Ice_nine Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 Like I said, I agree with you. I don't think this argument would apply unless you also favor overthrowing a bunch of other regimes as well. If so, then I don't think that's feasible. True
Aloysius Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 the whole premise still seems to assume Assad used the chemical weapons, which I am not at all convinced of. the US narrative framing the evidence ignores the large amount of evidence that the Syrian rebels themselves have stockpiles of chemical weapons and the testimony of experts who have argued that the scene which permitted workers to deal with people without hazmat suits and not get sick themselves. I understand someone saying they're not an intelligence expert so they can't make a determination, but I can't understand anyone giving the benefit of the doubt to the US intelligence community that has time and again been shown to frame the evidence to promote war. one should listen to the many contrary narratives coming from other experts and observers--the kinds of things that have often been shown, after we've irresponsibly marched into wars, to have been more accurate. Anyway, I'm really unclear, are you suggesting that it would help the civilian population to fight against the Syrian regime? to be honest, the thing that would help the civilian population most would be the war between these two vicious factions coming to an end, and it would actually probably be better that the rebels don't win because those are the groups full of people looking to go on revengeful ethnic cleansing campaigns. I think most civilians would prefer the fighting to just stop. unluckily for them, we're about to get involved on shotty evidence in a way that will definitely prolong the war. I'm in favor of the war coming to an end, I think it's been clear that the rebel forces are unable to win against the government, it's pretty clear from my perspective that they would actually be a WORSE option for people to be in charge of Syria. I'm not exactly sure what the options are that you're talking about? humanitarian aid, facilitating refugees, etc... well I'm all in favor of that. but anything that would strengthen the rebel forces and thereby prolong the war, I'm against. brokering a ceasefire (sure I know it's unlikely but it's the only morally possible option when faced with a war in which you cannot support either side) that facilitates the retreat of some foreign fighters out of the region, and perhaps accepting refugees from among the rebels who are not wanted terrorists, would be a good step maybe. this doesn't mean I support Assad, but I do definitely believe not only that Assad is better than the rebel groups, or at least than what the rebel groups have transformed into (maybe I could agree they were better at the beginning), but that he has already effectively won the war and anyone insisting upon continuing the fighting rather than trying to negotiate their concession is just dragging out the bloodshed. and those are the only two groups that are possible right now. the idea that coming in to escalate and prolong the war would in any way help the civilian population is, I think, absolutely wrong.
Lilllabettt Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 (edited) For me, it does not matter who used the gas. Innocent people are being gassed -- if somebody has the power to stop that, that somebody has the moral responsibility to try. Remember the no fly zone debate. A no fly zone would make it harder to kill people. It would mean no more of this carpet bombing stuff. But there is no no-fly zone, and there will be no no-fly zone, because a no fly zone would unfairly impact the government's killing abilities. It would seem like we were "taking sides." The government has planes with which to kill people and the rebels do not. Never mind that if the government cannot use its planes there will be less killing. We cannot have one side be less able to kill than the other. Wait, I have a solution. We can abandon the idea of a no fly zone; instead we will ship big guns to the Syrian rebels. Then their killing powers will be equal. Then it will be fair. I know. Lets ask Dick Cheney what he thinks. I think it’s important for the Administration to come back and specify what is the U.S. national interest here? And it seems to be, if the only reason you’re going is because now you have evidence that they used chemical weapons and killed 150 people with chemical weapons, is that our national interest? Read more: http://nation.time.com/2013/06/17/syrian-no-fly-zone-no-brainer-or-no-sense/#ixzz2dVfy9ZMC Edited August 31, 2013 by Lilllabettt
Semper Catholic Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 So we don't know who we need to help, or what we need to do to help them, just that we need to do something. I'll think of people like you when I'm stuck wearing a rubber gas mask and full MOPP suit in 100 degree temperatures for the next 10 years.
Lilllabettt Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 (edited) "this is the business we've chosen." -- Hyman Roth, The Godfather Part II you weren't drafted. You have been training to do your job for years. If you abhor the day you are finally called on to do your job, then by all means, pursue some other profession. Edited August 31, 2013 by Lilllabettt
Aloysius Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 that's NOT the job he signed up for, he signed up to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States from all enemies foreign and domestic, to defend his country and his home... not to go off fighting in totally unrelated conflicts where we cannot morally support either side on the off chance that our involvement will somehow magically decrease, not increase the casualty count. that's something you cannot know, and I would propose to you it is something that is extremely unlikely... adding another side to the war will only increase the casualty count. I think it's a fairy tale to imagine a US no fly zone, which will serve to extend the war by evening the playing field, would result in less casualties. Extending the duration of a war results in more casualties in the long run, not less. The only reason it's considered the best option for some people is because somehow those people are unwilling to accept the idea of the war ending with the rebels losing. but yeah, it's absolutely not the job our soldiers signed up for.
4588686 Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 (edited) I mean, I suppose we could go in and fight against all the people committing atrocities--ie, the Syrian Government and the Syrian Rebels. but then, is that even possible, and who would be left? the factors in the Syrian civil war are entirely different than those in Rwanda. the reason for inaction here is because there is no morally justifiable action, it is completely morally unjustifiable to side with the murderous Syrian Rebels or with the murderous Syrian government. I'm curious as to what you would have us do here? Because siding with the Syrian Rebels is probably the best way to promote an eventual genocide against Alawites, Christians, and other minorities in Syria. you can't just throw out a generic statement about "inaction" being bad--what exactly is the action you would have us take? That's a false dichotomy. The administration has been pretty clear that these strikes are intended to be punitive. A way of punishing Asaad for either directing the use of chemical weapons against a large civilian population or allowing conditions where an overly zealous officer could use them. The Obama Administration has, so far, been pretty reluctant to get seriously involved in the Syrian conflict. A good disposition, I think, because, while you are painting with a very broad brush, there isn't a clearly good side here. Maybe the Obama administration is lying. Obama has certainly lied, or allowed members of his administration to lie, before. See the NSA programs. I doubt it, though. Maybe there will be mission creep. Very possible here. And maybe this is all unconstitutional. Also a very good point. I'm simply saying that your trichotomized 'either we fight for the rebels or we fight for Asaad or we do nothing' presentation is simplistic. We should not get seriously involved in this conflict. If Obama tries to deploy troops on the ground he should be impeached. Launching some cruise missiles from some battle ships against some conventional military forces may get Asaad to reign in his Officers when he comes to slaughtering civilians en mass with chemical weapons may work. Edited August 31, 2013 by Hasan
4588686 Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 "this is the business we've chosen." -- Hyman Roth, The Godfather Part II you weren't drafted. You have been training to do your job for years. If you abhor the day you are finally called on to do your job, then by all means, pursue some other profession. People in the Military were allowed to have opinions. My grandfather thought Vietnam was a pretty a shitty and awful war before that evil, lying sack of shit President Nixon sent him off to comfort dying 18 year olds who had been ripped apart in the jungle.
Aloysius Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 well I dealt with the "punitive" idea earlier, I think it's absurd and untenable. it helps the rebels, which we shouldn't be doing, thereby prolonging the war, which we shouldn't be doing; and, by the way, I see no moral argument that justifies "oh, yeah, we have no intention to participate in this conflict, to end it in any way, but one side did something bad therefore we will launch tomahawk missiles at them and feel self-righteous about it". no, there has to be a calculation that you are bettering the situation somehow, that you are taking a side or doing something productive. since we can't pick a side that we want to be with, there's no moral justification for going into the war. if a scenario ever arises in which somehow, somewhere, someway Bashar Al Assad could be tried in the International Criminal Court for war crimes and punished, then that'd be great. to just throw missiles around as punishments, with the President deciding as judge, jury, and executioner, I am totally unequivocally against that. It's insane, it's callous, it's completely non-justifiable morally IMO.
add Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 Syria would retaliate against Israel if hit by the U.S. All hell will brake lose
Era Might Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 "this is the business we've chosen." -- Hyman Roth, The Godfather Part II The Godfather, the answer to all questions in life, foreign and domestic. Michael Corleone: I saw a strange thing today. Some rebels were being arrested. One of them pulled the pin on a grenade. He took himself and the captain of the command with him. Now, soldiers are paid to fight; the rebels aren't. Hyman Roth: What does that tell you? Michael Corleone: They could win.
Era Might Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 Fredo Corleone: I'm your older brother, Mike, and I was stepped over! Michael Corleone: That's the way Pop wanted it. Fredo Corleone: It ain't the way I wanted it! I can handle things! I'm smart! Not like everybody says... like dumb... I'm smart and I want respect!
Lilllabettt Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 (edited) that's NOT the job he signed up for, he signed up to protect and defend the Constitution of the United States from all enemies foreign and domestic, to defend his country and his home... not to go off fighting in totally unrelated conflicts Actually, they sign up to obey the orders of the President of the United States. We have a civilian controlled military, which means it is a politician who defines who is a threat to "our country and our home." Perhaps you have not been paying attention --- they have expanded those definitions repeatedly, for um .... several decades. I daresay everyone who signs up with the military is aware of that. SemperCatholic for example, signed up with the marines after we were several years into the Iraq War. I think its an insult to his, and every member of the military's intelligence to suggest that they sign up for the armed forces unaware of what it might involve. There are a lot of benefits for military service (they are not just for war veterans btw; all military veterans get them.) The drawback is that one day you may have to leave your family, work where people are trying to kill or maim you, possibly kill some of them, all for a project a bunch of politicians have decided is worth undertaking. And the mission will not be neat and clear (it never is) and the conditions will be inhumane and miserable (they always are.) I'd never want to do that job. So I don't sign up for it. Some people in the military never get sent to war, but the reality is war-making is their job. Its the business they have chosen. Edited August 31, 2013 by Lilllabettt
Semper Catholic Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 Actually, they sign up to obey the orders of the President of the United States. We have a civilian controlled military, which means it is a politician who defines who is a threat to "our country and our home." Perhaps you have not been paying attention --- they have expanded those definitions repeatedly, for um .... several decades. I daresay everyone who signs up with the military is aware of that. SemperCatholic for example, signed up with the marines after we were several years into the Iraq War. I think its an insult to his, and every member of the military's intelligence to suggest that they sign up for the armed forces unaware of what it might involve. There are a lot of benefits for military service (they are not just for war veterans btw; all military veterans get them.) The drawback is that one day you may have to leave your family, work where people are trying to kill or maim you, possibly kill some of them, all for a project a bunch of politicians have decided is worth undertaking. And the mission will not be neat and clear (it never is) and the conditions will be inhumane and miserable (they always are.) I'd never want to do that job. So I don't sign up for it. Some people in the military never get sent to war, but the reality is war-making is their job. Its the business they have chosen. This is the general attitude of the Rush Limbaugh/Glenn Beck fueled political plebes, that the military is just a lapdog for whomever is in power and that it's ok to put them in harm's way because "America, Toby Keith, and Freedom." As easy as it is to dismiss the military as pimply faced kids who boarded a bus right of high school, I'm always blown away at how well they can smell elderberries from a mile away. If we learned anything from Iraq it's that sending the military in with no clear plan or Commander's Intent leads to a terrible situation. I highly doubt anyone on the democrat side of things is chomping at the bit to become the next Paul Bremer, trying to decide who to help while being dropped into a Civil War. Don't worry though, that's the cool thing about the military, no matter what decision Obama decides, good or bad, the military will be there to pick up the Check.
add Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 for more than two years of conflict which hundred of thousand people died, it seems that Mr. Obama sets side, provides support to the Muslim extremists, with al quada terrorists, those created chaos in the region. Mr. Obama! better you go home, set the red line for your country to stop killing their own children in the abortion, then come here to teach us how to kill people
4588686 Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 (edited) well I dealt with the "punitive" idea earlier, I think it's absurd and untenable. it helps the rebels, which we shouldn't be doing, thereby prolonging the war, which we shouldn't be doing; and, by the way, I see no moral argument that justifies "oh, yeah, we have no intention to participate in this conflict, to end it in any way, but one side did something bad therefore we will launch tomahawk missiles at them and feel self-righteous about it". no, there has to be a calculation that you are bettering the situation somehow, that you are taking a side or doing something productive. since we can't pick a side that we want to be with, there's no moral justification for going into the war. if a scenario ever arises in which somehow, somewhere, someway Bashar Al Assad could be tried in the International Criminal Court for war crimes and punished, then that'd be great. to just throw missiles around as punishments, with the President deciding as judge, jury, and executioner, I am totally unequivocally against that. It's insane, it's callous, it's completely non-justifiable morally IMO. You're distorting the rational. Asaad does not want the US to seriously intervene militarily in the conflict because he does not want lose the war. The rationale for punishing him by launching some missiles at some of his military assets is to discourage his from allowing his regime from using those weapons against a civilian population again. The idea being to provide an incentive for the regime to keep the conflict between itself and the rebel forces. If you don't see a moral component to that then it's because you don't want to for ideological reasons. I don't know how I feel about that idea. But at least engage with it and stop distorting the rationale. Edited August 31, 2013 by Hasan
4588686 Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 . And the mission will not be neat and clear (it never is) and the conditions will be inhumane and miserable (they always are.) I'd never want to do that job. So I don't sign up for it. Some people in the military never get sent to war, but the reality is war-making is their job. Its the business they have chosen. Your transactional description of military service is kind of silly given how bad the VA has been with actually supporting veterans and how much shit veterans have to deal with that isn't in any contract. For example, I don't know how many people sign up for PTSD. Probably about half the men in my family are still suffering from some war they fought in years or even decades ago. Nor is there anything about serving if you President commits treason (hey look, Nixon again) or is a lying, manipulative piece of shit (hey there, Bush) or decides to ramp of a war that he probably doesn't, deep down, really believe can be won (hey there, Obama and Johnson).
Aloysius Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 oh come on, I understand the rationale perfectly well, it's still illegal under international law and at the end of the day serves no purpose in saving any lives or defending any people, everything I said about it still applies completely. it's like if two guys (who are both bad guys) are engaged in a vicious fight against each other, and some innocent bystanders got in the way and get killed. one of the two guys is injured to the point where the other guy has the clear advantage so that the other guy should really just give up and run away, so you go in and you shoot the other guy in the foot to even up the fight, and then you leave, and you call that justice, and suggest you've done a great deed to make sure no more innocent bystanders get killed between their fight. and anyway the rationale is much more about not being okay with Assad staying in power because we want to weaken Iran in the Middle East... it is most certainly in their reasoning that they want to weaken the Assad government so that the fight can continue. the talk of deterring future chemical attacks is just that--talk--now, maybe President Obama believes it, but if he does, I am sure the people advising him to do it have convinced him of that because they have done their calculations on the geopolitics and want him to attack the Assad government for entirely different rationale. I have a feeling Mr. Obama's in on it too, he's a smart guy, maybe he believes some convergence of the two things and also really does believe it's a deterrent for chemical weapons, but the other calculation is far more likely to play into the decision making process I suspect. the fact of the matter is that bombing the Syrian government aids the rebel forces. to pretend that it doesn't, to pretend that we can do it for some pure motivation of a chemical weapons punishment and deterrent, it's just not tenable. you have to look at the effect you're having on the war--the effect of bombing the Syrian government is to benefit the rebels and prolong the war.
Lilllabettt Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 This is the general attitude of the Rush Limbaugh/Glenn Beck fueled political plebes, that the military is just a lapdog for whomever is in power and that it's ok to put them in harm's way because "America, Toby Keith, and Freedom." As easy as it is to dismiss the military as pimply faced kids who boarded a bus right of high school, I'm always blown away at how well they can smell elderberries from a mile away. If we learned anything from Iraq it's that sending the military in with no clear plan or Commander's Intent leads to a terrible situation. I highly doubt anyone on the democrat side of things is chomping at the bit to become the next Paul Bremer, trying to decide who to help while being dropped into a Civil War. Don't worry though, that's the cool thing about the military, no matter what decision Obama decides, good or bad, the military will be there to pick up the Check. Actually no. Rush Limbaugh/Glenn Beck plebes canonize members of the American military as individuals who disinterestedly sacrifice for the ideals of liberty, freedom, etc. When the reality is military people have made a rational, self-interested choice of profession. It can be a very noble profession, sure. But it is a job. Yes, the military is the lapdog of whatever politician is in power. This is not Egypt, where the military is enrobed with mystical moral authority. (Although Glenn Beck might prefer it were that way.) Here the President says jump and the military says "how high, sir?" That's an oath that is taken as part of the job description. "No clear plan." Gulf War II, Afghanistan, Kosovo, Gulf War I, Vietnam, Korea, in WWII they had no clue what the goal was in Japan. Here the goal might be: Neutralize the ability of combatants to use chemical weapons. Or: establish and defend a safe zone for Syrian civilians. During the Rwandan genocide, we refused to intervene because we considered Africa a political tar-baby, we could not be sure who we would be helping (Hutu and Tutsi people look the same), helping civilians would indirectly aid the Tutsi rebels, whom we did not like, we did not want to take sides in a civil war without a goal (end the war? prop up Tutsi leadership? Occupy? what?) History condemns us for that. When kids learn about it in school they are disgusted. President Clinton describes it as the deepest failure of his presidency. Parliament did not vote down action because they think it will make it worse for Syrian civilians. They were worried about British skin; about getting entangled in the mess "those people" have "over there." And we have Dick Cheney of all people wondering aloud if the use of chemical weapons has anything to do with the national interest.
Lilllabettt Posted August 31, 2013 Posted August 31, 2013 Your transactional description of military service is kind of silly given how bad the VA has been with actually supporting veterans and how much poo veterans have to deal with that isn't in any contract. For example, I don't know how many people sign up for PTSD. Probably about half the men in my family are still suffering from some war they fought in years or even decades ago. Nor is there anything about serving if you President commits treason (hey look, Nixon again) or is a lying, manipulative piece of poo (hey there, Bush) or decides to ramp of a war that he probably doesn't, deep down, really believe can be won (hey there, Obama and Johnson). Teachers, cops, firemen, lawyers, doctors all run the risk of PTSD. It is called an "occupational hazard." People who sign up for the military realize it comes with a high risk of PTSD. They choose to go into the profession anyway. In their analysis the rewards out weigh the risks. They choose to roll the dice, and sometimes they get lucky. There was a 20 year stretch where the vast majority of American military people never saw a day in combat. And they got their veterans benefits all the same. It's different when there's a draft. When you take some guy who is a plumber, give him a gun and 3 weeks of training and send him into a war zone. But there is no draft. Everyone I know in the military loves America. None of them signed up to for the military "because America and freedom and the flag." Once again, that is Glenn Beck myth-making. Most people I know in the military are initially attracted by the education benefits, or the training. A couple joined because they just wanted to leave home and they needed a job to do it. My best friend liked the structure of the military, how it is run as an organization.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now