Era Might Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 thats the problem. This issue is being debated as a "national interest" thing- how does this impact us. I think that is the realistic way things work. I used to be more hostile to nationalism, but I think there is a healthy aspect of nationalism as a way to delineate power and give peoples a specific area to direct their public affairs. It has negative aspects, but it also provides balance and limits against empire of the old sort. Values are always a factor in American foreign policy, but I don't think in reality you can take part in the international system on a basis of "moral outrage." And I don't dismiss the importance of moral witness in society, such as the Pope writing "War, never again" on Twitter. I don't dismiss what he's saying, but I don't take it literally either.
Winchester Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 Nationalism is "I contribute by sitting on my ass saying 'We need to help' from well out of the battlezone" It's a cheaply bought claim of being a protector.
Era Might Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 Nationalism is "I contribute by sitting on my ass saying 'We need to help' from well out of the battlezone" It's a cheaply bought claim of being a protector. It means getting a say in the direction and leadership of your country. Every voice is equal at the ballot box, but not in society. Of course we have leaders who make decisions based on their expertise. Is it perfect? No, but to have a civilization you have to have a structure.
Winchester Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 It means getting a say in the direction and leadership of your country. Every voice is equal at the ballot box, but not in society. Of course we have leaders who make decisions based on their expertise. Is it perfect? No, but to have a civilization you have to have a structure. Voting on someone to occupy an office over which you have zero direct control is not having a say. That's utter nonsense.
Winchester Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 sigh. Join the military and get to killing if you want. Otherwise, your "we" talk is complete fiction.
Era Might Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 Voting on someone to occupy an office over which you have zero direct control is not having a say. That's utter nonsense. When you're dealing with millions of people it's not nonsense. On a micro level, of course, one person in three hundred million doesn't do much. But the medium is the message, and the institution creates the system. We have a democratic institution where power is functionally organized by blocs of millions of votes. It doesn't work in a simplistic way...power is about knowing where the powerful move, and how to harness it. That's what politicians are best at, through parties, through media, etc. But the system we have is a functional democratic system where public affairs are a matter for everyone. What do you want, everyone on an Internet forum to be a commander in chief? We've come a long way from the Persian, Roman, Greek empires.
Winchester Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 When you're dealing with millions of people it's not nonsense. On a micro level, of course, one person in three hundred million doesn't do much. But the medium is the message, and the institution creates the system. We have a democratic institution where power is functionally organized by blocs of millions of votes. It doesn't work in a simplistic way...power is about knowing where the powerful move, and how to harness it. That's what politicians are best at, through parties, through media, etc. But the system we have is a functional democratic system where public affairs are a matter for everyone. What do you want, everyone on an Internet forum to be a commander in chief? We've come a long way from the Persian, Roman, Greek empires. You have no direct control. You vote someone in and hope. They vote in their little temple and you either obey or suffer punishment. You can idealize and make excuses if you want.
Era Might Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 You have no direct control. You vote someone in and hope. They vote in their little temple and you either obey or suffer punishment. You can idealize and make excuses if you want. Control over what?
Winchester Posted September 4, 2013 Posted September 4, 2013 Control over what? Over the actions of the political class. Even the lobbyists don't. But they have money. You've got letters and phone calls. www.geke.us
Era Might Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 Over the actions of the political class. Even the lobbyists don't. But they have money. You've got letters and phone calls. www.geke.us There are lots of controls built into the system, the biggest one being term limits and elections. All control can't be personal control.
Winchester Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 There are lots of controls built into the system, the biggest one being term limits and elections. All control can't be personal control. That must be why the Federal government has not consistently obtained more and more power during its existence. Those "controls" are nonsense.
Era Might Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 ;aklj;oihrpoithoiahdf;lkasd;lfkha;odsihgpoaihepoihgoiweh;lohag That's nonsense.
Apotheoun Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 that's just rude. I agree. Someone needs to draw a red line on comments like that.
Hna.Caridad Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 I don’t sign in to Phatmass very often & I leave comments even less frequently, so I’m going to apologize right from the start for throwing a grenade (or a cruise missile?) into this conversation & running. Nonetheless, I remain surprised that in 11 pages of comments, not one person brought up the very real financial benefits to the U.S. that an invasion of Syria would bring. I’m quoting a Policy Planning Study that George Kennan of the U.S. State Department wrote in 1948. Yeah, 1948. “Furthermore, we [the Unites States] have about 50% of the world's wealth but only 6.3% of its population... In this situation, we cannot fail to be the object of envy and resentment. Our real task in the coming period is to devise a pattern of relationships which will permit us to maintain this position of disparity without positive detriment to our national security. To do so, we will have to dispense with all sentimentality and day-dreaming; and our attention will have to be concentrated everywhere on our immediate national objectives. We need not deceive ourselves that we can afford today the luxury of altruism and world-benefaction.†http://www.freemedialibrary.com/index.php/Memo_PPS23_by_George_Kennan Since then, the U.S. has helped to overthrow governments in Syria (1949), Iran (1953), Guatemala (1954), Democratic Republic of the Congo (1965), the Dominican Republic (1961), Chile (1973), Panama (1989), and most recently, Iraq, Afghanistan, and Libya. During the 1970s & 1980s, the U.S. supported a terrorist group in Nicaragua, genocide (separate from the 1954 coup) in Guatemala, and the outright persecution of the Catholic Church in El Salvador. Then, there are the Korean & the Vietnam Wars, providing weapons to both sides in the 8-year Iran-Iraq war, not to mention the first Persian Gulf War (what was that—Operation Desert Storm?). I’m sure I’m leaving some out… Of course Bashar al-Assad is a terrible leader, and…there are brutal dictatorships in Saudi Arabia, Bahrain, and Equatorial Guinea—all of which have U.S. support. Yes, there is an awful civil war going on in Syria, and…there are terrible civil wars going on in the Central African Republic, Democratic Republic of the Congo, and Somalia—where is the public outcry in these situations? So, who’s going to benefit from a U.S. military intervention in Syria? Probably not Syrians and certainly not Syrian Christians. Rather, it will be weapons manufacturers & those who invest in weapons manufacturing companies (a single cruise missile costs over $1 million). It will be reconstruction companies & those who invest in reconstruction companies (do you really think it was a coincidence that Halliburton got so many contracts to rebuild Iraq?) It will be private military & security firms and those who invest in private military & security firms. There’s a lot of money to be made in promoting violence & destruction, after all. In the meantime, let us all heed Pope Francis’ call for prayer, penance, and fasting for a peaceful resolution to the crisis in Syria.
4588686 Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 That must be why the Federal government has not consistently obtained more and more power during its existence. Those "controls" are nonsense. The Federal government has most increased in size and scope in response to popular will. Most people don't subscribe to political cults.
KnightofChrist Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 Brutality of Syrian Rebels Posing Dilemma in West The Syrian rebels posed casually, standing over their prisoners with firearms pointed down at the shirtless and terrified men. The prisoners, seven in all, were captured Syrian soldiers. Five were trussed, their backs marked with red welts. They kept their faces pressed to the dirt as the rebels’ commander recited a bitter revolutionary verse. “For fifty years, they are companions to corruption,†he said. “We swear to the Lord of the Throne, that this is our oath: We will take revenge.†The moment the poem ended, the commander, known as “the Uncle,†fired a bullet into the back of the first prisoner’s head. His gunmen followed suit, promptly killing all the men at their feet. This scene, documented in a video smuggled out of Syria a few days ago by a former rebel who grew disgusted by the killings, offers a dark insight into how many rebels have adopted some of the same brutal and ruthless tactics as the regime they are trying to overthrow. Continue Reading
Winchester Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 The Federal government has most increased in size and scope in response to popular will. Most people don't subscribe to political cults. "Will" isn't in the contract, even if that speculation is true. If it really is true, then we can remove penalties for disobedience. I think we'll find "popular" will translates to "political class will".
Lilllabettt Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 What Kind of Peace Are You Calling For? http://www.nytimes.com/2013/09/05/opinion/kristof-the-right-questions-on-syria.html?smid=fb-share&_r=0 I received a mass e-mail from a women’s group I admire, V-Day, calling on people to oppose military intervention because “such an action would simply bring about more violence and suffering. ... Experience shows us that military interventions harm innocent women, men and children.†Really? Sure, sometimes they do, as in Iraq. But in both Bosnia and Kosovo, military intervention saved lives. The same was true in Mali and Sierra Leone. The truth is that there’s no glib or simple lesson from the past. We need to struggle, case by case, for an approach that fits each situation. To me, the central question isn’t, “What are the risks of cruise missile strikes on Syria?†I grant that those risks are considerable, from errant missiles to Hezbollah retaliation. It’s this: “Are the risks greater if we launch missiles, or if we continue to sit on our hands?â€
Winchester Posted September 5, 2013 Posted September 5, 2013 I suppose it's similar to the war you chickenhawks are calling for.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now