Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

it is amusing with all these developments how much Romney was berated for calling Russia our biggest geopolitical foe and how Biden warned Romney would cause a war in Syria... as the Obama administration has now been dealing with Russia as its biggest geopolitical foe and calling for strikes against Syria lol... not that I think Romney would be any better, of course, but he seemed to be correct about where relations with Russia were heading.

The interesting thing about Russia, as I see them, is they are sticklers for international rules. They may not be a haven of freedom, and they have their own interests separate from the U.S., but I don't see them as really hostile or "rogue." They play the international law card well because it's the best way to maintain their balance of power with the U.S.

 

Did you see the Assad interview with Charlie Rose? It was interesting, he seems like a Western-style politician. I don't know much about his regime, though, so maybe he's really a despot.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

well he's sort of a mix between a despot and a western style politician I think.  the attempts to frame him solely as a despot ignore the fact that he protects minorities in his country and that there are significant segments of the population that support him (that may even be a majority of those living in Syria at this point according even to some independent sources I've read)... but attempts to frame him as a good guy would ignore that he's attacked protesters and done various other unsavory things.  in general I still have the sense that Assad values his stockpiles as a deterrent to attack, not something he desires to use, much like the US does with its own WMD stockpiles. 

 

ultimately what we need now is maybe a UN Security Council resolution on the chemical weapons issue (that can find a way to assure Assad he still has some deterrent, which may be impossible though) to get the US to back down and help ensure the rebels never get access to Assad's stockpiles (though indications are they've already obtained some, though we don't know if that's taken from Assad or the Saudis), and a Geneva II convention.

Posted (edited)

tomorrow is 9/11, on the eve of this horrible tragedy, the most pious Obama has cast the first stone, to aid the  Al Qaeda rebels to bring down the Syrian regime

this action could not go well for US

 

 

 

Edited by add
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

The interesting thing about Russia, as I see them, is they are sticklers for international rules. They may not be a haven of freedom, and they have their own interests separate from the U.S., but I don't see them as really hostile or "rogue." They play the international law card well because it's the best way to maintain their balance of power with the U.S.

 

Did you see the Assad interview with Charlie Rose? It was interesting, he seems like a Western-style politician. I don't know much about his regime, though, so maybe he's really a despot.

Bashar went to medical school in London, so he has a grasp of western culture and can represent himself well on television.  I would say he's more of a parody of a western-style politician.

"Lol, let's hold elections this year. Oh, how convenient! 99% of the population chose me again." 
 

 

well he's sort of a mix between a despot and a western style politician I think.  the attempts to frame him solely as a despot ignore the fact that he protects minorities in his country and that there are significant segments of the population that support him (that may even be a majority of those living in Syria at this point according even to some independent sources I've read)... but attempts to frame him as a good guy would ignore that he's attacked protesters and done various other unsavory things.  in general I still have the sense that Assad values his stockpiles as a deterrent to attack, not something he desires to use, much like the US does with its own WMD stockpiles. 

The Assad family is responsible for a huge number of Christian deaths (see the Lebanese civil war). Bashar himself is responsible for the assassination of many Lebanese Christian leaders. While he does protect Christians in his own country, we can't overlook the fact that he kills Christians in another. Remember that Sadam also protected some minority groups. That didn't make him any less of a crummy person. 

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Obama administration has now been dealing with Russia as its biggest geopolitical foe 

 

 

No we're not.  Russia is a swiftly declining power that has some influence on a state in an important region that is declining in importance.  Chinais our biggest geo-political foe. Russia is just a side show.  

Posted

I don't think the Middle East is declining in importance, and I don't think Russia's influence broadly in the region is declining either.  I think you're way overstating that.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

Everyone gets props!

Posted

Russia is in the process of re-militarizing, and it still has thousands of nuclear warheads.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

I don't think a "World War" is a serious possibility here. The world wars were fought over expansionist powers (Austria, Germany, Japan) on the same continent (well, not Japan, but they were piggybacking off of a European war). Nobody today has anything to gain from a world war, except maybe a state like Iran or North Korea, to destabilize everything, but what would be the purpose of trying to do that now. Russia, China, and the U.S. don't have perfect relationships but they're all part of the international order, and have no reason to want a world war. Maybe some elements in the Islamic world would want a world war, but what serious basis do they have to provoke one? I don't think they have that much clout to be able to cause such a thing, and they can't even unite among themselves.

You're right, a lot of things would need to happen before it escalated into a world war but it is a possibility. I'll explain in more detail a couple of things that could go wrong...

Lets say we got attacked by Hezbollah and we responded by hitting Lebanon. Attacking both Hezbollah and Assad, who represent two Shi'ite groups, would prompt Iran to enter the conflict. Russia is a longtime ally and protector of Syria (since before the Cold War). We can expect Russia to act in some way if we strike as well. Israel, being so close to the action, might decide to join the fun if it doesnt end up being dragged into it. Iraq's government is shiite run and they're not so happy about us fighting an alawite. I doubt they'll enjoy the prospect of us fighting Iran as well. Imagine engaging with an army that we trained and equipped.

This example is pretty extreme but we should consider all possibilities before entering into a conflict. Obama bushed us by getting America trapped in this situation without knowing the possible outcomes. Russia is our saving grace right meow. Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

don't forget Mr. Magoo... er.. I mean... John Kerry, who seems to have inexplicably stumbled into a peaceful delay lol

Posted

If I see one more facebook post of an evangelical getting giddy over this because of the "rapture" I will...do nothing because I have no power. I'll get very cross, though.

 

(lol, had to make that phatmass friendly :p ).

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

If I see one more facebook post of an evangelical getting giddy over this because of the "rapture" I will...do nothing because I have no power. I'll get very cross, though.

 

(lol, had to make that phatmass friendly :P ).

 

You're just mad because Catholics aren't on the guest list.

Posted

You're just mad because Catholics aren't on the guest list.

 

But I'm not Catholic. Though, to be fair, I doubt Orthodox would be as well.

CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

don't forget Mr. Magoo... er.. I mean... John Kerry, who seems to have inexplicably stumbled into a peaceful delay lol

 

 lol, careful. Kerry will probably take undue credit for this in the future. It was actually very surprising that Russia reacted in this way and more surprising that Syria actually approved given its history.

Posted (edited)

You're right, a lot of things would need to happen before it escalated into a world war but it is a possibility. I'll explain in more detail a couple of things that could go wrong...

Lets say we got attacked by Hezbollah and we responded by hitting Lebanon. Attacking both Hezbollah and Assad, who represent two Shi'ite groups, would prompt Iran to enter the conflict. Russia is a longtime ally and protector of Syria (since before the Cold War). We can expect Russia to act in some way if we strike as well. Israel, being so close to the action, might decide to join the fun if it doesnt end up being dragged into it. Iraq's government is shiite run and they're not so happy about us fighting an alawite. I doubt they'll enjoy the prospect of us fighting Iran as well. Imagine engaging with an army that we trained and equipped.

This example is pretty extreme but we should consider all possibilities before entering into a conflict. Obama bushed us by getting America trapped in this situation without knowing the possible outcomes. Russia is our saving grace right meow.

 

I look at it differently than a domino effect (we attack, some else attacks, etc). That's not the model of the World Wars. The World Wars were centered around contintental Europe and the old "Great Powers" world order from the 19th century. The unification of the German empire helped lead to WWI, and then Germany was smacked down at Versailles, nursed that grievance for 25 years, and Hitler plotted his rise to power. Hitler tried to win back German Lebensraum, and that threatened all of Europe.

 

I don't think a World War is possible as a domino effect. The only way I can see some kind of World War coming out of this Syria situation is if it somehow became about the Middle East, not about the U.S. IOW, if someone used this as an opportunity to once and for all wipe Israel off the map and conquer all Arab lands, or something like that. Is there someone in the Middle East who could attempt something like that? Doesn't seem like it. The world model of the World Wars was a leftover from imperialism. Today, nationalism is the world standard. Even if, say, Iran tried to start a World War, would Iraq side with Iran? Saudi Arabia? Egypt? Libya? They all have national interests, not imperial. And Iran is not even Arab.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Not to mention in the two (modern) world wars, each side had a genuine conviction of being able to win, and win quickly.  Not so when an 800lbs gorilla is in the ring.

Posted (edited)

Article on Russia's geopolitical stake in the region.

 

 

 

For Putin, Syria is all too reminiscent of Chechnya. Both conflicts pitted the state against disparate and leaderless opposition forces, which over time came to include extremist Sunni Islamist groups. In Putin’s view -- one that he stresses repeatedly in meetings with his U.S. and European counterparts -- Syria is the latest battleground in a global, multi-decade struggle between secular states and Sunni Islamism, which first began in Afghanistan with the Taliban, then moved to Chechnya, and has torn a number of Arab countries apart. Ever since he took office (first as prime minister in 1999 and then as president in 2000) and was confronted by the Chechen war, Putin has expressed his fear of Sunni Islamist extremism and of the risks that “jihadist” groups pose to Russia, with its large, indigenous, Sunni Muslim population, concentrated in the North Caucasus, the Volga region, and in major cities such as Moscow. A desire to contain extremism is a major reason why Putin offered help to the United States in battling the Taliban in Afghanistan after 9/11. It is also why Russia maintains close relations with Shia Iran, which acts as a counterweight to Sunni powers.

 

http://www.foreignaffairs.com/articles/139079/fiona-hill/the-real-reason-putin-supports-assad

Edited by Era Might
Posted

Chemical warfair kills over 400 children in Syria in one day.
~ USA to atack Alleged perpetrators with 100 million hours worth of Crouse missile

there are about 1.3 million abortions each year, which works out to 3,562 abortions each day, according to the New England Journal of Medicine in the USA
~ nobody cares!

Posted

Chemical warfair kills over 400 children in Syria in one day.
~ USA to atack Alleged perpetrators with 200 million dollars worth of Tomahawk missile

there are about 1.3 million abortions each year, which works out to 3,562 abortions each day, according to the New England Journal of Medicine in the USA
~ nobody cares!


Meanwhile the Syria rebels who the USA will assist with there barrage of weapons of mass destruction (tomahawks missiles) is raping, killing and decimating Syria's Christians population in a Deliberate attempt to purge the country of all Christians.

Pray for peace
KnightofChrist
Posted

Meanwhile the Syria rebels who the USA will assist with there barrage of weapons of mass destruction (tomahawks missiles) is raping, killing and decimating Syria's Christians population in a Deliberate attempt to purge the country of all Christians.

Pray for peace


I read the other day the CIA has already begun to arm them. We are now giving ad and comfort to al qaeda.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...