ToJesusMyHeart Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 "What Women Want from the Church: To Have (and Enjoy) Sex You promised me I would never regret this. I thought I did everything right. After all, I did the things you told me to do. I prayed for my future husband. I made a list of non-negotiables. I kissed dating goodbye. I was a lady in waiting. I let God write my love story. I sat on the front row of the ‘damaged goods’ sermon with my head held high. I knew who the girls were in the room our youth pastor was talking to. I wasn't one of those girls. I was sexless and shameless. And proud. Sexual purity became my idol. 
 Sexual purity fueled my pride. Whenever I was asked about my life calling, my life purpose, my answer was rehearsed and ready: "My mission is to inspire others to have an appreciation for the anticipation of sacred waiting." (I'm 99% sure I stole that straight from an Eric and Leslie Ludy book.) Somewhere along the way I bought into the lie that my worth as a Christian, that my identity in Christ, was directly connected to my sexual purity. that "somewhere" was church. But I regret this. I regret buying into the things you told me about sex, about my body, about my sexuality. But mostly I regret saving sex for marriage. I got married about five months ago... Is there a sexuality switch that you forgot to tell me about? Perhaps my switch disabled when my Sunday school teacher described to me the excruciating pain of sexual intercourse as the worse pain she had ever experienced. So I am married. And I am still sexless. But I am not shameless. Not anymore. Let me tell you how it feels to be a woman whose singleness was spent in "sacred waiting" and whose marriage is spent in secret shame. Let me tell you, church, about my anxiety and panic attacks and fear and tears and disappointment and anger that I experience every time we get somewhat close to intercourse. I feel shame because NO I HAVE NEVER BEEN SEXUALLY ASSAULTED. I feel shame because there is no reason that I can make sense of as to why I would have such severe sexual anxiety, besides the reality that I have spent most of my life clinching tight to my sexual purity and have found my worth in this very virtue. Let me tell you, church, about my husband who is so gracious and patient and understanding, even five months into this sexless marriage. I feel shame that because of my sexual anxiety, this sweet and perfect and gentle man of valor whom I love so much has not yet had the amazingly blessed married sex that he, too, had been promised after waiting so long. Let me tell you, church, about lying through my artificial smile when my friends ask me about "married life" as they fish for details about married sex. I feel shame because I am certain that no one else would understand. I feel shamebecause I am certain that my Christian community would be quick to judge. I feel shame because a sexless marriage is not what a good "Christian" marriage looks like. I feel shame because I lie about it again and again. Let me tell you, church, about your "experts" in marriage counseling who insist that if I don't buck up and let my husband penetrate me, that he will find someone else to meet his needs. I feel shame to know that these Christian "experts" can justify my husband's hypothetical extramarital affair, and insist that my withholding of and my resistance to sex would be to blame. I’m drowning in this shame. I’m so lonely in this shame. I thought I did everything right, but I’m not so sure anymore that I did. What do I, a woman, want from you, the church? I want the church to be gentle with the hearts and minds of the young girls and recognize that many of these same young girls will soon be young, married women. I want the church to stop equating virginity with purity so that girls, like me, aren’t put on a purity pedestal. I want the church to stop taking the easy, lazy way out by teaching a fear-based, shame-based view of sexuality and to stop shying away from a healthy and honest conversation about sexuality. I want the church to give me, and those like me, a chance to be vulnerable without judgment, without correction, without shame. Finally, I want the church to stop reducing me to a failed wife because it was the church who failed me." http://prestonyancey.com/blog/2014/2/13 Curious what you think.
cmaD2006 Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 Leaving this in open mic for now ... if at some point Phatmassers think this belongs in Debate Table please hit the report button.
NotreDame Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 I don't like it when people who are clearly dealing with personal issues blame "the Church." It makes it difficult to defend the church or even disagree with the premise without appearing to attack the individual.
CatholicCid Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 I would wonder what "Church" the author is referring to when using the term "Church". Especially with this line: "I want the church to stop taking the easy, lazy way out by teaching a fear-based, shame-based view of sexuality and to stop shying away from a healthy and honest conversation about sexuality." From the controversial angle and through the lens of the Catholic Church, I would think this would be controversial only in that I wouldn't believe it is something reflective of Church teaching. Cue Theology of the Body, etc... The Church, in her teachings, has been trying for some time to show how sex is beautiful. This seems to be written more from someone raised either in a puritanical Christian tradition or a very misunderstood Catholicism.
PhuturePriest Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 There are obviously many issues with this woman (And I don't say "issues" in the personal attack sort of way, but the literal psychology term for it), but the main thing I noticed was she made her virginity who she was. If she loses it, she loses what she has used to define herself all these years, so obviously she wouldn't want to lose it. I think perhaps well-meaning people told her that her virginity was her most treasured thing about her, and that is what has caused this whole issue to happen. Rather than blaming the people who gave her false information, she is blaming the Church.
ardillacid Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 She sounds very unhappy. Who is responsible for an individual's happiness?
blazeingstar Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 I don't see why she's blaming the church when most of the things that she references are protestant. That and people will always have inverse reactions to some things. She could of been taken down a notch...SHE was the smug one, and she ignored the words about sex, not those who taught her.
NotreDame Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 Well, know that you all have broken the seal I'll say what I was thinking the whole time I was reading that.. I don't know anything about her husband because she never mentioned him in her little narcissistic diatribe, but man do I feel sorry for him.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 (edited) Sexual purity became my idol. 
Sexual purity fueled my pride. This is the problem, right here. She made it into an idol; she says it herself. For her, her faith was reduced simply to a somewhat unhealthy view of purity. Whether that is her fault, her parents', her priest's, I do not know, but it seems clear to me, based on this article, that her idea of sexual purity was, in essence, her god. Is/was this person Catholic? Edited February 13, 2014 by Nihil Obstat
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 (edited) In the comments so far, I don't see any mercy and love and sadness at another person's hurt. I also find it very interesting that virtually all the comments so far have been by men. (Blazeingstar has chosen not to reveal his/her gender.) Sexuality is VERY different for men and women. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be a member of Phatmass. Edited February 13, 2014 by IgnatiusofLoyola
NotreDame Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 In the comments so far, I don't see any mercy and love and sadness at another person's hurt. I also find it very interesting that virtually all the comments so far have been by men. (Blazeingstar has chosen not to reveal his/her gender.) Sexuality is VERY different for men and women. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be a member of Phatmass. Now this is more of the type of comment I was expecting. Blazingstar is a female, btw.
Nihil Obstat Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 I do not think it is particularly offensive to point out that having sexual purity become an idol is bound to cause problems. Like I said, it is not necessarily her fault.
CatholicCid Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 (edited) In the comments so far, I don't see any mercy and love and sadness at another person's hurt. I also find it very interesting that virtually all the comments so far have been by men. (Blazeingstar has chosen not to reveal his/her gender.) Sexuality is VERY different for men and women. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be a member of Phatmass. She clearly has very severe sexual anxiety that she and her husband will have to work together to overcome. She is clearly wounded in some way; Thankfully, she seems to have an understanding husband and is attempting to work through her anxiety. Overall, the situation is, of course, a sad one. That being said, we are responding to a C/P article under the title of "Is this Controversial? Do you agree/disagree?" which appears to be asking for opinions of the contents and arguments made in the article, not necessarily empathetic responses to the anonymous author. What are your thoughts towards the article itself? Towards the question of the OP in general? Her general point seems to be that the way her church educated her towards sexuality was one that saw sex as shameful and that purity is to be sought after above all. This experience has left her unable to accept physical intimacy. What was your experience through your church? Was sexuality taught in a healthy and comfortable way? Or, more in the fear-inducing way described in the original article? In my experience with various Catholic Churches and schools throughout the US in the past several years, I've, thankfully, seen the topic of sexuality handled very well. Not being controlled by fear, but by taught as the love it is meant to be. Edited February 13, 2014 by CatholicCid
IgnatiusofLoyola Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 Whatever. I sincerely doubt that Jesus would have reacted to the story of a person's emotional pain in the way any of you reacted. Your reactions are so "up in arms" that anyone, in their pain, might possibly think of blaming the Church, that you are ignoring the story and the person behind it. If/when any of you shared a story of serious emotional pain, I would try to understand your pain and show sympathy and caring and love before passing judgement. If you are examples of the kinds of things members of the Catholic church would say, and the judgements you would pass, about ANY person obviously in serious emotional pain--whether Catholic or Protestant--it should be immaterial--then I don't want any part of it. I'm ashamed to be associated with all of you.
NotreDame Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 Ignatius of Loyola, I agree with your sentiments and if it was the first time I'd seen it I would have been very sympathetic. But I see these type of woe-is-me stories from the Gen-Y/Z crowd so often now that it just rolls right over me. Maybe it's because I'm callous, but it also could be because deep down inside I think the underlying issue in all of these situations is narcissm - or well placed trolling. Regardless, that person isn't on the board, it wasn't their blog that it was posted at (the blog belonged to a guy), and there's no reason to believe we have to sugar-coat things for the ostensibly fragile writer since they are probably never going to see these comments.
beatitude Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 (edited) In the comments so far, I don't see any mercy and love and sadness at another person's hurt. I also find it very interesting that virtually all the comments so far have been by men. (Blazeingstar has chosen not to reveal his/her gender.) Sexuality is VERY different for men and women. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be a member of Phatmass. I also was taken aback by the comments. Some people, men and women, have anxiety about sex - even without having had any traumatic experiences. This woman mentions the fact that she hasn't been raped as though this is just one more thing to hurt and confuse her, so she perhaps hasn't come across the idea that psychosexual problems don't have to stem from rape and that they are just part of human existence. Vaginismus is one fairly common medical issue that can make sex distressing and physically painful for women. But it's true that sex is often romanticised in various Christian communities as this wonderful gift that is sure to be out of this world if only you abide by all the terms and conditions first. It's rare to hear people talk about the fact that it can be uncomfortable (from the physically painful to the laughably awkward), that the earth isn't necessarily going to move for you first time (or second time, or third time...), that anxieties can exist without any obvious good reason (just like anxieties about everything - I'm sure everyone here knows at least one person with an irrational fear that has no clear cause), that medical problems affecting sex aren't unusual. Frank discussions about all this sort of stuff would be more helpful than the purity rings and romantic 'true love waits' mentality that for many unmarried Christians do constitute the basis of their knowledge. I have come across people being shamed out of sex before marriage by being compared to boxes of chocolates already opened - in a Christian youth group. This woman was apparently scared off sex by being taught by her Sunday school teacher about how much it hurt. Now this may not be good orthodox theology, but for many Christians, it's what they get, and I don't think the right response is to immediately start talking about how they obviously just don't understand the church and how they must be narcissistic. A married couple who are much in love and who suddenly find that sex is impossible for them are not going to be helped by that approach. The emotional pain and the sense of being a disappointment to their spouse or 'faulty' somehow is what's concerning them now. I don't think it's controversial to discuss this kind of stuff. It happens. It's not the end of the world. It can be dealt with. Edited February 13, 2014 by beatitude
SilentJoy Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 I also was taken aback by the comments. Some people, men and women, have anxiety about sex - even without having had any traumatic experiences. This woman mentions the fact that she hasn't been raped as though this is just one more thing to hurt and confuse her, so she perhaps hasn't come across the idea that psychosexual problems don't have to stem from rape and that they are just part of human existence. Vaginismus is one fairly common medical issue that can make sex distressing and physically painful for women. But it's true that sex is often romanticised in various Christian communities as this wonderful gift that is sure to be out of this world if only you abide by all the terms and conditions first. It's rare to hear people talk about the fact that it can be uncomfortable (from the physically painful to the laughably awkward), that the earth isn't necessarily going to move for you first time (or second time, or third time...), that anxieties can exist without any obvious good reason (just like anxieties about everything - I'm sure everyone here knows at least one person with an irrational fear that has no clear cause), that medical problems affecting sex aren't unusual. Frank discussions about all this sort of stuff would be more helpful than the purity rings and romantic 'true love waits' mentality that for many unmarried Christians do constitute the basis of their knowledge. I have come across people being shamed out of sex before marriage by being compared to boxes of chocolates already opened - in a Christian youth group. This woman was apparently scared off sex by being taught by her Sunday school teacher about how much it hurt. Now this may not be good orthodox theology, but for many Christians, it's what they get, and I don't think the right response is to immediately start talking about how they obviously just don't understand the church and how they must be narcissistic. A married couple who are much in love and who suddenly find that sex is impossible for them are not going to be helped by that approach. The emotional pain and the sense of being a disappointment to their spouse or 'faulty' somehow is what's concerning them now. I don't think it's controversial to discuss this kind of stuff. It happens. It's not the end of the world. It can be dealt with. I ran out of props, but... :like:
SilentJoy Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 Even without "idolizing" virginity, I think that sex can still be terrifying for many people. I got the impression that she thought that, if she hadn't "saved herself," marital sex wouldn't have been so scary, but why wouldn't pre-marital sex have NOT been so awful? Or maybe she was trying to say that she wouldn't have sought out marriage if she knew it was going to be that bad? She seems to be blaming "the church" entirely for these struggles, which I think is incorrect. Yet I can understand how such a deeply terrifying and humiliating difficulty could bring out that response.
blazeingstar Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 In the comments so far, I don't see any mercy and love and sadness at another person's hurt. I also find it very interesting that virtually all the comments so far have been by men. (Blazeingstar has chosen not to reveal his/her gender.) Sexuality is VERY different for men and women. Sometimes I'm ashamed to be a member of Phatmass. I'm female. And I am a bit jaded. I work with people her age every day. I see her not as a victim of somewhat questionable religious teachings, but as another whiny young adult who is blaming something in her life on someone else. Mind you I've just had to deal with a student who blamed his hating class on the fact that everyone else in class knew more than he did. I see it every day. Not only that, I went to a lukewarm Catholic college and stuck close to the other practicing Catholics and Christians. There were girls like this, and they were mean and nasty towards other girls, especially those who had/were having sex. Some even believed that you needed to ask for Gods' forgiveness in any "part" you had in an assault. I think I may have gone a bit softer if she had taken some responsibility, ANY responsibility for her actions. Truth is, all I got from this was, "I let my young idealism turn me into a self-rigorous prick, i don't acknowledge that my attitude could of hurt anyone in any way, I have an issue and now I need someone to blame"
arfink Posted February 13, 2014 Posted February 13, 2014 Ignatius of Loyola, I agree with your sentiments and if it was the first time I'd seen it I would have been very sympathetic. But I see these type of woe-is-me stories from the Gen-Y/Z crowd so often now that it just rolls right over me. Maybe it's because I'm callous, but it also could be because deep down inside I think the underlying issue in all of these situations is narcissm - or well placed trolling. Regardless, that person isn't on the board, it wasn't their blog that it was posted at (the blog belonged to a guy), and there's no reason to believe we have to sugar-coat things for the ostensibly fragile writer since they are probably never going to see these comments. I would be very cautious with these words. First of all, you're making very sweeping generalizations about an entire generation of people based on your limited experience. I might add that I find it very ironic of you to do so, since you are part of that age group. I would also be cautious about being overly blunt or harsh in your comments in this thread, for a number of reasons including linkbacks/pingbacks which could in fact lead the author here, but also because I can assure you that a large number of people both Catholics and non-Catholics have in fact been deeply hurt, oftentimes in matters of sexuality, by people who had claims to authority in the church. This stuff is not to be taken lightly, no matter how suspect you think a person's motives are, or how much you suspect them of being narcissists.
Recommended Posts
Create an account or sign in to comment
You need to be a member in order to leave a comment
Create an account
Sign up for a new account in our community. It's easy!
Register a new accountSign in
Already have an account? Sign in here.
Sign In Now