was I don't think it'd be for a monetary goal. I'm about to speak without fact checking (you should be used to that by now). There's a reason why the US and much of the world haven't done much in Syria. While taking Bashar out would be good for stability in the region, replacing him with a religious government wouldn't. Even Israel would prefer Bashar over that possibility. I'm not convinced that the chemical gas claims are disingenuous though. I think I remember one of my Syrian friends showing me something about it from an oppositional news source (though I guess that could be faked as well). 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

I don't know... America could be lying about chemical weapons but if it was I don't think it'd be for a monetary goal. I'm about to speak without fact checking (you should already know that by now). There's a reason why the US, and much of the world, hasn't done much in Syria. While taking Bashar out would be good for stability in the region, replacing him with a religious government wouldn't. Even Israel would prefer Bashar over that possibility. I'm not convinced that the chemical gas claims are disingenuous though. I think I remember one of my Syrian friends showing me something about it from a oppositional news source (though I guess that could be faked as well). 

 

I'm no expert in the Middle East / Arab region but it seems like the situation right now is something like the Third World in the 60's, Left-wing and Right-wing authorities trying to establish and maintain control, and the U.S. and Russia watching over it all. The situation is different, of course, but that question of "religious government" is crucial. What shape is the Middle East going to take? The Western dream solution would be for them to develop into national secular democracies, etc. I don't know if that's realistic. It seems like the first major goal of the West is to prevent someone like Iran from gaining hegemony over the region (probably wouldn't happen anyway, but you never know in these chaotic situations). And then preventing terrorist / fundamentalist groups from taking over individual countries. Making a limited response to chemical weapons use may seem like nothing, but what are the options? The idea, it seems, is to insist on this international norm against chemical weapons...maybe it's not a huge victory for the West, but it at least maintains precedent and does not just write the region off, and helps prevent that hegemon or fundamentalist government from gaining legitimacy in the future. idk, that's my armchair analysis.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

saw on the first page the question of what purpose the USA would have to get involved?  why, it's a little proxy war against Iran and, to a lesser extent, Russia.  there is EVERY motivation for the US to want to get involved in Syria.  any reason you could imagine for them not to want to get involved is completely off of the radar of the geopolitic game that they play at those high levels, budgets don't matter at that level--war is the health of the state--and good diplomatic relations with Russia are actually bad for war profiteers who need motivation for keeping the military funding growing.   of course they want to get involved.  if Assad falls, Iran is much more vulnerable in the Middle East... and the war drums have been beating now through two presidencies as the neocons in the CFR and congress and in both White Houses, have been drooling over war with Iran.  the US absolutely has been wanting to claim a reason to knock out Assad; however, they were for a long time hoping that the internal conflict would bleed him dry first; instead, Assad was summarily winning the war by conventional warfare (and therefore had no reason to turn to chemical weapons), so the US needs an excuse to ensure that he doesn't win... enter the big chemical weapons fiasco that would have had ZERO strategic purpose for Assad, and would have a LOT of strategic purpose for the Syrian Rebels (probably some small group of extremists to release it on their own people) and a LOT of strategic purpose for the USA and the west, whose hegemony in the middle east depends upon weakening Iran's power.

 

it's a fact that the Syrian rebels have obtained at least sarin gas, probably more stuff as well, there are videos showing them testing it on Rabbits, and even videos that are verifiably from within the Syrian rebel movement of them placing suspicious canisters onto rockets.  moreover, much of the evidence from the attack shows something very inconsistent with the Syrian government's stockpile of sophisticated chemical weapons, there are plenty of inconsistencies in the symptoms that have been pointed out but the real kicker pointed out by experts is the lack of protective gear from the people treating the victims, and the complete lack of symptoms exhibited by people who are treating the victims--huge inconsistency if Assad had lobbed something from his arsenal, but makes perfect sense if the rebels either had an accident with some of the chemical weapons they had obtained, or if some of the extremists within the various rebel factions had decided it was time to bring the west into the war and launched something basic themselves.

 

now, as to the LEGAL question, President Obama has consulted a bunch of international bodies from NATO to the Arab League to the UN, but he refuses to consult the only body that could give him the permission he needs, under the war powers act, to engage in such a strike.  this is totally unacceptable, and especially if he goes in without a UN resolution he will be on even more flimsy ground than Kosovo was (and that was already on pretty flimsy ground, he should need approval from the US congress).  this is absolutely illegal NOT ONLY under international law, but under US law.  http://www.law.cornell.edu/uscode/text/50/1541

 

someone tried to tell me it'd be okay if we classified what Assad is accused as doing as "terrorism"... however, as I pointed out, the Authorization for Use of Military Force that allows the President to attack "terrorists" actually only specifically authorizes attacks against Al Qaeda and their allies (in its broadest possible sane reading), and of course President Assad is an enemy of Al Qaeda (which is why Al Qaeda forces are among the Syrian forces fighting against him)... meaning that the President would be authorized to attack the Syrian Rebels by the AUMF, but to attack anyone else he would need authorization from congress.  Of course, we've always been at war with Eastasia, haven't we?

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

saw on the first page the question of what purpose the USA would have to get involved?  why, it's a little proxy war against Iran and, to a lesser extent, Russia.  there is EVERY motivation for the US to want to get involved in Syria.  any reason you could imagine for them not to want to get involved is completely off of the radar of the geopolitic game that they play at those high levels, budgets don't matter at that level--war is the health of the state--and good diplomatic relations with Russia are actually bad for war profiteers who need motivation for keeping the military funding growing.   of course they want to get involved.  if Assad falls, Iran is much more vulnerable in the Middle East... and the war drums have been beating now through two presidencies as the neocons in the CFR and congress and in both White Houses, have been drooling over war with Iran.  the US absolutely has been wanting to claim a reason to knock out Assad; however, they were for a long time hoping that the internal conflict would bleed him dry first; instead, Assad was summarily winning the war by conventional warfare (and therefore had no reason to turn to chemical weapons), so the US needs an excuse to ensure that he doesn't win... enter the big chemical weapons fiasco that would have had ZERO strategic purpose for Assad, and would have a LOT of strategic purpose for the Syrian Rebels (probably some small group of extremists to release it on their own people) and a LOT of strategic purpose for the USA and the west, whose hegemony in the middle east depends upon weakening Iran's power.

 

Interesting points. I disagree with the notion that the U.S. has been patiently waiting for an excuse to go in. 100,000 deaths is a good enough excuse if we wanted to find one. Let's consider Libya. There were thousands of deaths at most before we intervened militarily.

 

I don't know why we would be attacking now. Imo we're either bluffing or Iran/Syria pose such a great threat to us at this point that the benefit of knocking assad out outweighs  the instability his fall would bring to the region. 

 

 

 

someone tried to tell me it'd be okay if we classified what Assad is accused as doing as "terrorism"... however, as I pointed out, the Authorization for Use of Military Force that

allows the President to attack "terrorists" actually only specifically authorizes attacks against Al Qaeda and their allies (in its broadest possible sane reading), and of course President Assad is an enemy of Al Qaeda (which is why Al Qaeda forces are among the Syrian forces fighting against him)... meaning that the President would be authorized to attack the Syrian Rebels by the AUMF, but to attack anyone else he would need authorization from congress.  Of course, we've always been at war with Eastasia, haven't we?

 

 

Isn't the fact that Syria funds Hezbollah enough justification for us to attack him? 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

if Assad falls, Iran is much more vulnerable in the Middle East... and the war drums have been beating now through two presidencies as the neocons in the CFR and congress and in both White Houses, have been drooling over war with Iran.  the US absolutely has been wanting to claim a reason to knock out Assad; however, they were for a long time hoping that the internal conflict would bleed him dry first; instead, Assad was summarily winning the war by conventional warfare (and therefore had no reason to turn to chemical weapons), so the US needs an excuse to ensure that he doesn't win... enter the big chemical weapons fiasco that would have had ZERO strategic purpose for Assad, and would have a LOT of strategic purpose for the Syrian Rebels (probably some small group of extremists to release it on their own people) and a LOT of strategic purpose for the USA and the west, whose hegemony in the middle east depends upon weakening Iran's power.

 

The U.S. has hegemony in the Middle East? How so?

Posted

How many military attacks does President Obama get to order before he has to give his Nobel Peace Prize back?

Posted

How many military attacks does President Obama get to order before he has to give his Nobel Peace Prize back?

rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl  rotfl

Posted (edited)

It was 2009, everyone was on an Obama high. It's kinda like John Adams winning the Vice Presidency.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

I disagree with the notion that the U.S. has been patiently waiting for an excuse to go in. 100,000 deaths is a good enough excuse if we wanted to find one. Let's consider Libya. There were thousands of deaths at most before we intervened militarily.

 

your mistake, I think, is assuming that the number of deaths has anything to do with whether we want to intervene.  we haven't been patiently waiting to intervene out of some humanitarian concern, humanitarian concerns are just used by shrewd geopolitical thinkers to get otherwise good people onto their side in favor of wars.  like I said, we were perfectly happy to watch the Syrian Rebels keep Assad busy and weaken him with a long civil war where it is in our interests for both sides to be occupied fighting there... I think we were hoping they would topple him eventually but be too weak themselves to create their own strong Islamist government... because as much as we dislike Assad, it's even worse in our minds to add an unpredictable, 'democratic' in the sense of 'majority rules', ideologically Islamist government so close to Israel.  now it looks like we miscalculated and the rebels are losing... if we do turn out to keep it limited to just strategic strikes, one reason for that may be that we're hoping that the war will continue to extend.  Weaken the government enough that the rebel forces can remain strong, and Islamist radical fighters will continue to pour in to fight against Assad so that two sides we don't like for different reasons will keep devoting themselves to fighting each other.  the government weakening helps our position against Iran, and radical Islamist fighters will keep getting killed off in the fight in the process.

God the Father
Posted

 I think the president and everyone involved are smart people, and have reasons for doing what they do. That's why they're in government.

 

rotfl

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

your mistake, I think, is assuming that the number of deaths has anything to do with whether we want to intervene.

No. My mistake was that I wasn't clear enough. I was referencing the # of deaths as an excuse to enter Syria, not the reason for entering. My point was that they could have invaded long ago if they had really wanted to.

we haven't been patiently waiting to intervene out of some humanitarian concern, humanitarian concerns are just used by shrewd geopolitical thinkers to get otherwise good people onto their side in favor of wars. like I said, we were perfectly happy to watch the Syrian Rebels keep Assad busy and weaken him with a long civil war where it is in our interests for both sides to be occupied fighting there...

Hmm, I wonder if our government sees it that way. Instability in Syria could lead to instability in surrounding areas. I don't think the U.S. is looking at this situation with a drooling lip. Israel certainly isn't (the actions of Syria under a Bashar rule is at least somewhat predictable).

I think we were hoping they would topple him eventually but be too weak themselves to create their own strong Islamist government... because as much as we dislike Assad, it's even worse in our minds to add an unpredictable, 'democratic' in the sense of 'majority rules', ideologically Islamist government so close to Israel.

From what I have seen in my limited time in Syria, I would argue that there is still a big chance for a religious government to eventually spring up if Bashar is taken out. Even if that isn't the case, a stateless Syria is still very dangerous. Consider the fact that you can sneak a whole tank across Lebanon's borders. There are a lot of possibilities that open up that aren't in America/Israel's best interests.

if we do turn out to keep it limited to just strategic strikes, one reason for that may be that we're hoping that the war will continue to extend. Weaken the government enough that the rebel forces can remain strong, and Islamist radical fighters will continue to pour in to fight against Assad so that two sides we don't like for different reasons will keep devoting themselves to fighting each other. the government weakening helps our position against Iran, and radical Islamist fighters will keep getting killed off in the fight in the process.

I can see that being the case. I don't think we'd get involved, though. It makes more sense to me that we'd want to drag this situation out than it does that we'd want to intervene militarily. The radical islamist fighters aren't the only opposition dying, though. No matter how many rebel soldiers die during this civil war, I believe the religious views of the majority of the population that remains will still be more extreme than Bashar's. Edited by CatholicsAreKewl

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...