Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Possible reasons why Assad would use chemical weapons:

 

The conflict has been growing in intensity and scope for more than two years, with the United Nations estimating more than 100,000 dead and millions displaced, why would the government use chemical weapons now?

 

There are a number of theories about why the Syrian government might have chosen to use chemical weapons at this point, just days after United Nations weapons inspectors arrived to investigate earlier allegations of chemical weapons use. One theory proposed by a senior Israeli official is that the attack in the Damascus suburbs may have been a miscalculation: Syria may have been using chemical agents on a smaller scale for some time, and used an unintentionally large amount in last week’s attack. “Maybe they were trying to hit one place or to get one effect and they got a much greater effect than they thought,” said the official.

 

Another theory, argued by Juan Cole, a professor of Middle East Studies at the University of Michigan, is that a siege mentality may have contributed to the Assad government’s decision to use chemical weapons. Faced with intractable Sunni rebels in the Damascus suburbs, the Alawite-led government may have decided to send them a message that the capital would be defended at all costs. “It is the typical behavior of a weak regime facing superior demographic forces (the Alawites are far outnumbered by Sunnis) to deploy unconventional weaponry,” Mr. Cole wrote in a blog post.

 

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/28/world/middleeast/the-conflict-in-syria.html

Posted

An op-ed that touches on Aloysius' point about legality, entitled "Bomb Syria, Even if It Is Illegal":

 

Norms and institutions of international criminal law, including 11 years of experience with the International Criminal Court, have strengthened since then. Special tribunals for Cambodia, Rwanda and the former Yugoslavia reflect a growing consensus that perpetrators of atrocities should be punished.

 

But if the White House takes international law seriously — as the State Department does — it cannot try to have it both ways. It must either argue that an “illegal but legitimate” intervention is better than doing nothing, or assert that international law has changed — strategies that I call “constructive noncompliance.” In the case of Syria, I vote for the latter.

 

http://www.nytimes.com/2013/08/28/opinion/bomb-syria-even-if-it-is-illegal.html

Posted

Possible reasons why Assad would use chemical weapons:

I find these arguments entirely unconvincing as they all boil down to a huge coincidental breakdown of Assad's strategic thinking just at a moment when he was hugely dominating the war and when weapons inspectors were right nearby, and in any event, they are far less likely motivations than the far more likely scenario of radical islamists using the weapons to draw the west into the war.. and I think there's a good deal of evidence to suggest that.

 

and perhaps the Syrian Rebels are not all Islamists, but there are huge factions of militant Islamists among them.  and it's a lightning rod for them (huge numbers of the Syrian Rebels are certainly not Syrian)

 

 catholicsarekewl, of course there are problems for us with instability in Syria, I don't claim that we started the insurrection or that we would've chosen for it to happen that way... but I think they made a calculation after it occurred that it was better to deal with the chaos this way, and of course the position taken by Russia and China played into that calculation.  and no, I don't think they could've gone with the number dead at this point, they needed to be able to point to chemical weapons... they had already stated that as the "red line"

Posted

An op-ed that touches on Aloysius' point about legality, entitled "Bomb Syria, Even if It Is Illegal":

:sick:

 

of course that doesn't touch at all on the one thing that should govern whether US forces do something above all else--the United States Congress should be in control of that decision.

 

as far as just declaring that international law has changed and we can do what we want... well, that's all well and good for us sitting up here high and mighty, but no one would accept any other nation on earth pulling something ridiculous like that, and quite frankly, the world shouldn't accept the US doing it either.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=GxyBKKYPT4c

"I haven't really decided what to do yet but i'm really upset. I might not even invite Bashar to my next birthday party."

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Yeah this situation is getting awkward. Obama is not doing a good job of projecting clear leadership.

Posted

Yeah this situation is getting awkward. Obama is not doing a good job of projecting clear leadership.

The president isn't a leader. He's a functionary. Like a person who assembles watches.

Posted

The president isn't a leader. He's a functionary. Like a person who assembles watches.

 

 That's an insult to Swiss people.

Semper Catholic
Posted

Surprise another proxywar! Can't wait to fight the Russians again for the next decade. 

 

It's amazing how holding that office completely turns you into something different. Obama's administration has become W's, right down to the spying on citizens and sketchy wars.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Surprise another proxywar! Can't wait to fight the Russians again for the next decade.

It's amazing how holding that office completely turns you into something different. Obama's administration has become W's, right down to the spying on citizens and sketchy wars.


Pepsi vs coke.
Posted

British parliament said no.

Posted

nice. wonder how Obama will proceed with the UK opting out. it'd be nice if congress would actually debate this. do we even have a congress anymore? o.O

KnightofChrist
Posted

nice. wonder how Obama will proceed with the UK opting out. it'd be nice if congress would actually debate this. do we even have a congress anymore? o.O

 

Congress will likely not be called in to special session. The Obama administration is suggesting they'll attack unilaterally. Meet the new Boss same as the old Boss. All though the old Boss did have Congressional approval, somewhat UN approval, and did have a 'coalition of the willing'.

Posted

British parliament said no.

 

I'm glad parliament has more sense than David Cameron does. 

Posted

Free screenings of Hotel Rwanda at my house. Come refresh y'alls memory.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

I'm glad parliament has more sense than David Cameron does.

That's not very Christian, emilyann.
KnightofChrist
Posted

That's not very Christian, emilyann.

 

I don't think her comment rose to the level of you needing to make the comment you did.

Posted

Free screenings of Hotel Rwanda at my house. Come refresh y'alls memory.

of course, we should be concerned about all kinds of genocide and ethnic cleansing. like the type that will likely take place if the Syrian rebels are allowed to take control of Syria, as a large number of those groups have vowed ethnic cleansing against the Alawites and have already engaged in pogroms against the Christians.

but yes, by all means, let's pick one group of atrocities against the other based on the unverified claims that the Syrian government suddenly made a ridiculously stupid miscalculation in a war they were winning by conventional means and had no reason to turn towards chemical weapons in (in the chemical weapons strike, cui bono? unquestionably the rebels and terrorists), let's take sides to extend this bloody war by attacking the Syrian government to ensure that the rebel groups' terrorist campaigns can continue, rather than trying to help work towards a ceasefire for both despicable sides.
Posted

I hope we do not invade. All of this upsets me.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...