Jump to content
Join our Facebook Group ×
An Old School Catholic Message Board

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

There can be many cases where treatment to save the mothers life puts the child in danger however neither of us are of the medical field and thus cant really fathom what those reasons are. 

 

>>> There can be many cases where treatment to save the mothers life puts the child in danger

 

Yes, I know.  I gave examples of some.  Go re-read the thread.

 

>>> however neither of us are of the medical field and thus cant really fathom what those reasons are.

 

Actually, you know nothing about me, so you don't know what field I'm in or not in.  Putting that aside, I can in many cases fathom what those reasons are or I wouldn't be giving examples of those reasons, as I did.

Edited by NotreDame
Posted

>>> There can be many cases where treatment to save the mothers life puts the child in danger

 

Yes, I know.  I gave examples of some.  Go re-read the thread.

 

>>> however neither of us are of the medical field and thus cant really fathom what those reasons are.

 

Actually, you know nothing about me, so you don't know what field I'm in or not in.  Putting that aside, I can in many cases fathom what those reasons are or I wouldn't be giving examples of those reasons, as I did.

 

Have some hot cocoa

Posted

Yeah, I want to call shenanigans too. There are many cases where non-medical people can discuss treatments that could presumably harm an unborn child. Otherwise bioethics would be a much smaller field...

PhuturePriest
Posted

This article simply reinforces my theory that stupid people strive to attain the highest level of stupidity that their stupid minds can.

 

Their argument in short: "We don't agree with what you believe, so you can't be in charge of things anymore." I love how people that tout tolerance are the worst at it.

Posted

Their argument in short: "We don't agree with what you believe, so you can't be in charge of things anymore." I love how people that tout tolerance are the worst at it.

 

Very insightful.  Yet even your unfavorable assessment is a bit restrained.  What they really think is: "We don't agree with what you belive, therefore you need to do exactly as we tell you." 

 

Actually, you could probably just boil it down to "You need to do exactly as we tell you", but they don't usually come out and say that until they are 100% in charge.  Give them some time. 

Posted

I really doubt the ACLU is going to win this. Even assuming for the sake of argument that abortion was a legitimate course of treatment, that a doctor took another, reasonable alternative course of treatment which turned out to fail does not seem to support medical negligence when at least a substantial minority of qualified experts would sanction the practice.

As to the suit against the USCCB, the claim to me lacks merit, and the defense might even be able to get this shot down on procedural grounds. Even assuming their facts, the USCCB is protected under the First Amendment.

Bottom line, the ACLU are not so much trying to win this suit as to turn Protestant public opinion against Catholic healthcare. It's a chilling effect lawsuit, and a good judge IMO should dismiss the latter claim.

Posted

And if they bring up Walker v. City of Birmingham, I would dare to say that we will have a new source of alternate energy, because Martin Luther King's body in his grave would spin so fast Metropolitan Atlanta would have a new source of power.

Semper Catholic
Posted

Catholics treating women as second class citizens? STOP THE PRESSES!!

Posted

Because this is totally what is going on. /snark

Posted

The American Civil Liberties Union filed a sweeping federal lawsuit against the U.S. Conference of Catholic Bishops over its ethical guidelines for Roman Catholic hospitals.

i guess that they never heard of the Hippocratic Oath

 

if the person at the center of this lawsuit wanted an abortion why did she seek out a catholic hospital, i wonder.  it seams a little odd, doesn't it?

 

i would love to hear "Mercy Health Partners" side of the story.

Posted

They probably want to have it done at the Catholic hospital because those are the best.

Posted

 

This is persecution.  Until we put the fear of God into politicians at the ballot box, I expect the left to continue to persecute the Church for it's stands against abortion, 'contraception', homosexuality, etc. 

Sob, sob.  Somebody call the whambulance.  The mean old ACLU is trying to stop the poor church from limiting the freedoms of other people!!!!  :'(.  :'(   

Tab'le De'Bah-Rye
Posted

Are you allowed to go to holy mass if you get ex communicated, or can you just not partake of the holy sacraments ?

Posted (edited)

Sob, sob.  Somebody call the whambulance.  The mean old ACLU is trying to stop the poor church from limiting the freedoms of other people!!!!  :'(.  :'(   

 

what about the right to Life, Liberty and the pursuit of Happiness" and religious freedom, that this ACLU may infringe?  Cowboy!

Edited by add
Posted

the ACLU is like the most annoying kid on the playground who tattles on everyone for stupid **** who then cries and whines when the grown-ups tell him to knock it off.

 

 

 

On the other hand I don't like Catholics whining about persecution. Yes the current culture is quite hostile to our values and is trying to abolish the Church's influence, but Christ didn't tell us to whine about it. I think He said something more about prayer, persistence, and not being surprised/melodramatic, He might of even told us to rejoice when we are persecuted. But I don't remember exactly, He might have been crazy.

 

In summation: punch the ACLU in the mouth, don't whine at them.

Posted

Sob, sob.  Somebody call the whambulance.  The mean old ACLU is trying to stop the poor church from limiting the freedoms of other people!!!!  :'(.  :'(   

 

By definition, Catholic hospitals are private institutions, not public. They can offer whatever services they choose to, and not offer other services.

 

The problem is that the ACLU wants the right to tell private institutions what services to offer.

 

 

Let the ACLU open their own hospitals and offer any services they want to.

Posted

Sob, sob.  Somebody call the whambulance.  The mean old ACLU is trying to stop the poor church from limiting the freedoms of other people!!!!  :'(.  :'(   

 

The ACLU by itself wouldn't concern me so much if the President, the entire executive branch, half the courts and half of congress weren't intent on redefining my reluctance to do something immoral into a violation of other people's freedoms like you just did.
 

Posted

The ACLU is made up of some very ignorant people. The Hyde amendment exempts religious hospitals from performing abortions and has since the 70s. This lawsuit might be a blessing in disguise for the church, because Catholic hospitals on the ground do not follow their own directives. The ACLU cannot argue against directive 47.

 

47. Operations, treatments, and medications that have as their direct purpose the cure of a
proportionately serious pathological condition of a pregnant woman are permitted when they
cannot be safely postponed until the unborn child is viable, even if they will result in the death of
the unborn child

 

In the Phoenix case, the hospital refused to consult the National Catholic Bio-ethics center. In the Michigan case, the woman's life was not in danger. She wanted an abortion on demand. Choice is a two-way street. The doctor has a choice not to perform an abortion.

 

 

 

 

 

 

Posted

Savvy,

 

I don't think the point of contention is a refusal to perform an abortion.  I think it's a refusal to lay out abortion as a possible treatment option, even if that treatment were performed elsewhere:

 

http://www.reuters.com/article/2013/12/02/us-usa-abortion-michigan-lawsuit-idUSBRE9B10X820131202?

 

http://wdtprs.com/blog/2013/12/another-evil-attack-on-the-church-and-religious-freedom-in-these-usa/
 

Despite her being in excruciating pain and with virtually no chance her pregnancy could survive, Mercy Health Partners told Means there was nothing it could do and did not tell Means that terminating her pregnancy was an option and the safest course for her condition, the lawsuit said.

 

The lawsuit accuses the United States Conference of Catholic Bishops of creating health care directives “that cause pregnant women who are suffering from a miscarriage to be denied appropriate medical care, including information about their condition and treatment options.”

 

So I'm not sure to what extent the hyde ammendment plays a role in this case, but I could be wrong.

Posted

But that again doesn't necessarily support a finding of negligence, especially sice this is like what, one sixth of hospitals we are talking about? And it's not as if abortion is an uncontroversial form of treatment, so the shocks the conscience of the layman standard won't work.

Like I said, I don't thing the ACLU cares if it wins the case or not. They just want to stir up anti-Catholic prejudice among our Protestant neighbors. Divide et impera.

Create an account or sign in to comment

You need to be a member in order to leave a comment

Create an account

Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!

Register a new account

Sign in

Already have an account? Sign in here.

Sign In Now
×
×
  • Create New...