Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted

Since according to you the federal government isn't a representative body but a private collective, akin to a gang. But surely even gangsters can have property, right? Or does the fact that they acquired property using funds that are partially illicit (taxes) invalidate their whole claim to property? If so then what other moral qualifications must an individual have in order to legitimately obtain property?

Posted

as fascinating as this is, I can pretty much guarantee that the philosophical issue of whether the Federal Government has the right to exist will not be factoring into the decision here lol.  nothing wrong with treating governments as gangs of elite raiders and rejecting their claims to legitimacy based upon 'democracy', but at the end of the day we have to deal with how things really operate, with the authorities the government claims to have. 

 

in other news: a majority of americans approve of sending congress to Syria

http://www.theonion.com/articles/poll-majority-of-americans-approve-of-sending-cong,33752/

 

in more serious news: more outrage from the Syrians we've decided to terrorize along with our so-called enemy terrorists:

Catholic Patriarch Of Syria To Obama: Your 'Criminal' Attack Will Only Benefit Muslim Extremists

http://www.ijreview.com/2013/09/76796-catholic-patriarch-syria-obama-criminal-attack-will-benefit-muslim-extremists/

Posted

WASHINGTON—The U.S. has intercepted an order from Iran to militants in Iraq to attack the U.S. Embassy and other American interests in Baghdad in the event of a strike on Syria, officials said, amid an expanding array of reprisal threats across the region.


The U.S. has intercepted communications between Iran and Shiite militants in Iraq involving orders to the militia groups to attack the U.S. Embassy and other U.S. interests in Baghdad in the event of an American strike in Syria. Julian Barnes has more. Photo: AP.

Military officials have been trying to predict the range of possible responses from Syria, Iran and their allies. U.S. officials said they are on alert for Iran's fleet of small, fast boats in the Persian Gulf, where American warships are positioned. U.S. officials also fear Hezbollah could attack the U.S. Embassy in Beirut.

While the U.S. has moved military resources in the region for a possible strike, it has other assets in the area that would be ready to respond to any reprisals by Syria, Iran or its allies...

America can flood the region with humanitarian aid and should. Invade with love not war!

KnightofChrist
Posted

Not that that's anything to dismiss, but I think it is more concerning that Putin/Russia has promised to help Syria should there be an attack, and has been sending and building up ships in the region for the last couple of days.

Semper Catholic
Posted

So at what do GWB and Dick Cheney pull off their Obama and Kerry masks? Before or after we lay waste to Damascus? I'm sure the real Obama and Kerry are tied up and gagged in a janitors closet somewhere

Posted

Russia has interests in the region, too. They have to react to U.S. involvement.

Posted

Within your ideological framework, what is wrong with this? An association of individuals, acting towards a common end, acquired property. Somebody seemingly took that property and they used violence to protect their property from a thief. Seems completely legit to me.

A bandit gang is also organized.

Posted

So at what do GWB and Dick Cheney pull off their Obama and Kerry masks? Before or after we lay waste to Damascus? I'm sure the real Obama and Kerry are tied up and gagged in a janitors closet somewhere


What, you actually thought they were any different?
CatholicsAreKewl
Posted (edited)

WASHINGTON—The U.S. has intercepted an order from Iran to militants in Iraq to attack the U.S. Embassy and other American interests in Baghdad in the event of a strike on Syria, officials said, amid an expanding array of reprisal threats across the region.


The U.S. has intercepted communications between Iran and Shiite militants in Iraq involving orders to the militia groups to attack the U.S. Embassy and other U.S. interests in Baghdad in the event of an American strike in Syria. Julian Barnes has more. Photo: AP.

Military officials have been trying to predict the range of possible responses from Syria, Iran and their allies. U.S. officials said they are on alert for Iran's fleet of small, fast boats in the Persian Gulf, where American warships are positioned. U.S. officials also fear Hezbollah could attack the U.S. Embassy in Beirut.

While the U.S. has moved military resources in the region for a possible strike, it has other assets in the area that would be ready to respond to any reprisals by Syria, Iran or its allies...

America can flood the region with humanitarian aid and should. Invade with love not war!

 

Although that is good evidence, it's not strong enough to warrant the way Obama's been handling the situation. Rushing into conflict makes it harder to get other nations on our side. Why couldn't we have waited for the U.N. chemical weapons team to finish their analysis? We don't even know for sure what chemical weapons were used. I also question why Assad would have used such weapons on a nonstrategic area when he was already winning. He had everything to lose by doing this. It seems more plausible, with the limited knowledge we currently have, that the rebels orchestrated the attack in order to get the world stage involved. Even if Assad is guilty, it was the U.N.'s job to take care of this, not Obama's.

Consider the fact that Hezbollah claims it has rockets capable of hitting any part of Israel (and Israel believes this). What if Hezbollah happens to fire a rocket at a U.S. warship once we begin our attacks? I imagine the obvious response would be to strike Lebanon. Once that happens, we'll bring more countries into the mix, possibly turning our small intervention into another world war.

Edited by CatholicsAreKewl
Posted

this is why it's ridiculous for them to suggest that firing a few missiles into another country is not "war in the classic sense".  it's an act of war, and that country and its allies would justifiably want to respond to that act of war in any way they are capable of, just as we would if someone fired missiles into our country.  there is every possibility that these attacks will result in our soldiers being in harm's way due to reprisals and escalations.  

Posted

http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ysmDDTuC6Rk

Posted

harry reid just postponed the senate vote on thursday because of a Russian proposal, thats pure bs, he postponed the vote because they (obama) wont win

this administration is going to war no matter what the american people think, this Congressional approval is a scam the democrats are playing 

Posted

Honestly - I don't think anyone will want to take on the US on a world conflict at this point.  Not just yet.  The US is still the 800lbs gorilla in the ring that no one can measure themselves with.

 

Whatever gains or loses for the US comes from this (others than more American lives lost overseas) it will be political, economical and diplomatic if any. 

 

However, the economic state of the US at this point is extremely fragile, and a conflict like this will further isolate the US.  The closest precedent I can think of is the king of France helping the English revolution in the future US while his people were starving (plunging in the conflict enough economic resources to feed the people of France in their entirety for 2 years by scant estimates).  Although the conflict once resolved had no direct impact to France political status, it set up the French revolution.

Semper Catholic
Posted

Honestly - I don't think anyone will want to take on the US on a world conflict at this point.  Not just yet.  The US is still the 800lbs gorilla in the ring that no one can measure themselves with.

 

Whatever gains or loses for the US comes from this (others than more American lives lost overseas) it will be political, economical and diplomatic if any. 

 

However, the economic state of the US at this point is extremely fragile, and a conflict like this will further isolate the US.  The closest precedent I can think of is the king of France helping the English revolution in the future US while his people were starving (plunging in the conflict enough economic resources to feed the people of France in their entirety for 2 years by scant estimates).  Although the conflict once resolved had no direct impact to France political status, it set up the French revolution.

 

LOL WUT.In a conventional war yes, but another COIN conflict is exactly what Al-Qaeda and the US's other enemies want. Long drawn out wars with no clear cut victories was basically Osama's blueprint for taking down the US.

Posted

LOL WUT.In a conventional war yes, but another COIN conflict is exactly what Al-Qaeda and the US's other enemies want. Long drawn out wars with no clear cut victories was basically Osama's blueprint for taking down the US.

 

Hence my last paragraph.

Posted (edited)

I don't think a "World War" is a serious possibility here. The world wars were fought over expansionist powers (Austria, Germany, Japan) on the same continent (well, not Japan, but they were piggybacking off of a European war). Nobody today has anything to gain from a world war, except maybe a state like Iran or North Korea, to destabilize everything, but what would be the purpose of trying to do that now. Russia, China, and the U.S. don't have perfect relationships but they're all part of the international order, and have no reason to want a world war. Maybe some elements in the Islamic world would want a world war, but what serious basis do they have to provoke one? I don't think they have that much clout to be able to cause such a thing, and they can't even unite among themselves.

Edited by Era Might
Posted

In a different but agreeing view EraMight, I think China, Japan, Russia and European powers have far too much to lose to enter a world war, and no one outside these groups really have any military capabilities to match the US.  Thus I am convinced a world war is categorically out of the question.

 

However, any strikes like Iraq, and now perhaps Syria, can only weaken the US.  I think the US has only to gain to a peaceful solution in Syria, and to support such a drive, rather than the 'quick fix' of another military involvement.

 

 

But that's just my canadien two cents (which on occasion is worth more than the US 2 cents - :flex2: )

Posted

In a different but agreeing view EraMight, I think China, Japan, Russia and European powers have far too much to lose to enter a world war, and no one outside these groups really have any military capabilities to match the US.  Thus I am convinced a world war is categorically out of the question.

 

However, any strikes like Iraq, and now perhaps Syria, can only weaken the US.  I think the US has only to gain to a peaceful solution in Syria, and to support such a drive, rather than the 'quick fix' of another military involvement.

 

 

But that's just my canadien two cents (which on occasion is worth more than the US 2 cents - :flex2: )

 

I agree, the situation can go badly for the U.S., but not because it descends into a world war. But as far as not having matching military capability, that would not be a necessary factor in a world war. WWI and WWII did not begin with U.S. involvement. It's not necessary to take on the U.S. directly in order to start a world war. And even superior force is not a guarantor of success or deterrence. How would the U.S. fare in a war in China with a billion people, or in Russia? Who knows. But anyway, there is absolutely nothing in the world order right now akin to WWI or WWII.

Posted

I don't think we're anywhere near the brink of a world war, we're slightly closer to the possibility of an increasingly destabilized Middle East that could transform into a deeper proxy war than is already going on for the great powers... IF that were to occur, THEN we would maybe be again on the brink of a world war.  but for all the reasons you listed, the great powers would have a vested interest in keeping that proxy war contained... but it could get out of control.

 

but you are right, I don't think anyone in power has any interest in letting this turn into a world war.  the only danger would be escalations getting out of control to the point where they couldn't avoid it... since these are all Russia's southern neighbors, there is a certain line that they would not be able to allow to be crossed without the threat of actual world war... like if a bunch of Foreign Powers were suddenly all up in South and Central America in this way with Mexico being peripherally involved, we'd of course not want a world war but we couldn't say we would be totally able to avoid it no matter what.

 

anyway, it seems some off the cuff remarks from Kerry opened the door to a stall on the Syria strike for now as the Whitehouse initially backed off of them but is now more open to them, if Kerry knew what he was doing then I give him major props, but I don't think he did, I think he was just throwing out an impossible suggestion (especially setting an "end of the week" deadline for it) that ended up being seized upon by Russia and gained traction... the UN Security Council should seriously consider this possibility to have the chemical weapons turned over to international control... ultimately this is a hugely important idea because not only does it take them away from the Assad government, it prevents them from being able to fall into the hands of the rebels, who, I must reiterate, we should NOT be supporting by any means.  luckily this kind of solution would allow Obama to politically save face because he could point to the threat of war as having accomplished this and come out with a Reaaganite level of political good will.  I don't believe for a minute that this option would even be on the table if it weren't for the strong opposition of Russia and of the American people, but good diplomacy will always allow both sides to save face so I hope this can be accomplished.  Russia will, of course, be wary of the wording of any UN resolution as they felt that the Libya resolution was totally misused, so any resolution that would seem to call for securing those weapons by force couldn't pass... 

Posted

it is amusing with all these developments how much Romney was berated for calling Russia our biggest geopolitical foe and how Biden warned Romney would cause a war in Syria... as the Obama administration has now been dealing with Russia as its biggest geopolitical foe and calling for strikes against Syria lol... not that I think Romney would be any better, of course, but he seemed to be correct about where relations with Russia were heading.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...